Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAppeal Hearings Official Public Hearing 04/29/2026AGENDA Phone: 541-682-5377 Meeting Location: Virtual Meeting (Via Zoom) www.eugene-or.gov/406/hearings-official The Eugene Hearings Official welcomes your interest in these agenda items. The Permit and Information Center (PIC) is open 12:00pm —4:00pm, Monday through Friday. Information about online or other options for access and participation is available on the next page of this agenda. For the hearing impaired, assistive-listening devices or an interpreter can be provided with 72- hour notice prior to the meeting. Spanish-language interpretation may also be provided with 72- hour notice. These services may not be available during the meeti ng but may occur as a follow up service. To arrange for these services, contact the Planning Division at 541-682-5699. WEDNESDAY, APRIL 29, 2026 – PUBLIC HEARING 5:30 PM Hearings Official: David Doughman 1. Public Hearing: Appeal of the Planning Director’s Decision for the Braewood Hills 3rd Addition Final Planned Unit Development and concurrent Standards Review applications. Description: Appeal of the Planning Director’s Decision that conditionally approved the Braewood Hills 3rd Addition Final Planned Unit Development and concurrent Standards Review Applications. File Name (File #): Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02) Subject Property Location: East side of Hawkins Lane and northeast of Randy Lane Assessor’s Map / Tax Lot: 18-04-11-12 / 00200 Lead City Staff: Nick Gioello, Associate Planner, 541-682-5453, NGioello@eugene-or.gov PUBLIC HEARING FORMAT 1. Staff introduction/presentation 2. Public testimony from applicant. 3. Testimony from the public. Due to the virtual meeting platform, the order of speakers will be based on order that persons request to speak (raise virtual hand), as opposed to the order specified under EC 9.7075. For this reason, each person providing comment will be asked to state whether they are in support, neutral, or i n opposition to the application. 4. Staff response to testimony. 5. Questions from Hearings Official. Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 1 of 79 6. Rebuttal testimony from applicant. 7. Closing of public hearing. The Hearings Official will not make a decision at this hearing. The Eugene Code requires that a written decision must be made within 15 days of close of the public comment period. To be notified of the Hearings Official’s decision, state your name and address during the public testimony portion of the public hearing or contact the lead City staff noted above. The decision will also be posted at https://www.eugene-or.gov/406/Hearings-Official. HOW TO ACCESS THE MEETING To be able to participate in Public Comment join using one of the two following options: 1. Join on your computer, tablet or smartphone Visit: https://eugene-or-gov.zoom.us/j/89461876548 When prompted, sign up to speak by clicking once on the “raise hand” icon 2. Join on your phone Dial one of the numbers below and enter the Webinar ID: 894 6187 6548 +1 833-548-0276 (Toll Free); or +1 833-548-0282 (Toll Free); or +1 877-853-5257 (Toll Free); or +1 888-475-4499 (Toll Free) When prompted, sign up to speak by dialing *9 (Star-9) For higher quality, dial a number based on your current location. International numbers available: https://eugene-or-gov.zoom.us/u/kdqkbXk182 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 2 of 79 1 Date: April 22, 2026 To: David Doughman, Eugene Hearings Official From: Nicholas Gioello, Associate Planner, City of Eugene Planning Division Subject: Appeal of Braewood Hill Third Addition Final PUD and Standards Review Approval (City Files PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02) ______________________________________________________________________________ ACTION REQUESTED: To hold a public hearing on April 29, 2026, and make a final local decision on an appeal of the Eugene Planning Director’s decision approving a Final Planned Unit Development (PUD) and Standards Review (City Files PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02). BACKGROUND: The subject site is located east of Hawkins Lane and north of Herald Lane. The site is approximately 15.47 acres, is zoned R-1 Low-Density Residential with /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay. Previously, in 2024, the applicant applied for a Tentative PUD and Tentative Subdivision for the creation of a 39-lot residential