Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutApplicant TestimonyLAW OFFICE OF BILL KLOOS PC OREGON LAND USE LAW 375 W. 4TH AVENUE, SUITE 204 EUGENE, OR 97401 TEL: 541.954.1260 WEB: WWW.LANDUSEOREGON.COM BILL KLOOS BILLKLOOS@LANDUSEOREGON.COM April 20, 2026 David Doughman Eugene Hearing Official c/o Eugene Planning Dept. 99 West 10th Ave. Eugene, OR 97401 Re: Appeal of Braewood 3rd Addition Final PUD (PDF 25-01, SDR 25-02) Applicant’s Pre-hearing Statement Dear Mr. Doughman: Please accept this pre-hearing statement and the accompanying materials into the record. This is an appeal of a Final PUD approval and related Standards Review by the Director. These kinds of appeals do not come along very often; however, this residential in-fill project has been the focus of the neighborhood at every step in the local process (Tentative PUD and Tentative Subdivision) and at the state (DSL Removal and Fill Permit). The Staff Report will have background information and maps documenting this proposal as a proposed reconfiguration of the last 15-acre piece of the Braewood 3rd PUD that was originally tentatively approved as an 80-acre project in 1999 and is now otherwise fully developed. In that respect, when this project is completed, it will contain lots and dwellings that match everything surrounding it. Typically, it is risky being the last residential jigsaw puzzle piece to be put on the table; suddenly, the last puzzle piece of ground is too precious or sensitive to be developed like the uses that surround it. The Staff Report will provide a competent procedural context. That said, I am attaching here the Hearing Official and Planning Commission decisions on the tentative approvals that preceded these final applications. In summary, your predecessor HO denied the applications for a long list of reasons. On appeal the Planning Commission approved the project with conditions. A LUBA appeal was filed by the applicant, intending to get relief on one condition, and the neighbors intervened. Piculell Properties, LLC v. City of Eugene, LUBA No. 2025-020 (June 3, 2025). Following intervention by the neighbors, the applicant dismissed the appeal. Piculell Properties, LLC v. City of Eugene, LUBA No. 2025-020 (July 10, 2025). Procedural Issue The Notice of Appeal Public Hearing (April 9, 2026) stated the scope of this hearing: “The basis of the appeal is limited to the issues raised during review of the original application and David Doughman April 21, 2026 Page 2 otherwise set out in the appeal statement.” However, both the Final PUD and Standards Review decisions at issue here are statutory “permit” decisions, as defined in ORS 227.160(2), and, therefore, this hearing must allow new issues, not listed in the appeal statement, to be raised at the hearing. This limitation has been corrected in a follow-up notice to all parties entitled to mailed notice on 4/21. It likely will be restated in the Staff Report. To ensure fairness to all parties you should similarly correctly state the de novo character of this hearing with respect to issues. Substantive Issues: Final PUD Section 2 of the Director decision addresses Final PUD review. The relevant standard at EC 9.8365 requires conformity with the tentative plan and conditions. The conditions are listed and addressed beginning at page 20. Compliance is found with the imposition of Conditions 10-12 at page 28. Issue 1: “The Decision contradicts the Fire Marshal’s review and errs in finding compliance with EC 9.8365.” There are several subparts to this alleged error. 1. The maximum slope of Tambour Court has steepened impermissibly from the tentative to the final PUD plans. This criticism is valid. The final PUD plans were in error. This error was discovered and corrected in the city’s review of the engineering plans for this section of private road. The site plans were corrected in that process. The applicant’s engineer has attached a corrected sheet for the record here, which meets the standards and is included in the pending building permit application. 2. Fire Marshall’s “strong recommendation” for no parking signs on the private roads. The Fire Marshall’s Final PUD comments make a recommendation about parking. First, the Fire Marshall’s “recommendation” is just a recommendation. More importantly, the recommendation, which is attached to the Director decision, is unrelated to any requirement of the tentative PUD approval or any condition imposed on the tentative approval. Therefore, the recommendation is outside the scope of the final PUD review. Second, the Fire Marshall bases this recommendation on the Eugene Fire Code. The Eugene Fire Code is not a part of the zoning code. It was not a standard for the tentative PUD approval, and it not a standard for the final PUD. As LUBA explained in Trautman v, City of Eugene, LUBA No. 2015-077 (April 14, 2016): David Doughman April 21, 2026 Page 3 “The city and Meadows respond that the EFC is a technical code that provides standards against which an application for a building permit is reviewed and the site's compliance with the EFC is evaluated during building permit review. Accordingly, the city and Meadows argue, the standards of the EFC do not apply to the PUD application. We agree.” 3. Inadequacy of width of utility and access easements for fire apparatus. First, the Fire Marshall’s comments correctly note that the requirements of the Eugene Fire Code will be applied at the time of building permit review, not that they must be complied with now. In this respect, the HO must resolve this allegation of error similarly to the point above, for the reasons explained in Trautman. Furthermore, there is no basis to otherwise conclude that this is an issue relevant to final PUD review. The issue is not related to any condition imposed on the tentative PUD, and it is not inconsistent with anything shown on the tentative plan. Substantive Issues: Standards Review The standards at issue in this appeal are really in the nature of performance standards. They explain how an activity must be done. They do not state a bar that must be gotten over to get an approval with evidence of how it can be done in advance of an approval. They do not call for an exercise of discretion on the part of the decision maker. Performance standards of this sort require a commitment to act according to the rules of the road. These commitments can be reduced to notes on a site plan; however, whether they are or not, the standards in the code become a basis for monitoring and enforcement. The staff, the eagle-eyed neighbors, and the world at large can monitor the work and drop the hammer if the work jumps outside the stated parameters. 4. Compliance with 9.4980(4)(a) – Construction Practices/Compaction The appeal challenges Conditions 5-7, which were imposed on the Standards Review approval to ensure compliance with the construction practices standards in (4)(a). Both the Director’s conditions and the appellant’s complaint misunderstand the nature of the standard in (4)(a) and what is needed to demonstrate compliance with that standard. The applicant’s written statement asserts that the work will be done in compliance with the performance standard in (4)(a). Applicant Written Statement at 11: “Machinery, tools, supplies and other construction materials will not be stockpiled or stored in the /WR area. Machinery use within the /WR area will be the minimum necessary and limited to the period between June 15 and September 30 unless otherwise approved by the planning director.” David Doughman April 21, 2026 Page 4 The Director found that this statement alone was not evidence of compliance. The appellant endorsed that finding by the Director. Both the Director and the appellant are wrong. The statement by the applicant that it will comply with the performance standard is evidence of compliance with what the code requires. The statement, standing alone, is adequate to approve the use under the (4)(a) standard and to move on. It is OK to tell the applicant to include that same information in a note on the final site plan or to show where equipment will be used or stockpiled or not used. However, as discussed above, such notes or graphic renderings would be redundant to the language of the written statement and to the language of the performance statement itself. The obligation of the applicant is to minimize use of heavy equipment in the Conservation Area. Assuming that “use” might include storage, the applicant has committed storage and stockpiling of machinery, tools, supplies and construction materials outside of the Conservation Area. This standard anticipates that the City, the opponents and the world at large will be monitoring the work done and can initiate enforcement action if the applicant is doing more work than necessary in the Conservation Area. Conditions 5, 6 and 7 are not necessary. That said, the applicant’s proposal for compliance can be reduced to a note on the final Site Plan. 5. Compliance with 9.4980(4)(b) – Construction Practices/Deleterious Materials The appellant is not satisfied with the Director’s conditioning of the approval to require that the final site plans include a note stating that this standard applies to actual construction activities. This standard is similar to that above; it explains how the applicant must go about its onsite work; the applicant has committed to operating in accordance with this standard; the applicant is fine with this requirement being reflected on the site plan. This argument over compliance with this standard is analogous to arguing over a speed limit. If the performance standard were a 30 mph speed limit on a city street, all the applicant could do ahead of time would be to commit to not exceeding the speed limit. That is evidence that the standard will be complied with. It would not satisfy the Director unless the speed limit restriction were written down somewhere, which would be OK with the applicant. However, it does not satisfy the appellant because there is no guarantee that the applicant will not accelerate David Doughman April 21, 2026 Page 5 to 40 mph. The assurance of compliance is the applicant’s exposure to a speeding ticket. Here, the assurance of compliance is the applicant’s exposure to an enforcement complaint. That is a meaningful assurance, as the opponents surround the site, and they have shown themselves to be aggressive at footing and ticking the land use regulation spreadsheets that apply to this site. Sincerely, Bill Kloos Bill Kloos Encl. Sheet C3.0-Grading Update 10' SLOPE EASEMENTDOC. NO. 2003-114114,RECORDED 11/25/200314' UTILITY EASEMENTDOC. NO. 2001-044541,RECORDED 07/18/200114' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT14' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT14' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT14' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT10' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT14' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT10' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT10' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT14' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT14' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASMENTN 22 ° 3 1 ' 5 0 " E 32.9 6 'N 57 °25 '28 " E 34 .95 'N 72°33 '51" E45.29 '44.82'50.00'180.00'10' WIDE PRIVATE JOINT USEACCESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT7' UTILITY EASEMENTDOC. NO. 2003-114113,RECORDED 11/25/20031' WIDE ACCESS RESTRICTION STRIP5' WIDE PUBLIC UTILITYEASEMENTFUTURE 40' WIDERIGHT-OF-WAYDEDICATION7' 7' 7' 7'5'5'7' 7'14'7'7'49.90'30.44 '34.71'7'7'7'7'5' 5' 5' 5' 5' 5' 2''G 2''G 2''G 2''G 2''G 2''G 2''G2''G8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W8''W2''G2''G8''WE E E EEEEEEEEEEEEE E E STOPE N D END 2 ' 'G2''G2''G2''G2''G2''G2''G2''GEEEEEE T[T][T][T][T][T][T][T][T][T][T][T][ T ] 8''W 8''W 8''W 8''W 8''W8' 'WUCUC12''SD 12' 'SD12' 'SD8''SS8' 'SS8' 'SS8''SS8''SS8''SS8''SS12''SD 30''SD 18''SD8''SS 8''SS8''SS8''SS8''SS8''SS8 ' ' S S 1 2 ' ' S D 12''SD12''SD12''SD18''SD12''SD12''SD12''SD12''SD8''SS 8''SS 8''SS8''SS8''SS8''SS30''SD 30''SD 8 ' ' SD 8''SS8''SS8''SS8''SS8''SS8''SS8''SS 8''SS 8''SS 8''SS8''SS12''W12''W8''SSPER AS-BUILT8''SS8''SS8''SSPER AS-BUILTPER AS-BUILT8''SS8''SSPER AS-BUILTPER AS-BUILTHAWKINS LANEHAWKINS LANE RANDY LANEB L A C K T A I L D R I V E RANDY LANE25'VARIES25'VARIES25'25'27.5'27.5'27.5'27.5'2 7 . 5 ' 2 7 . 5 ' 27.5' 27.5'[E][E][E][E][E][E][E][E]CDCDCDGATEGATEGATEGUARDRAIL TRANJBJBEVLT EVLTEVLTJBJBJBTRTRTRTRTRTRTRTELVLTETRTRTRWICVICVICVICV(2)ICV(3)WICV(2)WWWICV(2)SSSDSDDDDDDDDDDSSSSSSDGARDENGATEWOOD PILESDSDSTRSSSBBD12345678101112131415123456789101112131415161718192021222324252628D /WHCRHCRHCRHCRSSSSS927EGRAVEL PATHGRAVEL PATH GRAVEL PATH 12" CPP CULVERTIE = 823.24'24" CPP CULVERTIE = 754.53'24" CPP CULVERTIE = 756.20'8" RCP OUTFALLIE = 879.33'15" RCP INLETIE = 773.10'LOT 1LOT 6LOT 5LOT 12LOT 28LOT 7LOT 2LOT 3LOT 31LOT 22LOT 29LOT 33LOT 18LOT 24LOT 17LOT 34LOT 21LOT 35LOT 25LOT 32LOT 37LOT 4LOT 20LOT 36LOT 27LOT 30LOT 10LOT 15LOT 11LOT 14LOT 16LOT 19LOT 23LOT 26LOT 13LOT 38LOT 9LOT 8>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> > > >>>> >>>>>> HAWKINS LANE RANDY LANERANDY LANE8208 3 0 840 850 8128148168 1 8 8228248268 2 8 8 3 2 8 3 4 83 6 83 8 842 844 846 848 860 870880862 864 866868872874876878882884810808812814816818818820 830840816818818818822 824 826 828832834 836 838 790 800810 788 792 794 7967988 0 2 8 0 4 80 6 80 8 812 814 81 6 820 830 840 850820 830 840 850860770 772 768 766 7 6 4 76 2 758 (755) (760) (765) (770) (775) (780) (785) (790) (795) (80 0 ) (805) (810) (815) (820) (825) (830) (835) (840) (845) (850) (855) (860) (86 5 ) (87 0 ) (875 ) (880 ) (885 ) (790)(795)(800) (805) (810) (815) (820) (825) (830) (835) (840) (845) (850) (855) (860) (865) (870) (875)(880)(820)(825)(830)(835)(840)(845)(850)(855)(860)(865)(870)(875)(880)(885) (890)(865)(870)(875)(880)(885)(890)(895)(900)(905)(910)(915)(920)3C3.02C3.0TAMBOUR LANEWQ1+882+003+004+004+301/C3.0WQWQWQWQWQWQWQWQWQDETWQWQDETDETWQWQTAMBOUR COURTCONTOUR MAJOR (FG)CONTOUR MINOR (FG)EX. CONTOUR MAJOREX. CONTOUR MINORSHEET LEGEND4950(49)(50)STORMWATER WATER QUALITY FACILITYWQAREAS WHERE SLOPES EXCEED 15%DETENTION FACILITYDETCURB & GUTTERCURB &SIDEWALKWATER QUALITYSWALESLOPE AT 3:1 TOMATCH EXISTINGSLOPE AT 3:1 TOMATCH EXISTING21'SHED SECTION4' WALK2.0%EXISTING GRADECURB & GUTTERCURB &SIDEWALKWATER QUALITYSWALESLOPE AT 3:1 TOMATCH EXISTINGSLOPE AT 2.5:1TO MATCHEXISTING21'SHED SECTION5' WALK2.0%EXISTING GRADEOFF-PICULELL PROFILE7757807857907958008058108158208257757807857907958008058108158208251+502+002+503+003+504+004+50EXISTINGGRADEPROPOSEDGRADE-2.00%-5.00%-8.00%-10.93%-19.00%-15.00%2+43.80 PVIS815.34' PVIE55.01' VCK = 5.002+16.30 BVCS 817.54' BVCE 2+71.30 EVCS 810.11' EVCE 2+10.50 GB818.004+06.00 GB 787.42 3+60.05 GB 793.25 3+80.00 GB 790.26 OREGONEXPIRATION DATE:12/31/202788168BRAEWOOD HILLS THIRD ADDITION PUD FEBRUARY 11, 2026 2100216ABAB/FUAB/FUC3.04/21/26 11:11amABackusC3.0File: O:\c\p\2021\2100216-Braewood-Hills-PUD\CAD\PLOT\PUD\2100216-03GD.dwg TAB:C3.0 Plotted: 4/21/26 at 11:11am By: ABackus 800 Willamette Street, Suite 400Eugene, OR 97401O: 541.684.4902F: 541.684.4909www.kpff.comSTAMP2100216-03GD.dwgSCALE501 INCH = 50 FEET501000SCALE:2PRIVATE DRIVE SECTIONNTSGRADING PLAN SCALE:1" = 20'1TAMBOUR COURT PROFILESCALE:3PUBLIC ROAD (RANDY LANE) SECTIONNTS EXHIBITA February 21,2025 https://pdd.eugene-or.gov/LandUse/SearchApplicationDocuments?file=PDT-24-0001 Eugene. NOTICE OF APPEAL DECISION: Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1/ST 24-3) The decision of the Eugene Planning Commission is final.Persons who appeared before the local government orally or in writing may appeal the decision to the Oregon Land Use Board of Appeals within 21 days of the Planning Commission's decision.Appeals to the Oregon Land Use Board of Appeals are governed by ORS 197.805 to 197.860 and OAR Chapter 661,Division 10. A copy of the application materials can also be made available for review at the Planning Division offices.Copies may be obtained at a cost. As a courtesy,the Planning Commission's Final Order (decision),application materials,prior decisions, and all other documents and evidence submitted by or on behalf of the applicant and applicable criteria, general information,and relevant materials for this land use application may be accessed by visiting: On February 18,2025,the Eugene Planning Commission issued a final local decision on appeal,reversing and modifying the Eugene Hearings Official's previous denial of concurrent land use applications for Braewood Hills 3rd Addition,including a Tentative Planned Unit Development (PDT)and Tentative Subdivision to create 39 residential lots,streets,and associated infrastructure improvements.(City Files: PDT 24-1/ST 24-3,City File Name:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition).The result of this decision on the appeal is that the subject applications have been conditionally approved. City of Eugene •99W.10th Ave.•Eugene,OR 97401 •541-682-5481 •541-682-5572 Fax www.eugene-or.gov/planning If you have questions,or would like more information,please contact City staff at the contact information listed below. Nick Gioello,Associate Planner City of Eugene Planning Division 99 West 10th Avenue,Suite 290 Eugene,OR 97401 E-mail:NiGioello@eugene-or.gov Phone:(541)682-5453 vffiBTEyplanning 2 r» INTRODUCTIONI. Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 1 LEugene. On January 14,2025,the Planning Commission held a public hearing on the appeal,At the public hearing,Bill Kloos provided testimony on behalf of the applicant/appellant in support of the appeal and requested approval of the subject applications.One interested party provided testimony that took a neutral position on the appeal and 20 interested parties provided testimony opposed to the appeal and in support of the Hearings Official's decision denying the applications, On October 11,2024,the City mailed written notice of an appeal hearing before the Planning Commission to be held on October 22,2024.On October 16,2024,the applicant's attorney requested a 90-daytime extension pursuant to ORS 227.178(5),and cancellation of the October 22nd public hearing.On October 16,2024,the City mailed a notice of cancellation of the appeal hearing to all affected parties.Subsequently,the hearing was rescheduled for January 14,2025. On January 3,2025,the City mailed written notice of the rescheduled appeal hearing to interested parties. The Eugene Hearings Official held the initial public hearing for this request on July 10,2024. Following that hearing and an open record period for additional testimony,the Hearings Official denied the applications in a written decision issued on September 5,2024 (see Attachment A).The applicant,represented by the Law Office of Bill Kloos,filed an appeal of the Hearings Official's decision on September 17,2024.The applicant/appellant has asserted a series of errors by the Hearings Official related to evidence,findings,and conditions of approval,and has requested that the Planning Commission modify or reverse the Hearings Official's decision and approve the Tentative PUD and Tentative Subdivision applications. This Final Order of the Eugene Planning Commission concerns an appeal of the Eugene Hearings Official's decision denying the applicant's Tentative Planned Unit Development and Tentative Subdivision applications for Braewood Hills 3rd Addition.The subject property is an approximately 15.47-acre vacant site abutting the east side of Hawkins Lane and Randy Lane.The property is zoned R-1,Low-Density Residential with /PD Planned Unit Development and /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlays.The applicant,Piculell Properties,LLC,filed concurrent applications for a Tentative Planned Unit Development (PUD)and Tentative Subdivision,under the City's Housing/Clear and Objective approval criteria for those application types,to create a 39-lot residential subdivision with private streets and associated infrastructure. FINAL ORDER OF THE EUGENE PLANNING COMMISSION ON APPEAL OF THE HEARINGS OFFICIAL’S TENTATIVE PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT AND TENTATIVE SUBDIVISION DENIAL FOR: BRAEWOOD HILLS 3RD ADDITION (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) ^feffij^Planning Commission 5 II.RECORD BEFORE THE PLANNING COMMISSION III.PROCEDURAL ISSUES Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 2 Rejection of Testimony The Planning Commission has limited its consideration to evidence available to the Hearings Official and to the appeal issues identified by the applicant At the Planning Commission meeting on January 28,2025,the Planning Commission reviewed and rejected the following written testimony (or portions thereof)submitted prior to the close of the hearing and record: Bias/Ex Parte Contacts None of the Planning Commissioners disclosed potential bias or ex parte contacts,and no bias or ex parte contact challenges were asserted. Under EC 9.7655,appeals to the Planning Commission are "on the record,"that is,the Planning Commission is limited to consideration of the record before the Hearings Official and may not consider new evidence provided during the appeal process.In addition,appeals to the Planning Commission are "limited to issues raised in the record that are set out in the filed statement of issues."The Planning Commission's decision on the appeal is therefore limited to the issues raised by the appellant and the relevant evidence and argument within the record.A few pieces of new evidence not provided to the Hearings Official and testimony regarding issues not raised by the appellant was rejectedby the Commission as discussed in more detail below. The record before the Planning Commission consists of all the items that were placed before,and not rejected by,the Planning Commission prior to its final decision.This includes all application and appeal materials,evidence,recordings,and written testimony submitted and accepted prior to the close of the record;which occurred immediately following Planning Commission's public hearing,on January 14,2025. Prior to the Planning Commission's deliberations on the appeal,the applicant requested an additional 60-day time extension pursuant to ORS 227.178(5),to allow the Planning Commission more time for deliberations prior to the deadline for a final local decision.The Planning Commission subsequently deliberated on the appeal issues at its meetings on January 28 and February 18,2025,and reached a final decision reversing and modifying portions of the Hearings Official's decision;resulting in approval of the subject applications with conditions,as reflected in this Final Order.The Planning Commission's decision is further detailed below,with findings addressing each of the appellant's 10 assignments of error. Following the applicant's final rebuttal,Planning Commissioners asked several clarifying questions of the applicant and staff and then closed the public hearing and the record for the appeal. 1.The Planning Commission rejected Elaine Hanks'October 13,2024,email because the Planning Commission determined that the testimony included in the email was entirely unrelated to the appeal issues raised by the applicant.Because the Planning Commission is limited to consideration of the issues raised in the appeal,the Planning Commission cannot consider Ms.Hanks'testimony. 6 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 3 7.The Planning Commission rejected the following portions of Larry Smith's January 14,2025, submitted video testimony because the Planning Commission determined that they were unrelated to the appeal issues raised by the applicant and/or constituted new evidence not provided to the Hearings Official: 6.The Planning Commission rejected the following portions of Larry Smith's January 13,2025, testimony because the Planning Commission determined that they were unrelated to the appeal issues raised by the applicant and/or constituted new evidence not provided to the Hearings Official: a.The entirety of the second-to-last paragraph and the first two sentences of the final paragraph under the heading "1)A Long Series of Plans,"because these portions of Mr.Smith's testimony were unrelated to the appeal issues raised by the applicant; and, b.The text and Figure 6 under heading 4 on page 8 of Mr.Smith's letter,because it includes new evidence that was not available to the Hearings Official. 5.The Planning Commission rejected the third full paragraph of Carol Scherer's January 12, 2025,email because the Planning Commission determined that testimony was unrelated to the appeal issues raised by the applicant.Because the Planning Commission is limited to consideration of the issues raised in the appeal,the Planning Commission cannot consider those pieces of Ms.Scherer's testimony. 4.The Planning Commission rejected the first four sentences of the third paragraph and the entirety of the fourth paragraph (all related to traffic)of Beth Kitselman's January 12,2025, email because the Planning Commission determined that testimony was unrelated to the appeal issues raised by the applicant.Because the Planning Commission is limited to consideration of the issues raised in the appeal,the Planning Commission cannot consider those pieces of Ms.Kitselman's testimony. 2.The Planning Commission rejected the following portions of Deborah Killian's October 13, 2024,email because the Planning Commission determined that they were unrelated to the appeal issues raised by the applicant.Because the Planning Commission is limited to consideration of the issues raised in the appeal,the Planning Commission cannot consider the following portions of Ms.Killian's testimony: a.The third sentence of the third paragraph regarding wildlife and fencing; b.The second sentence of the fifth paragraph regarding a traffic study; c.The entirety of the sixth and seventh paragraphs regarding density and affordable housing;and, d.The final sentence of paragraph eight regarding the use of the land as a park. 3.The Planning Commission rejected the paragraphs numbered 2 and 5 in Elaine Hanks' January 5,2025,email because the Planning Commission determined that testimony was unrelated to the appeal issues raised by the applicant.Because the Planning Commission is limited to consideration of the issues raised in the appeal,the Planning Commission cannot consider those pieces of Ms.Hanks'testimony. 7 FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAWIV. Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 4 After consideration of the applicable law and all argument and evidence in the record,the Planning Commission finds that the subject applications meet all applicable Tentative PUD approval criteria from EC 9.8325,and all applicable Tentative Subdivision approval criteria from EC 9.8520 as specified by the Hearings Official,with the additional findings and conditions of approval Consideration of Testimony Rejected by the Hearings Official The Hearings Official rejected and declined to consider some of the applicant's testimony that was timely submitted during the second open record period following the initial public hearing (dated August 14,2024)because she concluded that the testimony was new evidence,and that new evidence was not allowed during the second open record period.This evidentiary issue is discussed in detail below under Appeal Issue #1,and as discussed in greater detail below,the Planning Commission finds that all the applicant's evidence submitted on August 14,2024,was responsive to argument and evidence submitted during the first open record period ending on July 31,2024,and therefore it should have been considered by the Hearings Official.The evidence rejected by the Hearings Official is therefore included within the record for this decision and was considered by the Planning Commission as part of the Commission's decision on this appeal. The testimony that was received by City staff after the close of the record on January 14,2025, was not placed before the Planning Commission and is therefore also excluded from Planning Commission's consideration on the appeal. 9.The Planning Commission rejected the paragraphs numbered 1,2 and 5 in the letter attached to Keri Green's January 14,2025,email sent at 5:29 p.m.because the Planning Commission determined that they were unrelated to the appeal issues raised by the applicant.Because the Planning Commission is limited to consideration of the issues raised in the appeal,the Planning Commission cannot consider those pieces of Ms.Green's testimony. 8.The Planning Commission rejected the entirety of the table and the fourth through sixth paragraphs (all related to wetland fill permits)on the first page of Al LePage's January 14, 2025,testimony because the Planning Commission determined that they were unrelated to .the appeal issues raised by the applicant.Because the Planning Commission is limited to consideration of the issues raised in the appeal,the Planning Commission cannot consider those portions of Mr.LePage's testimony. a.The portion of the video that showed Figure 6 from Smith's January 13,2025, written testimony because the testimony included new evidence that was not available to the Hearings Official;and, b.The portion of the video that showed a photograph from the applicant's neighborhood meeting and Mr.Smith's various statements purporting Bill Kloos and Carl Schirmer (applicant's agents)having expressed misgivings about various aspects of the project,because these portions of Mr.Smith's testimony were unrelated to the appeal issues raised by the applicant. 8 The applicant also asserts that the Hearings Official erroneously determined that the applicant Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page5 Hearings Official's Decision Following the initial public hearing,the Hearings Official left the record open for three consecutive periods.During the first open record period anyone could submit any information,including new evidence and argument.There was some confusion and inconsistent instruction about whether new evidence was allowed during the second open record period.Only the applicant could submit testimony during the third open record period and that testimony was limited to argument -no new evidence was allowed.The applicant submitted new rebuttal evidence during the second open record period.The Hearings Official rejected and refused to consider that evidence.The Hearings Official's rejection of the evidence appears to stem from two assumptions:first,that no new evidence was permitted during the second open record period;and second,that the applicant was inappropriately attempting to use ORS 197.522 to submit new evidence into a closed record. Summary of Applicant's Argument The applicant argues that the evidence the applicant submitted during the second open record period on August 14,2024,was rebuttal evidence,as it directly responded to testimony submitted during the first open record period.The applicant further argues that rebuttal evidence was allowed during the second open record period both by ORS 197.797(6)(c)and by the July 10,2024, open record notice included in the application file and posted on the City's website.The applicant asserts the following: The written appeal statement submitted by Bill Kloos as the applicant's representative includes 10 appeal issues identifying alleged errors in the Hearings Official's decision denying the Tentative PUD and Tentative Subdivision applications.The appeal makes the case that the Hearings Official's decision should be reversed and modified,resulting in conditional approval of the subject applications.Each assignment of error in the appeal is set forth below,followed by the Planning Commission's findings of fact and conclusions related to each appeal issue.As noted above,the Planning Commission's deliberations supporting this decision took place on January 28 and February 18,2025. described below.In the event Of any conflict between the Hearings Official's decision and this Final Order,this Final Order shall prevail. The Decision at page 2 para 2 misstates the post-hearing procedures that were followed.The decision says the second open record period was "until 5:00 pm on August 14,2024,for testimony responding to the additional testimony and evidence submitted during the initial open record period."The actual notice given on July 10 stated the second open record period is for:[wjritten testimony (evidence and argument)that directly responds to testimony received during the first open record period."The notice given matches state law -ORS 197.797(6)(c). Appeal Issue #1 Applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred by rejecting rebuttal evidence submitted by the applicant during the second open record period on August 14,2024. 