Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutHearings Official Appeal DecisionPDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Final Decision 1 BEFORE THE HEARINGS OFFICIAL FOR THE CITY OF EUGENE, OREGON File Name (Number): Braewood Hills Third Addition (PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02) Applicant: Piculell Properties, LLC Applicant’s Representatives: Carol Schirmer, Schirmer Consulting, LLC and Bill Kloos, Law Office of Bill Kloos PC Lead City Staff: Nicholas Gioello, Associate Planner FINAL DECISION Appeal Denied Application Approved with Conditions Summary of Application and Appeal: This matter relates to an appeal of a decision of the City of Eugene Planning Director (“Director”). On March 12, 2026, the Director approved the applicant’s request for a Final Planned Unit Development (“PDF”) and concurrent request for Standards Review (“SDR”) subject to conditions of approval (the “Director’s Decision”). Sections 9.8350-9.8375 and sections 9.8460-9.8474 of the Eugene Code (“EC” or “Code”) respectively govern the review and approval of PDF and SDR applications. The property is located east of Hawkins Lane and north of Herald Lane and is approximately 15.5 acres in size. It is zoned R-1 (Low-Density Residential) and is subject to the Water Resources Conservation (/WR) overlay. In 2024, the applicant sought approval for a tentative PUD and tentative subdivision to create 39 lots on the property. Following a hearings official’s denial, the Eugene Planning Commission approved the applications, with conditions. In 2025, the applicant submitted the PDF and SDR applications that are the subject of this appeal for 38 lots.1 The SDR is necessary due to the extension of Randy Lane across Videra Creek, a protected Goal 5 resource. Pursuant to EC 9.8365, the Director will approve, approve with conditions, or deny a PDF based on the following criteria: (1) The final PUD plan conforms with the approved tentative PUD plan and all conditions attached thereto. (2) For final PUDs not associated with a land division, public improvements as required by this land use code or as a condition of tentative plan approval will be completed prior to issuance of a development permit, or: (a) A performance bond or suitable substitute as agreed upon by the city has been filed with the city finance officer in an amount sufficient to assure the completion of all required public improvements; or 1 Consistent with a condition in the tentative PUD approval, the applicant combined lots 37 and 38 into one lot, resulting in 38 lots total. PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Final Decision 2 (b) A petition for public improvements and for the assessment of the real property for the improvements has been signed by the property owner seeking the subdivision, and the petition has been accepted by the city engineer. With respect to subsection (2), the Director determined it did not apply because there is a land division associated with the PUD. The hearings official agrees. Regarding subsection (1), the Director found the plan the applicant submitted with the PDF conformed to the approved tentative PUD plan. The Director also found the final plan conformed to the conditions imposed on the tentative PUD approval, subject to three additional conditions imposed by the Director.2 Section 9.8470 of the Code contains the approval criterion for an SDR, which states that “[t]he decision-maker shall determine whether the application is in compliance with the standards setout in the code section that calls for standards review.” In this case, the /WR overlay zone contains standards that apply to the application, which are found at EC 9.4980(1)-(11). The Director found the application met these standards, subject to nine conditions of approval.3 Wes Van Winkle, on behalf of Save Videra Oak Meadows, filed a timely appeal of the Director's Decision through legal counsel Charles W. Woodward, IV. The appellant asserted the Director erred in approving PDF application based on comments received from the Fire Marshall and because the final PUD plan did not conform to the tentative plan. Likewise, the appellant asserted the Director erred in approving the SDR application because the applicant failed to demonstrate compliance with certain standards in the /WR overlay zone. The hearings official addresses these and other issues raised in opposition to the Director's Decision below. Summary of Hearing: The city scheduled a hearing for April 29 for the hearings official to consider the appeal, and mailed notice of the hearing on April 9. On April 21, the city issued a supplemental notice to clarify that, in accordance with EC 9.7606(3), the hearing would not be limited to the issues the appellant identified in its appeal statement. The city reiterated this point in the April 22 memorandum/staff report to the hearings official (the “Staff Report”).4 At the April 29 hearing, the hearings official described the order of proceedings and made statements required by Oregon law and the Code regarding the rights and obligations of parties. The hearings official declared he had no ex parte contacts prior to the hearing and that he was free of any bias or conflicts of interest. The hearings official invited any challenges to his ability to conduct the hearing. There were none. At the hearing, staff made a presentation and ultimately recommended the hearings official affirm the Director's Decision, subject to adding a condition requiring the applicant to submit an 2 See conditions 10-12 of the Director's Decision. 