development and associated infrastructure city streets and utilities on the site. A public hearing was held and the application was denied by the Eugene Hearings Official on September 5, 2024 (City Files: PDT 24-01 and ST 24-03). A subsequent appeal of the decision was filed by the applicant and the Eugene Planning Commission modified the Hearing Official’s decision and conditionally approved the Tentative PUD and Tentative Subdivision. In 2025, the applicant filed concurrent applications for Final PUD and Standards Review for a 38-lot1 residential development on the site. A Standards Review approval is required due to a proposed street crossing of a protected Goal 5 resource on the site. On March 12, 2026, the Planning Director approved the Final PUD and Standards Review that are the subject of this appeal. 1 The Tentative PUD approval for 39 lots included a condition of approval requiring the applicant to update the site plan and depict Lot 38 with frontage on a public street or show a private street or private access easement connected to a public street; alternatively, the condition of approval also allowed the combination of Lots 37 and 38 into one lot. The applicant chose to combine Lot 37 and 38, therefore the Final PUD was approved with a total of 38 lots. Memorandum The Atrium Building 99 West 10th Avenue, Eugene, Oregon 97401 Phone: 541.682.5377 | Fax: 541.682.5572 www.eugene-or.gov/planning Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 3 of 79 2 On March 27, 2026, Wes Van Winkle and Attorney Charles W. Woodword, IV, filed an appeal of the Planning Director’s Final PUD and Standards Review. The appeal asserts that the Planning Director erred in the decision regarding the Eugene Code on one issue related to the Final PUD and two issues related to the Standards Review approval. Public notice of the April 29, 2026, appeal hearing was mailed on April 9, 2026. On April 21, 2026, a Supplemental Appeal Notice was sent to clarify information pertaining to the scope of the appeal and allowed evidence and testimony. This supplemental notice clarified that the appeal of a Planning Direction’s decision is in accordance with Eugene Code Section 9.7605(3). At this time no testimony has been received. Testimony has been received just prior to the publishing of this staff report and it will be forwarded to the Hearings Official and added to the record. Further background information on this appeal, including the Hearings Official’s decision denying the Tentative PUD and Tentative Subdivision application, the decision on appeal of the Planning Commission to modify and affirm the Tentative PUD and Tentative Subdivision approval, and the applicant’s Final PUD and Tentative Subdivision applications, are included in the full record of materials provided separately. The following attachments are provided for reference: A vicinity map and reduced site plan are included as Attachments A and B to this memorandum; the written appeal statement is included as Attachment C; the Fire Marshal’s Office referral comments are included as Attachment D, a Public Works memorandum regarding maximum street grade is included as Attachment E; the Planning Director’s decision granting Final PUD and Standards Review approval is included as Attachment F. Also, for reference purposes, staff has added the Hearings Official Decision and the Planning Commission Final Order (PDT 24-01 and ST 24-03) to the file materials. APPEAL PROCEDURES The appeal hearing will follow quasi-judicial procedures as required by EC 9.7625 and EC 9.7065-9.7095. The decision on this appeal will be based on whether the Planning Director properly evaluated the request and made a decision consistent with applicable approval criteria for the Final Planned Unit Development at EC 9.8365 and Standards Review application at EC 9.8470. The decision on this appeal will be made within 15 days from the close of the public record unless the parties agree otherwise. The Hearings Official may affirm, reverse, or modify the decision of the Planning Director. Once made, the decision of the Hearings Official will be the City’s final local decision. The final local decision on these appeals is required by May 29, 2026 to meet the statutory 120-day deadline. Appeals of Planning Director Decisions are subject to the provisions at EC 9.7600 through 9.7635. Because the Final Planned Unit Development and Standards Review applications are being considered concurrently, and both the Final Planned Unit