9 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 6 First,on balance,the Planning Commission finds that the open record instructions were intended to allow new evidence during the second open record period,as long as the new evidence directly responded to testimony provided during the first open record period.Second,the Commission finds that although the applicant's materials could have been more clearly written,the applicant did not intend to invoke ORS 197.522 or amend the application.The Commission finds that the new evidence presented by the applicant during the second open record period is intended to rebut testimony submitted during the first open record period and should therefore be considered by the Planning Commission. Planning Commission's Determination For the reasons articulated below,the Planning Commission reverses this portion of the Hearings Official's decision and will therefore consider the evidence the applicant submitted during the second open record period. The applicant argues that the evidence submitted on August 14,2024,was limited to rebuttal evidence and should be considered. modified the application by invoking ORS 197.522.The applicant argues:"[T]he applicant stated an intent to amend the proposal as needed to secure an approval,as allowed by ORS 197.522. Nothing in the applicant's submittal invokes a 197.522 proceeding before the Hearing Official. Nothing in the second open record submitted requested to modify the proposal." Both sets of open record instructions provided that the third open-record period was only open to the applicant and the applicant was only allowed to submit "[wjritten argument (not evidence) that directly responds to testimony received during the first and second open record periods." The Planning Commission finds that the PowerPoint instructions shown at the public hearing The open record notice included in the application file and posted on the website is consistent with the City's usual practice,and more importantly,is consistent with the quasi-judicial procedures required by ORS 197.797(6)and the caselaw interpreting those procedures.See Landwatch Lane County v.Lane County,75 Or LUBA 302,307-08 (2017)(new evidence is allowed during the second open record period as long as it responds to evidence and argument submitted during the first open record period);see also Friends of the Hood River Waterfront v.City of Hood River,67 Or LUBA 179,195-96 (2013). Open Record Instructions The Planning Commission finds that Planning staff mistakenly provided two different sets of open record instructions to interested parties.One set of open record instructions was provided at the close of the public hearing.That set of instructions incorrectly stated that no new evidence would be accepted during the second open record period,only "responsive testimony."A separate set of open record instructions was included in the application file and posted on the City's website. That set of open record instructions correctly stated that during the second open record period "Written testimony (evidence and argument)that directly responds to testimony received during the first open-record period [may be submitted].Testimony received during the second open-record period should specifically identify the testimony from the first open-record period to which it responds."(Emphasis added). 10 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3}Page 7 The Planning Commission finds that the evidence submitted by the applicant on August 14,2024 (during the second open record period),including a discussion of the issue by Kioos in his August 14,2024,letter,Exhibit D titled Randy Lane Connectivity Profile -KPFF Engineering,and Exhibit F titled PDT 18-4 Staff Report and Attachments,is responsive to the new recommended condition of approval.In his letter dated August 14,2024,Kloos also included the following arguments and exhibits,all of which are responsive to sections of the City's Memorandum submitted during the first open record period on July 31,2024,and/or to public testimony submitted during the first open record period as detailed below: During the first open record period,City staff proposed an additional condition of approval regarding street connectivity.The new proposed condition provided: •Kloos argument regarding Middle Housing rights on Lot 39 and no development above 901 feet,is responsive to the City's Memorandum and the discussion of the prohibition of single-unit dwellings and middle housing units on Lot 39 and no development above 901 feet (pages 2 and 3,pages 7 through 10)and the recommended condition of approval The Planning Commission finds that in making her decision,Hearings Official appears to have applied the incorrectly transcribed open record instructions provided at the close of the public hearing,not knowing that the correct open record instructions had also been provided to the applicant and interested parties.The Planning Commission finds the correct open record instructions were included in the notice that was placed in the application file and posted on the website.The open record instructions that were placed in the file and posted on the website are consistent with the quasi judicial procedures required by ORS 197.797(6)and the caselaw interpreting those procedures.The open record instructions included in the notice allow for new evidence to be submitted during the second open record period,as long as that new evidence “directly responds to testimony received during the first open-record period."The Planning Commission hereby reverses the portion of the Hearings Official's decision determining that no new evidence was allowed during the second open record period and instead finds that the record was open to new evidence during the second open record period as long as the new evidence directly responded to testimony received during first open record period. Prior to final PUD approval,the applicant shall submit updated application materials demonstrating that an exception is warranted for Randy Lane under EC 9.6815(2)(h). Alternatively,the applicant may submit for an Adjustment Review under EC 9.68 15(2)(i ), which requires a Type II land use application and is subject to the approval criteria at EC 9.8030(29). incorrectly transposed the "no new evidence"requirement from the third open record period to the second open record period,which is likely why the Hearings Official believed that no new evidence was allowed during the second open record period. Consideration of Previously Rejected Argument &Evidence As discussed in more detail below,the Planning Commission finds that the evidence submitted by the applicant during the second open record period directly responds to testimony submitted during the first open record period and should not have been rejected by the Hearings Official. 11 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 8 1 See submitted testimony (7-10-24 Smith,Larry)referencing a recommended condition of approval for individual lot owners to treat impervious surface flows from their lots.See submitted testimony (7-10-24 Laule,Kim) questioning how individual property owners will provide water retention and maintenance on their own properties. Also see submitted testimony (7-27-24 Lawrence,Grace)citing EC 9.6790(2)and 9.6793(3)(a)concern with individual lot owners building and maintaining water detention systems. The Planning Commission finds that the evidence rejected by the Hearings Official was responsive to testimony submitted during the first open record period and should have been considered by the Hearings Official.The Planning Commission therefore reverses the portion of the Hearings Official's decision rejecting the evidence submitted by the applicant during the second open record period. ORS 197.522 requires local governments to approve needed housing applications that are consistent with,or can be made consistent with,through reasonable conditions of approval,the comprehensive plan and applicable land use regulations,and to deny requiring a site plan revision to remove references to middle housing above 901-foot elevations and a note on the plan for no development above 901-foot elevation (page 10 of the August 14,2024 Kloos letter). •Kloos argument regarding Randy Lane and the demand for public road improvements is responsive to the City's Memorandum and the revised Public Works Referral Comments requiring Randy Lane as a public street and the addition of two new conditions of approval requiring the design and construction of Randy Lane as a public street and the dedication of a 40-foot right-of-way (pages 4 and 5 of Kloos letter). •Kloos argument that the entire site is a Goal 5 resource and its inclusion on the Scenic Sites Working Paper,is responsive to the City's Memorandum and the discussion about the entire site as a Goal 5 resource because of its inclusion on the April 12,1978,Scenic Sites Working Paper (pages 8 and 9,page 11 of Kloos letter). •Kloos argument regarding a proposal to combine Lots 37 and 38 in response to the lack of access for Lot 38 and the inclusion of Exhibit H titled Site Plan Combining Lots 37 and 38 by Schirmer Consulting,is responsive to the City's Memorandum and the revised Public Works Referral Comments and condition of approval requiring that Lot 38 have frontage on a public street or having access to a public street over a private street or proposed private access easement (page 5 of Kloos letter). •Kloos argument regarding a request for an exception to connectivity between the two ends of Randy Lane due to steep topography,is responsive to the City's Memorandum and the revised Public Works Referral Comments regarding street connectivity and condition of approval requiring the applicant submit updated materials that an exception is warranted or submit for Adjustment review (page 4 of Kloos letter). •Kloos Argument about Stormwater planning for Middle Housing buildout ahd a request for a condition of approval requiring on-site detention for any lots that are developed with Middle Housing,and the inclusion of Exhibit I titled Storm Water Memo -KPFF Engineering,is responsive to various submitted pieces of testimony1 regarding stormwater runoff from individually owned and developed lots. ORS 197.522 As the Hearings Official explained (see Hearings Official's Decision,page 4): 12 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 9 The Planning Commission finds that nothing in the applicant's submitted materials invokes a 197.522 proceeding before the Hearings Official,and the applicant's second open record submittal did not modify the applications.The applicant's submittals to date have been appropriately limited to evidence,argument and proposed conditioning in response to staff's post-hearing submittals. The Planning Commission finds that the applicant did not intend to invoke ORS 197.522 to amend the application,but instead intended to remind the Hearings Official of the applicant's entitlement under ORS 197.522 to amend the application in the event the application was denied.The applicant's appeal statement confirms this understanding. The applicant is also entitled to amend the proposal,including with modifications and additional evidence,if that is what is needed for approval.See generally ORS 197.522. The applicant believes that it is entitled to approval,as submitted here and suggested for modest changes,under clear and objective standards. ORS 197.522 does not,however,authorize the applicant to achieve this end outside the public hearing process or without giving the public an opportunity to participate.The applicant cannot simply amend its application "on the fly"-or introduce new evidence into the record after the record has closed for new evidence -and demand that ORS 197.522 entitles it to an approval. applications that are not.ORS 197.522(3)allows an applicant to amend its application or to propose reasonable conditions to make its application consistent with the comprehensive plan and applicable land use regulations. For all the reasons discussed above,the Planning Commission reverses the portion of the Hearings Official's decision rejecting the new evidence submitted by the applicant during the second open record period.Because the Planning Commission finds that all the applicant's testimony (evidence and argument)submitted on August 14,2024,is responsive to testimony submitted during the first open record period,the Planning Commission will consider that testimony as part of the record in this appeal to the extent it is relevant to applicable approval criteria and/or conditions of approval. Although the applicant's materials could have been worded more clearly,the Planning Commission finds that the applicant did not intend to invoke ORS 197.522 before the Hearings Official.In the applicant's August 14,2024,submission,the applicant mentions ORS 197.522 only one time (page 3),stating: Appeal Issue #2: Applicant argues that because the subject property is shown on the Scenic Sites Working Paper Figure H-2,it is a Goal 5 resource;therefore,the tree preservation standards referenced in EC 9.8325 do not apply and the Hearings Official erred by denying applicant's application. Regarding Goal 5 resources and the inclusion of the Scenic Sites Working Paper Figure H-2 as evidence,the applicant raises three sub-issues: 13 The relevant approval criterion at EC 9.8325(3)states: Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 10 City staff have always taken the position that the subject property is depicted as a Goal 5 protected area on a map (Figure H-2)that is a part of the City's adopted 1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper,which was identified by both the Eugene City Council and the Oregon Land Use Board of Appeals (LUBA)as part of the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory and was acknowledged by Oregon's Land Conservation and Development Commission (LCDC). In this case,the applicant has not submitted evidence demonstrating compliance with the City's tree preservation and removal standards.If the subject property is not included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,the applicant's lack of demonstrated compliance with the City's tree preservation and removal standards is a basis for denial of the application.Therefore,the question on appeal is whether the entire subject property is included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory;specifically,whether Figure H-2 is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,and whether the entire subject property is depicted on that map. Background When an applicant chooses to have a PUD application evaluated pursuant to the City's Housing/Clear and Objective standards,as this applicant did,if the property that is the subject of the application is not included on the City's acknowledged Statewide Planning Goal 5 inventory, the applicant must demonstrate compliance with the tree preservation and removal standards in EC 9.6880 to 9.6885.However,if the subject site is included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,the applicant does not need to demonstrate compliance with the City's tree preservation and removal standards. (a)The Hearings Official erred by assigning to the applicant the burden of proving whether Figure H-2 in the Scenic Sites Working Paper is a part of the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. (b)If the Hearings Official cannot determine whether the subject property is on the Scenic Areas inventory,then that piece of the Goal 5 program is not "clear"enough to be applied. (c)The City should decide that the acknowledged Goal 5 Scenic Sites Inventory is shown on Figure H-2. EC 9.8325(3):For areas not included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,the PUD preserves existing natural resources by compliance with the provisions of EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885 Tree Preservation and Removal Standards. The applicant initially argued to the Hearings Official that a different map (Map 3)was acknowledged by LCDC instead of Figure H-2.Map 3 does not depict the subject property as a Goal 5 protected area.The applicant initially argued to the Hearings Official that only the stream running through the subject property is protected by Goal 5;the rest of the property is not protected.Planning staff agreed with the applicant that the stream corridor is protected by Goal 5 but continued to take the position that the entire site is included as part of the City's Goal 5 inventory by way of the Scenic Sites Working Paper,as demonstrated by its depiction on Figure H- 2.,and as discussed in more detail below. 14 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 11 The staff presentation during the Hearing Official's public hearing on July 10,2024,provided a visual illustration showing how the City determined that the subject property is included within the area of visual prominence and prominent vegetation on Figure H-2 using streets as reference points for locating the subject property.The following illustration was shown during the public hearing and included in the staff memorandum dated July 31,2023.The left side graphic is a blow up from Figure H-2;the right side graphic is a screen shot from the City's GIS aerial data.The red lines correlate to the same identifiable streets in both graphics and the yellow star depicts the general location of the subject site in both graphics: The Hearings Official questions the City's finding from the July 2024 staff report that the April 12, 1978,Scenic Sites Working Paper designates the subject property as one of the "Natural Sites of Visual Prominence and Prominent and Plentiful Vegetation"protected as part of the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.City staff entered into the record "Figure H-2",titled "Metro Plan Update,Natural Assets and Constraints-Working Papers Scenic Areas"during the first open record period as an attachment to a Staff Memorandum dated July 31,2024.Staff argued that Figure H-2 generally identifies the entire subject property (as well as a large swath of the City's South, Southwest,and East Hills)as a part of the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. Hearings Official's Decision On pages 8 through 16 of her decision,the Hearings Official discusses whether the subject property has status as a "Goal 5 site,"and questions if this site is included in its entirety in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. Therefore,the specific question before the Planning Commission is whether the entire subject property is protected by Goal 5 because it is shown on a map that was acknowledged by LCDC as part of the City's Goal 5 inventory. Following the public hearing before the Hearings Official,the applicant changed its position to mirror that of Planning staff;that is,the applicant began to argue that:the entire property is a protected Goal 5 area;the entire property is discussed in the Scenic Sites Working Paper;and the entire property is depicted as a Goal 5 area on Figure H-2.The applicant also argued that the Oregon Land Use Board of Appeals (LUBA)has already determined that Figure H-2 and the Scenic Sites Working Paper are part of the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.The Hearings Official thoroughly considered the arguments made by the applicant,Planning staff,and other interested parties,and ultimately determined that,while the City's adopted Scenic Sites working paper is part of the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,given the confusion about which map was acknowledged by LCDC,the applicant had not sufficiently demonstrated that the entire subject property is included in the City's Goal 5 inventory.Because the applicant had not either:(1) demonstrated compliance with the tree preservation and removal standards,or (2)demonstrated that the entire subject property was protected by Goal 5 and therefore the applicant was not required to demonstrate compliance with the City's tree preservation and removal standards;the Hearings Official denied the PUD and Tentative Subdivision applications. 15 I3TH »| I tf Additionally,on page 14 of her decision,the Hearings Official acknowledged that LUBA: Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 12 On pages 9 and 10 of her decision,the Hearings Official discusses that during the July 10,2024, public hearing,and in a written hearing memorandum dated July 10,2024,the applicant argued that,with the exception of the protected upland stream corridor on the subject property,the site is not a part of the City's Goal 5 inventory.However,the Hearings Official then notes that in the applicant's August 14,2024,response testimony,the applicant reversed position and agreed with Planning staff that the entire property is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.The Hearings Official also considered post-hearing testimony from Lloyd Helikson,which extensively analyzed the 1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper,listed the document's limitations,and argued that the Scenic Sites Working Paper should not have been the basis for the City's Goal 5 inventory. While recognizing the limitations of Goal 5 documents drafted more than 40 years ago,on pages 14 and 15 of her decision,the Hearings Official ultimately concluded that in 1982,the Scenic Sites Working Paper "and other similar working papers,likely did form the basis for the Metro Plan Goal 5 acknowledgment"and therefore the Scenic Sites Working Paper is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. It was also noted during the public hearing that a protected upland stream corridor exists on the subject property,which is listed on the City's adopted Goal 5 Water Resources Inventory (2005) and is reflected by the /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay Zone placed on this property. [D]id appear to recognize that,in 1982 the Metro Plan acknowledgment relied on the imprecise Working Papers as the basis for [the]Metro Plan Goal 5 inventory.As LUBA explained: Identifying the City's Goal 5 inventory is not an easy task,in part because it was adopted as part of a regional planning process,and in part because the inventory consists,as far as we can tell,of a large collection of various "working papers"and maps. 5 o I STH il w f 2<TH 'I I s.L 5 % 16 Homebuilders v.City of Eugene,41 Or LUBA 370,428 (2002). [Footnote 17]The LUBA finding states: (Hearings Official's Decision,page 14). Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 13 Summary of Applicant's Argument The applicant argues that if the Scenic Sites Working Paper Figure H-2 is an acknowledged map of Goal 5 resources,then the Tree Preservation and Removal Standards at EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885 do not apply because the entire site is identified on Figure H-2 and therefore the entire site should be considered a Goal 5 resource.The applicant also argues that the mapped Goal 5 Water Resource (stream)located on a portion of the site operates to make the entire site a Goal 5 resource.The applicant points to Exhibit G of the applicant's August 14,2024,submission -the Hearings Official's decision on the Willow Springs Subdivision application (ST 04-12)-and argues in that The Hearings Official considered the narrative Scenic Sites Working Paper and Figure H-2 to be separate documents and determined that although the Working Paper is part of the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,there was not enough evidence in the record to conclude that Figure H-2 was acknowledged,or to conclude that the entire subject property was identified as a Goal 5 protected area on any document acknowledged by LCDC. After summarizing different categories of inventoried resources (for purposes of determining whether,or the extent to which various provisions of the City's Land Use Code Update (LUCU)impacted continued Goal 5 compliance)LUBA did appear to recognize that the Scenic Sites Working Paper map formed the basis of the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. The Hearings Official ultimately determined that,except for the clearly identified stream corridor located on the subject property,the record does not demonstrate that the subject property is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.The Hearings Official declared that unless the applicant demonstrates that the entirety of the subject property is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory or provides a demonstration of compliance with EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885 Tree Preservation and Removal Standards,the criterion at EC 9.8325(3)is not satisfied. Thus,while it is far from clear,it appears that 1982 Metro Plan acknowledged the Scenic Sites Working Paper as part of the [City's]acknowledge^]Goal 5 inventory.Consequently, while the Helikson analysis clearly articulates the limitations of that Working Paper and establishes that it was likely a preliminary assessment that was not intended to create a Goal 5 inventory of specific Goal 5 resource sites,it is what the City has adopted.And,that adoption cannot be collaterally attacked through the review of this application. "Significant scenic areas are not listed in any resource list,but instead are mapped at Figure H-2.***Buttes,ridgelines,viewpoints with public access,parklands,golf courses and cemeteries are identified as scenic areas on Figure H-2.Apparently some of the VWWH [significant vegetation,wildlife,and wildlife habitat]sites [are also scenic areas.] Homebuilders v.City of Eugene,41 Or LUBA 370,428-29 (2002)." 17 Homebuilders v.City of Eugene,41 Or LUBA 370,428 (2002)(emphasis added). Homebuilders v.City of Eugene,41 Or LUBA 370,428-29 (2002)(emphasis added). Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 14 LUBA then went on to discuss the various documents that make up the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,including Figure H-2. Further,the Planning Commission acknowledges that LUBA has previously determined that both the Scenic Sites Working Paper and Figure H-2 are included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.Specifically,LUBA held: Although the Hearings Official refers in several places to Figure H-2 as "unlabeled and undated," the Planning Commission finds that the legend on the upper right corner of the Figure clearly identifies it as a part of the Natural Assets and Constraints Working Papers and also identifies it as a Figure that depicts Scenic Areas.The cover page of the Scenic Sites Working Paper provides that "[t]h is is one of a series of working papers describing the Metro Area's natural assets and constraints."The Planning Commission finds that Figure H-2 is clearly intended to be part of,and to depict,the scenic areas narratively described in the Scenic Sites Working Paper. decision the Hearings Official found that the location of a Goal 5 resource on the site was sufficient to qualify the entire site as an "area"included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.The applicant also asserts the Hearings Official erred in "assigning"the applicant the burden of proving whether Figure H-2 in the Scenic Sites Working Paper is a part of the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory;instead,the applicant argues that the City should have to carry that burden. Significant scenic areas are not listed in any resource list,but instead are mapped at Figure H-2...Buttes,ridgelines,viewpoints with public access,parklands,golf courses and cemeteries are identified as scenic areas on Figure H-2.Apparently,some of the VWWH [significant vegetation,wildlife,and wildlife habitat]sites are also scenic areas. Identifying the City's Goal 5 inventory is not an easy task,in part because it was adopted as part of a regional planning process,and in part because the inventory consists,as far as we can tell,of a large collection of various "working papers"and maps. Planning Commission's Determination The Planning Commission finds that there is sufficient evidence in the record to determine that Figure H-2 is an acknowledged map of Goal 5 resources,and that the entire subject property is depicted on Figure H-2.The Planning Commission agrees with City staff and the applicant that the ScenicSites Working Paper Figure H-2 is an acknowledged map of Goal 5 resources,and that the entire subject property is depicted on Figure H-2;therefore,the Planning Commission finds that the subject property is included in the City's adopted Goal 5 inventory and the applicant need not demonstrate compliance with the Tree Preservation and Removal Standards at EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885. 18 Specifically,the Planning Commission agrees with the Hearings Official's determination that: (See Hearings Official's Decision,page 11). Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 15 Because the Planning Commission has determined that the entire subject property is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,the Commission need not address the applicant's sub assignments of error.However,in the interest of a thorough decision that addresses all the issues raised by the applicant,the Commission provides the following analysis of the applicant's sub assignments of error below. Based on all the above,the Planning Commission hereby affirms the Hearings Official's determination that Figure H-2 is an acknowledged map of Goal 5 resources but reverses the portion of the Hearings Official's decision finding that the applicant failed to demonstrate that the entire subject property is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.The Planning Commission finds that there is substantial evidence in the record demonstrating that Figure H-2 is part of,and clearly depicts,the scenic areas narratively described in the Scenic Sites Working Paper,and there is substantial evidence in the record demonstrating that Figure H-2 is one of the documents that forms the City's adopted and acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.The Planning Commission also finds that there is substantial evidence in the record demonstrating that the entire subject property is depicted on Figure H-2 and is therefore "included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory;"therefore,the applicant need not demonstrate compliance with the Tree Preservation and Removal Standards at EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885. Finally,the Planning Commission finds that when the City updated its Goal 5 inventory in 2005 to include additional riparian,upland wildlife habitat,and wetland sites through the adoption of Ordinance No.20351,the City Council took the opportunity to clearly identify the documents that make up the City's adopted and acknowledged Goal 5 inventories,including the 1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper and to list them in Ordinance No.20351. [Djespite the applicant's attempt to introduce an "ambiguity"into this evaluation,the question [of]whether or to what extent the Goal 5 resource on the property was acknowledged in 1982 does not render EC 9.8325(3)"ambiguous."As LUBA explained in 2022 [in]an appeal of the City's Accessory Dwelling ordinance [in]Conte v.City of Eugene Or LUBA (LUBA No.2021-092 (May 9,2022),"complicated does not equate to ambiguous."Rather,LUBA explained: To be "clear"for purposes of ORS [197A.400],a standard must be "clear enough for an applicant to know what he must show during the application process,"it must be "easily understood and without obscurity or ambiguity,"and it must not be capable of multiple constructions that support diametrically opposed conclusions. The Clear and Objective Requirement The Planning Commission agrees with the Hearings Official's finding that a disagreement over "what,if any,Goal 5 resource was acknowledged"does not make EC 9.8325(3)"sufficiently ambiguous"so that it is not clear and objective under ORS 197A.400. 19 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 16 For all the reasons discussed above,the Planning Commission reverses the portion of the Hearings Official's decision determining that the applicant failed to demonstrate that the entire subject property is included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.The Planning Commission finds that there is substantial evidence in the record to show that Figure H-2 is part of,and clearly depicts,the scenic areas narratively described in the Scenic Sites Working Paper,and that Figure H-2 is one of the documents that forms the City's adopted and acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. The Planning Commission also finds that there is substantial evidence in the record to show that the entire subject property is depicted on Figure H-2 and "included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,"and therefore the applicant need not demonstrate compliance with the Tree Preservation and Removal Standards at EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885. The Planning Commission finds that EC 9.8325(3)itself is clear and objective.An applicant must either demonstrate that the subject property is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,or the applicant must demonstrate compliance with the Tree Preservation and Removal Standards at EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885.The fact that such a demonstration might be complicated does not make the standard unclear or subjective.See Piculell v.City of Eugene,80 Or LUBA 492, 495-96 (2019)(LUBA determined that the fact that the Hearings Official and Planning Commission relied on different rationales to determine that a property was located within the boundaries of the South Hills Study did not make EC 9.8325(2),which is applicable to properties within the boundaries of the South Hills Study,either unclear or subjective).This sub-assignment of error is denied. Appeal Issue #3: The applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred when making a finding of compliance with the secondary emergency access standard on a condition prohibiting any parking on the streets with 21-foot paving. Burden of Proof The Planning Commission finds that LUBA's decisions make it extremely clear that the applicant bears the burden of proof to establish compliance with the applicable approval criteria. Woodburn Petroleum,LLC v.City of Woodburn,Or LUBA (LUBA No.2022-077,January 9, 2023,slip op at 6),quoting Wilson v.Washington County,63 Or LUBA 314, 322 (2011)("[A]n applicant bears the burden of proof to demonstrate that an application complies with applicable approval standards....").The Planning Commission finds that the applicant's statements to the contrary are inconsistent with applicable law.This sub-assignment of error is denied. Willow Springs Decision The Planning Commission finds that the text of the Willow Springs decision does not support the applicant's argument that location of a Goal 5 protected resource (such as a stream)on a portion of a development site automatically means that the entire site is included in the City's Goal 5 inventory.The Hearings Official's Willow Springs decision states a few times that the Willow Springs property is included in the City's Goal 5 inventory,but never explicitly states that Goal 5 protection of a specific identifiable resource extends Goal 5 protections to the entire development site.The Planning Commission finds that the Willow Springs decision does not constitute substantial evidence that Goal 5 protection of a specific identifiable resource extends Goal 5 protection to the entire development site.This sub-assignment of error is denied. 