3 See conditions 1-9 of the Director's Decision. 4 In addition, at the hearing, the hearings official clarified it was being held de novo, that any party was allowed to submit new evidence and argument, and that the issues were not limited to those raised in the appellant’s appeal statement. PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Final Decision 3 updated site plan and a modification to a condition regarding the use of heavy machinery, as described in the Staff Report. The applicant and the appellant likewise provided testimony at the hearing, and the hearings official received testimony from two members of the public opposed to the application. After the conclusion of applicant rebuttal testimony, the hearings official left the record open pursuant to a request from the appellant. In accordance with ORS 197.797(6) and (7), the record was left open for an initial seven day period until 5pm on May 6 for the submission of any additional evidence, argument and testimony. A second open record period followed, which allowed parties to respond to issues raised during the first period, and which ended at 5pm on May 13. The final period ran through 5pm on May 20, and was limited to allowing the applicant to submit final written argument. Discussion of Appeal Issues: The appellant raised three issues relative to the approval criteria that govern the PDF and SDR applications.5 1. The Director erred in finding compliance with EC 9.8365(1) As noted, this criterion requires the final PUD plan to conform with the approved tentative plan and conditions imposed on that approval. Based on comments from the Fire Marshall, the appellant argued that the final plan showed a section of Tambour Court with a grade of approximately 24 percent, which exceeds the maximum slope of 20 percent that is permitted. Both staff and the applicant acknowledged that this was an error that needed to be addressed before a finding of compliance could be made. To address the issue, staff recommended the hearings official impose the following as an additional condition of approval: Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that includes a profile view of Tambour Court. The updated profile view of Tambour Court shall comply with EC 9.6875 and not exceed 20% slope. The applicant concurred with staff’s recommendation, and included in the record a corrected sheet with an updated profile for Tambour Court, which the applicant asserted meets the standard.6 The appellant stated that if the corrected sheet supplants the incorrect version included in the PDF application, this would resolve the issue.7 5 In an April 29 email and through oral testimony at the hearing, the appellant also described aspects of the subject property they believe distinguish it from previously developed property in Braewood Hills. These include the presence of oak trees, the relationship of the property to Videra Creek, and an assertion that the property serves as a firebreak. However, the appellant does not tie these issues to applicable criteria, nor do they appear to relate to any. Therefore, the hearings official does not consider them further. 6 See April 20 prehearing statement from B. Kloos at 2. 7 April 29 hearing statement from C. Woodward at 1. PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Final Decision 4 Based on the applicant’s submittal and the appellant’s response, this issue appears to be resolved. To ensure a final confirmation from the appropriate city staff person, the hearings official nevertheless includes staff’s recommended additional condition in this decision. With this condition, the hearings official finds this standard is met. In the appeal statement, the appellant also argued that two separate comments from the Fire Marshall undermined the Director’s determination that the application complied with EC 9.8365(1). Those comments related to parking on private streets in the PUD and the adequacy of access to certain lots.8 In response, staff and the applicant asserted those comments relate to standards under the Eugene Fire Code, which are not standards that apply to the PDF application. According to staff, compliance with the fire code will be determined at the time of building permit review. The hearings official agrees with staff and the applicant. The Eugene Fire Code is not applicable to the application.9 The Fire Marshall’s comments expressly refer to sections of the Eugene Fire Code, and unlike the slope of Tambour Court, the subject matter does not relate to conformance with the approved tentative plan. Regarding the adequacy of access to certain lots, the Fire Marshall states that those requirements “will be evaluated at the time of building permit submittal, when such access is proposed.” Finally, the Fire Marshall “strongly recommends” following the fire code regarding parking on private streets, which suggests ambiguity about what the fire code may ultimately require at the time of building permit review. For these reasons, the Director did not err in finding that the applicant complied with EC 9.8365(1). 2. The applicant did not demonstrate compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(a) This subsection states: (4) Construction Practices. Construction within the /WR conservation area, and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: (a) For purposes of this subsection, heavy machinery is defined as motorized or mechanized machinery or equipment capable of deliberately or inadvertently damaging vegetation, or damaging or compacting soil. The following standards shall apply to use of heavy machinery within the /WR conservation area: 1. On sites where soils are susceptible to severe compaction or structural damage when wet or saturated, use of heavy machinery shall be limited to the period between June 15 and September 30, unless otherwise approved by the planning director. 