Development and Standards Review are considered a “permit” as defined by ORS 227.160(2), in accordance with ORS 227.175(10), the appeal hearing will be “de novo” (new evidence and information may be submitted) and the presentation of testimony, arguments and evidence is not limited to issues raised in a notice of appeal. APPEAL ISSUES AND STAFF RESPONSE: Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 4 of 79 3 The appeal statement asserts the applicant failed to comply with applicable provisions of the Final PUD and the Director erred approving the Final PUD. The appeal statement also asserts the applicant did not demonstrate compliance with two specific approval criterion and the Director erred approving the Standards Review. To assist the Hearings Official in determining whether to affirm, reverse, or modify the Planning Director’s decision, staff have identified pertinent record information and considerations below. A summary of the appeal issues is provided below, followed by a summary of the Planning Director’s decision and staff comments and recommendation. Issue of appeal #1: Final Planned Unit Development (PDF 25-01) The Planning Director’s decision contradicts the Fire Marshal’s comments2 and errs in finding compliance with EC 9.8365 Summary of Appellant’s Argument: The appellant asserts that the Director’s Decision responded to public comments regarding concerns of emergency access, narrow streets and steep grades by stating that the Fire Marshal's Office comments (see Attachment D) "expressed no concerns related to emergency service access to the site". Also, the Director’s Decision responded to public comments regarding the driveways being too narrow for emergency vehicle access, stating the Fire Marshal provided referral comments "which did not express concerns with the driveway widths or indicate a risk to public safety." The appellant asserts that these statements in the Decision are false. The appellant also asserts that other comments by the Fire Marshal regarding No Parking Fire Lane signage posted on Randy Lane, Tambour Lane and Tambour Court and the proposed 14- foot access easements will not be adequate for the required fire apparatus access requirements of 20-foot minimum, which contradicts the Director’s Decision. The appellant asserts the Director erred in finding compliance with EC 9.8365(1). Summary of Planning Director’s Decision: The Director’s decision approving the Final PUD application included findings that the Final PUD plan conformed with the approved Tentative PUD plan and all conditions attached thereto. The Director reviewed the Final PUD application for consistency and conformance with 27 conditions of approval in the Tentative PUD decision and provided findings for each of the conditions. The Director found that for most of the conditions, the applicant had either met the criteria or future compliance with the criteria would be ensured through the Final Subdivision and Final Plat process or during future Privately Engineered Public Improvements (PEPI) permit or building permit process during development of the streets and lots. In three instances, additional conditions of approval were imposed by the Director to ensure three of the Tentative PUD conditions of approval would be met prior to final site plan approval. 2 Fire Marshal’s Office comments dated February 25, 2026. Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 5 of 79 4 Staff Comments and Recommendation: Appeal Issue #1 is based on the appellant’s assertion that statements in the Decision about the Fire Marshal’s comments are false regarding emergency service access to the site, adequate driveway widths and access easement widths, and the Director erred in finding compliance with EC 9.8365(1). The director’s Decision includes a section at the beginning titled Procedure, Public Notice, and Agency Referrals. This section of the Decision provided a bullet point summary of the concerns raised in the received public testimony. Analysis and discussion about these concerns was also provided. It is important to note that this section of the Decision is purely informational and is not established in the Eugene Code as criteria for approval. For this Final PUD approval, there is one applicable criterion at EC 9.8365(1), which states: The final PUD plan conforms with the approved tentative PUD plan and all conditions attached thereto. As previously stated, the Director’s Decision provided an analysis of each of the 27 conditions of