20 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 17 However,the Planning Commission disagrees with the Hearings Official's reference to and reliance on the Eugene-Springfield Fire Marshal's referral comments (dated July 10,2024)and recommendation for No-Parking Fire Lane signage on both sides of the private streets.The Planning Commission disagrees that the imposition of a condition prohibiting parking on the two internal streets and requiring the additional restrictions identified in the Fire Department Planning Commission's Determination The Planning Commission agrees with the Hearings Official that the requirement for secondary access standards for fire and emergency medical vehicles at EC 9.6870 is met by the existing intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive,which will allow for access from the subdivision to the existing street system to the north (Hawkins Lane),to the east (Blacktail Drive),and to the west (Timberline Drive). The Hearings Official discusses the Staff Memorandum,dated August 14,2024,from Public Works staff that explains how the secondary access standards at EC 9.6815(2)(d)are satisfied by the existing intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive,which will allow for access to the existing street system and the construction of emergency vehicle turn arounds within the development site.The Hearings Official notes on page 22 of her decision that,"while the access to the vast majority of the proposed lots would rely on a single access point from the intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive,the express language of EC 9.6815(2)(d)requires only that the property itself have a secondary access;it does not require secondary access to each,or even to a majority, of the lots." Hearings Official's Decision The relevant approval criterion for this appeal issue is EC 9.8325(4)(a)which requires compliance with EC 9.6800 through 9.6875.Specifically,EC 9.6815 (2)(d)states: (d)Secondary access for fire and emergency medical vehicles consistent with EC 9.6870 is required. Summary of Applicant's Argument The applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred in basing a finding of compliance with the secondary emergency access standard on a condition prohibiting any parking on the streets with 21-foot paving.The applicant asserts that the finding is discretionary,therefore not a "lawful" condition,citing the case Olson Memorial Clinic v.Clackamas County,21 Or LUBA 418 (1991). The Hearings Official found that secondary access for fire and emergency vehicles needs to be consistent both with EC 9.6870 street width requirements and Eugene-Springfield Fire Marshal's referral comments dated July 10,2024,recommending "NO PARKING-FIRE LANE"signage be posted on both sides of the Randy Lane and Stonehenge Way,consistent with 2022 Eugene Fire Code,Section 503.2.1.To satisfy the Eugene Code and the 2022 Eugene Fire Code,Section 503.2.1,the Fire Department comments recommend that no parking be allowed on either side of the internal private streets,and that both sides of both streets be marked with "NO PARKING-FIRE LANE"signage.The Hearings Official determined that by prohibiting parking on the two internal streets,the proposed PUD would satisfy the requirements of EC 9.6815(2 )(d). 21 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 18 The Hearings Official addressed this appeal issue on pages 24 through 26 of her decision,under approval criteria at EC 9.8325(4)(a),which requires compliance with EC 9.6815,including subsection (2)(b),unless an exception can be granted under (2)(h).The relevant street connectivity standards at EC 9.6815(2)are as follows: Hearings Official's Decision As previously discussed under Appeal Issue #1,the Planning Commission reverses the portion of the Hearings Official's decision rejecting new evidence the applicant attempted to enter into the record during the second open record period.The Planning Commission will therefore consider the evidence submitted by the applicant on August 14,2024,that is relevant to this appeal issue. Based on the findings above,the Planning Commission finds that the applicant has demonstrated compliance with the standard for secondary access for fire and emergency medical vehicles, consistent with EC 9.6870.The Planning Commission reverses the portion of the Hearings Official's decision imposing a requirement for No-Parking Fire Lane signage as a condition of approval since it is unnecessary to meet the relevant approval standard at EC 9.6815(2)(d).However,the Planning Commission notes that Fire Code requirements will nonetheless (and appropriately)be addressed at the time of building permits. EC 9 .6815(2)(d)states,"Secondary access for fire and emergency medical vehicles consistent with EC 9.6870 is required."The standards at EC 9.6870 only require right-of-way and paving widths. The Planning Commission finds that the Hearings Official erred by imposing requirements from the Eugene Fire Code as part of the Tentative PUD decision because those requirements are not supported by EC 9.6815(2)(d).The requirement for No-Parking Fire Lane signage and other Eugene Fire Code-related requirements will be addressed separately at the time of building permits. (h)For applications proposing housing to be reviewed with ciear and objective approval criteria,exceptions to street connectivity standards may be granted if one of the following conditions exists: 1.Existing building(s)on the development site or on land abutting the development site and under separate ownership obstruct the extension of the planned street.For the purposes of this subparagraph,"building"is defined as a (b)The proposed development shall include street connections in the direction of all existing or planned streets within 1/4 mile of the development site.The proposed development shall also include street connections to any streets that abut,are adjacent to,or terminate at the development site. comments (dated July 10,2024),is necessary in order for the proposed PUD to satisfy EC 9.6815(2)(d). Appeal Issue #4: The applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred by not considering the applicant's evidence submitted on August 14,2024,during the second open record period,rebutting Public Works First Open Record evidence (dated July 31,2024)that the applicant had not justified an exception allowed under EC 9.6815(2)(h)to connect to Randy Lane. 22 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 19 Summary of Applicant's Argument The applicant asserts that the Hearings Official erred by rejecting their August 14,2024,evidence rebutting Public Works first open record evidence (dated July 31,2024)that indicated the applicant had not justified an exception under EC 9.6815(2)(h)to the requirement to connect the proposed extension of Randy Lane to the existing terminus of Randy Lane to the east of the The Hearings Official determined that to the extent the applicant wishes to invoke ORS 197.522, on appeal that statutory process would permit the applicant to amend the application and demonstrate compliance with the EC 9.6815(2)(h)exceptions,while also providing both the City and the public an opportunity to review and evaluate the evidence. Instead of imposing one of the alternative conditions proposed by staff,the Hearings Official determined the applicant asserted its right to amend the application "on the fly"by arguing that "the applicant is also entitled to amend the proposal,including with modifications and additional evidence,if that is what is needed for approval.See generally ORS 197.522."She found that the applicant had submitted new evidence after the record was closed,by amending its application to add a request for an exception to EC 9.6815(8)based on slopes.She also found that while ORS 197.522 may allow the applicant to amend its application,it does not do so at the expense of the required public hearing process. In the Staff Memorandum dated July 31,2024,submitted after the public hearing before the Hearings Official and during the first open record period,staff recommended a condition of approval requiring either that the applicant submit updated application materials to demonstrate an exception is warranted under one of the permitted exception bases in EC 9.6815(2)(h)or that the applicant request an Adjustment Review under EC 9.6815(2)(i). structure designed and used as a place of occupancy.For the purposes of this subparagraph,"building"does not include a shed,carport,detached garage, accessory building,or other structure designed and used solely for storage or shelter; 2.Existing slopes would result in a street grade exceeding current adopted street design standards when measured along the centerline of the proposed streets to the existing grade of the subdivision boundary or abutting property under separate ownership; 3.Provision of public street connection would require dedication of 25 percent or more of the total development site area; 4.Abutting residential land cannot be further divided under current development standards. The Planning Commission finds that the applicant initially requested an exception to the street connectivity requirements of subsection (2)(b)above,which would otherwise require an extension to connect the two existing sections of Randy Lane as a public street though the subject site.The applicant requested an exception to the requirement to build the portion of Randy Lane that would have been constructed above 901-foot elevation to connect through the site;however,the applicant's request was not based on one of the applicable codified exceptions identified in EC 9.6815(2)(h). 23 development. Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 20 Regarding the third consideration,Planning Commission finds that the applicant has satisfied EC 9.6815,by showing that the applicant is entitled to an exception under EC 9.6815 (2)(h ).The Planning Commission agrees with the Hearings Official,who,on page 27 of her decision,correctly Also as discussed in more detail in response to Appeal Issue #1,the Planning Commission finds that the new evidence presented by the applicant during the second open record period was intended to rebut testimony submitted during the first open record period (in this case,the new proposed condition of approval)and should therefore be considered by the Plan ning Commission as the decision-maker. As explained in detail in response to applicant's first appeal issue,Planning Commission finds that the applicant did not intend to invoke the applicant's right to amend the application pursuant to ORS 197.522,and the Hearings Official erred by so finding. Planning Commission's Determination The Planning Commission has identified three major considerations with respect to this appeal issue:(1)Did the applicant actually invoke their rights under ORS 197.522;(2)should the applicant's materials submitted on August 14,2024 be considered part of the record for review; and (3)did the applicant's response to EC 9.6815 within the August 14,2024 evidence provide sufficient response to warrant an exception to the street connectivity standards under EC 9.6815(2)(h)to not require the connection of two sections of Randy Lane? The applicant argues that its August 14,2024,submission was not under the authority of an ORS 197.522 proceeding to amend the application with new evidence.The applicant argues that the evidence submitted did not change the application,but rather it responded to the revised findings from Public Works staff that the applicant had failed to submit evidence to justify an exception to making a street connection.The applicant asserts that under state law (ORS 197.797(6)(c)),the applicant is entitled to rebut the new position articulated by City staff on July 30,2024,with new evidence. The originally submitted application materials requested an exception to the requirement to connect Randy Lane,citing the prohibition on development above 901 feet in the Tentative PUD approval criteria at EC 9.8325(8).The applicant asserts that the initial staff report indicated support for this exception.However,the City's Memorandum submitted into the record on July 31,2024,revised the findings at EC 9.6815(2)(a)and (b)Street Connectivity Standards,and added a recommended condition of approval requiring the applicant to submit updated application materials demonstrating that an exception is warranted for Randy Lane under one of the bases articulated in EC 9.6815(2)(h).Alternatively,the staff memo provided that the applicant could submit for an Adjustment Review under EC 9.6815(2)(i). The applicant notes that the City's written notice given on July 10,2024,stated the second open record period is for:"(wjritten testimony (evidence and argument)that directly responds to testimony received during the first open record period."The notice given matches state law -ORS 197.797(6)(c). 24 found that: Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 21 On page 18 of the Hearings Official decision,she references the initial referral comments from Public Works which determined that the applicant had demonstrated a basis for an exception to the connectivity standards based upon the Tentative PUD approval criterion at EC 9.8325(8)(i.e.,because Hearings Official's Decision The Hearings Official addressed these issues on pages 19 through 21 of her decision,under the approval standards for street connectivity at EC 9.6815(2)(a)and (b)which state: Based on the findings above and Planning Commission's decision that the applicant's evidence (submitted August 14,2024)under Appeal Issue #1,as responsive to staff's proposed condition of approval (submitted on July 31,2024),will be considered by the Commission;the Planning Commission hereby concludes that the applicant's engineers have demonstrated a credible basis for an exception under the street connectivity standards in EC 9.6815(2)(h). The applicant is requesting an exception to EC 9.6815(2)(b),pursuant to EC 9.6815(2)(h)2.,due to existing grades on the site.In the submitted materials dated August 14,2024,the applicant submitted Exhibit E,an annotated graphic from KPFF Engineering that shows existing topography exceeding 20%slope and shows that a street connection to Randy Lane at the southeast corner of the site will not meet current adopted street design standards,more specifically Section 2.05 (J)(4) of the City of Eugene's Public Improvement Design Standards (P IDS),as the proposed street grade would exceed 20%.Public Works staff has reviewed this additional evidence and confirmed that the exception to the street connectivity standards should be granted under EC9.6815(2)(h)2. based on the applicant's evidence of the existing slope conditions. (b)The proposed development shall include street connections in the direction of all existing or planned streets within 1/4 mile of the development site.The proposed development shall also include street connections to any streets that abut,are adjacent to,or terminate at the development site (a)All streets and alleys shall be public unless the developer demonstrates that a public street or alley is not necessary for compliance with this land use code or the street connectivity standards of subparagraphs (b)through (f)of this subsection. [W]hile...it is certainly possible that a different configuration could potentially create a superior design,the applicant's engineers have established a credible basis for an exception under EC 9.8615(2)(h)(2)to compliance with the street connectivity standard in EC 9.8615(2)(b). Appeal Issues #5 and #6: The applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred in concluding that the applicant failed to show there is no "need"for the extension of Randy Lane to be developed to public road standards.The applicant also argues that the Hearings Official erroneously rejected the applicant's argument that the demand for a public road stub is not justified under constitutional law standards. 25 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 22 The July 31,2024,Staff Memorandum also recommended a condition of approval requiring a revised site plan depicting the extension of Randy Lane as a public street and a condition of approval requiring the dedication of a 40-foot-wide right-of-way extending the public right-of-way for Randy Lane from its existing intersection with Blacktail Drive to the proposed terminus of Randy Lane.These proposed conditions included the following constitutional findings: Planning Commission's Determination The Planning Commission finds that the July 31,2024,Staff Memorandum included new recommended findings and three new recommended conditions of approval that would require the construction and dedication of Randy Lane as a public street within a 40-foot-wide public right-of-way.The Staff Memorandum asserted that the applicant needed to demonstrate an exception was warranted under the Housing/Clear and Objective track standards and proposed a condition requiring the submission of updated application materials demonstrating that an exception is warranted for Randy Lane under EC 9.6815(2)(h).As an alternative,the Staff Memorandum recommended a condition allowing the applicant to apply for an Adjustment Review under EC 9.6815(2)(i). Summary of Applicant's Argument The applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred by refusing to consider the applicant's testimony dated August 14,2024.The applicant maintains that the excluded evidence showed there was no need for the street to be public or to meet public street standards because the excluded evidence showed that an exception to street connectivity is justified,due to the steep topography that does not meet the City's limit of a 20%grade for roads.The applicant argues that the Hearings Official should have admitted this rebuttal evidence,found the connectivity exception justified,and agreed that the applicant demonstrated that the Randy Lane extension did not need to be a public street and could remain as a private street.The applicant also argues that the City has not sufficiently justified the exaction with an adequate basis for requiring a public street under constitutional requirements. a portion of the street section that would need to be constructed in order to connect both ends of Randy Lane as a public street through the subject site is above 901 feet in elevation).The initial comments from Public Works staff indicated that on that basis,a public street could not be required for the proposed extension of Randy Lane.However,in the July 31,2024,Revised Referral Comments, Public Works staff revised its analysis and recommendation.While adhering to its analysis that the existing grades precluded compliance with the current street design standards for connections in the direction to the north and northeast,the Public Works staff determined both that the applicant had not established a valid basis for an exception to the connectivity requirement for Randy Lane and also that,in accordance with EC 9.6815(2)(a),Randy Lane should be required to be a public street. [IJt is in the public's interest to have an interconnected public street system in order to reduce travel distance,and have the right-of-way adjacent to residential developments be improved with the full range of City street improvements i.e.,paving,curbs and gutters,sidewalks,street trees and street lights,so that all public amenities are available for motorists,bicyclists and pedestrians.Additionally,requiring Randy Land as a public street will also ensure that all residents of the subdivision will have access to Videra Park,which abuts the proposed extension of Randy Lane to the south. 26 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 23 Summary of Applicants Argument The applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred in requiring a geotechnical certification because the entire site is included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.The applicant argues that the site is depicted on Figure H-2 in the Scenic Sites Working Paper,which is a part of Hearings Official's Decision The Hearings Official addressed this issue on page 35 of her decision.Similar to EC 9.8325(3), which requires that the applicant either that establish that the subject property is included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory or demonstrate compliance with Tree Preservation and Removal Standards,EC 9.8325(5)(d)requires that the applicant either that establish that the subject property is included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory or provide a Geological and Geotechnical Analysis of the site.The Hearings Official determined that the applicant had not established that (with the exception ofthe protected upland stream corridor)the entire subject property is included in the City's Goal 5 inventory;therefore,the applicant was required to demonstrate compliance with the requirements of EC 9.8325(5)(d)for a Geological and Geotechnical Analysis of the site and that the applicant had not provided the required analysis. Based on all the above,the Planning Commission hereby affirms the Hearing Official's finding that EC 9.6815(2)requires that Randy Lane be constructed to public street standards (but does not require connection to the existing portion of Randy Lane to the east due to the street connectivity exception affirmed above).The Planning Commission also finds that the proposed conditions are necessary to ensure that:the applicant provides an updated site plan depicting the proposed extension of Randy Lane as a public street;dedicates a 40-foot public right of way;and provides an irrevocable petition for public improvements.Those conditions,with minor revisions for clarity based on these appeal proceedings,are adopted by the Planning Commission and included at the end of this Final Order along with all other conditions being imposed as part of the decision to approve the subject applications. The Hearings Official incorporated these constitutional findings and proposed conditions into her decision by reference.The Planning Commission hereby adopts and affirms the constitutional findings and determines that the findings establish the constitutionally required nexus and rough proportionality to support the condition requiring the dedication of public right-of-way and construction of Randy Lane to public street standards.The Planning Commission notes that the findings were based on the assumption that there would be no condition of approval requiring the applicant to connect the western portion of Randy Lane shown on the applicant's site plans to the existing portion of Randy Lane to the east.The applicant's appeal argument,which seems to imply that the exception to connectivity would also obviate the need for the construction of Randy Lane as a public street,is without merit,as the findings clearly demonstrate the need for a public street system with public amenities for motorists,bicyclists and pedestrians,and to ensure all residents of the new PUD with access to Videra Park to the south of Randy Lane. Appeal Issue #7: The applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred in requiring compliance with the requirement for a geotechnical certification at EC 9.6710(6)due to the applicant's failure to carry its burden of proof that the site is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. 27 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 24 Hearings Official's Decision The Hearings Official addresses this issue on pages 37 through 40 of her decision,under the approval criteria at EC 9.8325(5)which requires compliance with: Based on all the above,the Planning Commission hereby modifies the Hearings Official's decision by determining that Figure H-2 is an acknowledged map of Goal 5 resources and that the entire subject property is depicted on Figure H-2;therefore,the EC 9.6710(3)(f)exempts the applicant from the requirements in EC 9.8325(5)(d)and EC 9.6710(6)for a Geological and Geotechnical Analysis. The Planning Commission also finds that EC 9.8325(5)(d)and EC 9.6710(6)are clear and objective. Those two code provisions clearly require an applicant to either demonstrate that the subject property is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,or to demonstrate compliance with the geotechnical standards at EC 9.6710.The fact that such a demonstration might be complicated does not make the standard unclear or subjective.See Piculell v.City of Eugene,80 Or LUBA 492,495-96 (2019)(LUBA determined that the fact that the Hearings Official and Planning Commission relied on different rationales to determine that a property was located within the boundaries of the South Hills Study did not make EC 9.8325(2),which is applicable to properties within the boundaries of the South Hills Study,either unclear or subjective.). the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.The applicant further argues that the City,not the applicant,has the burden to show what constitutes the City's Goal 5 inventory for Scenic Sites. The applicant notes that in the event that Planning Commission finds the entire site is not on the Scenic Sites inventory,the applicant will request an opportunity to provide the geotechnical certification in an ORS 197.522 proceeding. 0)EC 9.6791 through 9.6797 regarding stormwater flood control,quality,flow control for headwaters area,oil control,source control,easements,and operation and maintenance. The Planning Commission finds that because the entire site is included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,the applicant is not required to provide evidence demonstrating compliance with EC 9.8325(5)(d)and EC 9.6710(6). Planning Commission's Determination As discussed in detail under Appeal Issue #2 above,the Planning Commission finds that the subject property is depicted as a Goal 5 protected area on a map (Figure H-2)that is a part of the City's adopted 1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper,which was identified by both LUBA and the Eugene City Council as part of the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory and was acknowledged by the Land Conservation and Development Commission (LCDC). Appeal Issue #8: The applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred by not finding that the proposed stormwater system can comply with the city standards for stormwater,even if the system must be adjusted in the event Randy Lane must be a public road. 28 As the Hearings Official further explains regarding Randy Lane at page 40 of her decision: Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 2S The Hearings Official ultimately concluded that based on the Revised Public Works Referral Comments dated July 31,2024,that the requirement to construct Randy Lane as a public street may impact the applicant's analysis and calculations,resulting in changes to its proposed system, and could impact the applicant's proposed stormwater detention system and thus compliance with the requirements of EC 9.6791 through EC 9.6797.The Hearings Official found that given the potential modifications that could be necessitated,whether the proposed development could satisfy the criteria at EC 9.6791 through 9.6797 cannot yet be determined. The Hearings Official's decision includes an extensive discussion of the applicant's proposed stormwater system and opposing testimony,as it relates to compliance with the applicable stormwater standards listed under this criterion,As she describes at pages 37-38 of her decision: Also,as noted in the Revised Public Works Referral Comments,the requirement to construct Randy Lane as a public street may impact the applicant's analysis and calculations,resulting in changes to its proposed system. [WJhile neighbors raise legitimate concerns regarding the proposed "piece-meal" approach,the City's clear and objective criteria do not appear to include any requirements for a more integrated approach or otherwise allow controls over the timing of the improvements.And,while there is certainly conflicting evidence and testimony,the Revised Public Works Referral Comments evaluate the proposal for compliance with each of the EC 9.6791 through 9.6797 standards and finds that conceptually the proposal can satisfy each of the applicable standards.Public Works notes that,at the time of development,the system would be subject to more detailed Bui I ding/Site Development permit reviews.Those findings (Revised Public Works Referral Comments,July 30,2024, pages 21-25)are incorporated and adopted here. The applicant acknowledges that,should it decide to develop the lots under the Middle Housing standards in such a way that the impervious area of each site is increased,the applicant would be required to provide an updated stormwater detention system to reflect that increase. Essentially,the applicant proposes that it will complete initial property improvements, filling the wetlands and completing private street improvements.Thereafter,rather than a single,site-wide stormwater detention and filtration solution for the entire 15-acre property,each individual landowner would be responsible for development of their own stormwater detention and filtration system. Summary of Applicant's Argument The applicant argues that because the finding can be made that the system design can be adjusted to accommodate the increment of stormwater from the public road,the Planning Commission may condition the approval to achieve compliance.In addition,the applicant provided additional argument and evidence as part of the second open record period which was rejected by the Hearings Official and should have been considered in her decision.The applicant argues that the 29 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 26 Planning Commission also takes note of the applicant's more recent suggested modifications to the following condition about analysis demonstrating the feasibility of accommodating (and detention for)stormwater runoff in the event that the proposed lots could be developed with middle housing rather than single-unit dwellings,as described in their written appeal testimony dated January 10,2025 (see Applicant's Outline from Argument to the Planning Commission). The additional condition recommended by Public Works staff to address the stormwater requirement for middle housing to be developed on individual lots,which the applicant now seeks to modify on appeal,was included in a Staff Memorandum submitted during the second open record period (see Staff Memorandum dated August 14,2025)which stated the following: The applicant does not appear to object or challenge this condition on appeal,except for the fact that it requires the stormwater analysis to address Randy Lane being constructed as a public street rather than a private street as initially proposed.Planning Commission agrees that the requirement to construct Randy Lane as a public street may impact the calculations provided in the applicant's Storm Drainage Memorandum dated March 5,2024,and that the Hearings Official erred in not relying on the applicant's evidence and argument provided in their second open record materials dated August 14,2025 (see Kloos letter dated August 14,2025,including Exhibit I,Stormwater Memo from KPFF Consulting Engineers).That argument and evidence,including the engineer's memo should have been considered as responsive to the recommended conditions of approval from Public Works staff related to compliance with applicable stormwater standards. additional information and argument supports a conclusion consistent with the recommendations from Public Works staff that the system can feasibly be engineered in compliance with the applicable stormwater standards.More specifically,that the system is scalable to accommodate on-site detention on individual lots if middle housing is developed (see Kloos letter dated August 14,2025,including Exhibit I titled Storm Water Memo -KPFF Engineering),as well as from from shared driveways and streets in the event that Randy Lane is required to be public. The applicant shall submit an updated stormwater memo,demonstrating the feasibility of a proposed stormwater detention system where the proposed lots are developed with Prior to final PUD approval,the applicant shall submit an updated Storm Drainage Memorandum that addresses the conditions of approval under EC 9.6815 requiring Randy Lane to be constructed as a public street and demonstrate compliance with EC 9.6791-EC 9.6797 based on this change. Planning Commission's Determination In the Staff Memorandum dated July 31, 2024,Public Works referral comments were revised with findings regarding the application's compliance with EC 9.6815 (2)(a)and (b)Street Connectivity Standards,recommending that the proposed extension of Randy Lane,initially proposed as a private street,should be a public street instead.This change also triggers necessary changes in stormwater facilities,as discussed in the referral comments regarding the application's compliance with EC 9.6791 through 9.6797,because portions of the proposed private conveyance system will need to be constructed as a public conveyance system.In order to accommodate these changes,Public Works recommended the following condition,believing it is conceptually feasible to design a public conveyance system that will meet the City's stormwater standards: 30 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 27 These revised conditions provide more specificity about the required stormwater detention for the proposed development,and account for the associated changes based on the requirement that Randy Lane be constructed as a public street.These revised conditions are also appropriate in Based on the applicant's argument and evidence from the second open record period (which is now included in the record and hereby considered),and the applicant's subsequent appeal testimony suggesting modification to this condition based on that evidence from the applicant's engineer,Planning Commission finds that the above conditions should be modified. •"In addition to the on-site detention requirements noted above,all subsequent site development permits,building permits,and Privately Engineered Public Improvement (PEPI)permits for development of the PUD shall demonstrate compliance with applicable stormwater standards at EC 9.6791 through 9.6797 and requirements of the Stormwater Management Manual." Prior to final PUD approval,the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that includes the following notes: •"The approved stormwater system shall be designed and sized by a civil engineer for the full build-out of the project to handle a 10-year design storm,including 20%of each lot assumed to be impervious surface area.If a lot is proposed to be developed with more than 20%impervious surface area,then additional on-site detention is required. Stormwater runoff from private facilities may also be combined with runoff from the public street (Randy Lane),so long as the public detention system is sized and designed in accordance with applicable Public Improvement Design Standards." Middle Housing fourplexes in accordance with the State's Large Cities Middle Housing Model Code,which was included as Exhibit B to OAR 660-046-0010. Planning Commission finds that the updated stormwater report partially satisfies the above condition of approval as it demonstrates the conceptual feasibility of a proposed stormwater detention system,but to ensure compliance with the assumptions provided,and because Randy Lane will be required to be constructed as a public street,the following (revised)conditions of approval should be imposed instead: As explained by the applicant's engineer in their letter dated August 14,2024,a shared stormwater system would be provided for the full build out of the project assuming a single-unit dwelling on each lot,and the shared driveways are assumed to be impervious and would be included in the shared detention facilities,to handle detention of a 10-year storm.Based on this design,if a lot is developed with under 20%impervious surface area,no on-site detention would be required,and if the lot has more than 20%impervious surface area then on-site detention would be required.They explain that the detention facility must be sized by an engineer so that peak flow from the lot does not exceed the peak flow generated by a 20%impervious area. Furthermore,that the peak flow based on a 10-year storm event should be assumed at 2.1 cubic feet per second per acre,based on site conditions.They recommend that any on-site detention system should be designed by a civil engineer to meet applicable City standards. 