HomeMy WebLinkAboutApplicant Second Open Record Letter 5.13.2026.pdfLAW OFFICE OF BILL KLOOS PC
OREGON LAND USE LAW
375 W. 4TH AVENUE, SUITE 204
EUGENE, OR 97401
TEL: 541.954.1260
WEB: WWW.LANDUSEOREGON.COM
BILL KLOOS
BILLKLOOS@LANDUSEOREGON.COM
May 13, 2026
David Doughman
Eugene Hearing Official
c/o Eugene Planning Dept.
99 West 10th Ave.
Eugene, OR 97401
Re: Appeal of Braewood 3rd Addition Final PUD (PDF 25-01, SDR 25-02)
Applicant’s Second Open Record Period Statement
Dear Mr. Doughman:
The applicant did not file additional materials in the First Open Record Period.
This is the applicant’s Second Open Record Submittal. It responds to the three 5/6 submittals by
Butler, Green and Dillon.
Butler May 6 Submission:
Butler raises an issue that is physically and legally unrelated to either the final PUD or Standards
Review. If we understand the Butler issue correctly, the argument is that tentative PUD
Condition 18 says that the Standards Review must be obtained “subject to the applicable
standards at EC 9.4900-9.4980,” and that global reference to all the standards related to the /WR
Water Resources Conservation Zone requires a revisiting of where setbacks should apply in the
project – that is, that reference requires a second trip through the review that was conducted in
the tentative PUD review.
There is nothing about the language of the condition that requires reading it as conducting the
same review twice. The condition is better understood as requiring applying any standards in the
/WR code sections that are relevant to the Standards Review inquiry. That limitation seems plain
in its use of the term “applicable.”
Furthermore, it should be noted that the 2B wetland, as shown on the Site Plan, is a smidge of
wetland that is quite remote from the footprint of all the work to be done as part of Standards
Review.
Green May 6 Submission:
The Green submittal discusses alternative possible uses of the property, which are not relevant to
the applications at issue.
David Doughman
May 13, 2026
Page 2
Dillon Submission:
Condition 18: The Dillon argument regarding PUD Condition 18 suggests that the
Standards Review approval needs to precede the Final PUD approval in order to satisfy
Condition 18. The applicant suggests that the HO indicate that the Standards Review is signed
prior to the Final PUD.
Condition 19: This Dillon argument requests that the HO make a new determination that
all 40-foot conservation setbacks shown on the final Site Plan are accurate. The applicant’s
materials vouch that the final Site Plan submitted complies with Condition 19 with respect to
setbacks. The Dillon argument does not assert that any setback shown on the Site Plan is
incorrect. Therefore, it does not state a basis for denial.
Condition 22: This Dillon comment notes the continued validity of the prohibition of
vegetation removal, wetland impacts, and drainage alteration pending final PUD approval. The
applicant concurs. It does not assert any violations to date; the applicant is unaware of any; if
there were any, that would be a matter for enforcement.
Part III of the Dillon comments seeks a remapping of wetland and stream setbacks for the
subject property. The gist of this request is a reconfirmation that the various Goal 5
Conservation setbacks are accurately mapped in the record. This request, in effect, reflects
revisiting the application of the original standards for review/evaluation of the tentative PUD
standards. That kind of inquiry is not relevant to either the standards for final PUD approval or
Standards Review approval.
Part IV of the Dillon comments points to a July 25, 2025, jurisdictional determination by
the Army Corps which relates to Wetland 2B, which, according to the mapping, amounts to
0.016 acres – two strips of linguini or, maybe, just capellini. The comment requests information
on the applicant’s plans for these wetland strips. Federal wetland jurisdiction areas need to be
respected by all, wherever they are and whenever they are determined. This issue, however, is
not relevant to the standards at issue here.
Sincerely,
Bill Kloos
Bill Kloos