2. Use of heavy machinery shall be the minimum necessary for the use or activity and shall be restricted to those areas where its use is necessary. 8 See March 27 appeal statement from C. Woodward at 3. 9 Trautman v. City of Eugene, 73 Or LUBA 209 (2016) (the standards of the fire code do not apply to PUD applications). PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Final Decision 5 Subject to conditions, the Director found the applicant met this standard. The conditions the Director imposed are listed as follows: 5. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan that shows staging area(s) for heavy machinery. Alternatively, the applicant may include a note on the final site plan stating, “No staging areas for heavy equipment will be located within a Conservation Area.” 6. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan that shows the location of access for and use of heavy machinery within the extent of the Conservation Area impacted by the construction of the road. 7. Prior to final site plan approval, the following note shall be added to the final site plans: “Heavy machinery may only be used in the /WR conservation areas between June 15 and September 30 and will not be used outside of the area shown on this site plan for staging and access to the construction impact area.” According to the appellant, ambiguity exists between conditions #5 and #7. The appellant argued that in condition #5, the note on the site plan the Director allowed as an alternative to depicting the staging areas contradicts the note the Director required in condition #7. The appellant also argued that a condition that simply restates the applicable provision does not demonstrate the applicant has complied with the standard. Finally, the appellant asserted the absence of protective fencing along the conservation area south of the Randy Lane extension results in a failure to comply with EC 9.4980(4)(a).10 While they disagreed that a contradiction necessarily exists between conditions #5 and #7 of the Director's Decision, staff proposed a revision to condition #7 they believed would resolve the issue, as follows (revised language is bolded): Prior to final site plan approval, the following note shall be added to the final site plans: “Heavy machinery may only be used in the /WR conservation areas between June 15 and September 30. Heavy machinery may only be used in the staging area, access area and the construction impact area.”11 In the hearing statement and through testimony provided at the hearing, the appellant stated the revision would resolve the ambiguity between conditions #5 and #7.12 While the applicant asserted conditions #5 through #7 were unnecessary, it ultimately did not object to placing 10 The hearings official finds the appellant has insufficiently developed this issue for review. Moreover, as staff notes, this area will be within the construction area associated with the extension of Randy Lane, and a sediment fence will be required downstream as part of an erosion control permit associated with the construction. 11 Staff Report at 6. 12 April 29 hearing statement from C. Woodward at 3. PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Final Decision 6 notes on the site plan to demonstrate compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(a) with the inclusion of language from (4)(a)(1) in condition #7.13 Based on the absence of staging areas identified on the site plan and the requirement to use machinery only in areas where the use is necessary, the hearings official agrees with the Director’s reasons for imposing conditions #5 through #7 to ensure compliance with the standard. Likewise, the hearings official finds the modifications to condition #7 to be warranted to resolve any ambiguity between the conditions, and therefore includes those revisions in this decision. With respect to the appellant’s argument regarding what is required of the applicant to demonstrate compliance with the standards, the applicant argues that the standards are best viewed as performance standards, as opposed to traditional approval criteria. According to the applicant, they describe how certain activities must be performed on site or within a certain area and do not require a decision maker to weigh evidence to determine whether the standards are satisfied. The hearings official generally agrees with the applicant’s characterization of the standards listed in EC 9.4980. They are not criteria that serve as the basis to approve or deny a proposed development.14 Rather, they establish specific standards or rules to govern uses or development that is otherwise permitted or previously approved, as is the case here. Compliance with the standards may be found based on a site plan or narrative submitted with a PDF application, or may be ensured through conditions of approval, as the Director determined was necessary relative to some of the standards. As staff and the applicant note, if development deviates from the standards of EC 9.4980, the city may compel compliance through a code enforcement action or through the Performance Agreement the applicant will be required to execute pursuant to EC 9.7025(1)(e). For these reasons, and with the modification to condition #7 contained in this decision, the applicant demonstrated compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(a). 