Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCorrected Application Materials (Written Narrative) Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning ADJUSTMENT REVIEW APPLICATION REDDY PROPERTY A RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT PROJECT Assessor’s Map Tax Lots 17 03 16 41 904 905 906 November 6, 2026 Reddy Property Page 2 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning Table of Contents Adjustment Review Application ..................................................................................... 3 – 4 General Site Plan Requirements ......................................................................................... 5 Adjustment Review Written Statement .......................................................................... 6 – 8 Reddy Property Page 3 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning November 6, 2026 ADJUSTMENT REVIEW APPLICATION Project Name Reddy Property PROPERTY OWNER/APPLICANT Reddy, LLC 2375 Lakeview Drive Eugene, OR 97408 Contact: Dinesh Reddy Email: reddyortho@gmail.com Phone: 541.954.6606 APPLICANT’S REPRESENTATIVE Landscape Architect + Land Use Planner Schirmer Consulting, LLC PO Box 10424 Eugene, OR 97440 Contact: Carol Schirmer Email: schirmer@schirmerconsulting.com Phone: 541.234.5108 ARCHITECT Dustrud Architecture 1699 Pearl Street Eugene, OR 97401 Contact: Shane McCloskey Email: shane@dustrudarchtecture.com Phone: 541.338.8544 Reddy Property Page 4 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning The following is specific proposal information from the Adjustment Review Application Checklist. This information addresses the development on the development site located on Old Coburg Road. MAP and TAX LOT and ZONING Assessor’s Map: 17 03 16 41 Tax Lot: 904, 905, 906 Zoning: R-1 CODE SECTIONS PROPOSED FOR ADJUSTMENT REVIEW SB Section 38(4)(g)(B) Table EC 9.2170 Building Height ASSOCIATED PENDING LAND USE APPLICATION OR BUILDING PERMIT NUMBERS? MHF 26-18 and MHF 26-19 Reddy Property Page 5 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning General Site Plan Requirements Date, north arrow, scale See Site Plan. Assessor’s Map and Tax Lot number See Site Plan. Vicinity Map See Site Plan Site Plan Boundary Dimensions See Site Plan. Existing Structures See Site Plan. Show Features Related to Development See Site Plan and Architectural Elevations Site Plan Prepared, Stamped, and Signed See Site Plan. Reddy Property Page 6 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning ADJUSTMENT REVIEW WRITTEN STATEMENT Code criteria is shown as plain text, and my responses (in italics). Project Information The application requests adjustments to the city code standards for the Reddy property. This development site consist of 3 tax lots, 2 of which are in the Final Plat stages of Middle Housing Land Division. Tax Lot 904 has a single family house to be converted into a duplex. Tax Lot 905 will have a 4-plex and Tax Lot 906 will have a triplex. Th total acreage of the 3 lots combined is .59 acres. Total units is 9. Units per acre is 15.25 for the development site. The requested adjustments are authorized by state law, specifically SB 1537, Or Laws 2024, Ch. 110, Section 38. One adjustments is being requested: · Building height These adjustments address zoning standards that require no interpretation of code or legal judgment. As a result, the statute authorizes the City to approve them through a ministerial process, which does not involve public notice, a local hearing, or an appeal. Using a ministerial process will also allow these adjustments to align seamlessly with the building permit and construction schedule. I. Background · The proposed project is for 8 new residential units and 1 existing residential dwelling. · Units are typical garden style apartments. · Building Permit submittal will likely be first quarter of 2027. · All proposed buildings will not meet the required building height II. Justification of Proposed Adjustments to Building Articulation and Building Orientation. Oregon Laws 2024, Ch. 110, Sec. 38(2): (2) Except as provided in section 39 of this 2024 Act, a local government shall grant a request for an adjustment in an application to develop housing as provided in this section. An application qualifies for an adjustment under this section only if the following conditions are met: (a) The application is for a building permit or a quasi-judicial, limited or ministerial land use decision; This application will be associated with a building permit whose submittal is forthcoming. In any case this is a limited land use decision. (b) The development is on lands zoned to allow for residential uses, including mixed-use residential; The R-1 zoning allows Residential: Multiple Units Dwellings use. Table 9.2170 