HomeMy WebLinkAboutOpen Record memo 1
Date: May 13, 2026
To: David Doughman, Eugene Hearings Official
From: Nicholas Gioello, Associate Planner, City of Eugene Planning Division
Subject: Open Record Period 2
Appeal of Braewood Hill Third Addition Final PUD and Standards Review Approval
(City Files PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02)
______________________________________________________________________________
In accordance with the open record periods established following the public hearing held on
April 29, 2026, staff provides this memorandum to give response to some of the submitted
written testimony by the public during the first Open Record Period which ended on May 8,
2026.
Staff response to testimony submitted by Julie Butler, May 6, 2026
Butler asserts that The Planning Director erred in stating that condition of approval 18 has not
been met. Butler asserts that the Planning Director made a narrow interpretation of condition
18 by applying only EC 9.4980 in the decision and that the condition is subject to all applicable
standards of EC 9.4900 through 9.4980. Specifically, Butler asserts that although the 40-foot
conservation area for the category C stream was established and mapped during the Tentative
PUD process, the 25-foot conservation area for the Category B wetland was not established and
mapped following the standards in EC 9.4920(2)(b).
Condition of approval 18 states the following:
Prior to final PUD approval, the applicant shall obtain Type II Standards Review approval for
the proposed public street extension of Randy Lane and any other utility crossings or other
allowed improvements within the protected /WR conservation area, subject to the
applicable standards at EC 9.4900–9.4980.
It is important to note that this condition pertains only to the extension of Randy Lane and any
utility crossing or other improvements within the protected /WR conservation area and does
not apply to the site generally for future development of the proposed lots. Also, it appears
that Butler possibly conflates her argument as applying to the entire area where the Goal 5
Memorandum
The Atrium Building
99 West 10th Avenue, Eugene, Oregon 97401
Phone: 541.682.5377 | Fax: 541.682.5572
www.eugene-or.gov/planning
2
stream crosse the subject site. The condition of approval only applies to the area impacted by
the extension of Randy Lane. It should also be noted that during the building permit process for
individual lots adjacent to the Goal 5 resource, both the 40-foot conservation area for the
category C stream and the 25-foot conservation area for the Category B wetland will need to be
shown on the plans in accordance with the requirements of EC 9.4920 and EC 9.4930.
As evidenced by the submitted site plans, the construction activity within the protected /WR
conservation area is the Randy Lane street extension and underground utilities within the street
right-of-way along the southern portion of the site. In the area where the street will cross the
40-foot conservation area for the category C stream, the mapped wetlands do not exist. As
shown, the underground culvert east of the street extension area captures the water flowing
through the wetlands and goes underground and daylights within Vedera Park to the west. In
the area where the mapped wetlands end, the 40-foot conservation area for the category C
stream creates an 80-foot-wide protected area that is far greater than the 25-foot conservation
area for the Category B wetland and those conservation areas and setbacks are considered
combined, as required under EC 9.4920(3). In staff’s opinion there is no need to show to the 25-
foot conservation area in this location, nor anywhere other than those areas specified in the
condition of approval.
Staff response to testimony submitted by Dillon Thomson (Fertile Ground Conservancy), May
5, 2026
Thomson asserts that the Final PUD record does not appear to demonstrate conformance with
conditions of approval 18, 19 and 22.
Condition of approval 18
Regarding condition of approval 18, Thomson argues that this condition requires the Standards
Review application to be approved and predated prior to the final PUD approval.
Per EC 9.8005(2) an applicant may elect to have the applications reviewed concurrently, which
occurred in this case. The provisions of Eugene code and respective approval criteria continue
to apply to each application. In the event that the Hearings Official were to deny the Standards
Review application, the final PUD would also have to be denied because the applications were
elected to run concurrently and a finding of compliance with condition of approval 18 could not
be made. Therefore, staff do not find that the condition of approval prohibits the decisions
from being issued concurrently.
Condition of approval 19
Regarding condition of approval 19, Thomson argues this condition requires the Final PUD plans
to not be in conflict with the required 40-foot protective setback from top of bank. Thomson
requests the Hearings Official confirm that the Final PUD plans are consistent with Condition 19
and that the Goal 5 resource and 40-foot setback are correctly depicted and not contradicted.
However, condition of approval 19 specifically requires that all future building permits for Lots
30 through 35 show the protective Goal 5 setback on the submitted building plans. Thomson’s
argument does not indicate how the Final PUD record does not appear to demonstrate
3
conformance with this condition; instead, Thomson requests the Hearings Official confirm the
Final PUD plan in the record is consistent with condition of approval 19 and that the 40-foot
setback is correctly depicted. This argument seems to imply that the Hearings Official should be
able to confirm that the Final PUD plan that exists in the record is consistent with condition 19;
however, condition 19 requires future building permits to demonstrate accuracy with the final
PUD plan. It is noted that should the Hearings Official approve the Final PUD and Standards
Review, the Final PUD plan set would also be approved, which would confirm the location of
the 40-foot Goal 5 setback. Future building permits submitted for Lots 30 through 35 would be
compared with the approved Final PUD plans for accuracy regarding the Goal 5 setback as
intended by condition of approval 19.
Condition of approval 22
This condition prohibits site alteration prior to final PUD approval, which includes site grading,
the removal of trees and other vegetation, impacts to wetlands and the protected stream, and
changes to the existing drainage pattern. Thomson requests that this prohibition be addressed
in the record and that the applicant be notified of condition 22's continued applicability during
the pendency of this appeal.
Staff notes that the applicant had submitted a permit for site development (permit #25-05775)
to include clearing of trees and vegetation, installation of utilities, paving of new private roads
and grading on all the lots. This permit is currently under review and cannot be issued until the
Final PUD and Standards Review applications are approved in accordance with condition 22.
Additionally, per EC 9.7025, a Performance Agreement is required for final planned unit
developments and EC 9.7025(2) states that, “the performance agreement binding the applicant,
and the applicant’s successors in interest, assuring construction and performance in accordance
with the approved final plans shall be executed by the applicant and city and notarized in a
manner suitable for recording prior to issuance of a development permit.” A Performance
Agreement is a signed agreement between the property owner or developer and the City which
describes the scope of work, requires compliance with the approved final site plans, which are
included as an exhibit to the agreement, and lists all the conditions of approval from the
Tentative PUD, Final PUD and Standards Review decisions. The Performance Agreement also
includes remedies for Breach and Liquidated Damages and is binding on all successors in
interest. In accordance with Eugene Code, the applicant is provided with a copy of all decision
documents and notices. Based on these facts, the applicant has been provided clear
information regarding the prohibitions for onsite work prior to permit issuance and, in staff’s
opinion, no additional statements in the record or notices to the applicant are necessary.