3. The applicant did not demonstrate compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(b) This subsection states: (4) Construction Practices. Construction within the /WR conservation area, and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: **** 13 See April 20 prehearing statement from B. Kloos at 4 and May 13 final argument from B. Kloos at 1-2. The applicant also asserts that (4)(a) violates ORS 197A.400. Because the applicant accepts the condition as amended, the hearings official does not find it necessary to determine whether the standard complies with the requirements of the statute. 14 See generally Home Builders Association of Lane County v. City of Eugene, 59 Or LUBA 116 (2009). PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Final Decision 7 (b) Petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process shall not be allowed to enter a stream or wetland that is within a /WR conservation area. The appellant argues the applicant failed to provide evidence demonstrating compliance with this standard. The appellant also argues condition #8 in the Director's Decision, requiring the applicant to add a note to the site plan in accordance with this standard, is insufficient to allow a finding of compliance. Consistent with the discussion above regarding (4)(a), this standard establishes a rule that the applicant must follow in the future during construction. The standard broadly prohibits the applicant from allowing certain materials used during construction to enter a stream or wetland within a conservation area. Other than committing to comply with (4)(b), and noting that commitment on the final plans as conditioned by the Director, it is not clear what specific evidence is necessary to ensure the applicant complies with this rule during construction. The standard does not require any particular type of evidence from the applicant, nor does the appellant describe what would constitute such evidence. The hearings official believes that the applicant’s statement that it will not allow deleterious materials used during construction to enter a stream or wetland within a conservation area, coupled with condition #8 in the Director's Decision, are sufficient to show that the applicant has complied with EC 9.4980(4)(b). Moreover, as discussed above, the city will be able to ensure compliance with the standard through a code enforcement action and/or through an action at law in accordance with the Performance Agreement the applicant will need to execute pursuant to EC 9.7025(1)(e). For these reasons, the hearings official finds the applicant demonstrated compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(b). Other Issues Raised by Opponents to the Application15 Opponents argued that the applicant has alternatives to developing the property, and that it could be used for different purposes or preserved as open space. In addition, arguments were raised regarding the economic feasibility of developing the property. These issues do not relate to relevant approval criteria and are not a basis to deny the application. Arguments were raised regarding the need to ensure that the applicant will comply with state and federal laws. While the applicant will have to meet relevant state laws, and potentially relevant federal laws as well, those laws are not applicable approval criteria that govern the PDF and SDR applications or serve as a basis to condition or deny the applications. Arguments were raised that the condition requiring the applicant to submit an updated profile of Tambour Court is insufficient to show that the final PUD plan conforms with the approved 15 In response to other issues raised in opposition to the application, the hearings official adopts and incorporates by reference the May 13 second open record statement and responses from B. Kloos. PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Final Decision 8 tentative plan and unlawfully defers compliance with relevant approval criteria. The hearings official disagrees. The city will not have to exercise any discretion to determine whether the applicant satisfies the condition. Determining whether the updated profile shows that Tambour Court does not exceed 20 percent slope will be a ministerial exercise. To the extent the city needs to exercise any discretion to make that determination, the hearings official finds that it is feasible and well within the applicant’s ability to ultimately provide an updated profile that meets the standard. Decision: For the reasons stated above, the hearings official denies the appeal and affirms the Director's approval of the PDF and SDR applications. The hearings official adopts and incorporates by reference the Director's Decision, subject to the findings in this decision and the following conditions: Condition #7 of the Director's Decision is amended to read as follows: 7. Prior to final site plan approval, the following note shall be added to the final site plans: “Heavy machinery may only be used in the /WR conservation areas between June 15 and September 30, unless otherwise approved by the planning director. Heavy machinery may only be used in the staging area, access area and the construction impact area.” Condition #13 is added to the Director's Decision as follows: 13. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that includes a profile view of Tambour Court. The updated profile view of Tambour Court shall comply with EC 9.6875 and not exceed 20% slope. Signed: David Doughman Eugene Hearings Official June 9, 2026