Residential Zone Land Use and Permit Requirements. (c) The residential development is for densities not less than those required under section 55 (3)(a)(C) of this 2024 Act; Not applicable. (d) The development is within an urban growth boundary, not including lands that have not been annexed by a city; The site is in the city. (e) The development is of net new housing units in new construction projects, including: (E) Middle housing as defined in ORS 197A.420; This is a new Middle Housing development on 3 tax lots (the Middle Housing Lots shown are not yet recorded as of this application). One single dwelling unit will remain, and 8 new dwelling units will be added to produce new net housing. Reddy Property Page 7 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning (f) The application requests not more than 10 distinct adjustments to development standards as provided in this section. A “distinct adjustment” means: (A) An adjustment to one of the development standards listed in subsection (4) of this section where each discrete adjustment to a listed development standard that includes multiple component standards must be counted as an individual adjustment; or One discrete adjustment is requested. (B) An adjustment to one of the development standards listed in subsection (5) of this section where each discrete adjustment to a listed development standard that includes multiple component standards must be counted as an individual adjustment; and One discrete adjustment is requested. (g) The application states how at least one of the following criteria apply: (B) The adjustments will enable development of housing that reduces the sale or rental prices per residential unit; This is true for this project. The requested building height adjustment would provide flexibility to achieve a more efficient building design. Designing the proposed development with the applicable height limit can require additional architectural work, design revisions, and more complex construction detailing. Allowing additional height can reduce these constraints and the associated design and construction costs. These savings could reduce the rental revenue needed to make the project financially feasible, creating an opportunity for lower rents. (3) . . . . . . (4) A local government shall grant an adjustment to the following development standards: (g) For manufactured dwelling parks, middle housing as defined in ORS 197A.420 (1)(c)(D), Multi- family housing and mixed-use residential housing: (B) For uses other than cottage clusters, as defined as ORS 197A.420 (1)(c)(D), building height maximums that: (i) Are in addition to existing applicable height bonuses, if any; and (ii) Are not more than an increase of the greater of: (I) One story: or (II) A 20 percent increase to base zone height with rounding consistent with methodology outlined in city code, if any: The R-1 base zone height is 30 feet (Table EC 9.2750); a 20% increase allows an adjusted increase of up to 6 feet or a 1 story increase allows an adjustment of up to 8’ – 10’. The proposed adjusted elevations show and increase of less than and including 6 feet III. Justification for the Ministerial Review Process. The statute allows the City to follow a ministerial process where appropriate: Oregon Laws 2024, Ch. 110, Sec. 45(6): (6) A city shall apply the procedures in this section, and only the procedures in this section, to a limited land use decision, even if the city has not incorporated limited land use decisions into land use regulations, as required by ORS 197.646 (3), except that a limited land use decision that is made under land use standards that do not require interpretation or the exercise of policy or legal judgment may be made by city staff using a ministerial process. The language above affords the City discretion to use a ministerial review process to review adjustment requests that “do not require interpretation or the exercise of policy or legal judgment.” The applicant believes this is such a situation: Reddy Property Page 8 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning · The R-1 building height standards are numerical: the authorized adjustment is numerical; the requested adjustment is within the numerical parameters allowed by the statute. Section 38 – Eligible Development and Design Standards: Required Eligible Adjustment Amount states ‘Must be eligible for full adjustment’ so this adjustment does not require interpretation by staff or the exercise of policy or legal judgement. The applicant requests a ministerial process for review of this request. This application is being submitted in advance of the building permit submittal to ensure clarity and assurance for the design team as the project proceeds. Thank you! Sincerely, Schirmer Consulting, LLC Carol Schirmer Principal Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning ADJUSTMENT REVIEW APPLICATION REDDY PROPERTY A RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT PROJECT Assessor’s Map Tax Lots 17 03 16 41 904 905 906 November 6, 2026 Reddy Property Page 2 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning Table of Contents Adjustment Review Application ..................................................................................... 