approval of the Tentative PUD and how the Final PUD either met the criteria or future compliance with the criteria would be ensured either through future building permit review or with additional conditions of approval. The appellant argues that The Fire Marshal commented (see Attachment D) that the maximum slope of Tambour Court had changed from 19% to 24% and is not acceptable for fire apparatus access. Public Works staff have reviewed this issue and issued a memorandum (see attachment E) that concurs with the Fire Marshal’s comments. Public Works concludes that Sheet C3.0 of the Final PUD plans includes a profile view of Tambour Court that depicts a 29-foot section with a grade of 24.22%, which does not comply with EC 9.6875 and is inconsistent with the Tentative PUD approval. Staff acknowledges that this is not in compliance and needs to be addressed. However, rather than warranting denial, staff recommends the Hearings Official modify the Director’s Decision with the addition of the following condition of approval to demonstrate compliance with EC 9.8365(1): 1. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that includes a profile view of Tambour Court. The updated profile view of Tambour Court shall comply with EC 9.6875 and not exceed 20% slope. For informational purposes, within the above condition, “final site plan approval” refers to the final site plan included as an exhibit to the required Performance Agreement (See EC 9.7025), which dictates and controls future development on the property. The appellant fails to further articulate how the Final PUD approval does not conform with the approved Tentative PUD or any of the Conditions of Approval of the Tentative PUD. The Planning Director correctly complied with the requirements of EC 9.8365 by reviewing the Final PUD plan for consistency and conformance with the Tentative PUD plan and all conditions of approval attached thereto. It is also important to note that the 2022 Eugene Fire Code (as referenced in the Fire Marshal’s comments) is enforced through the authority of the Eugene-Springfield Fire Marshal’s Office Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 6 of 79 5 and is not part of the Eugene Land Use Code. Therefore, land use decisions such as the subject of this appeal cannot impose restrictions or conditions of approval based on the 2022 Eugene Fire Code. The Fire Marsal’s Office will provide review of fire code regulations during the building permit phase as the site develops and has the regulatory power to impose revisions and restrictions for site development. Based on the available information and with the addition of a condition of approval as discussed above to ensure compliance with EC 9.8365, staff finds the Director did not err by approving the Final PUD if modified by the Hearings Official. Issue of appeal #2: Standards Review SDR 25-02 Issue of appeal #2 includes two sub-assignments of error. The appellant asserts the Standards Review does not comply with EC 9.4980(4)(a) regarding the use of heavy machinery on the site and EC 9.4980(4)(b) regarding petroleum products, chemicals, and other deleterious materials used in the construction process. Sub-assignment of error 1 - The Applicant has not demonstrated compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(a). Summary of Appellant’s Argument: Regarding compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(a), the appellant cites inconsistencies in the wording of condition of approval #5, 6 and 7 claiming it allows the applicant to not designate staging areas on the site plan and renders the conditions of approval insufficient to ensure compliance with the provision. Summary of Planning Director’s Decision: Regarding sub-assignment of error 1, in the findings for the Standards Review, the Director found the site plan did not show staging locations for machinery, and no explanation was provided in the written statement to demonstrate how construction on the site would comply with EC 9.4980(4)(a). The following conditions of approval were required in the Director’s decision to ensure minimal impacts to areas outside of the conservation setback during road construction as follows: 5. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan that shows staging area(s) for heavy machinery. Alternatively, the applicant may include a note on the final site plan stating, “No staging areas for heavy equipment will be located within a Conservation Area.” 6. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan that shows the location of access for and use of heavy machinery within the extent of the Conservation Area impacted by the construction of the road. Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 7 of 79 6 7. Prior to final site plan approval, the following note shall be added to the final site plans: “Heavy machinery may only be used in the /WR conservation areas between June 15 and September 30 and will not be used outside of the area shown on this site plan for staging and access to the construction impact area”. Staff Comments and Recommendation: The inclusion of specific notes on the final plan set ensures the ability of the City to monitor construction activities on the on the site and the impacts to the Goal 5 resource. As noted in the first appeal issue, per EC 9.7025, the applicant will be required to execute a Performance Agreement with the City. A Performance Agreement is a signed agreement between the property owner or developer and the City which describes the scope of work, requires compliance with the approved final site plans, which are included as an exhibit to the agreement, and lists all the conditions of approval from the Tentative PUD decision. The Performance Agreement also includes remedies for Breach and Liquidated Damages and is binding on all successors in interest. This provides the City the ability to ensure that all criteria and regulations are met during all phases of construction and development of the site. Regarding sub-assignment of error 1, the appellant references Conditions #5, #6 and #7, all of which are related to the use of heavy machinery and staging on the site. The appellant specifically discusses conditions #5 and #7, stating: [B]y including the word "alternatively" [in Condition #5] the Decision contradicts itself with regard to Condition of Approval 7 which requires a note on the site plan referring to areas that are designated as the staging areas for heavy equipment. Providing a note that allows the Applicant not to designate staging areas on the site plan renders the conditions of approval insufficient to ensure compliance with the provision. Condition #5 is intended to restrict the location of construction staging areas to ensure they are located outside of the conservation area, where machinery will be parked when not in use and where loaded and unloaded from transport vehicles. Condition #5 is intended to allow two options; either the final plan shows specifically where the staging area is located, or a note is added that indicates no staging area is allowed within the conservation area. As worded, Condition #7 anticipates that a staging area and access area will be shown on the final site plan, while Condition #5 allows an option that would not show a staging and access area. While staff no not agree with the applicant’s assertions, a simple revision to the condition could be included to provide clarity regarding the location of staging areas for heavy machinery on the site. If determined necessary by the Hearings, Official, the following revision to condition #7 is recommended, with added clarifying text provided in bold italic font: 7. Prior to final site plan approval, the following note shall be added to the final site plans: “Heavy machinery may only be used in the /WR conservation areas between June 15 and September 30. Heavy machinery may only be used in the staging area, access area and the construction impact area.” Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 8 of 79 7 Regardless of whether the applicant chooses to show the staging and access area on the site plan or provides the note prohibiting staging within the conservation area, either option will still allow the City to enforce compliance with the /WR standards during construction activities on the site. The appellant argues that Director’s Decision failed to address the lack of protective fencing proposed along the Conservation Area south of the Randy Lane extension. This area is an approximately 5-foot strip between the south property boundary and the edge of the new sidewalk adjacent to Randy Lane. This area, although within the Resource Conservation setback, will be part of the construction area associated with the road extension. It is also noted that the Goal 5 stream in this location is contained within an existing underground culvert and will not be disturbed by the proposed road construction. As part of the Erosion Control Permit that is required during the