Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSupplemental TestimonySUPPLEMENTAL WRITTEN TESTIMONY OF FERTILE GROUND CONSERVANCY In the Matter of: Appeal of Planning Director's Decision Applications: PDF 25-01 (Final PUD) and SDR 25-02 (Standards Review) Braewood Hills 3rd Addition — Tax Lot 18-04-11-12 / 00200 Eugene, Oregon Submitted to: David Doughman, Hearings Official Via: Nick Gioello, Associate Planner (ngioello@eugene-or.gov) Date: May 6, 2026 I. INTRODUCTION AND STANDING Fertile Ground Conservancy (FGC) is a 501(c)(3) land trust dedicated to the protection and defense of wild places in the Cascadia region, with a specific conservation focus on waterways, wetlands, riparian corridors, and associated listed-species habitat. FGC submitted written testimony in this proceeding on April 29, 2026, and has standing as an organization that submitted written comments in the original proceeding (EC 9.7605(1)(d)) and is adversely affected by the proposed development's impacts on Videra Creek, a tributary of Amazon Creek and the Long Tom River within FGC's primary conservation area (EC 9.7605(1)(f)). This supplemental submission raises additional arguments based on FGC's review of the Planning Commission's Final Order on the Tentative PUD appeal (PDT 24-1 / ST 24-3, February 18, 2025) and newly received regulatory documentation from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, attached as Exhibit A. II. THE FINAL PUD RECORD DOES NOT DEMONSTRATE CONFORMANCE WITH BINDING TENTATIVE PUD CONDITIONS Under EC 9.8365(1), the final PUD plan must conform with the approved tentative PUD plan and all conditions attached thereto. The Planning Commission's February 18, 2025, Final Order imposed 27 conditions of approval on the Tentative PUD. FGC submits that the Final PUD record does not appear to demonstrate conformance with at least three of those conditions. Condition 18 (verbatim): "Prior to final PUD approval, the applicant shall obtain Type II Standards Review approval for the proposed public street extension of Randy Lane and any other utility crossings or other allowed improvements within the protected /WR conservation area, subject to the applicable standards at EC 9.4900–9.4980." Condition 18 is a condition precedent: it requires that the Type II Standards Review approval — subject to the EC 9.4900–9.4980 /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay standards, for the Randy Lane extension and any other crossings or allowed improvements within the /WR conservation area — be obtained before the Planning Director could issue Final PUD approval. The operative question is binary: is the Type II Standards Review approval decision in the record, and is it dated prior to the Final PUD approval? If the Final PUD record does not contain the Standards Review decision, conformance with Condition 18 has not been established. FGC's understanding from the April 22, 2026, staff memorandum is that /WR construction-practice compliance for the /WR-area improvements was not fully demonstrated on the public record at this stage and instead was anticipated to be addressed through a Performance Agreement. Regardless, the dispositive question for Condition 18 is whether the Type II Standards Review decision exists in the record and predates the Final PUD decision. Condition 19 (verbatim): "All future building permits for Lots 30 through 35 shall depict the Goal 5 resource and its 40-foot setback from top of bank and shall include site plans showing the location of protective fencing subject to the applicable standards at EC 9.4920–9.4930." Condition 19 fixes the operative protective setback for the Goal 5 stream resource at 40 feet from the top of bank for Lots 30–35 — the lots closest to the protected stream corridor — at the building permit stage. This is consistent with EC 9.4920(1)(c), which establishes a 40-foot conservation setback from the top of high bank for Category C streams. The Final PUD plans must not conflict with this setback treatment. FGC requests the Hearings Official confirm that the Final PUD plans are consistent with Condition 19 and that the Goal 5 resource and 40-foot setback are correctly depicted and not contradicted. Condition 22 (verbatim): "No site alteration is allowed prior to final PUD approval. This prohibition includes site grading and the removal of trees and other vegetation, as well as any impacts to wetlands and the protected stream on the subject property including changes to the existing drainage pattern. Any such alterations shall only be allowed subject to permit review and approval, and erosion control measures as required for the proposed work." Condition 22 prohibits site grading, vegetation removal, wetland impacts, and drainage alteration prior to final PUD approval. EC 9.7630(3) provides that the action of the appeal review authority is final. Because the Hearings Official has not yet issued a decision on this appeal, the final city-level action on the Final PUD is not yet complete. There is a strong argument that "prior to final PUD approval" in