3 – 4 General Site Plan Requirements ......................................................................................... 5 Adjustment Review Written Statement .......................................................................... 6 – 8 Reddy Property Page 3 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning November 6, 2026 ADJUSTMENT REVIEW APPLICATION Project Name Reddy Property PROPERTY OWNER/APPLICANT Reddy, LLC 2375 Lakeview Drive Eugene, OR 97408 Contact: Dinesh Reddy Email: reddyortho@gmail.com Phone: 541.954.6606 APPLICANT’S REPRESENTATIVE Landscape Architect + Land Use Planner Schirmer Consulting, LLC PO Box 10424 Eugene, OR 97440 Contact: Carol Schirmer Email: schirmer@schirmerconsulting.com Phone: 541.234.5108 ARCHITECT Dustrud Architecture 1699 Pearl Street Eugene, OR 97401 Contact: Shane McCloskey Email: shane@dustrudarchtecture.com Phone: 541.338.8544 Reddy Property Page 4 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning The following is specific proposal information from the Adjustment Review Application Checklist. This information addresses the development on the development site located on Old Coburg Road. MAP and TAX LOT and ZONING Assessor’s Map: 17 03 16 41 Tax Lot: 904, 905, 906 Zoning: R-1 CODE SECTIONS PROPOSED FOR ADJUSTMENT REVIEW SB Section 38(4)(g)(B) Table EC 9.2170 Building Height ASSOCIATED PENDING LAND USE APPLICATION OR BUILDING PERMIT NUMBERS? MHF 26-18 and MHF 26-19 Reddy Property Page 5 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning General Site Plan Requirements Date, north arrow, scale See Site Plan. Assessor’s Map and Tax Lot number See Site Plan. Vicinity Map See Site Plan Site Plan Boundary Dimensions See Site Plan. Existing Structures See Site Plan. Show Features Related to Development See Site Plan and Architectural Elevations Site Plan Prepared, Stamped, and Signed See Site Plan. Reddy Property Page 6 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning ADJUSTMENT REVIEW WRITTEN STATEMENT Code criteria is shown as plain text, and my responses (in italics). Project Information The application requests adjustments to the city code standards for the Reddy property. This development site consist of 3 tax lots, 2 of which are in the Final Plat stages of Middle Housing Land Division. Tax Lot 904 has a single family house to be converted into a duplex. Tax Lot 905 will have a 4-plex and Tax Lot 906 will have a triplex. Th total acreage of the 3 lots combined is .59 acres. Total units is 9. Units per acre is 15.25 for the development site. The requested adjustments are authorized by state law, specifically SB 1537, Or Laws 2024, Ch. 110, Section 38. One adjustments is being requested: · Building height These adjustments address zoning standards that require no interpretation of code or legal judgment. As a result, the statute authorizes the City to approve them through a ministerial process, which does not involve public notice, a local hearing, or an appeal. Using a ministerial process will also allow these adjustments to align seamlessly with the building permit and construction schedule. I. Background · The proposed project is for 8 new residential units and 1 existing residential dwelling. · Units are typical garden style apartments. · Building Permit submittal will likely be first quarter of 2027. · All proposed buildings will not meet the required building height II. Justification of Proposed Adjustments to Building Articulation and Building Orientation. Oregon Laws 2024, Ch. 110, Sec. 38(2): (2) Except as provided in section 39 of this 2024 Act, a local government shall grant a request for an adjustment in an application to develop housing as provided in this section. An application qualifies for an adjustment under this section only if the following conditions are met: (a) The application is for a building permit or a quasi-judicial, limited or ministerial land use decision; This application will be associated with a building permit whose submittal is forthcoming. In any case this is a limited land use decision. (b) The development is on lands zoned to allow for residential uses, including mixed-use residential; The R-1 zoning allows Residential: Multiple Units Dwellings use. Table 9.2170 Residential Zone Land Use and Permit Requirements. (c) The residential development is for densities