road construction a sediment fence will be required along the south property line in this area that is downstream from the resource and will restrict any disturbed soil or construction debris from exiting the property and entering the stream where it surfaces on the Videra Park property as it exits the culvert. It is staff’s opinion that no additional fencing in this area is necessary to be consistent with the /WR Development Standards at EC 9.4980. Based on the available information, staff finds the Director did not err by finding the application in compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(a) and approving the Standards Review application, but provides an option to modify the Director’s decision with a revision to condition of approval #7 to ensure compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(a). Sub-assignment of error 2 - The Applicant has not demonstrated compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(b). Summary of Appellant’s Argument: Regarding compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(b), the appellant cites condition of approval #8, alleging the Applicant failed to provide evidence of compliance with this criterion. The appellant argues that adding the language of the code provision to the final plat3 in no way actually provides any evidence that ensures compliance with this provision. Summary of Planning Director’s Decision: In the Findings for the Standards Review, the Director found the applicant provided a statement that agreed with the criterion, but did not provide evidence to demonstrate how their plan would comply with EC 9.4980(4)(b), which states: Petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process shall not be allowed to enter a stream or wetland that is within a /WR conservation area. To ensure compliance with this criterion, the following condition of approval was required in the Director’s decision: 3 The appellant refers to notes being added to the final plat, however, the Directors decision clearly requires notes to be added to the final site plans. Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 9 of 79 8 8. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall add a note to the final site plans that states, “Petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process shall not be allowed to enter a stream or wetland that is within a /WR conservation area.” Staff Comments and Recommendation: Regarding Condition of Approval #8, the appellant argues that the code provision at EC 9.4980(4)(b) pertaining to petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials being added to the final plat as a note does not provide evidence that ensures compliance with the provision. Staff disagrees with this assertion. As previously discussed, the applicant will be required to execute a Performance Agreement with the City which describes the scope of work, requires compliance with the approved final site plans and lists all the conditions of approval from the Tentative PUD decision. The Performance Agreement also includes remedies for Breach and Liquidated Damages and is binding on all successors in interest. This provides the City the ability to ensure that all criteria and regulations are met during all phases of construction and development of the site. Based on the available information, staff finds the Director did not err by finding the application in compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(b) and approving the Standards Review application. ATTACHMENTS A. Vicinity Map B. Site Plans (reduced in size) C. Written Appeal Statement and Attachments D. Fire Marshal’s Office Memorandum E. Public Works Memorandum F. Planning Director’s Decision (PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02) The full record has been provided to the Hearings Official separately. Related application and appeal materials are also available as a courtesy on the City’s website at: https://pdd.eugene-or.gov/LandUse/ApplicationDetails?file=PDF-25-0001 A hardcopy of the complete record can also be made available for free inspection at the Atrium Building, 99 West 10th Avenue, between 12:00 p.m. and 4:00 p.m. Monday through Friday. FOR MORE INFORMATION Please contact Nicholas Gioello, Associate Planner, City of Eugene Planning Division, 541-682-5453 or via email at ngioello@eugene-or.gov Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 10 of 79 Vicinity Map•Braewood Hills Third Addition (PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02) Cl