Condition 22 means prior to the Hearings Official's ruling. FGC recognizes the City portal may display an effective date for the Planning Director's decision; Condition 22 is keyed to "final PUD approval," and EC 9.7630(3) makes the appeal review authority's action the final city-level action. Any site grading, clearing, wetland disturbance, or drainage alteration before that ruling may violate a binding condition of the Tentative PUD approval, depending on how 'final PUD approval' is interpreted in Condition 22. FGC requests that this question be addressed on the record and that the applicant be notified of Condition 22's continued applicability during the pendency of this appeal. III. GOAL 5 WETLAND SETBACKS UNDER EC 9.4920 — AMA-5A AND AMA-5B The City's adopted Goal 5 Water Resources Conservation Plan ESEE Conclusions Summary Table identifies wetland sites in the Videra Creek and Hawkins vicinity. Specifically: AMA-5A ("West Eugene Uplands wetland at Videra Ck," 0.16 acres) is designated Category B Wetland, Limit Conflicting Uses, with a 25-foot conservation setback. AMA-5B ("West Eugene Uplands wetland at Videra Ck," 1.00 acres) carries the same designation. AMA-4 ("West Eugene Uplands wetland at Hawkins," 1.44 acres) is designated Fully Allow Conflicting Uses with no setback. To the extent any of the delineated wetland features on Tax Lot 18-04-11-12 / 00200 correspond to AMA- 5A or AMA-5B — or any other Category B wetland designation under the City's adopted Goal 5 program — EC 9.4920(2)(b) requires a 25-foot conservation setback measured from the jurisdictional wetland boundary. This setback operates independently of the stream setback established by Condition 19. Where a Category B wetland setback applies, the /WR conservation area is the union of the stream setback footprint and the wetland setback footprint, consistent with the combined-footprint framework of EC 9.4920(3): any area within 25 feet of the AMA-5A or AMA-5B boundary is within the /WR conservation area regardless of its distance from the stream. FGC requests that the record confirm which, if any, of the delineated on-site wetland features correspond to AMA-5A, AMA-5B, or AMA-4, and that the Final PUD plans reflect the applicable setbacks accordingly. The record does not appear to include a combined setback analysis — specifically, a plan sheet or exhibit showing both the 40-foot stream setback line and any applicable Category B wetland setback line(s) — addressing both the Goal 5 stream setback and any applicable Goal 5 wetland setbacks independently. IV. USACE APPROVED JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION — WETLAND 2B FGC recently received an Approved Jurisdictional Determination (AJD) issued by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Portland District, dated July 25, 2025 (reference: CENWP-ODG, NWP-2022-30), attached as Exhibit A. The AJD identifies Wetland 2B on the subject property as a federally jurisdictional Waters of the United States. According to the AJD, all other delineated wetland features on the property were determined to be non-jurisdictional. This AJD post-dates the City's Tentative PUD approval process and was not part of the analytical baseline on which prior approvals relied. The federal jurisdictional status of Wetland 2B means that any fill or disturbance of that feature requires a Section 404 permit from the Corps of Engineers. FGC has not located evidence in the City record that the applicant has obtained a Section 404 authorization for any proposed disturbance of Wetland 2B, and requests the applicant and City identify whether such authorization exists and how the jurisdictional status of Wetland 2B is being incorporated into the project's avoidance, minimization, and permitting posture. V. REQUESTS FGC respectfully requests that the Hearings Official: (1) Confirm on the record whether a Type II Standards Review approval under EC 9.4900–9.4980 was obtained and is documented in the record prior to the Planning Director's Final PUD decision. If it is not, reverse or remand the decision on that basis. (2) Confirm whether any on-site wetland features are designated Category B wetlands under the City's adopted Goal 5 program, and if so, confirm that the 25-foot conservation setback required by EC 9.4920(2)(b) is reflected in the Final PUD plans and does not conflict with them. (3) Address on the record whether Condition 22's site alteration prohibition applies during the pendency of this appeal, and if so, notify the applicant accordingly. (4) Accept Exhibit A (USACE Approved Jurisdictional Determination, CENWP-ODG, NWP-2022-30, July 25, 2025) into the record and direct the applicant and City to confirm the permitting posture with respect to Wetland 2B. Respectfully submitted, Dillon Thomson Executive Director, Fertile Ground Conservancy PO Box 11262, Eugene, OR 97440 info@fertilegroundconservancy.org 541-515-7747 Exhibit A: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Approved Jurisdictional Determination, CENWP-ODG, NWP- 2022-30, dated July 25, 2025 (attached)