Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutApplicant Final Argument 5.13.2026LAW OFFICE OF BILL KLOOS PC OREGON LAND USE LAW 375 W. 4TH AVENUE, SUITE 204 EUGENE, OR 97401 TEL: 541.954.1260 WEB: WWW.LANDUSEOREGON.COM BILL KLOOS BILLKLOOS@LANDUSEOREGON.COM May 13, 2026 David Doughman Eugene Hearing Official c/o Eugene Planning Dept. 99 West 10th Ave. Eugene, OR 97401 Re: Appeal of Braewood 3rd Addition Final PUD (PDF 25-01, SDR 25-02) Applicant’s Final Argument Dear Mr. Doughman: Please accept this final argument into the record. This submittal is intended to be strictly argument, without any evidence. If anything is viewed as evidentiary in nature, please strike it. Suggested conditions are argument, not evidence. The applicant hereby waives the balance of its time for final argument in order to expedite a final decision. The scope of these two applications is really pretty narrow. Final PUD review is limited to compliance with the approved tentative PUD Site Plan and conditions of approval. Standard review is limited to those standards listed in the code, and many of those standards are in the nature of performance standards for conducting the development in order to minimize impacts on the protected resources. The code provides as number of mechanisms to ensure the Final PUD and Standards Review requirements will be met. You can approve with conditions. Your conditions may include final changes to or annotations on the Site Plan. The Final PUD will be reduced to a Performance Agreement, as required by the code, which turns the land use approval into a contract between the developer and the City. As explained by the staff, every Performance Agreement will include liquidated damages provisions, which will further leverage compliance. All of that amounts to belt and suspenders and strong hands to keep things in place. There is a substantial collection of evidentiary submittals. Staff submittals thus far support approval with conditions. The applicant supports the Staff recommendations. The objections raised fall into a handful of categories: • Some testimony is unrelated to the applications in any direct manner. These include suggestions of better uses for the subject property, speculation about the economic David Doughman May 13, 2026 Page 2 feasibility of actually delivering housing, or threats to resources on the site that are unrelated to any standards, such as impacts on old oak trees. • Some testimony seeks a revisiting of standards that were applied in the tentative PUD review; these are not relevant to the standards that apply here. • Some testimony fails to actually allege specific errors in a way that allows the HO to provide relief. An example would be the request that code setbacks from the stream or from wetlands be reconfirmed as accurate. • Some testimony request assurance that federal or state law will be complied with, such as the testimony relating to a smidge of wetland fount to be subject to Army Corps jurisdiction. This is not the place to tell the applicant, generally, that it must comply with the law. A considerable amount of the discussion at the hearing related to the “construction practices” component of Development Standards in EC 9.4980(4)(a), as incorporated into the Standards Review. The applicant can comply with the conditions recommended by the staff to ensure this standard is met. However, the applicant does not want a condition that would negate the flexibility of last clause of (4)(1): “unless otherwise approved by the planning director.” That flexibility may be critical to what building season the applicant may be able to use. “(a) For purposes of this subsection, heavy machinery is defined as motorized or mechanized machinery or equipment capable of deliberately or inadvertently damaging vegetation, or damaging or compacting soil. The following standards shall apply to use of heavy machinery within the /WR conservation area: 1. On sites where soils are susceptible to severe compaction or structural damage when wet or saturated, use of heavy machinery shall be limited to the period between June 15 and September 30, unless otherwise approved by the planning director. 2. Use of heavy machinery shall be the minimum necessary for the use or activity and shall be restricted to those areas where its use is necessary.” [Emphasis added] As a backstop to avoid this standard being used as a basis for appeal of the approval, the applicant believes this is not a standard that may be applied at all under the provision of ORS 197A.400(1)(a), as mentioned at the hearing. This statute allows only clear and objective standards to be applied to development of housing. It is an entitlement for this application. The standard in 9.4980(4)(a) includes operative language that flunks the clear and objective test. For example: “susceptible to severe compaction or structural damage when wet;” “use of heavy equipment shall be minimized;” and “restricted to those areas where its use is necessary.” Those provisions of the standard may not be applied at all, which makes the standard as a whole inapplicable. David Doughman May 13, 2026 Page 3 The applicant requests a finding that this standard is not applicable under ORS 197A.400. That said, the applicant will comply with the conditions recommended by the staff, provided the bold face code language is included. Sincerely, Bill Kloos Bill Kloos