31 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 28 (8)For any PUD located within or partially within the boundaries of the South Hills Study, the following additional approval criteria apply: 2 Footnote 27 references a decision for Braewood Hills 3rd Addition Phases 5 and 6 (PDT 18-4),to create a similar 36- lot residential subdivision on the subject property.That Hearings Official's decision to approve the application was appealed to the Eugene Planning Commission,which issued a Final Order on June 25,2019,affirming the Hearings Official's decision with revised conditions of approval.The Planning Commission's decision was appealed to the Land Use Board of Appeals (LUBA),which issued a Final Order (2019-067)affirming the Planning Commission's decision.The 2018 Tentative PUD approval expired on June 11,2024. The Hearings Official determined that subject property is residentia I ly zoned and subject to the • /PD Planned Unit Development Overlay Zone.Because the applicant has applied under the Housing/Clear and Objective approval criteria at EC 9.8325,the applicant is subject to the limitations on development imposed by EC 9.8325(8)(a),which provides that no development is allowed on any property above 901 feet,unless the lot was in existence as of August 1,2001.The Hearings Official determined that the applicant did not argue,and there is no evidence in the record,that Lot 39 was in existence as of August 1,2001.In footnote 27 (page 42)2,the Hearings Official's decision states: The Planning Commission hereby modifies the Hearings Official's decision and finds that the requirements of EC 9.6791 through EC 9.6797 can be met as conditioned,that the applicant has demonstrated the storm system design can be adjusted to accommodate the increment of stormwater from the required public road,and will include sufficient on-site detention meeting applicable standards in the event that it may be needed for future development on individual lots. response to opposing testimony expressing concerns about the need for a stormwater system that is designed overall to meet applicable standards for the whole site,whether lots are developed with middle housing or only single dwelling units,and to respond to the Hearings Official's unresolved determination about whether it is feasible to demonstrate compliance with the applicable stormwater standards. During the applicant's 2018 PUD application for the subject property,the applicant asserted that this area of the site was part of a larger lot that existed on August 1,2001. (a)No development shall occur on land above an elevation of 901 feet except that either middle housing or one single-unit dwelling may be built on any lot in existence as of August 1,2001. Hearings Official's Decision The Hearings Official addressed this issue on pages 42 through 44 of her decision,under approval criterion at EC 9.8325(8),which states: Appeal Issue #9: The applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred by finding that because almost all of proposed Lot 39 is above 901 feet and the land comprising proposed Lot 39 did not exist as a separate lot on August 1,2001,the applicant is prohibited from further development on that lot. 32 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 29 The Planning Commission agrees with and adopts the Hearings Official's conclusion on pages 43- 44 of her decision that: The Planning Commission rejects the applicant's argument that the middle housing statute and implementing rules (ORS 197A.420,OAR Chapter 660,division 46,and the Large Cities Middle Housing Model Code)provide that because the subject property is zoned for residential development,the applicant is unequivocally entitled to develop Lot 39 with middle housing.The Planning Commission further rejects the applicant's argument that the middle housing statute and implementing rules somehow require the City to consider only "base zones"and prohibit the City from applying its PUD overlay requirements. Planning Commission's Determination The Planning Commission affirms the Hearings Official's finding that the approval criterion at EC 9.8325(8)prohibits all development above 901 feet on Lot 39 because it did not exist as a separate lot on August 1,2001. Summary of Applicant's Argument The applicant argues that the Hearings Official incorrectly analyzed the relationship between the middle housing statute and the 901-foot prohibition in the code by concluding it is appropriate to use overlay zones to limit middle housing rights. As for the applicant's argument that state law requires middle housing to be allowed above 901 feet,the Hearings Official determined that the state law does not require the City to consider only base zones or ignore its /PD overlay requirements when determining whether the property Is an area where residential development is allowed.The Hearings Official also found that state law does not require the City to allow middle housing on residentia fly zoned property that expressly prohibits residential development.The Hearings Official determined that state law requires that the City allow middle housing only in areas that otherwise allow the development of a single-unit dwelling and,since no development of any kind (single-unit dwelling or otherwise),is permitted on Lot 39 under the Clear and Objective PUD criteria,state law does not require the City to allow the development of middle housing on Lot 39. Regarding the current Tentative PUD application (PDT 24-1)the Hearings Official found that because almost all of proposed Lot 39 is above 901 feet3 and because the land comprising proposed Lot 39 did not exist as a separate lot on August 1,2001,no development can occur on the lot. The Hearings Official determined that the area now identified as Lot 39 "was not created as a separate lot until the Braewood Hills Third Addition PUD was approved in 2002"and accordingly imposed a condition prohibiting any development on that lot. The Planning Commission affirmed that condition. 3 Based on the applicant's site plan Sheet L2.0 included with supplemental materials dated May 10,2024,a variable width strip of land approximately 1 to 20 feet wide located on Lot 39 is shown under 901-feet in elevation,where it abuts proposed Lots 33,37 and 38. 33 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 30 The Planning Commission notes that if the applicant or any future owner wishes to develop the portion of the subject property above 901 feet in elevation (with middle housing or otherwise), they could submit a new Tentative PUD application under the track for General/Discretionary approval subject to the applicable standards at that time. The Planning Commission therefore imposes the following condition of approval to ensure compliance with EC 9.8325(8)(a): Because EC 9.8325(8)(a)prohibits development of detached single-family dwellings on the portion of Lot 39 above 901 feet,the Planning Commission finds that Lot 39 is not an "area...that allows for the development of detached single-family dwellings,"and therefore neither ORS 197A.420, OAR Chapter 660,division 46,nor the Large Cities Middle Housing Model Code require that the development of middle housing be permitted on Lot 39. The Planning Commission finds that ORS 197A.420,OAR 660-046-0105,OAR 660-046-0205 and the Large Cities Middle Housing Model Code all require the City to allow duplexes on each lot or parcel "zoned for residential use that allows for the development of detached single-family dwellings,"and all other middle housing types in "areas zoned for residential use that allow for the development of detached single-family dwellings"The Planning Commission finds that while the subject property is zoned for residential use,EC 9.8325(8)(a)prohibits all development (including development of detached single-family dwellings)on the portion of Lot 39 above 901 feet in elevation because Lot 39 did not exist as a separate lot on August 1,2001. The final PUD plans shall be revised to remove any references to middle housing lots to be created on land above 901-foot elevation.The final PUD plans shall also include a note stating that:"No development of middle housing,single-unit dwellings,or any other development,including but not limited to land divisions,may occur on any land above 901 feet in elevation." The applicant is simply incorrect that Lot 39 is "zoned for residential use that allowfs]for residential development."The subject residentially zoned property is subject to the PUD overlay and,in accordance with the clear and objective criteria of EC 9.8325(8)(a),no residential development is allowed on any property above 901 feet. Contrary to the applicant's desired reading,the Middle Housing statute does not require the City to consider only base zones or ignore its PUD overlay requirements when determining whether the property is an area where residential development is allowed. Nor does it suggest that the City must otherwise allow middle housing on residentially zoned property that expressly prohibits residential development.Rather,it expressly requires middle housing only in areas that otherwise allow residential development. Appeal Issue #10: The applicant argues that the Hearings Official erred by not doing a separate review of the subdivision proposal,relying instead on the analysis of the PUD. 34 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 31 The Hearings Official's denial of the Tentative PUD application was primarily based on her finding that the applicant had not demonstrated that the subject property is included on the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.Because of this fact,the Hearings Official determined that the applicant was required to demonstrate compliance with the Clear and Objective requirements for Tree Preservation and Removal and Geological and Geotechnical Analysis required under the Tentative PUD and Tentative Subdivision approval criteria.Because the applicant did not make those required demonstrations,the Hearings Official denied the applicant's Tentative PUD and Tentative Subdivision applications.However,as discussed above under Appeal Issues #2 and #7, Planning Commission finds that the entire subject property is included in the City's acknowledged Goal 5 inventory and reverses the portions of the Hearings Official's decision determining otherwise. Planning Commission Determination The July 10,2024,Staff Report provided analysis and recommendations regarding the Tentative PUD criteria at EC 9.8325 (Section 1 of the Staff Report)and concurrent Tentative Subdivision criteria at EC 9.8520 (Section 2 of the Staff Report).As demonstrated therein,most of the Tentative Subdivision approval criteria are identical to the Tentative PUD approval criteria.When analyzing the Tentative Subdivision criteria,wherever they were identical to the Tentative PUD criteria,staff incorporated the PUD evaluation by reference in justifying findings of compliance or, in some cases,inapplicability with the correlating Tentative Subdivision criteria.Where the Tentative Subdivision criteria were different than the Tentative PUD criteria,staff provided a separate analysis as necessary.The Hearings Official found that staff's analysis of the Tentative PUD approval criteria could be used in determining whether the proposed Tentative Subdivision criteria were also satisfied. Summary of Applicant's Argument The applicant argues that Hearings Official should have included a separate review of the subdivision criteria,and that the subdivision application should have been approved. Hearings Official's Decision The Hearings Official noted that in the staff report,staff relied almost exclusively on its analysis of the Tentative PUD approval criteria in determining that the proposed subdivision also satisfied the Tentative Subdivision approval criteria.Because the PUD is subject to the requirements of EC 9.8325(3)and EC 9.8325(5)(d),which the Hearings Official found were not satisfied,the Hearings Official determined that the Tentative PUD application could not be approved.To the extent the Tentative Subdivision application relies on compliance with the PUD criteria,she determined that it also could not be approved. The Tentative PUD approval criteria at EC 9.8325(3)and the Tentative Subdivision approval criteria at EC 9.8520(5)both require a demonstration of compliance with Tree Preservation and Removal Standards of EC 9.6880 to 9.6885.Similarly,the Tentative PUD approval criteria at EC 9.8325(5)(d) and the Tentative Subdivision approval criteria at EC 9.8520(2)(e)both require a demonstration of compliance with Geological and Geotechnical Analysis standards of EC 9.6710(6).Because the Tentative PUD approval criteria and Tentative Subdivision approval criteria reference many of the same standards,it is appropriate to incorporate the findings regarding compliance with the Tentative PUD criteria when making findings of compliance with identical Tentative Subdivision 35 V.CONCLUSION Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 32 The Eugene Planning Commission has reviewed the record and the assignments of error in the appeal and has voted to reverse and/or modify portions of the Hearings Official's decision and impose the conditions of approval discussed in this Final Order.Therefore,the Planning Commission hereby approves Tentative PUD and Tentative Subdivision applications for Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)subject to the following conditions of approval: Based on all the above,the Planning Commission modifies the Hearings Official's decision to conclude that any modification to the Hearing Official's findings regarding the Tentative PUD application should also modify any identical Hearings Official findings regarding the Tentative Subdivision application. To the extent the Hearings Official relied on a denial of the Tentative PUD to also deny the Tentative Subdivision,the Planning Commission finds that the modifications as described above to the findings and conditions under the Tentative PUD criteria at EC 9.8325(3),EC 9.8325(4),EC 9.8325(5)(d)and EC 9.8325(5)(j),allow the approval of the Tentative PUD and the Tentative Subdivision by incorporating those findings by reference under identical Tentative Subdivision criteria. criteria.The Hearings Official addressed the concurrent Tentative Subdivision application acknowledging that: 1.On the final PUD site plans and final plat,the applicant shall create an access restriction strip along the westerly boundary line of Lot 15 abutting Hawkins Lane. As reflected in the Staff Report,the staff relied almost exclusively on its analysis of the PUD approval criteria in determining that the proposed subdivision also satisfied the tentative subdivision approval criteria.To the extent the review of the proposed development satisfies the PUD approval criteria,the corresponding tentative subdivision approval criteria are also satisfied. 5.Prior to final PUD and plat approval,the applicant shall submit Private Joint Use Access and Utility Easement and Maintenance Agreement (JAM).The JAM will include a description 4.The structural design and construction inspection for the private streets will remain the developer's responsibility.Certification by a licensed engineer that a structural design meeting the applicable standards will be required at the time of the site development permit for the private street. 3.The private streets shall be labeled on the final plat and final PUD site plans as "[Approved Street Name]-Private". 2.Prior to final plat approval,the applicant shall demonstrate approval from the regional road naming group for alternate street names to replace "Stonehedge Way"and "Stonehedge Court". 36 16.The location of proposed Joint Access Easements shall also be clearly shown and labeled as Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 33 15.The proposed Joint Access Easements,which are subject to City review and approval prior to recording with the final plat,shall be cross-referenced on the plat and be accompanied by a maintenance agreement for each shared driveway, which addresses the rights and responsibilities of each parcel relative to each shared driveway. 14.The applicant shall submit an Irrevocable Petition for public improvements in Randy Lane (existing portion between Hawkins Lane and Blacktail Drive)to include setback sidewalks and street trees. 13.The applicant shall submit an Irrevocable Petition for public improvements in Hawkins Lane to include sidewalks. 12.Prior to final PUD approval,the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that depicts wastewater service to Lot 38.Alternatively,the applicant may combine Lots 37 and 38 to demonstrate compliance with the requirement for wastewater service. 11.Prior to final plat approval,the applicant shall provide documentation that EWEB has received a financial guarantee,ensuring water will be provided to each lot in the plat. defining the area of the private street and will also identify permitted improvements, construction expectations,rights of usage and maintenance responsibilities for the facilities in the street.The JAM will be recorded concurrent with and cross-referenced on the final plat. 8.The final PUD site plans shall include the following note:"No building,structure,tree or other obstruction shall be placed or located on or in a Public Utility Easement,consistent with EC 9.6500(3)". 10.The final PUD site plans shall include the following note:"A Privately Engineered Public Improvement (PEPI)permit shall be issued for the construction of public improvements prior to development." 9.The final PUD site plans shall include the following note:"Compliance with public improvement requirements shall be demonstrated in accordance with EC 9.6505 as part of the permitting process for development within the PUD including Privately Engineered Public Improvement (PEPI)Permits,Site Development Permits and Building Permits." 7.Prior to final plat approval,the applicant shall dedicate a 14-foot Public Utility Easement or Public Wastewater Easement that will encumber the proposed public wastewater system. The required easement shall also be shown on revised final PUD plans. 6.Provisions for a public emergency access easement within the private street may be included in the proposed JAM which creates the private street,or alternatively,may be dedicated as a Public Emergency Access Easement on a standard City form. 37 such on final PUD plans. Final Order.Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 34 24.On the final plat,the applicant shall dedicate a 40-foot-wide right-of-way extending the public right-of-way for Randy Lane from its existing intersection with Blacktail Drive westerly (toward the western terminus of Randy Lane)to the proposed terminus of Randy Lane as currently depicted on Sheet L2.0 of the applicant's site plans.The right-of-way shall also encompass the required turnaround area at the end of the street and include a 23.Prior to final PUD approval,the applicant shall submit an updated site plan depicting that portion of Randy Lane now shown as a proposed private street on Sheet L2.0 of the applicant's site plans,as a public street instead.The revised site plan shall show that portion of Randy Lane will be designed and constructed to City standards as a public street meeting the standards for an Access Lane in accordance with EC 9.6505(3)(a)and the Local Street Design Standards of the Design Standards and Guidelines for Eugene Streets, Sidewalks,Bikeway and Accessways,as well as the City’s Public Improvement Design Standards (PIDS)Manual. 22.The final PUD plans shall include the following note:"No site alteration is allowed prior to final PUD approval.This prohibition includes site grading and the removal of trees and other vegetation,as well as any impacts to wetlands and the protected stream on the subject property including changes to the existing drainage pattern.Any such alterations shall only be allowed subject to permit review and approval,and erosion control measures as required for the proposed work." 21.The final PUD plans shall be revised to remove any references to middle housing lots to be created on land above 901-foot elevation.The final PUD plans shall also include a note stating that:"No development of middle housing,single-unit dwellings,or any other development,including but not limited to land divisions,may occur on any land above 901- feet in elevation." 20.The final PUD plans shall include the following note:"Compliance with all applicable development standards,special use limitations,and other general development standards for single-unit or middle housing residential dwelling types shall be demonstrated at the time of future building permit on each individual lot." 19.All future building permits for Lots 30 through 35 shall depict the Goal 5 resource and its 40-foot setback from top of bank and shall include site plans showing the location of protective fencing subject to the applicable standards at EC 9.4920-9.4930. 18.Prior to final PUD approval,the applicant shall obtain Type II Standards Review approval for the proposed public street extension of Randy Lane and any other utility crossings or other allowed improvements within the protected /WR conservation area,subject to the applicable standards at EC 9.4900-9.4980. 17.Prior to final PUD approval,the applicant shall update their stormwater memo to show how the proposed shared driveways will satisfy EC 9.6792(3)(c). 38 reserve strip in accordance with EC 9.6840(1). Attachment A:Hearings Official's Decision,dated September 5,2024 Final Order:Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)Page 35 The foregoing findings and conclusions are adopted as the Final Order of the Eugene Planning Commission on Appeal of the Hearings Official's Denial for Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3),on the 18th day of February 2025. 27.Prior to final PUD approval,the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that includes the following notes: 26.Prior to final PUD approval,the applicant shall submit updated application materials that demonstrate compliance with EC 9.6796. •"In addition to the on-site detention requirements noted above,all subsequent site development permits,building permits,and Privately Engineered Public Improvement (PEPI)permits for development of the PUD shall demonstrate compliance with applicable stormwater standards at EC 9.6791 through 9.6797 and requirements of the Stormwater Management Manual." •"The approved stormwater system shall be designed and sized by a civil engineer for the full build-out of the project including 20%of each lot assumed to be impervious surface area.If a lot is proposed to be developed with more than 20%impervious surface area,then additional on-site detention is required.Stormwater runoff from private facilities may also be combined with runoff from the public street (Randy Lane), so long as the public detention system is sized and designed in accordance with applicable Public Improvement Design Standards." 25.Prior to final PUD approval,the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that depicts that Lot 38 will have frontage on a public street or having access to a public street over a private street or proposed private access easement.Alternatively,the applicant may combine Lots 37 and 38 to demonstrate compliance with the requirement for public street access. Ja^n Lear,Chair Eugene Planning Commission 39 DECISION OF THE HEARINGS OFFICIAL Conclusion: A.Background Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)1 FOR THE CITY OF EUGENE,OREGON REQUEST FOR PUD AND SUBDIVISION APPROVAL Following public notice,a public hearing was held on July 10,2024.The public hearing began with the hearings official’s explanation of the hearing process and the statutory and local procedural requirements for the hearing.1 Following the introductory explanation,Associate The applicant,Picullel Properties,LLC (applicant)submitted the subject tentative PUD and subdivision application on March 29,2024.The applicant submitted supplemental application materials on May 10,2024.The City deemed the application complete on May 28,2024. The applicant’s request for approval of a residential planned unit development (PUD)and subdivision is denied and subject to potential amendment under ORS 197.522. The following findings and conclusions are based upon testimony presented at the public hearing held on July 10,2024 and all documents in the Eugene City planning file for the requested Braewood Hills PUD submitted before the close of the Record on August 21,2024,including documents submitted before,at and after the public hearing. Lead City Staff: Nicholas R.Gioello,Associate Planner Applicant’s Representatives: Carol Schirmer,Schinner Consulting,LLC Bill Kloos,Law Office of Bill Kloos PC Applicant/Owner: Picullel Properties,LLC Application Summary: Request for approval of a tentative planned unit development (PUD)and subdivision to create 39 residential lots located on the east side of Hawkins Lane and northeast of Randy Lane (Assessor’s Map /Tax Lot 18-04-1 1-12 /00200) Application File Name (Number): Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) lThe hearing official’s explanation included a statement that she has had no ex parte contacts regarding the applications and has no personal or financial interest in the subject property. 40 B.Site Characteristics Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)2 The subject property includes 15.47 acres and abuts the east side of Hawkins Lane and the east and north sides of Randy Lane.The surrounding area is generally developed with single family homes.Videra Park abuts the property along the southern boundary. The subject property has been the subject of two previous planned unit development approvals. In 2002,the subject property was part of an approved 181-unit planned united development (PUD),the Braewood Hills Third Addition PUD,(PDT 01-11).Final PUD approval of that application (PDF 03-01 was effective June 25,2003 and included 151 units within Phases 5 and 6,which comprise the 15.47-acre subject property.Phases 1 through 4 of that PUD were constructed as approved.Phases 5 and 6 were not developed.In 2019 the applicant received tentative PUD approval for a 36-lot residential development for the 15.47 acres that were During the second open record period,the City staff submitted a memorandum from Public Works Engineering revising its evaluation and recommended conditions,nine individuals submitted responses in opposition to the evidence supporting the application,and the applicant submitted a memorandum that both responded to evidence in the record and modified the application,including introduction of new evidence not previously submitted.The applicant submitted its final written rebuttal testimony on August 21,2024. At the applicant’s request,at the close of the public testimony the Record was left open for a period of 21 days,until 5:00 pm on July 31,2024,for additional testimony and evidence;until 5:00 pm on August 14,2024 for testimony responding to the additional testimony and evidence submitted during the initial open record period;and until 5 :00 pm August 2 1 ,2024 for the applicant’s rebuttal argument. During the first open record period,the City staff submitted a staff memorandum and a revised Public Works Referral Response;the applicant submitted written confirmation of its request for an extended open record period and consequent suspension of the 120-day “clock”,a notification of the LUBA remand of the City’s Middle Housing Ordinance,and the applicant’s post hearing memorandum;the Oregon Division of State Lands aquatic resource coordinator submitted email correspondence;and 23 individuals submitted email correspondence opposing the application. Planner Nicholas Gioello presented the planning staff’s summary of the application.Following the staff presentation,Bill Kloss,the applicant’s attorney,presented testimony on behalf of the applicant.Following the applicant’s presentation,14 individuals presented oral testimony opposing the proposed PUD and subdivision.2 2 The names of the individuals who presented oral testimony and who presented written testimony before or after the public hearing are on file in the City’s planning records for this application. 41 C.Description of Request D.Preliminary Issue “If an application for housing needs to be amended in order to be approvable,the Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)3 The applicant’s attorney prefaced the introduction of new evidence by asserting his “right”to an approval under ORS 197.522.According to the applicant’s attorney,so long as the applicant can submit evidence that can,either outright or through conditions of approval,satisfy all approval criteria -at any point in the process -the applicant is entitled to that approval.In his final rebuttal he reiterates that Despite these instructions and limitations,during the second open record period,the applicant amended its application and submitted new evidence into the Record.Because the Record was otherwise closed at that time,the public was provided no opportunity to respond to that new evidence. The Hearing Official’s evaluation of this application must be based exclusively on the Record established for this application,including all evidence submitted in the application itself,before and during the public hearing,both orally and in writing,and during the prescribed Open Record period.As noted above,and as described in detailed at the end of the July 1 0,2024 public hearing,following the public hearing the Record was left open for a period of 21 days for the submission of new evidence.Following that period,the Record was open for an additional two weeks for responsive testimony -with the express admonition that no new evidence was permitted during that second open record period.Following that responsive period,as the party with the burden of proof,the applicant was allowed one week for rebuttal argument -again,with no new evidence permitted. The applicant seeks PUD and subdivision approval for 39 lots,with development in accordance with R-l zoning on 38 of those lots.5 While the applicant asserts that its current intent is to develop each of the 38 lots with single dwellings,the applicant also notes that the City is prohibited under the Middle Housing Statute from restricting the applicant’s ability to develop the properties with up to four dwelling units per lot.The applicant does not propose to immediately develop Lot 39,but instead provides a conceptual design for future middle housing development,including four dwelling units on that lot. originally Phases 5 and 6 of the 2002 approval.3 That approval expired on June 11,2024.4 That property is now the subject of the requested 39-lot PUD and subdivision. 3 The applicant appealed the hearing official’s approval of the Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD Phases 5 &6 (PDT 1 8-4)to the Eugene Planning Commission,which issued a Final Order on June 25,20 1 9,affirming the Hearings Official’s decision with revised conditions of approval.The Planning Commission’s decision was appealed to the Land Use Board of Appeals (LUBA).On November 19,2019,LUBA issued a final order (2019-067)affirming the Planning Commission’s decision. 4 Under EC 9.7340,the 2018 PUD approval would have expired on June 11,2021;City Council Ordinance No. 20643 extended the approval by three years,to June 1 1 ,2024. 