not less than those required under section 55 (3)(a)(C) of this 2024 Act; Not applicable. (d) The development is within an urban growth boundary, not including lands that have not been annexed by a city; The site is in the city. (e) The development is of net new housing units in new construction projects, including: (E) Middle housing as defined in ORS 197A.420; This is a new Middle Housing development on 3 tax lots (the Middle Housing Lots shown are not yet recorded as of this application). One single dwelling unit will remain, and 8 new dwelling units will be added to produce new net housing. Reddy Property Page 7 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning (f) The application requests not more than 10 distinct adjustments to development standards as provided in this section. A “distinct adjustment” means: (A) An adjustment to one of the development standards listed in subsection (4) of this section where each discrete adjustment to a listed development standard that includes multiple component standards must be counted as an individual adjustment; or One discrete adjustment is requested. (B) An adjustment to one of the development standards listed in subsection (5) of this section where each discrete adjustment to a listed development standard that includes multiple component standards must be counted as an individual adjustment; and One discrete adjustment is requested. (g) The application states how at least one of the following criteria apply: (B) The adjustments will enable development of housing that reduces the sale or rental prices per residential unit; This is true for this project. The requested building height adjustment would provide flexibility to achieve a more efficient building design. Designing the proposed development with the applicable height limit can require additional architectural work, design revisions, and more complex construction detailing. Allowing additional height can reduce these constraints and the associated design and construction costs. These savings could reduce the rental revenue needed to make the project financially feasible, creating an opportunity for lower rents. (3) . . . . . . (4) A local government shall grant an adjustment to the following development standards: (g) For manufactured dwelling parks, middle housing as defined in ORS 197A.420 (1)(c)(D), Multi- family housing and mixed-use residential housing: (B) For uses other than cottage clusters, as defined as ORS 197A.420 (1)(c)(D), building height maximums that: (i) Are in addition to existing applicable height bonuses, if any; and (ii) Are not more than an increase of the greater of: (I) One story: or (II) A 20 percent increase to base zone height with rounding consistent with methodology outlined in city code, if any: The R-1 base zone height is 30 feet (Table EC 9.2750); a 20% increase allows an adjusted increase of up to 6 feet or a 1 story increase allows an adjustment of up to 8’ – 10’. The proposed adjusted elevations show and increase of less than and including 6 feet III. Justification for the Ministerial Review Process. The statute allows the City to follow a ministerial process where appropriate: Oregon Laws 2024, Ch. 110, Sec. 45(6): (6) A city shall apply the procedures in this section, and only the procedures in this section, to a limited land use decision, even if the city has not incorporated limited land use decisions into land use regulations, as required by ORS 197.646 (3), except that a limited land use decision that is made under land use standards that do not require interpretation or the exercise of policy or legal judgment may be made by city staff using a ministerial process. The language above affords the City discretion to use a ministerial review process to review adjustment requests that “do not require interpretation or the exercise of policy or legal judgment.” The applicant believes this is such a situation: Reddy Property Page 8 of 8 Adjustment Review Application SB 1537: Written Statement November 6, 2026 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning · The R-1 building height standards are numerical: the authorized adjustment is numerical; the requested adjustment is within the numerical parameters allowed by the statute. Section 38 – Eligible Development and Design Standards: Required Eligible Adjustment Amount states ‘Must be eligible for full adjustment’ so this adjustment does not require interpretation by staff or the exercise of policy or legal judgement. The applicant requests a ministerial process for review of this request. This application is being submitted in advance of the building permit submittal to ensure clarity and assurance for the design team as the project proceeds. Thank you! Sincerely, Schirmer Consulting, LLC Carol Schirmer Principal