Stormwater <br />StormwaterManagementPlan:TheCHPUDsitelieswithinadesignatedheadwatersarea <br />withoutsufficientstorminfrastructure.Drainagefromtheeasternhalfofthesitesheetflowsonto <br />theRibbonTrailandforest.Thesystemwasdesignedonlyfora10yearpeakstormanddoesnot <br />includestormwatermanagementonthelots.Thiswillleadtomorepollutantsflowingtoward <br />theRibbonTrailfurtherendangeringitandposinganincreasedrisktopublichealthandsafety. <br />\[Seefulldiscussionunder EC9.8320(10)(j),p.124\] <br />TheCapitalHillPUDfailsEC9.8320(6)andshouldbedenied. <br />#### <br />EmergencyResponse(EmergencyVehicleAccess) <br />TheApplicationstates(p.47of67,underliningaddedforemphasis)"thereisnoknownlimitto <br />emergencyvehicleaccesscurrently."ThisassertionisdirectlycontradictedbytheFire <br />DepartmentComments/ConditionsregardingCHPUDdated3/27/17(seeApplication <br />CompletenessReviewdated3/31/17,pp.10-13)andsubmittedasAttachmentP. <br />DeputyFireMarshalMarkDahlstates: <br />“ThesesupportingdocumentsapplydirectlytotheCapitalHillPUDandrecognizeand <br />respecttheintentoftheCityofEugenePUDCriteriasection9.8320(6)whichstates, <br />“ThePUDwillnotbeasignificantrisktopublichealthandsafety,includingbutnot <br />limitedtosoilerosion,slopefailure,stormwaterorfloodhazard,or/andimpedimentto <br />emergencyresponse.” <br />ConcernReality#1: <br />TheinboundflowoffiredepartmentvehiclesisCapitaldriveviaSpringBlvd. <br />fromthenorth.Thisroutehasthefewesthairpinturnsbutalsohasveryrestricted <br />accessinseveralplacesalongSpringBlvd. <br />Withtheminimalaccessalongthisroute,FireDepartmentresponsecanbevery <br />significantlydelayedforanynumberofreasons:unusuallyhighopposingtraffic, <br />acollisionofvehicles,constructionontheroad,constructionvehiclesrelatedto <br />residentialhousing,downtreesorwires,otherdriversattemptingill-timedturn <br />aroundattemptsortryingtopark. <br />Inalargescaleincidentsuchasawildlandfireorevenahousefire,local <br />residentsmightbefleeingtheareaintheirvehiclesandimpedingtheflowoffire <br />vehicles. <br />Withanyoftheabovesituationsthealternateroutemightrequirethefirevehicle <br />backingupalongdistance(greaterthan150ft)beforefindinganavailableturn <br />aroundpointsuchasEast27thandSpringBlvd. <br />72 <br /> <br />