5 As further discussed below,in response to the City’s inquiry regarding the apparent lack of access to Lot 38, during the second open record period,the applicant modified the proposal to combine Lots 37 and 38. 42 (Bill Kloos August 21,2024 Written Rebuttal,page 2.) * * * * * Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)4 ORS 197.797 establishes a structure for submitting evidence to effectively allow the public to participate in the process.ORS 197.522 does not allow the applicant to bypass the statutorily required public hearing process by allowing the applicant to submit new evidence “on the fly” through an amended application,after the record has closed to new evidence,through a process (4)A local government shall deny an application that is inconsistent with the comprehensive plan and applicable land use regulations and that cannot be made consistent through amendments to the application or the imposition of reasonable conditions of approval. (3)If an application is inconsistent with the comprehensive plan and applicable land use regulations, the local government,prior to making a final decision on the application,shall allow the applicant to offer an amendment or to propose conditions of approval that would make the application consistent with the plan and applicable regulations.If an applicant seeks to amend the application or propose conditions of approval: (2)A local government shall approve an application for a permit,authorization or other approval necessary for the subdivision or partitioning of,or construction on,any land for needed housing that is consistent with the comprehensive plan and applicable land use regulations. applicant is entitled to amend it on the fly,including with new evidence and reasonable conditions,and that right applies even in the context of a local,on the record appeal.ORS 197.522(2)(3).” ORS 197.522 does not,however,authorize the applicant to achieve this end outside the public hearing process or without giving the public an opportunity to participate.The applicant cannot simply amend its application “on the fly”-or introduce new evidence into the record after the record has closed for new evidence -and demand that ORS 197.522 entitles it to an approval. (b)A City may extend the time limitation under ORS 227.178 (Final action on certain applications required withinl20 days)for final action by the governing body of a City on an application for needed housing and may set forth a new time limitation for final action on the consideration of future amendments or proposals. Essentially,ORS 197.522 requires local governments to approve needed housing applications that are consistent with,or can be made consistent with,through reasonable conditions of approval,the comprehensive plan and applicable land use regulations,and to deny applications that are not.ORS 197.522(3)allows an applicant to amend its application or to propose reasonable conditions to make its application consistent with the comprehensive plan and applicable land use regulations.What this means is that,if the applicant proposes a condition of approval that would satisfy a given approval criterion that the application does not otherwise meet,the decision maker must impose the proposed condition rather than deny the application.”6 6 ORS 197.522 provides,in relevant part: ***** 43 E.Evaluation of Requests 1.PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT (PUD)REQUEST EC 9.8325(1)The proposal complies with the EC 9.5860 Transition Standards. Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)5 The applicant seeks approval of the PUD under the Housing/Clear and Objective approval criteria at EC 9.8325.9 Those criteria require evaluation of the proposed PUD as follows: The Record of this proceeding closed for new evidence on July 31,2024.Any new evidence the applicant attempted to enter into the record after that date will not be considered. The hearings official is not an agent of the City;and while ORS 197.522 requires that “prior to making a final decision on the application”the local government must allow the applicant to amend an application that would otherwise be denied,IF it can be so amended to comply with all applicable approval criteria,it does not authorize an independent hearings official to allow such an amendment outside the public hearing process required under ORS 197.797.8 7 Consistent with ORS 197.797,the applicant could have moved to reopen the Record to allow it to add new evidence into the Record,which would have permitted the public to respond.It did not do so.Instead,in its cover email transmitting its August 14,2024 testimony,the applicant invited the City to respond,stating “It is quite possible that staff will want to respond to some of our responses -that is,respond with new evidence or argument. The applicant is not opposed to that,provided we can agree to a timeframe AND of course that the HO agrees.If the City is interested in that,let’s discuss promptly.”(August 14,2024 email from Bill Kloos to City Planners, transmitting second open record period letter and five supporting exhibits.(Emphasis in original.))This ‘invitation’ for the City to respond to new evidence was not,and cannot be construed as,a request to reopen the record. This applicant’s attorney invoked ORS 197.522 when it appealed a hearing official’s denial of the Laurelwood PUD (PDT 18-3).In that instance the City Planning Commission followed a process that allowed the applicant to amend its application and that ensured compliance with the requirements of then ORS 197.763. 9 The attorney representing Videra Oak Meadows and Wes Van Winkle submitted written testimony and argument, asserting that both the PUD and subdivision applications must be denied because they “are being processed under provisions directly affected by Ordinance No.20705”which was not acknowledged at the time of the applications and,accordingly,required findings of compliance with the Statewide Planning Goals.Neither the application nor the staff report included Goal compliance analysis or proposed findings. Ordinance 20705,which was on appeal to the Land Use Board of Appeals (LUBA)when the applications were filed,and which has now been remanded to the City for additional findings to establish Compliance with Goal 1 1,is the City’s Middle Housing Ordinance.While these applications certainly implicate the middle housing regulations,neither application is being processed under Ordinance No 20705.The PUD application is processed under and subject to compliance with EC 9.8325;and the subdivision application is processed under and subject to compliance with EC 9.8505.The City was not required to make findings of Goal compliance for either of the applicable approval processes. 10The EC 9.5860 Transition Standards apply only to new buildings and increases in the square footage of livable floor area of some existing buildings within multi-unit developments and assisted care,boarding and rooming houses,campus living organizations,university or college dormitories,and single room occupancy uses where those uses abut land zoned R-l,S-C/R-l,or S-RN/LDR. Finding:The EC 9.5860 Transition Standards do not apply to the proposed single-unit and middle housing development and,therefore,this criterion is inapplicable.10 that does not allow for public participation.7 44 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)6 The application proposes 39 lots.However,one lot (Lot 39)is located almost entirely above 901 feet and,as discussed below in findings regarding EC 9.8325(8)(a),that lot is precluded from further development.For purposes of compliance with this criterion,only the remaining 38 lots located below 901 feet are considered in calculating the proposed density. The applicable refinement plan is the South Hills Study (SHS),which does not include a land use diagram or land use designations.However,the text of the SHS does set a maximum density of 8 units per gross acre for areas west of Friendly Street,where the subject property is located. Finding:The subject property is designated Low Density Residential on the Metro Plan land use diagram,which is consistent with the property’s existing R-l zoning. The maximum residential densities established in this policy A.9,do not apply to the following housing types located within the City of Eugene:duplexes,triplexes, quadplexes,cottage clusters,and townhouses.A maximum residential density established by a refinement plan policy (whether through a limit on the number of dwelling units per acre,a minimum lot size requirement,a limit on total number of dwelling units in an area,or by any other similar regulation that has the effect of limiting density),may not be applied to the development of duplexes,triplexes, quadplexes,cottage clusters,or townhouses.The City of Eugene may incorporate maximum residential density requirements applicable to duplexes,triplexes, quadplexes,cottage clusters,and townhouses into the Eugene Code (including limits A.9 Establish density ranges in local zoning and development regulations that are consistent with the broad density categories of this plan. EC 9.8325(2)The proposed land uses and densities within the PUD are consistent with the land use designation(s)shown on the Metro Plan Land Use Diagram,as refined in any applicable refinement plan. High density:Over 20 dwelling units per gross acre (could translate to over 28.56 units per net acre depending on each jurisdiction’s implementation measures and land use and development codes) Medium density:Over 10 through 20 dwelling units per gross acre (could translate to over 14.28 units per net acre through 28.56 units per net acre depending on each jurisdiction’s implementation measures and land use and development codes) Low density:Through 10 dwelling units per gross acre (could translate up to 14.28 units per net acre depending on each jurisdiction’s implementation measures and land use and development codes) Policy A.9 of the Residential Land Use and Housing Element of the Metro Plan provides as follows: 45 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)7 Each of the originally proposed 38 lots has the potential to develop individually with middle housing units.EC 9.2741(4)provides the specific allowances for middle housing within the Special Use Limitations as follows: Policy A.9 is further implemented in the Eugene Code at EC 9.2751.EC 9.2751 is part of the City’s Middle Housing Ordinance,which is currently on remand from LUBA.Accordingly,it is currently not in effect.11 However,the language of EC 9.2751,which is not specifically subject to the LUBA remand requirement for additional findings,fully implements the state’s Large Cities Middle Housing Model Code,which applies directly.As directly reflecting and implementing the applicable code,EC 9.275 1 (l)(b)requires: EC 9.2751(l)(b):The maximum residential density requirements in Table 9.2750 do not apply to accessory dwellings,duplexes,triplexes,fourplexes,townhouses,or cottage clusters. 1.Cottage clusters in the R-l zone shall have a minimum net density of 4 units per acre. 2.Townhouses in the R-l zone shall have a maximum net density of 25 units per acre.Townhouses in the R-2 zone shall have a maximum net density of 39 units per net acre. on the number of dwelling units per acre and minimum lot size requirements),as long as those requirements comply with Oregon state law.If an adopted refinement plan policy is inconsistent with this policy,this policy will prevail. 11 The City’s original Middle Housing Ordinance (City Ordinance No.20667)went into effect on June 30,2022.As required by the state’s Middle Housing Statute,that Ordinance allows for the development of middle housing (i.e., duplex,triplex,fourplex,townhouses and cottage clusters)in areas zoned for residential use that allow the development of detached single-unit dwellings.The City’s Middle Housing Ordinance was appealed to the Land Use Board of Appeals.Ultimately,LUBA remanded the ordinance for additional findings regarding compliance with Statewide Planning Goal 1 1 (Public Facilities and Services).On March 11,2024,the City Council adopted a revised Middle Housing Ordinance,which included additional findings related to compliance with Goal 1 1 .That Ordinance was in effect when the applicant submitted the subject application.However,LUBA again remanded the City’s Ordinance on July 10,2024,again determining the City’s findings of compliance with Goal 1 1 to be deficient.Consequently,pending the City’s final adoption of a Middle Housing Ordinance,the state’s Large Cities Middle Housing Model Code applies directly to all impacted City applications. EC 9.2741(4)(a):Middle Housing is permitted on the following lots: 1.A duplex shall be permitted on: a.Any lot or parcel where a single-unit dwelling is permitted;and b.Any lot or parcel with a lot area that is at least 2,250 square feet. 2.A triplex shall be permitted on any lot or parcel with a lot area that is at least 3.500 square feet. 3.A fourplex shall be permitted on any lot or parcel with a lot area that is at least 4.500 square feet. 4.A cottage cluster shall be permitted on any lot or parcel with a lot area that is at least 4,500 square feet. 5.Individual units of middle housing are permitted on middle housing lots created pursuant to a middle housing land division. 46 The proposed development complies with this criterion. Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)8 The applicant’s written statement includes a table demonstrating that all lots within the proposed subdivision exceed 4,500 square feet and therefore,duplexes,triplexes,fourplexes and cottage clusters would be allowed on each of the originally proposed 38 lots.In accordance with Policy A.9,the maximum density for middle housing is not otherwise limited beyond the minimum lot standards described above. The applicant’s proposal for single-unit development on 15.47 acres with 38 lots has a density of 2.45 units per gross acre,which is well within the Metro Plan and applicable SHS density limitation.However,if the applicant chooses to develop the lots with middle housing,the maximum density of 8 units per acre established in the SHS does not apply to middle housing and instead the Middle Housing requirements,which require 4,500 square feet per lot or parcel, would be applicable. “Unfortunately,the entire site is identified as a Goal 5 resource due to its inclusion on the Scenic Sites Working Paper,which was adopted as a Goal 5 resource.Unlike the protections create for wetlands and other riparian resources,there were no specific environmental protections put in place for areas identified on the scenic working papers.As an outcome,we are left with a development project that can be approved without any specific tree preservation,exception for the protected stream and runs across the property. Given these facts,we believe we lack the authority to require tree preservation on the majority of the property through this PUD process and at the time of building permit.Tree preservation and removal is EC 9.8325(3):For areas not included on the City’s acknowledged Goal 5 inventory, the PUD preserves existing natural resources by compliance with the provisions of EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885 Tree Preservation and Removal Standards 12 The written staff report also explained that,subject to some potential exceptions,because the property is included in the City’s acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,the Tree Preservation and Removal Standards at EC 9.6885 would apply directly at the time of future development depending on the timing and scope of tree removal,lot size,and other factors that may require a separate tree removal permit under the requirements of EC Chapter 6.However,at the public hearing on the application,the staff explained that the staff report was in error and that because of changes to the City’s clear and objective standards,the acknowledged Goal 5 resources that have no specific environmental protections in place are no longer subject to any protections.As staff stated during the public hearing: Finding:The City staff report recommends a finding that this criterion is inapplicable because the subject property is included on the City’s acknowledged Goal 5,based on its inclusion in the April 12,1978,Scenic Sites Working Paper,which is adopted as an inventory of significant Goal 5 resource within the City of Eugene by Ordinance No.20351 .As the staff report explains,the Scenic Sites Working Paper designates the subject site as one of the Natural Sites of Visual Prominence and Prominent and Plentiful Vegetation.The City entered into the Record an undated and unlabeled map that the City states is the “Figure H2”that is identified as “Metro Plan Update,Natural Assets and Constraints-Working Papers Scenic Areas.”According to staff s calculations,this “Figure H-2”generally identifies the entire subject property (as well as a large swath of the City’s South,Southwest and East Hills)as being within the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.Within that general area,a protected upland stream corridor on the subject property is listed on the City’s adopted Goal 5 Water Resources Inventory (2005),as reflected by the /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay zone for this property.12 47 “The City Council of the City of Eugene finds that: Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)9 Consequently,according to staff,only the protected upland stream corridor on the subject property that is listed on the City’s adopted Goal 5 Water Resources Inventory (2005),as reflected by the /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay zone for this property,is subject to protection. (Written post-hearing testimony of Lloyd Helikson,page 1,footnote 2,quoting what staff advised him was read into the record during the public hearing.) While that Ordinance does not expressly adopt the April 12,1978,Scenic Sites Working Paper as.an acknowledged Goal 5 Resource,the City relies on that Ordinance 20351 as establishing that adopted the 1978 Scenic Site Working Paper as part of the City’s acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. therefore at the discretion and will of the developer.The Goal 5 status of this site and our recent adoption of Housing/Clear and Object standards as created the ability for an applicant to bypass long established tree preservation that the public has come to expect during this process.I believe this was not intended when the code was enacted,but is now in place and we are dealing with those unintended consequences in this Braewood application.” Ordinance No.20351,which the City asserts adopted the April 12,1978,Scenic Sites Working Paper as part of the City’s Goal 5 inventory,was adopted in 2005 and updated the City’s Goal 5 inventory.It references the April 12,1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper in its initial recitals, stating,in relevant part, Following the initial recitals,Ordinance 20351 adopted a Goal 5 Water Resources Conservation Plan,established applicable overlay zones and special development standards,and specifically, in Section 3 “[a]s they pertain to the areas within the City limits of Eugene,the following Exhibits are adopted as findings in support of this Ordinance:(a)Conflicting Uses and ESEE analysis attached as -Exhibit B and (b)the Eugene Local wetland Inventory,attached as Exhibit C ” * * * * “E.In addition to the inventories of riparian,upland wildlife habitat and wetland sites, referred to above,the following inventories make up the entire inventory of significant Goal 5 resources within the City of Eugene:The April 12,1978 Sand and Gravel Working Paper,the April 12,1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper,the April 12,1978 Willamette River Greenway Working Paper,the April 12,1978 Archeological Sites Working Paper,the December 1 ,1 976 list of historic land marks,and the West Eugene Wetlands Plan.” During his oral presentation at the JulylO,2024 public hearing,and in his July 10,2024 written hearing memorandum,the applicant’s attorney submitted evidence and extended argument to assert that,with the exception of the protected upland stream corridor on the subject property is 48 (Bill Kloos July 10,2024 Applicant’s Written Hearing Testimony,page 1-2.) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)10 listed on the City’s adopted Goal 5 Water Resources Inventory,the subject property was not a part of the City’s Goal 5 inventory.The applicant did not address the 2005 ordinance on which the City relies.Rather,the applicant argued the 1982 acknowledged Metro Plan demonstrates that the subject property was not part of the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory;and that the staff’s assertion (that the site is mapped as a Goal 5 “natural Site of Visual Prominence and Prominent and Plentiful Vegetation”)is not backed up with acknowledgement documents and in fact is contrary to what was acknowledged.The applicant explained in its written testimony: However,in his August 14,2024 response testimony,the applicant’s attorney reversed his position,and agreed with the City that the entire property was subject to the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.In a footnote,the attorney stated: In support of this position,the applicant attached the actual 1982 DLCD Goal 5 acknowledgement staff report as Exhibit D to the applicant’s July 31,2024 post-hearing memorandum. “Any acknowledged Goal 5 resource in this area must be referenced to an acknowledged map.The DLCD Staff Report (July 29,1982)at page 10,15 summarizes what was required for Goal 5 acknowledged and how the City complied: Response The Metro plan has been amended to include a consolidated natural resource map (Map 3,General Plan Technical Report.)In addition,very detailed site-specific maps of each resource site are provided in the amended Natural Resource working paper.Resources mapped include wetland vegetation,sand and gravel, significant vegetation and wildlife area,and slopes.”[Emphasis added.} Conclusion: The Eugene/Springfield area plan complies with Goal 5 for Lands within the Metropolitan UGB. “Staff’s statement that this site is an acknowledged Goal 5 resource (“Natural Site of Visual Prominence and Prominent and Plentiful Vegetation.”)needs to be supported by the acknowledged maps,beginning with “Map 3,General Plan Technical Report.We have attached hereto what we believe to be the acknowledged Map 3.It has a legend that shows property on Map 3 with a red box.Significant Vegetation is mapped as blue diagonal lines.None is mapped as being on this site.” Requirement 1.Amend the Metro Plan to include a consolidated natural resource map or maps which clearly define the location of sites where conflicting uses are prohibited or limited.[Emphasis added.}Figures 1 ,2 and D3 of the Working Papers are particularly relevant to this task.** *[Emphasis added.} 49 (Bill Kloos August 14,2024 Applicant’s Written Response Testimony,page 18,footnote 2.) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)11 The staff memorandum again includes a depiction of the generalized map on which it relies (which is not labelled but to which staff refer to as “Map H-2”)to show that the subject property is within the general depiction on that map of property referenced in the 1 978 working paper. Staffs July 31,2024 memorandum does state that the Map H-3,upon which the applicant originally relied,“was not a part of the City’s acknowledged Goal 5 inventory as formally adopted by Ordinance 20351 or any other formal adoption process known to staff or otherwise demonstrated as a matter of record by the applicant.”Relying on the staff report language cited above,the staff memorandum continues: The applicant’s response testimony does not further address its previous argument that the property is not on the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.Instead,the applicant argues that the subject property was acknowledged as a Goal 5 resource during the 1 982 Metro Plan Goal 5 acknowledgment,and that any argument to the contrary constitutes a collateral attack on the 1982 acknowledgment.13 13 The applicant’s attorney also asserts that “the dispute over the meaning of [EC 9.8325(3)]is sufficiently ambiguous that is may not be applied at all.”Presumably,what he means is that because there is disagreement over what,if any,Goal 5 resource was acknowledged,the standard itself “sufficiently ambiguous”that they City cannot enforce it under its clear and objective criteria.To substantiate this creative (and familiar)argument,he asserts that the “disagreement”concerns the “meaning of ‘areas’for purposes of applying this standard.” “The applicant does not present any evidence to refute the [staff report language],nor does the applicant provide any evidence that supports Kloos’argument that the April 12, 1978,Scenic Sites Working Paper is not acknowledged.Staff considers the subject property’s Goal 5 status due to its location on the Scenic Sites map as a settled matter according to the prior Tentative PUD approval (PDT 18-4),wherein the record shows that the applicant agreed with the subject property’s Goal 5 status according to the Scenic Sites Map.* * Despite the applicant’s attempt to introduce an “ambiguity”into this evaluation,the question over whether or to what extent the Goal 5 resource on the property was acknowledged in 1 982 does not render EC 9.8325(3) “ambiguous.”As LUBA explained in 2022 an appeal of the City’s Accessory Dwelling ordinance Conte v.City of Eugene Or LUBA (LUBA No.2021-092 (May 9,2022),“complicated does not equate to ambiguous.”Rather, LUBA explained: “To be ‘clear’for purposes of ORS 1 97.307(4),a standard must be “clear enough for an applicant to know what he must show during the application process,”it must be “easily understood and without obscurity or ambiguity,”and it must not be capable of multiple constructions that support diametrically opposed conclusions.[Citations omitted.]” “In our hearing letter we included a Map H-3 and suggested it could be the final, consolidated Goal map that exited the acknowledgment process.As staff correctly points out in their July 3 1 memorandum,the applicant has not been able to trace the pedigree of the H-3 map to any verification of acknowledgement.” 50 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)12 In written testimony submitted July 31,2024,a concerned citizen,Lloyd Helikson,provided an extensive analysis of the 1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper and its relationship to both the 1982 Metro Plan Goal 5 acknowledgment and the City’s 2005 Ordinance updating its Goal 5 inventory and concludes that the 1978 Working Paper,and the Map on which the City relies, was never adopted as part of the City’s Goal 5 inventory. However,while this finding indicates that as between the City and the applicant,an argument could be made that this issue could be considered a “a settled matter,”in fact this issue was not raised in the 2018 application.14 Further,while the time for appealing the 2018 application has long since passed,in fact this is not the same application.This is a new application,which must be reviewed on its own merits.The public has the right to raise any issues related to compliance with the applicable approval criteria as they apply to the present application.And,in fact,public testimony does challenge the City’s assertion that all of the subject property is an acknowledged Goal 5 resource. (Braewood Hills Third Edition Phases 5 &6 PUD,May 15,2019 Hearings Official Decision, page 8.) As the staff correctly referenced,the 2019 decision approving a PUD for the subject property includes the following finding: As analyzed and explained in detail in the Helikson testimony,and as evidenced by the language itself,Ordinance 20351 (adopted in 2005)does not purport to acknowledge the 1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper (or any of the other working papers referenced in Finding E of that Ordinance.) Rather,in recitals,it describes those papers as “inventories [that]make up the entire inventory of significant Goal 5 resources within the City of Eugene.”Thus,the City’s reliance on that Ordinance alone as being the document that adopted the April 12,2078 Scenic Sites Working Paper as part of the Goal 5 inventory,is not consistent with the Ordinance itself.15 However, “The staff report confirms that subject property is included on the City’s acknowledged Goal 5 inventory (based on the April 12,1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper,which designates the subject site as Natural Sites of Visual Prominence and Prominent and Plentiful Vegetation.)It is also listed on the 2005 Goal 5 Water Resources Inventory,as reflected in the /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay zone for this property. 14 At the beginning of the applicant’s oral presentation at the July 10,2024 public hearing on the present application,the applicant’s attorney suggested that he believed this hearings official’s finding in the 2019 decision was incorrect.He testified,at length,why he disagreed with City’s determination that the portion of the subject property outside the area subject to the /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay zone was within the City’s acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. 15 As explained in post-hearing written testimony submitted by Lloyd Helikson: “The Working Paper does not identify particular lots.* * *it states:“A map has been prepared as part of this paper that shows where these scenic standards have been identified in the Metro Area.”* * *The Map identifies broad areas of land in the Metro area as having several categories,which categories staff indicates apply to the development lot (Natural Sites of Visual Prominence and sites within the Presence of Prominent and Plentiful Vegetation.’)* * * 51 (Bill Kloos August 14,2024 Applicant’s Written Response Testimony,page 20.) (July 31,2024 written testimony from Lloyd Helikson,page 9-10 (citations omitted.) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)13 For the “Natural Sites of Visual Prominence”category in the Map,there appear to be about 7 sites in and around Eugene,with one immense site seeming to cover the Southwest,South and East hills (“Hills site”).The Hills site, where the development lot is said to be located,is far too large to have any kind of detail necessary for a proper Goal 5 analysis under the original Goal 5 rule.The description or map of the boundaries of the Hills site are difficult to determine.Lots and Goal 5 resources within the Hills site are not identified.” The Helikson analysis thoroughly explains the limitations of the “Scenic Sites Working Paper, and establishes a solid factual basis for its conclusion that this Working Paper was not intended to be and should not have been the basis for the City’s Goal 5 inventory.As the analysis Notwithstanding this argument,whether the 1 978 Working Paper mapping established the Metro Plan’s acknowledged Goal 5 inventory in 1982,and if so,what that mapping depicts,is far from clear;and,consistent with this attorney’s own earlier argument,that this mapping shows the site to be acknowledged is not “plainly”evident. “When the City completed its final version of the Goal 5 Water Resources mapping in 2005 with Ordinance 20351,Recital E in the Ordinance listed all the other parts of the Goal 5 program,and that listing included the “1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper.”* * * This was not a new Goal 5 analysis,just a statement of the City’s understanding of what had been in acknowledged in 1982. while the Ordinance does not purport to adopt that inventory as a Goal 5 resource,it does list the 1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper as one of several ‘working papers”that “make up”the City’s inventory of significant goal 5 resources.16 “The admittedly generalized nature of the Scenic Sites Working Paper is not a basis for saying the mapping therein does not include this site if the site can be found and the Working Paper mapping is acknowledged,which it plainly is.” In his August 14,2024 written response testimony,and in a reversal of his written and oral hearing argument,the applicant’s attorney argues that the 1978 Scenic Sites Working Paper was actually acknowledged in 1982: 16 In contrast,Ordinance 20315 does explicitly adopt the /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay zone and map,which protects the upland stream corridor on the subject property as an acknowledged Goal 5 resource. From the Map,it is difficult to identify any lot,let alone the development lot,as being within one or the other of these broad areas.It might be in one or the other,but the areas do not seem to overlap on the Map.* * *Staff indicated to me:“That is the map we have to work with.I have to find things (like key intersections)on this 1978 map that line up with detailed current maps and then triangulate from those points to figure out where a property is located.” For the “Prominent and Plentiful Vegetation”category,there are also large sites identified on the map.These large sites have similar problems in terms of the lack of detail regarding the sites,difficulty in determining boundaries, and lack of a description for each site.* * *Lots and Goal 5 resources within the sites included in this category are not identified.” 52 concludes: Homebuilders v.City ofEugene,41 LUBA 370,428 (2002.) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)14 Thus,while it is far from clear,it appears that 1982 Metro Plan acknowledged the Scenic Sites Working Paper as part of the acknowledge Goal 5 inventory.Consequently,while the Helikson analysis clearly articulates the limitations of that Working Paper and establishes that it was likely a preliminary assessment that was not intended to create a Goal 5 inventory of specific Goal 5 resource sites,it is what the City has adopted.And,that adoption cannot be collaterally attacked After summarizing different categories of inventoried resources (for purposes of determining whether,or the extent to which various provisions of the City’s Land Use Code Update (LUCU) impacted continued Goal 5 compliance)LUBA did appear to recognize that the Scenic Sites Working Paper map formed the basis for the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.17 This statement is correct to the extent that the Homebuilders case did appear to recognize that,in 1982 the Metro Plan acknowledgement relied on the imprecise Working Papers as the basis for Metro Plan Goal 5 inventory.As LUBA explained: (Lloyd Helikson,July 31,2024 Written Testimony,page 14.)However,notwithstanding the limitations of this Working Paper,it appears that in 1982 this,and other similar working papers, likely did form the basis for the Metro Plan Goal 5 acknowledgment.The applicant’s attorney argues that: “Half of the 2001 LUBA decision in Homebuilders [v.City ofEugene],reviewing Goal 5 compliance of the City’s recodification of Chapter 9,found the Working Paper and its map H-2 to show the acknowledged resources.” “Identifying the City’s Goal 5 inventory is not an easy task,in part because it was adopted as part of a regional planning process,and in part because the inventory consists, as far as we can tell,of a large collection of various “working papers”and maps. “[T]he Scenic Sites Working Paper and Map fundamentally lack the requirements for establishing an inventory of Goal 5 resources,consisting of “outstanding scenic views and sites”and lack the required ESEE analysis and program of appropriate Goal 5 protections.The Working Paper and Map were only a preliminary inventory,which identified “scenic areas”characterized as lands valued for their “aesthetic appearance,” but did not identify required inventories of “Outstanding scenic views and sites”as required by the original Goal 5.The Working Paper and Map perhaps could be utilized in the very first step of the process for establishing a Goal 5 inventory,but they fall far short of being a Goal 5 inventory under the original Goal 5.” 17 The LUBA finding states: “Significant scenic areas are not listed in any resource list,but instead are mapped at Figure H-2.** * Buttes,ridgelines,viewpoints with public access,parklands,gold courses and cemeteries are identified as scenic areas on Figure H-2.Apparently,some of the VWWH [significant vegetation,wildlife and wildlife habitat]sites.”Homebuilders v.City ofEugene,41 LUBA 370,428-429 (2002.) 53 through the review of this application. 55 Without any site specific maps,which -according to the acknowledgement documentation the Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)15 Moreover,while rejecting the applicant’s “Map 3”as not being “backed up with acknowledgement documents”and being “contrary to what was acknowledged”,the City relies instead on an undated and unlabeled,very general map that appears to locate a significant swath .of the southern part of what is now in the City -as subject to whatever resource the map generally references.It is clearly not the “very detailed site-specific maps of each resource”that DLCD referenced in acknowledging the City’s mapping. While the Scenic Sites Working Paper formed the basis for the Metro Plan Goal 5 acknowledgement in 1982,without the site-specific map(s)referenced in the acknowledgement documentation,which properties are subject to that acknowledgement cannot be determined. The very high-level,very generalized,undated and unlabeled map the City identifies as H-2, does not fit the description in the acknowledgement staff report of “a very detailed site-specific map of each resource.”And,while the City may be correct that the Map 3 Metropolitan Area General Plan Background Report Natural Features and Airport Limitations areas is not reflective of what is shown on the maps referenced in the DLCD staff report,it is labeled,and has a title that is consistent with the General Map referenced in that DLCD staff report.While,in retrospect,the applicant now states that it is not “able to trace the pedigree of the H-3 map to any verification of acknowledgement”,it is at least mentioned in the acknowledgement documentation the applicant provided.Contrary to the applicant’s revised evaluation,it is better evidence of what is acknowledged than is the City’s unlabeled and undated generalized depiction of the entire southern portion of the City. (Emphasis added .)“Map 3”,which the applicant’s attorney entered into the record during the July 10,2024 public hearing,is entitled “Metropolitan Area General Plan Background Report Natural Resources &Airport Limitation Areas.”The City argues that this “Map 3”“is not backed up with acknowledgement documents and in fact is contrary to what was acknowledged. However,as quoted above,while perhaps not the “very detailed site-specific maps”DLCD referenced,this Map is labeled consistent with the acknowledgement finding. “The Metro plan has been amended to include a consolidated natural resource map (Map 3,General Plan Technical Report.)In addition,very detailed site-specific maps of each resource site are provided in the amended Natural Resource working paper. Resources mapped include wetland vegetation,sand and gravel,significant vegetation and wildlife area,and slopes.” However,while the Scenic Sites Working Paper itself may have formed the basis for the 1 982 acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,as described in the applicant’s attorney’s initial argument,the acknowledgement itself required -and found --that the acknowledgement was based on clear, site-specific maps from those working papers.Specifically,as the applicant’s attorney quoted, LCDC required that the Metro Plan “include a consolidated natural resource map or maps which clearly define the location of sites where conflicting uses are prohibited or limited.” (Emphasis added.}And,it determined that 54 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)16 Based on the acknowledgement evidence provided by the applicant,and without any evidence to the contrary to document that,in fact,the entire property is part of the City’s acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,it appears that except for the clearly identified stream corridor,this Record does not demonstrate that the remainder of the property is within the Goal 5 inventory.Accordingly,this criterion requires that the applicant establish that the PUD preserves existing natural resources by compliance with the provisions of EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885 Tree Preservation and Removal Standards.The application does not include such a demonstration. Unless and until the applicant establishes either that Map 3,which it submitted into the record,is not “Map 3,General Plan Technical Report”relied upon in the DLCD acknowledgement of the City’s Goal 5 inventory and otherwise demonstrates that the entirety of the subject property is part of the acknowledge Goal 5 inventory;or provides a demonstration of compliance with EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885 Tree Preservation and Removal Standards,this criterion is not satisfied. Responding to the applicant’s initial argument and evidence that the property was not subject to the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,the July 31,2024 staff memorandum concluded: applicant submitted into the record -define what sites were included in the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory,it is not possible to determine that the area outside the clearly-identified footprint of the acknowledged Goal 5 stream corridor on the site,was in 1 982 -or is today -part of the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. The issue of whether middle housing is allowed on Lot 39 is addressed below under the EC 8.8325(8) findings. “Staff is also somewhat confused as to why and how the applicant would introduce this new issue now,given the implications.***** 18 The staff memorandum goes on to explain the apparent reason for the applicant’s position that the property is not a part of the Goal 5 inventory: “** *[Although staff disagrees with Kloos’argument,if he is correct and the site, except for the stream corridor,is not a Goal 5 resource,then according to EC 9.8325(3) and EC 9.8520(8)the tree preservation standards at EC 9.6855 would apply to the subject applications.Since the applicant has not submitted any evidence to demonstrate compliance with EC 9.6885,that would be a basis for denial.” “It appears that the applicant is making the argument about Goal 5 regulations because he believes that ORS 197.A.420,the middle housing rules and the Model Code create an entitlement to construct middle housing on any lot or parcel where the base zone allows development of a single-unit dwelling,except if the lot or parcel is subject to regulations adopted pursuant to a Statewide Planning Goal.In the case of the subject site,the applicable Statewide Planning Goal is Goal 5;therefore,the applicant believes if it can show that Lot 39 is not subject to a Goal 5 regulation,the applicant would be entitled to build middle housing on Lot 39,notwithstanding EC 9.8325(8)(a).However,that is simply not true.* * *The applicability of Goal 5 regulations to Lot 39 is not dispositive to the question of whether middle housing is allowed on that lot.” (July 31,2024 City Staff Memorandum,pages 8-9.)18 55 EC 9.6805 Dedication of Public Ways EC 9.6810 Block Length EC 9.6815 Connectivity for Streets EC 9.6815(1)Purpose and Intent Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)17 This standard addresses the dedication,location,and design of public streets and accessways, and standards for private streets. Finding:As discussed below in findings regarding EC 9.6815(2)(a),the City has demonstrated that Randy Lane must be developed as a public street,which requires compliance with the EC 9.6810 Block Length standard.EC 9.6810 requires that public street block lengths shall not exceed 600 feet,unless an exception is granted.Developed as a public street,Randy Lane would have a block length of approximately 595 feet,as measured from its intersection with Blacktail Drive,in compliance with EC 9.6810. Finding:EC 9.6805 allows the City to require dedication of public ways for bicycle and/or pedestrian use as well as for streets and alleys,provided the City demonstrates consistency with constitutional requirements.Streets dedicated to the public must conform to the adopted right-of- way map and EC Table 9.6870. EC 9.8325(4)The PUD provides safe and adequate transportation systems through compliance with all of the following: (a)EC 9.6800 through EC 9.6875 Standards for Streets,Alleys,and Other Public Ways. As discussed below in finding regarding EC 9.68 1 5 (2)(a),the City has recommended that the applicant’s proposed extension of Randy Lane comply with the requirement for public streets and has included findings demonstrating consistency with constitutional requirements.Subject to a condition requiring such dedication,the application would satisfy this standard. Finding:EC 9.6815(1)describes the numerous objectives of the connectivity standards.Several residents of the surrounding area provided oral and written testimony expressing their concern that the proposed subdivision is inconsistent with those objectives.In particular they assert that as proposed,the development does not satisfy EC 68 1 5(l)(a),which states that the standards are established to ensure that “Streets are designed to efficiently and safely accommodate emergency fire and medical service vehicles”;that they are not designed to “reduce travel distance,promote the use of alternative modes and provide for efficient provision of utility and emergency services,and provide for more even dispersal of traffic”as described in EC 9.68 15(1 )(d);that they will not “meet the needs of pedestrians and cyclists and encourage walking and bicycling as transportation modes”as described in EC 9.68 1 5(1 )(e);and that the street design is not “responsive to topography and other natural features”in a way that “avoids or minimizes impacts 56 EC 9.6815(2)Street Connectivity Standards Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)18 In the initial staff report,referral comments from Public Works determined that the applicant had demonstrated a basis under the street connectivity exceptions in EC 9.8325 from complying with any of the EC 9.8325(8)connectivity standards.On that basis,the City also stated that a public street could not be required for the proposed extension of Randy Lane.As described in the initial staff report,the City staff recommended: Finding:The proposed development abuts Randy Lane to the south and Hawkins Lane to the west.Public streets abutting the subject site include Randy Lane and Hawkins Lane.Other public streets located within %mile of the development include Suncrest Avenue and East 29th Avenue to the northeast,Blacktail Drive to the south and east;and the eastern portion of Randy Lane, which terminates at the property’s eastern boundary. Because they do not constitute approval criteria,compliance with the challenged provisions of EC 9.6815(1)is not subject to evaluation in this review. to water-related resources and wildlife corridors”as described in EC 9.681 5(l)(g).However, while EC 9.6815(1)speaks to the City’s intent for the street connectivity standards,the puipose and intent statements are not,in themselves,approval criteria through which a PUD application is evaluated.Instead,the purpose and intent statements are intended to be implemented through the specific standards articulated in EC 9.6815(2). “A street extension in the direction of Randy Lane to the east would typically be required in order to satisfy street connectivity standards.However,EC 9.8325(8)states,“No development shall occur on land above an elevation of 901 feet except that either middle housing or one single-unit dwelling may be built on any lot in existence as ofAugust 1, 20011'’This prohibits any street connection between the two existing portions of Randy Lane,since Lot 39 exceeds 901 feet in elevation.Accordingly,a public street extension in the direction of Randy Lane cannot be required.A street extension in the direction of Suncrest Avenue is also unnecessary as the existing residential development to the north prohibits any future street extension.The applicant is also requesting an exception due to No access is proposed from Hawkins Lane.The applicant proposes to extend Randy Lane as a private street east from its existing terminus as a public street at its intersection with Blacktail Lane southeast to the western boundary of proposed Lot 37;and to create two new private street, one running northerly from the intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive (Stonehedge Way),and a second ,a cul-de-sac (Stonehedge Court)extending westerly from Stonehedge Court.Although Hawkins Lane provides access to the westernmost portion of the property boundary to the west,and provides access to Randy Lane,no access to the lots within the development itself are proposed from Hawkins Lane.The intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive provides the sole access to all properties proposed to be accessed from either of the two new private streets (or shared driveways off those private streets.)19 19 While it is not clear from the site plans,it appears that up to five lots are proposed to be accessed from Randy Lane.The remaining lots would all rely on the two internal private streets,or shared driveways from those streets, for access. 57 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)19 In its revised analysis and recommendation,Public Works staff explained its recommendation that EC 9.6815(2)(a)requires Randy Lane be developed as a public street: The Public Works analysis also includes detailed findings demonstrating the public interest in establishing Randy Lane as a public street and the constitutional nexus between the impact of the requirement to dedicate the public right-of-way and that public interest.Those findings,at pages 3-5 of the July 30,2024 REVISED Public Works Referral Response are incoiporated and adopted by this reference. However,in its July 31,2024 Revised Referral Comments,Public Works staff revised its analysis and recommendation.While adhering to its analysis that the existing grades precluded compliance with the current street design standards for connections in the direction to the north and northeast,the Public Works staff determined both that the applicant had not established a valid basis for an exception to the connectivity requirement for Randy Lane and also that,in accordance with EC 9.6815(2)(a), Randy Lane be required to be a public street.Each of those issues is addressed in relation to the applicable approval criteria as follows: EC 9.6815(2)(b)The proposed development shall include street connections in the direction of all existing or planned streets within %mile of the development site.The proposed development shall also include street connections to any streets that abut, are adjacent to,or terminate at the development site. EC 9.6815(2)(a):All streets shall be public unless the developer demonstrates that a public street or alley is not necessary for compliance with this land use code or the street connectivity standards of subparagraphs (b)through (f). existing grades on site.Sheet EXH-1 of the applicant’s site plan shows that a future street connection to the north could not meet current adopted street design standards,more specifically Section 2.05(J)(4)of the City of Eugene’s Public Improvement Design Standards (PIDS),as the proposed street grade would exceed 20 percent.” The applicant asserts that this is a “discretionary demand’prohibited under the clear and objective criteria.Specifically,the applicant argues the City is not authorized to require its extension of Randy Lane,from its existing terminus as a public street at its intersection with Blacktail Drive,along the property’s southern boundary,to its proposed termination at or near the proposed 901 foot line of the property,as a public street.The applicant asserts that the “City “Randy Lane is an east/west public street that terminates at one end of this development site and resumes at the another;this development site constitutes the missing segment of Randy Lane.***** “Additionally,the missing segment needed to connect Randy Lane’s east and west termini is not entirely located on land above 901 feet,and the portion that is above 900 feet could be built;EC 9.8325(8)does not govern every scenario in which the street could be completed in the future.” 58 (Bill Kloos August 14,2024 Applicant’s Written Response Testimony,page 16.) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)20 Finally,the applicant argues that “the demand for public right of way dedication and improvements is an exaction that has not been and cannot be justified under the Nollan and Dolan tests.”(Bill Kloos August 14,2024 Applicant’s Written Response Testimony,page 16.)In his final rebuttal,the applicant’s attorney extends that argument,asserting that “exactions are only allowed in the context of discretionary applications that the City may deny.The nature of an application under clear and objective standards is that it may not be denied.”(Bill Kloos August 21,2024 Applicant’s Rebuttal Argument,page 6.) EC 9.6815(2)explicitly requires that “streets and alleys SHALL be public”unless the developer establishes that it is not necessary to do so in order to comply with EC 9.6815(2)(b)through Nor is there any merit to the applicant’s suggestion that by imposing conditions necessary for Randy Lane to be developed to public street standards,the City is improperly “imposing conditions in its discretion.”The conditions proposed would be necessary to develop the street to City standards.The applicant has not demonstrated that the City’s proposed conditions are discretionary. The applicant is essentially asserting that because the City is addressing each proposed street on its own merits -and evaluating them based on their own unique characteristics to determine whether the applicant has met its burden to NOT develop all three streets as public -it is somehow improperly asserting its “discretionary baton.”To the contrary,EC 9.6815 mandates that the applicant -and the City -apply the code requirements separately for each proposed street.The applicant’s argument that because it has evaluated each proposed street separately City’s application of EC 9.6815(2)indicates a “discretionary baton’is without merit. has not pointed to a standard that requires a nonconnecting road must be built to public road standards”and argues: “[The fact that there are other nonconnecting streets in this project that do not need to be built to public road standards,but the City wants this nonconnecting road built to public road standards,shows that the City is using a discretionary baton to direct the design,not a clear and objective baton.The statutes require clear and objective standards and conditions for housing.(ORS 197.307(4).That precludes the City from imposing conditions in its discretion.” EC 9.6815(2)(a)clearly and objective requires that “All streets and alleys shall be public unless the developer demonstrates that a public street or alley is not necessary for compliance with this land use code or the street connectivity standards of subparagraphs (b)through (f)of this subsection.”The City Public Works staff agreed that the applicant has demonstrated that its it is not necessary for its two new streets,both of which begin and terminate within the proposed development,to be public streets.In contrast,Randy Lane IS an existing public street at both ends of the proposed development and,based on the Public Works staffs evaluation,the applicant has not demonstrated compliance with the EC 9.68 1 5(2)(b)through (f)standards is not necessary. 59 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)21 Finding:In its initial staff report,the Public Works referral comments stated that the turnarounds at the ends of the two internal private streets provided “secondary access”.In its August 14,2024 response memo,Public Works revised its comments,explaining: The applicant’s request for an exception to EC 9.6815(2)(c)based on EC 9.6815(2)(h)(2)is addressed below. Finding:The proposed development is surrounded by residential development to the northeast, with existing rights-of-way bordering the development to the east,west,and south.However,an undeveloped,3-acre parcel of land lies adjacent to the subject property to the north.Absent an exception,EC 9.681,5(2)(c)requires that the proposed development includes streets that extend to that adjacent property. The City’s determination that EC 9.6815(2)requires that Randy Lane be extended as a public street,and subject to conditions requiring an updated site plan depicting the proposed extension of Randy Lane as a public street,dedication of public right of way,irrevocable petition for public improvements,is both justified and necessary to establish compliance with this criterion. (f).20 Public streets require development to specific standards,which include compliance with clear and objective conditions.The requirement for public streets also requires the dedication of the public right of way,which requires the City to justify exactions.They are necessary, regardless of whether the evaluation of their necessity is conducted through clear and objective or discretionary standards.And,contrary to the applicant’s arguments,the applicant is entitled to approval under the clear and objective criteria only to the extent the applicant does,or can with conditions of approval,satisfy all approval criteria.The local government retains the authority to deny an application that does not. “The secondary access standards at EC 9.6815(2)(d)are satisfied by the proposed construction of emergency vehicle turnarounds at the terminus of the proposed street system within the development site.The secondary access standards are also satisfied by the existing intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive,which will allow for access to the existing street system to the north (Hawkins Lane)and to the east (Blacktail Drive) and to the west (Timberline Drive.) (d)Secondary access for fire and emergency medical vehicles consistent with EC 9.6870 is required. (c)The proposed development shall include streets that extend to undeveloped or partially developed land that is adjacent to the development site or that is separated from the development site by a drainage channel,transmission easement,survey gap,or similar property condition.The streets shall be in locations that will enable adjoining properties to connect to the proposed development’s street system. 20 EC 9.6815(2)(h)(3)permits an exception to compliance with EC 9.681 5(2)(c)if “Provision of public street connection would require dedication of 25 percent or more of the total development site area.This clearly reflects that the City is otherwise authorized to require such a dedication of property for a public street. 60 He also challenges the logic behind the City’s revised analysis,arguing: (Charles Woodward 8/14/24 Written Response Testimony,page 6.) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)22 This standard does require that secondary access for fire and emergency vehicles be consistent with EC 9.6870,which establish the street width requirements.To satisfy that standard and the requirements of the 2022 Eugene Fire Code,Section 503.2.1,Fire Department comments As he states,“[O]n its face,a “turnaround”is the exact opposite of “secondary access.”(Charles Woodward 7-10-24 Written Hearing Testimony,page 5.) Numerous residents of the surrounding area also expressed concern regarding the lack of secondary access to and from the interior of the proposed development,and safety concerns regarding the limited ability for fire and emergency vehicles to access the property.And,the neighbors and the attorney representing the neighborhood association are correct that the City’s interpretation would not,for practical purposes,provide a secondary access to and from most of the development.However,while the access to the vast majority of the proposed lots would rely on a single access point from the intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive,the express language of EC 9.6815(d)requires only that the property itself have a secondary access;it does not require secondary access to each,or even to a majority,of the lots.And,in fact,as a technical matter,there are two public streets from which the property as a whole can be accessed. The code language does not require more.21 It is difficult to envision how turnarounds at the ends of the two internal private streets provide “secondary access”.As the attorney for some of the neighbors argues, “[A]‘secondary access’is a means by which ingress and egress to a property is provided in addition to the primary means of ingress and egress,in other words,a secondary access is a second point of ingress and egress to a property or area of a property.” 2 1 The Fire Department referral comments recognize that,for practical purposes,the proposed PUD has only a single access: «**$$* “2.Since there is only one access to this 39 lot subdivision,all dwellings in this development shall be equipped with approved automatic fire sprinkler systems meeting NFPA requirements * **.” “The applicant asserts,and public works seemingly agrees,an interpretation whereby secondary access is somehow demonstrated so long as there are at least two different streets providing access to the “project frontage.”However,the applicant’s interpretation adds words that are not in the provision in violation of ORS 197.01.* * *The applicant also attempts to argue that “secondary access”is somehow ambiguous despite the Code definition of “access”and the dictionary definition of “secondary,”plan language terms of the prevision,being quite clear and unambiguous:‘Secondary access’is a second means by which ingress and ingress to a property is provided in addition to the primary means of ingress and egress.” 61 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)23 Finding:The application is subject to review under the clear and objective approval criteria. This standard does not apply. Finding:The proposed development will not result in any street extensions to unimproved roadways and,therefore,this standard does not apply. Finding:The application is subject to review under the clear and objective approval criteria. This standard does not apply. With conditions prohibiting parking on the two internal streets and requiring the additional restrictions identified in the Fire Department comments (dated July 10,2024),the proposed PUD would satisfy the language of EC 9.6815(d). 1.Existing building(s)on the development site or on land abutting the development site and under separate ownership obstruct the extension of the planned street.For purposes of this subparagraph,“building”is defined as a structure designed and (h)For applications proposing housing to e reviewed with clear and objective approval criteria,exceptions to street connectivity standards may be granted if one of the following conditions exists: (e)Exception for applications proposing housing to be reviewed with clear and objective approval criteria,all applicants shall show that the proposed street alignment shall minimize excavation and embankment and avoid impacts to natural resources,including water related features. (f)In cases where a street connection would result in the extension of an existing street that is not improved to City standards and the street has an inadequate driving surface,the developer shall construct a temporary barrier at the entrance to the unimproved street section with provision for bicycle,pedestrian,and emergency vehicle access. (g)Except for applications proposing housing to be reviewed with clear and objective approval criteria,in the context of a Type n or Type III land use decision, the City shall grant an exception to the standards in subsections (2)(b),(c)or (d)if the applicant demonstrates that any proposed exceptions are consistent with either subsection 1 or 2 below:***** recommend that no parking be allowed on either side of the internal private streets,and that both sides of both streets be marked with “NO PARKING-FIRE LANE”signage.22 22 Those comments also recognize that the proposed 10 and 14 foot wide utility and access easements to several of the lots would not be adequate for the required fire apparatus access requirements,which require a 20-foot minimum and;that building permits for al lots within the subdivision would require proper fire department access and fire sprinklers meeting NPFA standards.Those comments also note that fire apparatus turnarounds may be required for Lots 1 and 2,6 and 7,5 and 10, 14,21,27 and 28,31,32 and 33,38 and 39 due to the distance from Randy Lane and Stonehenge Way. 62 With regard to this requested exception the Public Works staff explained, Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)24 An Adjustment Review requires a Type II land use application and is subject to the approval criteria at EC 9.8030(29),thereby satisfying the public participation requirements of ORS 197.797.However,because the City may not defer compliance with an application requirement The staff then recommended a condition requiring either that the applicant submit updated application materials to demonstrate an exception is warranted under one of the permitted exception bases in EC 9.6815(2)(h)or request an Adjustment Review under EC 9.68 15(2)(i). Finding:The applicant requests two exceptions to the EC 9.6815(2)Street Connectivity Standards: 3.Provision of public street connection would require dedication of 25 percent or more of the total development site area; 4.Abutting residential land cannot be further divided under current development standards. 2.Existing slopes would result in a street grade exceeding current adopted street design standards when measured along the centerline of the proposed streets to the existing grade of the subdivision boundary or abutting property under separate ownership; used as a place of occupancy.For the purpose of this subparagraph,“building”does not include a shed,carport,detached garage,accessory building,or other structure designed and used solely for storage or shelter; First,the applicant requested an exception to the Street Connectivity requirements,which otherwise require an extension to connect the two sections of Randy Lane.The applicant based this request on the location of that section above the 901-foot level and not on one of the conditions identified in EC 9.6815(2)(h). “The applicant asserts that the missing segment,to connect Randy Lane,cannot be developed because EC 9.8325(8)states that “no development shall occur on land above an elevation of 901 feet except that either middle housing or one single-unit dwelling may be built on any lot in existence as of August 1,2001.”PW [Public Works]staff notes that the requested exception found under EC 9.8325(8)is not listed as an exception to EC 9.6815 Street Connectivity,and that the applicant does not otherwise address any of the available exceptions under these standards to allow Randy Lane to dead-end without connection to the existing segment of Randy Lane that terminates at the eastly subject property boundary.The applicant therefore needs to demonstrate an exception is warranted according to the available options under the Housing/Clear and Objective track standards,including the Street Connectivity exceptions at EC 9.6815(2(H),or as an application for Adjustment Review in accordance with EC 9.68 1 5(2)(9)and EC 9.8030(29).” 63 (Bill Kloos August 21,2024 Written Rebuttal Argument,page 5.) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)25 As discussed above,the applicant’s “right”to amend its application “on the fly”does not allow the applicant to ignore the requirements of ORS 197.797 or to add evidence to the record after it A fundamental problem with the applicant’s rationale is that the applicant has amended the application and introduced new evidence into the record AFTER the record was closed to new evidence -thereby precluding the required hearing opportunity as it relates to that evidence.Just as a condition requiring the applicant to amend its application would invite “protest about evidentiary issues at the final PUD review without a hearing opportunity”,amending the application through this process -without a hearing opportunity -invites the same legitimate protest. In his closing rebuttal argument,the applicant’s attorney explains the decision to amend the application through his response testimony,stating: “Staff proposed conditions to require the applicant to make this exception showing in connection with the final PUD submittal.The applicant is keen on making that showing here,so as to avoid any protest about evidentiary issues at the final PUD review without a hearing opportunity.” 23 It is unclear why die City proposed a condition that would allow the applicant to amend the application and request an exception on a basis other than reflected in the application.To the extent the City’s rationale may have been that the,under application of the clear and objective standard,the evaluation of a new exception would require little judgment on the City’s part,LUBA has rejected that rationale.LUBA explained in Eng v.Wallowa County,79 OR LUBA 421 (2019): “We reject intervenor’s argument that the county may deter a determination of compliance with applicable approval criteria that is required to be made in this public proceeding to a future proceeding that does not allow for public participation,based on the theory that the deferred criteria “do not require interpretation or judgment.”Nearly every application for land use approval will involve some applicable approval criteria that are more subject than others,and other applicable criteria that do not require the exercise of much,if any interpretation or judgment.But that does not mean that the county may defer its review of the second category of criteria to a non-public proceeding.The county must either determine int his decision whether the applicable wildfire standards are satisfied,or defer a determination of compliance with the applicable wildfire standards to a future process that allows public participation.”(citing Rhyne v.Multnomah County, through a condition of approval that does not include a full and fair opportunity for public participation,a condition of approval requiring the applicant to submit updated application materials to demonstrate compliance with the exception standard would be permissible only if that amended application was subject to a full and fair review.23 Instead of either of these alternatives,the applicant asserted its right to amend the application “on the fly”,arguing that “[t]he applicant is also entitled to amend the proposal,including with modifications and additional evidence,if that is what is needed for approval.See generally ORS 197.522.”Accordingly,in responsive testimony submitted after the record was closed to new evidence,the applicant amended its application to add a request for an exception to EC 9.6815(8) based on slopes.The applicant submitted a new exhibit that included an annotated graphic from its engineering to demonstrate that the site’s topography precluded a connecting street that satisfied the 20%grade standard. 64 (Charles Woodward July 10,2024 Written Hearing Testimony,page 3.) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)26 The applicant’s engineers analyzed Exhibit A and provided an illustration (identified as Exhibit B to the applicant’s engineer’s July 31,2024 Written Testimony).That illustration,and accompanying analysis,indicates that the alternative proposed in Exhibit A to establish a street connection near the property’s northern boundary,would not satisfy the City’s street standards. That analysis explains: Several neighbors and the attorney for some of the neighbors,testified that neither the topographic conditions,nor the existing wetlands or geologic conditions,preclude a secondary access.The neighbors submitted an “Alternate Access Road Location”map,which depicts an access road connecting the proposed Stonehedge Court to Hawkins Lane.(Exhibit A to Charles Woodward July 10,2024 Written hearing testimony.)The supporting testimony explains: The applicant’s site plan,Sheet EXH-1,depicts a possible street connection,which reflects slopes greater than 20%.The initial Public Works referral comments indicated that the applicant’s depiction demonstrates that a future street connection to the abutting property to the north could not meet current adopted street design standards that require that street grades not exceed 20%(based on Section 2.05(J)(4)of the City’s Public Improvement Design Standards). To the extent the applicant wishes to invoke ORS 197.522,on appeal that statutory process would permit the applicant to amend the application and demonstrate compliance with the EC 9.6815(2)(H)exceptions standard,while also providing both the City and the public an opportunity to review and evaluate the evidence.ORS 197.522 does not authorize the applicant to ignore the basic evidentiary hearing requirements. has closed.While ORS 197.522 may allow the applicant to amend its application,it does not do so at the expense of the required public hearing process.The applicant cannot simply ‘on the fly’ ignore the evidentiary rules and eviscerate the public hearing process. “If Stonehedge Way connected back to Hawkins Lane,it would be a public street and subject to public street design requirements.This includes a transition into and out of intersections with vertical curves.A corrected profile has been added to the potential access exhibit submitted as part of the public comments.” Second,the applicant requests an exception to the street connectivity requirements of EC 9.6815(2)(c),which otherwise require an extension to the north,on the basis that a connection to the north would require slopes in excess of 20%.That basis for an exception is authorized under EC 9.681 5(2)(h). “[T]he topography of the northern end of the subject property does not preclude the inclusion of a secondary access for emergency services.See Exhibit A.The applicant already proposes an easement across part of this route for access to Lots 1,2,6 and7. Thus,it is certainly feasible to construct a secondary access on the subject property as part of the development without running afoul of applicable slope requirements.” 65 That profile includes a notation that: (Anna Backus,PE,KPFF Consulting Engineers,July 31,2024 Memorandum,page 2.) In its August 14,2024 response comments,Public Works Engineering explains: (Charles Woodard August 14,2024 Response Testimony,page 6.) EC 9.6835 Public Accessways EC 9.6840 Reserve Strips Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)27 Finding:This standard authorizes the City to require the developer to dedicate a reserve strip preventing access to an arterial or collector street when such access would be inconsistent with Finding:This standard authorizes the City to require the dedication and improvement of accessways to connect to adjacent undeveloped or publicly owned properties,subject to consistency with constitutional requirements.Videra Park,a 4.25-acre undeveloped park property owned by the City of Eugene,abuts the development site to the south.Public pedestrian and bicyclist access are already provided by the existing public street system,and otherwise by private streets and sidewalks proposed within the development,and therefore no such dedication or improvements are necessary. However,while there is certainly conflicting evidence in the Record,and it is certainly possible that a different configuration could potentially create a superior design,the applicant’s engineers have established a credible basis for an exception under EC 9.8615(2)(h)(2)to compliance with the street connectivity standard in EC 9.8615(2(c)). In his response testimony,the neighbors’attorney responds to this analysis,as well as the applicant’s evidence in response to its requested exception generally: “[N]o reasonable person would rely on the applicant’s analysis of slope and feasibility of connecting the street network according to Code given the contradictory facts and data in the record,especially considering that public works is now requiring the access road be a public road.Therefore,the Applicant has failed to demonstrate with substantial evidence compliance with EC 9.6815.” “The applicant has submitted an additional memorandum dated July 31,2024, demonstrating that a public street connection from the existing intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive then connecting to Hawkins Lane cannot comply with the City of Eugene standards (PIDS Manual section 2.05(J)(4))related to maximum allowable slopes.” “Accounting for the vertical transitions at the top and bottom of the slope,the resulting street grade would be 21%,exceeding the maximum allowable slope of 20%.The maximum cut and fill would also exceed what was reflected on the original exhibit.” 66 EC 9.6845 Special Safety Requirements. EC 9.6850 Street Classification Map EC 9.6855 Street Names EC 9.6870 Street Width Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)28 Finding:As explained in the staff report,EC 9.6870 requires that the right-of-way and paving widths of streets “conform to those widths designated on the adopted Street Right-of-Way map. When a street segment right-of-way width is not designated on the adopted Street Right-of-Way map,the required street width shall be the minimum width shown for its type in Table 9.6870 Right-of-Way and Paving Widths.”A greater width can be required based on adopted plans and policies,such as the adopted “Design Standards and Guidelines for Eugene Streets,Sidewalks, Bikeways and Accessways ”or other factors that necessitate a greater street width,as determined by the Planning Director and Public Works Director. The Revised Public Works analysis,which recommends a finding of compliance with the EC 9.6870 Street Width Standards are adopted as follows: Finding:The applicant has submitted the proposed street names of Stonehedge Way and Stonehedge Court for consideration to the regional road naming group.It appears that those proposed private street names are similar sounding to street names existing within Lane County. Accordingly,approval of this application would require a condition requiring changes to those street names to ones that are approved by the regional road naming group and revisions to the site plans to reflect the approved names. Finding:Based on findings of compliance with the EC 9.6870 Street Width requirements,the proposed development satisfies the street classification map requirements. Finding:These requirements are inapplicable to applications subject to review under the clear and objective approval criteria. In addition,based on the determination that Randy Lane must be constructed and dedicated as a public street,a reserve strip at the terminus of that street would be required. EC 7.420.As discussed below in findings regarding EC 9.6735(2),Public Works staff have determined that access from Lot 15 onto Hawkins Lane would be inconsistent with EC 7.420. Accordingly,approval of this PUD would require a condition requiring access from Lot 15 be taken from Randy Lane,a local street,rather than Hawkins Lane,which is a neighborhood collector. Per the City’s adopted street right-of-way map (Figure 60 of the Eugene 2035 Transportation System Plan (TSP)),Hawkins Lane is a neighborhood collector that does not have a planned right-of-way width.Per the tentative plan,the existing right-of-way width of Randy Lane abutting the proposed development is 50 feet,with 25 feet on the 67 EC 9.6873 Slope Easements Finding:The application does not include any request for any slope easements. EC 9.6875 Private Street Design Standards EC 9.83225(4)(b): Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)29 In accordance with the exception discussed above,the proposed private streets are permitted and conceptually comply with applicable standards.As shown on the applicant’s site plans,the proposed private streets would consist of a 21 -foot paved width,having curb and gutter on both sides and a 4-foot sidewalk on one side of the street. Subject to staff recommended conditions regarding design and construction inspection,and the requirement for a Private Joint Access and Utility Easement and Maintenance Agreement (JAM), the proposed PUD would satisfy the EC 9.6875 Private Street Design Standards. Finding:As explained in the Staff Report and Public Works Referral Comments,EC 9.6875 requires that private streets be designed and constructed in accordance with applicable requirements contained in the adopted “Design Standards and Guidelines for Eugene Streets, Sidewalks,Bikeways and Accessways ”(which are more specifically identified in Section M. Private Streets and Alleys,on page 39 of Exhibit A of City Council Resolution No.4608 in the Eugene Arterial and Collector Street Plan.) (b)The proposal will provide pedestrian circulation to transit stops and neighborhood activity centers located within 1/4 mile of the development site and bicycle circulation to transit stops and neighborhood activity centers located within 2 miles of the development site,provided that the City makes findings to demonstrate consistency with constitutional requirements.The Randy Lane,which is not identified on the adopted Street Classification Map (Fig.60 of the TSP)functions as a low volume residential street.Per EC Table 9.6870,low volume local streets are required to have between 50 and 60 feet of right-of-way with a paving width between 20 and 34 feet.Randy Lane,which has an existing 55-foot right-of-way width,was constructed to City standards under City Contract 2003-0502 with 27 feet of paving,curbs and gutters,and street lights,but is lacking setback sidewalks and street trees.Since the existing 55-foot right-of-way in Randy Lane exceeds the required right- of-way width for low-volume local streets as identified in EC Table 9.6870,no additional right-of-way or special setback is required for the existing portion of Randy Lane. east side of the centerline.Hawkins Lane was constructed to City standards under City Contract 1980-0011 with 28 feet of paving,curbs and gutters,and street trees,but is lacking curbside sidewalks abutting the development site and street lights.Since the existing 50-foot right-of-way in Hawkins Lane exceeds the required right-of-way width for neighborhood collectors as identified in EC Table 9.6870, no additional right-of-way or special setback is required for Hawkins Lane. 68 1.A sign identifying a transit stop;or 2.A point along a property line of a neighborhood activity center. Finding:As described in the Staff Report, EC 9.8325(5):The PUD complies with all of the following: 2.The /WQ Management Area. Finding:The Staff Report analysis and findings are adopted as follows: Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)30 Because there are no existing transit stops or neighborhood activity centers within %mile,no pedestrian circulation requirements apply. Lot Dimensions:All proposed standard lots meet or exceed the 50-foot minimum lot width.Lots 2,3,4,5,7,10, 14,21,26,27,28,31,32,33,37,38 and 39 do not meet the 50-foot minimum frontage requirements.However,EC 9.2761(l)(c)allows lot frontage requirements to be modified with an approved PUD.All other lots not identified above meet or exceed the minimum requirements for lot frontage,and otherwise meet or exceed the minimum requirements for lot size and lot width. (a)EC 9.2000 through EC 9.4170 regarding applicable lot dimensions and density requirements for the subject zone and any applicable overlay zones.Within the /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay Zone or /WQ Water Quality Overlay Zone,no new lot may be created if more than 33%of the lot,as created,would be occupied by either: “The subject property abuts Hawkins Lane and Randy Lane,which are currently improved with sidewalks on one side of the street that can be used by pedestrians and bicyclists to connect to nearby residential areas.There are no existing transit stops, neighborhood activity centers,office parks or industrial parks within a %mile of the site. The nearest Lane Transit District transit stop is located on Britany Street,approximately 0.88 miles,to the northwest.Hawkins Lane is developed with striped bicycle lanes on both sides from Randy Lane north to 18th Avenue,providing safe and efficient bicycle circulation to commercial areas.Videra Park is immediately adjacent to the site along the south border,and Hawkins Heights Park is approximately !4 mile north of the site on Hawkins Lane,also easily accessible to pedestrians and bicyclists.” distance between the development site and a transit stop or neighborhood activity center shall be determined using the shortest distance as measured in a straight line between a point along the perimeter of the development site and: 1.The combined area of the /WR conservation setback and any portion of the Goal 5 Water Resource Site that extends landward beyond the conservation setback;or 69 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)31 As indicated in the table provided in the applicant’s narrative,each of the above- mentioned lots are impacted by at least one of,and in some cases several,of the following:wetland areas;steep slopes or slope easements;and protected Goal 5 water resources areas.Subtracting these areas as unbuildable from each of the impacted lots, Lot Area:According to EC Table 9.2760,for new subdivisions in the R-l zone,lots have a maximum area of 13,500 square feet unless an exception is granted.The applicant’s written narrative (page 13)provides a table that indicates Lots 16,18,21,and 30 through 39 all exceed 13,500 square feet in size.Per EC 9.2761(5),exceptions to the maximum lot size shall be granted as follows: (5)Exceptions to the maximum lot size shall be granted if any of the following is met: (a)Existing physical circumstances such as topographically constrained lands, conservation easements,existing buildings,or utility easements prevent the ability to further divide the lot. (b)The lot exceeding the maximum lot size is intended to reserve a large lot for future land division with feasibility demonstrated by a conceptual buildout plan. (c)The subdivision achieves a minimum density of 9 units per net acre. (d)The exception will enable protection of natural resources. WR Overlay Zone:Regarding the requirement for no new lots with more than 33% combined /WR Conservation Area,the site has an identified Goal 5 protected stream and setback with a tributary of Videra Creek that runs across the subject property,from northeast to southwest in the eastern half of the site,as depicted on Sheet L2.0 of the applicant’s site plans.The site plans indicate that Lots 30 through 35 are impacted by a Goal 5 protected stream and setback and none of these lots exceed the 33%limitation. The proposed site plan indicates the developable site excluding Lot 39 is 582,770 square feet in area.The total area of parking and circulation is 42,595 square feet.Subtracting the parking and circulation area from the total developable site area yields 540,175 square feet,which amounts to a net acreage of 12.40.The resulting net density is 2.98 units per net acre,which is still well below the allowed maximum of 14 units per net acre.While the applicant does not address it here,staff also notes that any middle housing that might ultimately occur on the subject lots is exempt from density maximums of the R-l zone. Density:As described at EC 9.275 1 (l)(b),net density is the number of dwelling units per acre of land in actual residential use and reserved for the exclusive use of the residents in the development,such as common open space or recreation facilities,but excluding public and private streets and alleys,public parks and other public facilities.EC Table 9.2750 Residential Zone Development Standards allows up to 14 units per net acre in the R-l zone (although it is noted that this maximum is further limited for single-unit development to a maximum of 8 units per acre according to the SHS refinement plan,as discussed previously). 70 EC 9.6500 Easements Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1 ;ST 24-3)32 Finding:As shown on the site plans,the applicant is proposing to extend the existing wastewater mainline at the intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive,north and east through the subject site to serve the proposed development.Neither the written statement or the applicant’s site plan acknowledges the dedication of a Public Utility Easement (PUE)or a Public Wastewater Easement over the proposed public wastewater system.Therefore,compliance with this criterion would require a condition requiring the applicant to dedicate a 14-foot Public Utility Easement or Public Wastewater Easement that will encumber the proposed public wastewater system and be shown on revised final PUD plans. The following Staff findings are adopted to demonstrate that such a dedication meets constitutional requirements: (b)The PUD complies with EC 9.6500 through 9.6505 Public Improvement Standards. the applicant has demonstrated that each of the lots in question have buildable areas of less than 13,500 square feet and are consistent with the exceptions for topographically constrained lands or protection of natural resources.As such,this criterion is met,and the maximum lot size exceptions are justified.24 “There is a nexus between the requirement to dedicate a 14-foot-wide public utility easement/public wastewater easement and the public interest at issue.Without a sufficient public utility easement,the City of Eugene could be considered to be trespassing on private property when accessing the public facility for inspection, maintenance or repair of the wastewater line.The 14-foot width is the minimum necessary to allow for public maintenance vehicles to access the entirety of the proposed public wastewater line for inspection and maintenance purposes.The 14-foot width also allows sufficient width for excavation equipment in the event that the line needs to be replaced altogether.Dedication of the PUE/public wastewater easement is roughly proportional to the impact that the proposed development will have on the City’s sewer facilities to serve the development on the new lots which will be using the portion of the system requiring a public easement (roughly 25 of the proposed lots).This is also the last opportunity that the City will have to require the dedication of the necessary PUE.” 24 While not impacting compliance with this standard,after staff noted that proposed Lot 38 lacked any access, frontage,or wastewater service,the applicant proposed to combine Lots 37 and 38 into a single lot.The resulting Lot 37 has sufficient frontage allowed by the PUD process and the area would total 42,098 sf,with a total buildable area of 11,862 sf.The buildable area is reduced below 13,500 sf because of 13,584 sf of wetlands;3,203 sf of steep slopes;and 9.250 sf of property inaccessible due to wetlands.(Applicant’s August 14,2024 response testimony, Exhibit D,page 25.) “It is in the public’s interest to ensure that the City has access to that portion of the public wastewater system located on private property to prevent or address a backup or to conduct other wastewater system inspection,maintenance and repair needed to prevent damage to the public system and the private properties that it serves. 71 EC 9.6505 Improvements -Standards EC 9.6505(1)Water Supply: EC 9.6505(2)Sewage: Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)33 As depicted on the applicant’s site plan,service to Lots 1-37 will be provided by the extension of the public wastewater system,or the existing public wastewater system in Hawkins Lane and Randy Lane.Lot 39 would receive wastewater service by the existing public mainline that runs through the northern portion of Lot 39.However,the site plan depicts no wastewater service to Lot 38.(As discussed below,the site plan also depicts no access to Lot 38.) Finding:Water service for the proposed development must be provided in accordance with Eugene Water and Electric Board (EWEB)policies and procedures.EWEB referral comments confirm an existing water main within Randy Lane can provide water service to the development,subject to documentation from the applicant to demonstrate that EWEB has received a financial guarantee,ensuring water will be provided to each lot. Finding:These standards require that all public improvements be designed and constructed in accordance with adopted plans,policies,procedures and standards specified in EC Chapters 6 and 7.The public improvement standards in EC Chapter 7 also require the developer to enter into an agreement establishing installation and maintenance responsibilities for street trees in accordance with the standards in EC 7.280.Additionally,all developments are required to be served by and implement infrastructure improvements including water,sewage,streets,street trees,street lights,sidewalks,access ways,and stormwater drainage.The applicant could satisfy this standard with conditions that ensure compliance with public improvement requirements and issuance of a Privately Engineered Public Improvement (PEPI)permit In response to that apparent oversight,the applicant has now proposed to combine Lots 37 and 38. Finding:EC 9.6505(2)requires that all developments to be served by City wastewater sewage systems,in compliance with the provisions of EC Chapter 6.As explained in the application and evaluated by staff,in order to provide service to each of the lots,the applicant is proposing to extend the 8-inch wastewater line that is located at the intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive,within the proposed private street and in the proposed private utility easements.The public portions of the proposed wastewater system will also be required to be located within a PUE or public wastewater easement. The applicant is also proposing to dedicate 7-foot PUEs along the existing right-of-way of Randy Lane and Hawkins Lane,as well as to create numerous private access and utility easements throughout the site.The applicant’s proposal is conceptually acceptable,but would also require a condition requiring that the final PUD site plans include a note that “No building,structure,tree or other obstruction shall be placed or located on or in a Public Utility Easement,consistent with EC 9.6500(3)”. 72 EC 9.6505(3)and (4)Streets,Alleys,and Sidewalks: EC 9.6505(5)Bicycle Paths and Accessways: (d)EC 9.6710(6)Geological and Geotechnical Analysis. Finding:EC 9.6710(6)requires that,subject to specified exceptions under EC 9.6710(3), Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)34 Finding:The Flood Insurance Rate Maps do not depict the site as located within a Special Flood Hazard Area and,therefore,this standard is not applicable. Finding:EC 9.6505(3)and (4)require all streets in and adjacent to the development site to be paved to the width specified in EC 9.6870 and improved according to adopted standards and specifications pursuant to EC Chapter 7,unless such streets have already been paved to that width.The improvements are to include drainage,curbs &gutters,sidewalks,street trees and street lights adjacent to the development site according to the City’s adopted "Design Standards and Guidelines for Eugene Streets,Sidewalks,Bikeways and Accessways Finding:The applicant does not propose any bicycle paths or access ways,and referral comments from Public Works staff further confirm that neither facility is required. Hawkins Lane has been constructed to City standards with the exception of sidewalks abutting the proposed development,and the existing portion of Randy Lane has been constructed to City standards with the exception of setback sidewalks and street trees.Subject to submission of irrevocable petitions for the required public improvements to Hawkins Lane and Randy Lane,the proposed development could satisfy this standard. Subject to a revision to the Site Plan to combine Lots 37 and 38 into a single lot,it appears that wastewater service could be provided to each of the proposed lots. (c)EC 9.6706 Development in Flood Plains through EC 9.6709 Special Flood Hazard Areas -Standards. “[Applications proposing housing to be reviewed with clear and objective approval criteria shall include a certification from an Oregon licensed Engineering Geologist, an Oregon licensed Geotechnical Engineer,or an Oregon licensed Civil Engineer with geological experience,prepared within ten years of the date of application,that includes the following information: (a)Identification of any portion of the proposed development site that is located in an area of moderate or high landslide susceptibility as shown on the City’s adopted Eugene Landslide Hazard Map. (b)A statement that the proposed development will not be impacted by existing or potential stability problems or any of the following site conditions:slopes 20 percent or greater,springs or seeps,depth of soil bedrock,soil types,variations in soil types,open drainage ways,fill,or a combination of these conditions. 73 The application does not include any evidence to demonstrate compliance with this standard. (e)EC 9.6730 Pedestrian Circulation On-Site. Finding:This standard is inapplicable to the proposed development. (1)EC 9.6735 Public Access Required. Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)35 Finding:As depicted on the applicant’s site plans,with the exception of Lot 38,all proposed lots would have legal access to the existing public street system.Lots 2,5,7,10 through 14,21, 23 through 26,and Lots 31 through 33 would have legal access by utilizing various Private Joint Access Easements.Because the proposed access easement would encumber and be shared by Lots 1 through 7,9,1 1 through 13,18,20, 21,27 through 29,36 and 37 approval would require EC 9.6710(3)exempts compliance with this criterion for “activities on land included on the City’s acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.”As discussed above in findings regarding EC 9.8325(3), neither the City nor the applicant has provided documentation to establish that,with the exception of the protect upland stream corridor,the property is a part of the City’s Goal 5 inventory;and the applicant has presented evidence that it is not.Consequently,EC 9.6710(6) requires the applicant to comply with the requirements listed above. (1)Except as otherwise provided in this land use code,no building or structure shall be erected or altered except on a lot fronting or abutting on a public street or having access to a public street over a private street or easement of record approved in accordance with provisions contained int his land use code. (d)If proposed development will be located in an area identified as moderately or highly susceptible to landslides pursuant to (a)or will be impacted by existing or potential stability problems or any of the site conditions listed in (b),the certification must also include: 1.A review of the suitability of the proposed lot layout,street locations,and proposed locations for utilities,driveways,parking areas and buildings given the landslide hazards,stability problems,and/or site conditions identified in the certification; 2.Any recommended modifications to the proposed lot layout,street locations,and proposed locations for utilities,driveways,parking areas and buildings that in the engineer’s opinion,would mitigate the landslide hazards,stability problems,and/or site conditions identified in the certification; 3.Methods for safely addressing the landslide hazards and/or site conditions identified in (a)and (b);and 4.Recommendations,if any,for additional geotechnical analysis for future buildings or improvements on the development site. 5.Recommendations,if any,for additional geotechnical analysis for future buildings or improvements on proposed lots or parcels. If certification is submitted under (6)(c),the applicant shall include the applicant’s statement that it will develop in accordance with the Engineer’s certification. 74 (g)EC 9.6750 Special Setback Standards. Finding:No special setbacks are required for future right-of-way or public utility easements. (h)EC 9.6775 Underground Utilities. Finding:These standards would apply at the time of development. EC 9.6780 Vision Clearance Area;(i) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)36 Finding:As noted in the Revised Public Works Referral Comments,compliance with these standards would be determined at the time of building permit when precise access connections are determined. Finding:The applicant proposes that the development will be served by the three private streets as previously discussed:Randy Lane,and the two streets currently shown in the application materials as Stonehedge Way and Stonehedge Court.As discussed above,EC 9.86152(a)and (b) require that Randy Lane be developed as a public street.The two private streets will connect to the intersection of Randy Lane and Blacktail Drive. Subject to a revision to the Site Plan to combine Lots 37 and 38 into a single lot,it appears that each proposed lot would have public access. In response to the staffs identification of the lack of access to Lot 38,the applicant has proposed to combine Lots 37 and 38. a condition requiring City review and approval prior to the recording of the final plat,and cross- references on the pat to a maintenance agreement for each shared driveway,and the location of all proposed joint access easements depicted on the final PUD plans. (2)Access from a public street to a development site shall be located in accordance with EC 7.420 Access Connections -Location.If a development will increase the development site’s peak hour trip generation by less than 50%and will generate less than 20 additional peak hour trips,the development site’s existing access connections are exempt from this standard. The July 30,2024 Revised Public Works Response,pages 18-20,attached to the City’s July 31, 2024 Post Hearing Response Memorandum,lists each of the EC 7.420 Access Connection standards and establishes that the proposed development complies with each of those standards. That analysis,is adopted and incorporated here as findings of compliance with EC 9.6735(5)(f)(2). (3)Access Connections to Local and Neighborhood Collector Streets.In addition to the location standards set forth in EC 7.4201),access connections to local and neighborhood collector streets shall be located in accordance with the following standards:***** 75 (Anna Backus,PE,KPFF Consulting Engineers,July 31,2024 Memorandum,page 2.) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)37 Essentially,the applicant proposes that it will complete initial property improvements,filling the wetlands and completing private street improvements.Thereafter,rather than a single,site-wide stormwater detention and filtration solution for the entire 15-acre property,each individual land owner would be responsible for development of their own stormwater detention and filtration system. To summarize the applicant’s proposal,in its July 31,2021 Written Testimony,the applicant’s engineer states,in part: Finding:As described in the staff report,this standard applies to Lot 15 at the existing intersection of Randy Lane and Hawkins Lane;to Lots 24 and 29 at the proposed street intersection of Stonehedge Way and Randy Lane;and to Lots 12 and 17 at the intersection of the private streets currently named Stonehedge Way and Stonehedge Court. The applicant’s plans show no existing or proposed visual obstructions that would pose a hazard to the traveling public.These standards would be further enforced at the time of development. (j)EC 9.6791 through 9.6797 regarding stormwater flood control,quality,flow control for headwaters area,oil control,source control,easements,and operation and maintenance. Finding:The applicant has proposed to control stormwater flooding,quality and flow through a stormwater detention system,assuming a single unit dwelling on each lot,and assuming shared driveways would be impervious.The applicant states that it will comply with the City’s stormwater ordinance. “Currently,the system is sized for a single-family house on each lot.If the lots are developed using Middle Housing standards,the impervious area on each lot would increase from 20 to 60 percent.The required detention volume would be approximately 4 times higher.To detain this higher volume,more pipes would be added to the detention system.This approach is modular and easily scalable.” “Detention:A shared stormwater detention system is being provided for the full build-out of the project,including the private lots.* ** “The stormwater analysis has been performed per City of Eugene requirements.The City of Eugene requires that the runoff from this site does not increase at the 10-year storm event.Additionally,the wetland permitting process requires that the runoff from the site does not increase at the 2-yeear storm event.Both requirements are being met.The peak flow from the site will not increase from the current conditions to the proposed conditions. 76 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)38 Neighbors are concerned that the applicant’s proposal,as submitted with its application,does not sufficiently control the flow of stormwater runoff to ensure that the removal of the wetlands would not result in the release of unfiltered water or greater stormwater flows onto adjacent properties.As described in the written testimony from one of the many concerned neighbors: “The Piculell application proposes to fill more than three acres of these wetlands.If this is permitted the water that is currently held by those wetlands,and the water that constantly recharges those wetlands,will instead flow unimpeded across the property’s "These wetlands perform a critical water filtering function.In essence,water flowing downhill across the property gathers into the wetlands,thus slow its speed and ultimately holding the water in place for an extended period.During this period,sediment in the water settles to the bottom.Later,as the wetlands are recharged and filled and excess water gradually flows down the hill and into Videra Creek,this sediment is left behind, thereby improving the quality of the water that enters the creek and to other downstream destinations.The wetlands also regulate the amount of water that flows into the creek and maintaining relatively even quantity of water in the creek itself throughout the year.This process,in combination with the four holding ponds designed by Scott Goebel,is why Videra Creek is a year-round creek and neither floods in the winter and spring nor dries up entirely in the summer and fall. The applicant acknowledges that,should it decide to develop the lots under the Middle Housing standards in such a way that the impervious area of each site is increased,the applicant would be required to provide an updated stormwater detention system to reflect that increase.While the applicant has not yet provided evidence of the feasibility of such a system,in its Response Testimony,the applicant recommended that to ensure that “stormwater detention can be provided if any lot is built out under Middle Housing rights”a condition be added that would require the applicant to “provide on-site detention for the increment of stormwater associated with the additional development.The condition should require those plans be engineered.”(Bill Kloos August 14,2024 Written Response Testimony,page 21.)A condition ensuring compliance is appropriate once feasibility has been established.25 “The Piculell property that is the subject of the PUD application contains several acres of high-functioning wetlands and a Goal 5 stream.Indeed,nearly one-third of the property consists of wetlands.These wetlands collect an enormous amount of water from rainfall, snowmelt,springs on the property,run-off from the properties above it,and other sources and then store the collected water,slowly releasing it downstream. OAR 660-046-0205 authorizes cities to conduct a new analysis of public facilities impacts if,after a developer proposes a fixed number of dwelling units that is less than that maximum allowed under the applicable middle housing code,an applicant subsequently proposes units in excess of that proposal. “Flow control,either through infiltration,on-site detention,or on-site retention,must generally be sufficient to maintain peak flow rates at or below their pre-development levels.***Flow control is also required for development in areas where downstream capacity of an open or closed stormwater system is not sufficient to convey the post development flows. 77 (Wes Van Winkle July 10,2024 Written Hearing Testimony,pages 3-6.) Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)39 This testimony reflects the oral and written statements of numerous neighbors who are concerned that the proposed development will result in greatly increase stormwater peak flow rates and volumes for the indefinite future.Numerous residents of the surrounding neighborhoods challenge the feasibility of the applicant’s proposed system and the impacts it would have,both on the subject property and in the surrounding area.Specifically,by proposing to fill the wetlands and complete private street improvements,then deferring any construction of any stormwater detention systems until each lot is purchased (and requiring the individual lot owners to develop those systems)the neighbors are concerned that there will be no assurance that the increased stormwater that will result will ever be detained or controlled. largest impermeable clay soil and down the hillside,where most of it will end up in Videra Creek.If the wetlands’function is not replicated through some other means,this will constitute a clear violation of the City’s requirement that peak runoff of water from a developed property not exceed the amount that flowed off that property prior to development. The neighbors urge that a site-wide stormwater detention system is necessary before the wetlands are filled so that the removal of the wetlands does not result in a violation of the City’s run-off equilibrium requirement for any substantial period of time.An engineer,who has done a hydrologic analysis of the property in the past (and constructed the detention ponds noted in Wes Van Winkle’s testimony),questioned the applicant’s evaluation of the stormwater detention system capacity needed for the property.26 0^ Specifically,in a letter attached to Wes Van Winkle’s July 10,2024 written testimony,Scott Goebel,an engineer who has done hydrologic analysis of the subject property for previous applications,concludes that a stormwater detention system capable of holding 17,791 cubic feet would be required for the entire property,and questions whether there is sufficient space on the property for such a facility. “** *[E]ven if the owners of some of those lots actually construct stormwater detention systems,such piecemeal construction of these systems will likely leave large gaps between detention systems through which unfiltered stormwater can pass.It is also likely that lot owners who do comply with the requirement will use different contractors to construct their systems,and the systems they build may vary widely in their quality and effectiveness.In short,even if the plan to shift responsibility for mitigation onto individual lot owners is eventually implemented with some level of success,a prospect that seems highly unlikely -it will be neither timely nor adequate to prevent substantial excess flow of water into Videra Creek.” “The applicant apparently recognizes this problem and plans to mitigate it primarily by requiring the buyers of the 39 proposed individual lots to construct their own individual stormwater detention systems at their own expense.* **[U]nder this plan,no stormwater detention system will be constructed on any lot until after the lots are actually purchased,and there is no guarantee that any of them will ever be. 78 (k)AU applicable development standards explicitly addressed in the application. /WR Water Resource Conservation Overlay Residential Development Standards Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)40 Finding:The applicant’s proposal includes single-unit development on the proposed lots,with the potential for one or more of the lots to be developed with middle housing.The review of specific development plans must necessarily be deferred to building permits for each individual lot since the applicant does not specify the exact design or type of dwelling units to be developed.The applicant does not explicitly address the applicable development standards for these allowed residential dwelling types.Consequently,if ultimately approved,the review for compliance with specific standards such as building height,setbacks,lot coverage and additional requirements for middle housing types must be deferred to future building permits. Finding:The applicant has evaluated the applicable standards of /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay based on its proposed private street crossing (the extension of Randy Lane)over a protected upland Goal 5 stream,which required demonstration of feasibility and compliance with the /WR overlay Standards Review criteria at 9.4930(3)(j).With the revised requirement that the extension of Randy Lane be constructed as a Public Street,the proposed crossing would now subject to the Standards Review approval provision of EC 9.4930(3)(j). EC 9.8320(6)The applicant has demonstrated that wastewater service, transportation service,stormwater service,water service,and electrical service will be provided to the site prior to the need for those facilities and services.Where the Also,as noted in the Revised Public Works Referral Comments,the requirement to construct Randy Lane as a public street may impact the applicant’s analysis and calculations,resulting in changes to its proposed system.In addition,unless the applicant can,through an amended application,establish that the majority of the property is actually an acknowledged Goal 5 resource,the evidence and demonstration required under EC 9.8325(3)(compliance with the tree preservation requirements of EC 9.6880 to 9.6885)and EC 9.8325(5)(d),requiring Geological and Geotechnical Analysis under EC 9.6710(6)could impact the applicant’s proposed stormwater detention system and its compliance with requirements of EC 9.679 1 through EC 9.6797.Given the potential modifications that could be necessitated,whether the proposed development could satisfy the EC 9.6791 through 9.6797 cannot yet be determined. However,while neighbors raise legitimate concerns regarding the proposed “piece-meal” approach,the City’s clear and objective criteria do not appear to include any requirements for a more integrated approach or otherwise allow controls over the timing of the improvements.And, while there is certainly conflicting evidence and testimony,the Revised Public Works Referral Comments evaluate the proposal for compliance with each of the EC 9.6791 through 9.6797 standards and finds that conceptually the proposal can satisfy each of the applicable standards. Public Works notes that,at the time of development,the system would be subject to more detailed Building/Site Development permit reviews.Those findings (Revised Public Works Referral Comments,July 30,2024,pages 21-25)are incorporated and adopted here. 79 (b)The PUD shall provide common open space within the development as follows: Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)41 Finding:The 1 5.7-acre site is directly adjacent to City-owned Videra Park to the south,in compliance with EC 9.8325(7)(a). Finding:As noted in the staff report,Public Works staff concurs that adequate public utilities and services,including wastewater and stormwater service,are presently available to the site or will be constructed through the Privately Engineered Public Improvement (PEPI),site development,and building permit processes. EC 9.8325(8)For any PUD located within or partially within the boundaries of the South Hills Study,the following additional approval criteria apply: (a)No development shall occur on land above an elevation of 901 feet except that either middle housing or one single-unit dwelling may be built on any lot in existence as of August 1,2001. EC 9.8325(7)PUDs proposed on development sites that are two acres or larger must comply with either subparagraph (a)or (b),below: facility or service is not already serving the site,this demonstration requires evidence of at least one of the following: (a)Prior written commitment of public funds by the appropriate public agencies. (b)Prior acceptance by the appropriate public agency of a written commitment by the applicant or other party to provide private services and facilities. (c)A written commitment by the applicant or other party to provide for offsetting all added public costs or early commitment of public funds made necessary by development,submitted on a form acceptable to the City manager. 1.Common Open Space Area. a.If the average lot area is equal to or greater than the minimum lot area of the base zone,then the PUD shall provide common open space within the development site equal to a minimum of 10 percent of the net acres of the development site or 14,500 square feet,whichever is greater. b.If the average lot area is below the minimum lot area of the base zone, then the PUD shall provide common open space within the development site equal to a minimum of 15 percent of the net acres of the development site or 14,500 square feet,whichever is greater. (a)The PUD is located within 1/2-miIe of a public park,public recreation facility,or public school (determined using the shortest distance as measured along a straight line between a point along the perimeter of the development site and a point along a property line of a public park,public recreation facility,or public school);or 80 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)42 Contrary to the applicant’s description of the applicable criterion,EC 9.8325(8)(a)was not impacted by LUBA’s remand of 20667,by the City’s adoption of Ordinance 20705 in response The applicant does not argue,and there is no evidence in the record,that Lot 39 was in existence on August 1,2001.27 Nonetheless,the applicant’s proposed conceptual Site Plan (Site Plan Sheet 12.0)depicts four middle housing lots within Lot 39 and the applicant’s narrative explains that the applicant’s purpose for creating Lot 39 is to develop four middle housing lots: Finding:EC 9.8325(8)(a)expressly prohibits any development on land above an elevation of 90 1 unless the lot was in existence as of August 1 ,200 1 .The western property line of proposed Lot 39 is at 900 feet. “Middle Housing will be a permitted use on Lot 39,based on the Large Cities Middle Housing Model Code.The basic right requires the City to allow Middle Housing “development on lots or parcels zoned for residential use that allow for the development on lots or parcels zoned for residential use that allow for the development of detached single family dwellings.”Chapter l.C.2.a.The Model Code allows the City to restrict Middle Housing “triplexes,quadplexes,cottage clusters,or townhouses,or the creation of more than two dwelling units on a single lot or parcel,including accessory dwelling units”on “Goal Protected Lands.”Chapter l.C.2.b.Where Middle Housing is allowed to be developed the Middle Housing Land Division Statue requires the City to approve the platting of lots for the Middle Housing.ORS 92.031(1) “The conceptual plan for Lot 39 shows four Middle Housing lots,which will require a Middle Housing Land Division under ORS 92.131 in the future.A Middle Housing Land Division is feasible for Lot 39 because the Middle Housing Model Code applies directly. (Ordinance No.20667 (eff.June 25,2022)added the reference to “middle housing”and changed “900 feet”to “901 feet.”That ordinance was remanded,as discussed above. Effective with the remand,the former standard applies:‘No development shall occur on land above an elevation of 901 feet except that one dwelling may be built on any lot in existence as of August 1,2001.’ 27 During the applicant’s 201 8 PUD application for the subject property,the applicant asserted that this area of the site was part of a larger lot that existed on August 1,2001.The Healings Official determined that the area now identified as Lot 39 “was not created as a separate lot until the Braewood Hills Third Addition PUD was approved in 2002”and,accordingly imposed a condition prohibiting any development on that lot.The Planning Commission affirmed that condition. 28 While the applicant’s narrative may have been drafted after Ordinance 20667 had been remanded by LUBA,the applicant submitted its application after Ordinance 20705,which adopted the City’s Middle Housing standards and Middle Housing Land Division procedures in response to that LUBA remanded.Thus,when the application was filed,it was subject to the City’s middle housing standards rather than the State Model Code.However,as discussed above,on the day of the public hearing on this application,LUBA once again remanded the City’s Middle Housing Ordinance and,accordingly,die State Model Code once again applies to middle housing development in the City. Both Ordinance 20667 and Ordinance 20705 were remanded based on LUBA’s determination that the City’s middle housing standards do not comply with Goal 1 1 .Neither remand in any way implicates EC 9.8325(8)(a). (Application Narrative,page 27.)28 81 Thus,the creation of the lot itself is not prohibited under EC 9.8325(8)(a). 29 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)43 The express language of the Middle Housing Model Code -as quoted by the applicant -does not support the applicant’s interpretation of it.Contrary to the applicant’s desired reading,the Middle Housing statute does not require the City to consider only base zones or ignore its PUD overlay requirements when determining whether the property is an area where residential development is allowed.Nor does it suggest that the City must otherwise allow middle housing As the applicant correctly notes in the application and in its rebuttal argument,the Middle Housing Statute,“requires the City to allow ‘all middle housing types in areas zoned for residential use that allow for the development of detached single-family dwellings.’(Bill Kloos August 21,2024 Rebuttal Argument,page 2).In extensive argument,the applicant’s attorney asserts that the Middle Housing statute and implementing rules somehow require the City to consider only “base zones”and prohibit the City from applying its PUD overlay requirements. According to the applicant,the Middle Housing Statute should be read to mandate that if property has a base residential zone -regardless of whether residential development is allowed - the Middle Housing statute mandates that middle housing be allowed. However,EC 9.8325(8)(a)explicitly prohibits all development above 901 feet;and the applicant’s argument is premised on the assertion that the Middle Housing Statute prohibits the City from enforcing that prohibition.The essence of the applicant’s argument is that the applicable Middle Housing Model Code mandates that because the property is zoned for residential development,the applicant is unequivocally entitled to develop that lot with middle housing. Nonetheless,as an initial matter,as the applicant and City agree,EC 9.8325(8)(a)does not prohibit the creation of Lot 39 through this PUD process.Proposed Lot 39 divides from the rest of the site all of the property on the site above 900 feet.As the staff explain: “The Eugene Code defines “development”to include land divisions;however,staff agrees with the applicant that a land division that creates a lot which carves out all the property on the subject site located above 900 feet does not itself “occur on land above an elevation of 901 feet.”Therefore,staff agrees with the applicant that the creation of Lot 39 would not violate the prohibition on development over 901 feet and is consistent with this approval criterion.” to that remand or,now in response to LUBA’s remand of Ordinance 20705.The language of EC 9.8325(8)(a)was approved by the adoption of Ordinance 20679,effective January 1,2023.29 As the City explained in its July 3 1 ,2024 post-hearing memorandum,at.page 7 : “[C]ontrary to the applicant’s arguments about wording changes to EC 9.8325(8)(a),subsection (8)(a)of the Tentative PUD criteria at EC 9.8325 Housing/Clear and Objective and the Tentative Subdivision criteria at EC 9.8520 Housing/Clear and Objective were approved as part of City Ordinance 20679 which became effective on January 1,2023,and will not be affected by the remand of Ordinance No.20705.*** [T]he only Tentative Subdivision criteria affected by the remand are EC 9.8510(6),9.8515(13)and 9.8520(9),all of which relate to expedited land divisions.***All that said,the applicant’s arguments related to the wording in EC 9.8325(8)(a)(and whether it includes reference to middle housing or not)are essentially irrelevant based on the simple factthat Lot 39 was notin existence as of August 1,2001.” 82 (City Post-Hearing Memorandum,July 3 1 ,2024,page 2.) (c)Residential density is limited as follows: Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)44 Finding:While the property is more than 300 feet from the urban growth boundary,as discussed above EC 9.8325(8)(a)prohibits any development on the site located above 900 feet, above,no development above 901 -foot elevation can occur on this site. Since almost all of proposed Lot 39 is above 901 feet and the land comprising proposed Lot 39 did not exist as a separate lot on August 1,2001,the applicant is prohibited from further development on that lot.Accordingly,approval of this PUD would warrant a condition prohibiting development of any development on any land over 901 feet in elevation. The applicant is simply incorrect that Lot 39 is “zoned for residential use that allow[s]for residential development.”The subject residentially zoned property is subject to the PUD overlay and,in accordance with the clear and objective criteria of EC 9.8325(8)(a),no residential development is allowed any property above 901 feet.As the City correctly noted in its post hearing memorandum: on residentially zoned property that expressly prohibits residential development.Rather,it expressly requires middle housing only in areas that otherwise allow residential development. (b)Development on any portion of the development site located above 900 feet elevation shall be set back at least 300 feet from the ridgeline unless there is a determination by the City manager that the area is not needed as a connection to the City’s ridgeline trail system.For purposes of this section,the ridgeline shall be considered as the line indicated as being the urban growth boundary. 1.In the area west of Friendly Street,the maximum level of new development per gross acre shall be 8 units per acre. 2.In the area east of Friendly Street,the maximum level of new development per gross acre shall be limited to 5 units per acre. 3.Housing developed as Controlled Income and Rent Housing shall be exempt from the density limitations in subsections 1 and 2 above,but are subject to the other applicable development standards and review procedures. “Neither the Model Code,nor ORS 92.03 1 apply to the middle housing lots shown as part of Lot 39 on the applicant’s proposed site plan.ORS 197A.410 (the middle housing statute),OAR 660-046-0105(1)and OAR 660-046-0205(l)-(2)(middle housing rules) and the Model Code all require the City to allow development of duplexes on “each lot or parcel zoned for residential use that allows for the development of detached single family dwellings”and to allow for the development of triplexes,fourplexes,cottage clusters and townhouses “in areas zoned for residential use that allow for the development of detached single-family dwellings.”(Emphasis added.)Single-unit dwellings are prohibited on Lot 39;therefore,middle housing units are also prohibited on that lot.” 83 Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)45 Based on the written statement,the applicant is asking to capture stormwater flow from an existing pipe that outfalls onto Lot 18 prior to final PUD approval.The applicant proposes to reroute the stormwater flow through their proposed stormwater system.The proposed alteration would impact existing wetlands,requiring a Wetland Removal-Fill permit from the Oregon Department of State Lands (ODSL).ODSL has not issued a Wetland Removal-Fill permit for that purpose.30 A previous attempt to re-route the existing outfall in 2022 resulted in a Code Compliance enforcement action (Case No.22-00839)for trenching and drainage work diverting spring water away from wetlands on the subject site without any permits.It was noted at the time that trenching was done within the critical root zones of existing trees on the site.The City’s Erosion Control team monitored and confirmed the restoration of the site to its previous condition in December 2022.Numerous residents also expressed serious concerns about the applicant’s previous,improperly conducted work on the site. Based on the history of work done without permits on the site,possible negative impact to existing trees,the existence of a Goal 5 protected stream on site,and multiple identified wetlands on site requiring Wetland Removal-Fill approval from the Oregon Department of State Lands, alteration of the site prior to final PUD approval is not appropriate.Rather,if ultimately approved,the proposed drainage improvements and any related site work must be undertaken subject to appropriate permitting processes and review,following final PUD approval. Accordingly,as required under EC 9.8330,if ultimately approved,no features could be substantially altered until final PUD approval,and then only as authorized by the final PUD approval. Finding:Although not part of the “Housing/Clear and Objective”approval criteria,the applicant has specifically requested the Hearings Official’s permission for site alteration on the property prior to final PUD approval. Finding:As discussed at EC 9.8325(2),the development site,with 15.47 acres and 38 lots,has a density of 2.45 units per gross acre,which meets the maximum density requirement of 8 units per acre west of Friendly Street.Any middle housing development on Lots 1-38 would be exempt from this density limitation.The proposal does not include Controlled Income and Rent Housing. 4.This subsection (c)does not preclude middle housing or the addition of an accessory dwelling on any legal lot. EC 9.8330 Site Alteration. Unless specifically permitted by the hearings official,vegetation,topography,and other natural features of areas proposed for a PUD shall not be substantially altered until final PUD approval,and then only as authorized by the final PUD approval. “Substantially altered”includes,but is not limited to,site grading and removal of trees or other vegetation.If a subdivision is required,site alteration shall not be permitted until after tentative subdivision approval is granted. 'jn Written post-hearing testimony from the ODSL Aquatic Resource Coordinator submitted July 30,2024 confirms that no removal-fill permit has been issued,and that he has been aware of this project for several years and that all jurisdictional impacts will be accounted for in processing the permit. 84 Additional Consideration (City Staff July 3 1 ,2024 Post-Hearing Memorandum,page 1 0.) 2.TENTATIVE SUBDIVISION APPLICATION Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)46 Conclusion:Unless and until the applicant establishes either that the subject property is an acknowledged,inventoried Goal 5 resource or addresses and establishes compliance with the criteria at EC 9.8325(3),which requires compliance with the EC 9.6880 to EC 9.6885 Tree Preservation and Removal Standards;and EC 9.8325(5)(d),which requires compliance with EC 9.6710(6)Geological and Geotechnical Analysis,the applicant has not established compliance with each of the approval criteria and the application must be denied.In addition,provided the applicant could otherwise establish compliance with those approval criteria,an exception to the EC 9.6815(2)(c)street connectivity standards must be based on evidence that has properly been included into the record;and the applicant must confirm compliance with all stormwater standards. Consequently,because it is not an approval criterion,the City has no authority to require the impacts of traffic be evaluated through a TIA. Several residents of the surrounding area object to the absence of a Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA).As they correctly note,the proposed development could certainly generate more than the 1 00 or more vehicle trips during any peak hour.(This will be particularly so if middle housing is developed on any of the proposed lots.)However,a traffic impact analysis,as otherwise required under EC 9.8670 et seq,is not applicable to applications submitted the “clear and objective”approval criteria.As the staff explained in their post-hearing memorandum: EC 9.8505 Applicability of Subdivision,Tentative Plan Applications -confirms at EC 9.8505(4) that a tentative plan application to subdivide land may be submitted and reviewed concurrently with a Tentative PUD application following a Type III application procedure.In this case the applicant submitted a concurrent Tentative Subdivision application along with the Tentative PUD,to follow a Type III application procedure.Accordingly,the staff evaluated the proposed development under the applicable Tentative Subdivision approval criteria. “Many of the community members submitting written testimony or providing comments during the public hearing expressed concerns about the negative impacts of increased traffic and the lack of a Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA)as a required for the proposed Tentative PUD and Subdivision.Staff is sympathetic to the neighbors’concerns’ however,compliance with EC 9.6850 through EC 9.8680 Traffic Impact Analysis Review,is not an approval criterion applicable to a Tentative PUD or Tentative Subdivision application electing to use the City’s Housing/Clear and Objective track approval criteria.Because a TIA is not listed as an approval criterion for the Housing/Clear and Objective track applications as is the case here,the applicant is not required to submit a TIA,even if the development would otherwise trigger a TIA under the applicable criteria in EC 9.8670.” 85 DECISION A Hearings Official Decision (PDT 24-1;ST 24-3)47 SEE NOTICE OF HEARINGS OFFICIAL DECISION FOR STATEMENT OF APPEAL RIGHTS Virginia Gustafson Lucker Hearings Official To the extent the subdivisions application relies on complies with the PUD criteria,it also cannot be approved. As reflected in the Staff Report,the staff relied almost exclusively on its analysis of the PUD approval criteria in determining that the proposed subdivision also satisfied the tentative subdivision approval criteria.To the extent the review of the proposed development satisfies the PUD approval criteria,the corresponding tentative subdivision approval criteria are also satisfied.However,significantly,the applicant has not demonstrated that,with the exception of the protected uplands stream corridor,the subject property is subject to the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory.Unless and until that demonstration is made,the PUD is subject to the requirements EC 9.8325(3)and EC 9.8325(5)(d).Without evidence to establish either that those criteria are inapplicable or that the proposed development complies with them,the PUD application cannot be approved. Based on the above analysis and findings,the applicant has not established compliance with each of ' the applicable approval criteria and,therefore,the subject application for approval of a tentative PUD and Subdivision for the Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3)is DENIED. Dated this 5th day September,2024. Mailed this day of September,2024. 86