Subject Property Taxlots C Eugene UGB -Attachment A Caution: This map is based on imprecise source data, subject to change, and for general reference only. Created on 4/22/2026 by City of Eugene Planning Division --C:::::::::J Ft A. 0 140 2so NORTH Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 11 of 79 Attachment B Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 12 of 79 www.eugene-or.gov/planning Planning & Development Updated: May 2024 Planning Division 99 W. 10TH Avenue Suite 290, Eugene, OR 97401 Phone: 541.682.5377 or E-mail: planning@eugene-or.gov Page 1 of 2 Please check one of the following: Adjustment Review, Minor Adjustment Review, Major Code Interpretation HazardousMaterialsReview Historic Property Alteration HistoricPropertyDemolition Historic Property Move ModificationofaConditionalUse Permit Modification of a PUD Tentative Modification of a PUD Final Modification of a Site Review ModificationofaStandardsReview Modification of a Subdivision Plan Modification of a Willamette Greenway Partition Tentative Partition Final PUD Final Site Review Standards Review Subdivision Tentative Subdivision Final Traffic ImpactAnalysis Vacation Improved Public R-O-W Vacation ImprovedPublicEasement Unimproved PublicR-O-Wwith Re-dedication Variance APPEALOFPLANNINGDIRECTORDECISION This appeal form applies to appeals of interpretation of this Land Use Code made according to EC 9.0040(1) and to appeals to all Type II land use applications. The appeal of the Planning Director’s decision provides for a review of an administrative decision by a higher review authority specified in this Land Use Code. The Planning Director’s decision may be affirmed, reversed, or modified. City File Name:_______________________________________________________________________________________________ City File Number:_____________________________________________________________________________________________ Date of Planning Director Decision:______________________________________________________________________ Date Appeal Filed:___________________________________________________________________________________ (This date must be within 12 days of the date of the mailing of the Planning Director’s decision.) Attach a written appeal statement. The appeal statement shall include a written statement of issues on appeal and be limited to the issues raised in the appeal. The appeal statement shall explain specifically how the Planning Director’s decision is inconsistent with applicable criteria. Please contact Planning staff at the Permit and Information center, 99 West 10th Avenue, 541-682-5377, for further information on the appeal process. A filing fee must accompany an appeal of a Planning Director decision, with some exceptions for neighborhood groups. The fee varies depending upon the type of application and is adjusted periodically by the City Manager. Check with Planning staff at the Permit and Information Center to determine the required fee or check on the web at: www.eugeneplanning.org Braewood Hills Third Addition SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01 March 12, 2026 (mailed March 17, 2026) March 27, 2026 Attachment C Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 13 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 14 of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earings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 15 of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earings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 16 of 79       AB6347</:(,>:/<2=3A<=B1=<4=@;B=B63/>>@=D32B3<B/B7D3(,>:/<B63>>:71/<B6/A4/7:32B= 23;=<AB@/B31=;>:7/<13E7B6  /<2B63@34=@3B63317A7=<A6=C:203@3D3@A32/<2B63( />>:71/B7=<23<732  *7;7:/@:G>=7<B=4B637@3%/@A6/:LA1=;;3<BA<=B3A  *B@33BE72B6A=4 433BE7B6>/@97<5=<=<3A723/>>3/@B=;33B7BG=4C53<33<57<33@7<5 AB/<2/@2A4=@:=1/: /113AA =E3D3@C53<3*>@7<5473:27@3AB@=<5:G@31=;;3<2A4=::=E7<5 B63 C53<37@3=23*31B7=<   E6716@3?C7@3A 433B1:3/@E72B6E7B6<=>/@97<5 /::=E32=<0=B6A723AE7B67<5B6/B 4==BE72B64=@B63A3*+%/-!AB@33BA I&'()#!&!) $&JA75</53A6/::03>=AB32=<0=B6A723A=4B63)/<2G$/<3+/;0=C@$/<3/<2+/;0=C@ =C@B C53<37@3=23*31B7=<    (=7<B=4B637@3%/@A6/:LA1=;;3<BAAB/B3A  *3D3@/::=BAA6=E/113AAB=03>@=D72320G /<2  4==B E723CB7:7BG/<2/113AA3/A3;3<BA +67A E72B6                     ;>6/A7A/2232 113AA@3?C7@3;3<BAE7::033D/:C/B32/BB63B7;3=40C7:27<5>3@;7BAC0;7BB/: E63<AC16/113AA7A>@=>=A32 C53<37@3=23         $                     !        #   "  "            #                               %       "          "      #               # !<AC;B63317A7=<3@@327<47<27<51=;>:7/<13E7B6  /AB63>>:71/<B6/A<=B1/@@732 B637@0C@23<=4>@==40G>@=D727<53D723<13=41=;>:7/<137<AB3/2>@=D727<53D723<13=47;>3@;7AA70:G 16/<57<5B63/>>@=D32B3<B/B7D3(,   -( + ,!/%!0   $!**&%(-$,()- !')(,-+-! )'*&%(!0%-$    Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 17 of 79         >@=D723A I=<AB@C1B7=<(@/1B713A =<AB@C1B7=<E7B67<B63 .)1=<A3@D/B7=</@3//<2E7B67< /@3/A@3;=D324@=;B63 .)1=<A3@D/B7=</@3/A6/::1=;>:GE7B6B634=::=E7<5 AB/<2/@2A /=@>C@>=A3A=4B67AAC0A31B7=<63/DG;/167<3@G7A2347<32/A;=B=@7H32=@ ;316/<7H32;/167<3@G=@3?C7>;3<B1/>/0:3=423:703@/B3:G=@7</2D3@B3<B:G 2/;/57<5D353B/B7=<=@2/;/57<5=@1=;>/1B7<5A=7: +634=::=E7<5AB/<2/@2A A6/::/>>:GB=CA3=463/DG;/167<3@GE7B67<B63 .)1=<A3@D/B7=</@3/ '<A7B3AE63@3A=7:A/@3ACA13>B70:3B=A3D3@31=;>/1B7=<=@AB@C1BC@/:2/;/53 E63<E3B=@A/BC@/B32CA3=463/DG;/167<3@GA6/::03:7;7B32B=B63>3@7=2 03BE33<"C<3 /<2*3>B3;03@ C<:3AA=B63@E7A3/>>@=D320GB63 >:/<<7<527@31B=@   ,A3=463/DG;/167<3@GA6/::03B63;7<7;C;<313AA/@G4=@B63CA3=@/1B7D7BG /<2A6/::03@3AB@71B32B=B6=A3/@3/AE63@37BACA37A<313AA/@G J  .7B6@3A>31BB=1=;>:7/<13E7B6B67A>@=D7A7=<B63317A7=<AB/B3A I+63/>>:71/<BA>:/<2=3A<=BA6=EAB/57<5:=1/B7=<A4=@;/167<3@G/<2>@=D723A<=3F>:/</B7=< 7<B63E@7BB3<AB/B3;3<B:793:G2C3B=B634/1BB6/BB631=<AB@C1B7=<E7::CB7:7H3B63>@=>=A32@=/2 /AB63/113AA4=@B63A7B3E67167A;=AB:G:=1/B32=CBA723=4/<G=<A3@D/B7=<@3/  =E3D3@ E7B6=CBB6/B1:/@7BG7<B63@31=@2B634=::=E7<51=<27B7=<A/@3E/@@/<B32B=;7<7;7H37;>/1BAB= /@3/AB6/B2=<=B<332B=037;>/1B320G63/DG;/167<3@GB=1=<AB@C1BB63AB@33B/<2AB=@;E/B3@ 4/17:7BG  (@7=@B=47</:A7B3>:/</>>@=D/:B63/>>:71/<BA6/::AC0;7B/@3D7A32A7B3>:/<B6/BA6=EA AB/57<5/@3/A4=@63/DG;/167<3@G :B3@</B7D3:GB63/>>:71/<B;/G7<1:C23/<=B3=< B6347</:A7B3>:/<AB/B7<5K&=AB/57<5/@3/A4=@63/DG3?C7>;3<BE7::03:=1/B32E7B67</ =<A3@D/B7=<@3/ L  (@7=@B=47</:A7B3>:/</>>@=D/:B63/>>:71/<BA6/::AC0;7B/@3D7A32A7B3>:/<B6/BA6=EA B63:=1/B7=<=4/113AA4=@/<2CA3=463/DG;/167<3@GE7B67<B633FB3<B=4B63 =<A3@D/B7=<@3/7;>/1B320GB631=<AB@C1B7=<=4B63@=/2   (@7=@B=47</:A7B3>:/</>>@=D/:B634=::=E7<5<=B3A6/::03/2232B=B6347</:A7B3>:/<A 3/DG;/167<3@G;/G=<:G03CA327<B63 .)1=<A3@D/B7=</@3/A03BE33< BC<3  /<2*3>B3;03@ /<2E7::<=B03CA32=CBA723=4B63/@3/A6=E<=<B67AA7B3>:/<4=@ AB/57<5/<2/113AAB=B631=<AB@C1B7=<7;>/1B/@3/  /A32=<B63A347<27<5A/<21=<27B7=<AB63/0=D3AB/<2/@2A/@3;3B J  317A7=<>    7@ABB63317A7=<@31=5<7H3AB6/BB63>>:71/<B4/7:32B=>@=D7233D723<13=41=;>:7/<13 *31=<20G 7<1:C27<5B63E=@2I/:B3@</B7D3:GJB63317A7=<1=<B@/271BA7BA3:4E7B6@35/@2B==<27B7=<=4>>@=D/:E6716 @3?C7@3A/<=B3=<B63A7B3>:/<@343@@7<5B=/@3/AB6/B/@323A75</B32/AB63AB/57<5/@3/A4=@63/DG3?C7>;3<B  (@=D727<5/<=B3B6/B/::=EAB63>>:71/<B<=BB=23A75</B3AB/57<5/@3/A=<B63A7B3>:/<@3<23@AB631=<27B7=<A =4/>>@=D/:7<AC447173<BB=3<AC@31=;>:7/<13E7B6B63>@=D7A7=< )35/@2:3AAE7B6=CBB63/1BC/:3D723<13=4 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 18 of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earings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 19 of 79       =@B63/0=D3@3/A=<A*/D3-723@/'/9%3/2=EA/<2.3A-/<.7<9:3@3?C3ABAB6/BB63317A7=<=< B6347</:(,/<2B63AB/<2/@2A@3D73E/>>:71/B7=<A7:3&=A (+ *+ A6=C:203@3D3@A32/<2 23<732   )3A>31B4C::GAC0;7BB32 6/@:3A. .==2E/@2!- BB=@<3G4=@*/D3-723@/'/9%3/2=EA/<2.3A-/<.7<9:3  Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 20 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 21 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 22 of 79 A shared service of the cities of Eugene and Springfield, Oregon Eugene Office 1320 Willamette Street Eugene, OR 97401 (541) 682-5411 (541) 682-6882 FAX Fire Marshal’s Office Fire Department Comments For eugene or springFielD planning Departments Date: February 25, 2026 Project: Braewood Hills 3rd Addition File Number: PDF-25-01 Address: not yet assigned; east of Hawkins Lane-Eugene Existing Use: Vacant Proposal: Final Planned Unit Development to create 38 residential lots, streets, and associated infrastructure improvements. Planner: Nick Gioello, Associate Planner Fire Department Comments/Conditions Access: 1. The maximum street profile slope for Tambour Court has changed from the PDF-24-01 to the PTF-25-01 from a maximum slope of 19% to 24%. This is not acceptable for fire apparatus access. Show a revied profile with maximum slope of 20% with transitions to 10% on each side. 2.Street widths of 21 feet with parking on one side appear to meet City of Eugene engineering standards for local public access. However, Eugene Springfield Fire strongly recommends following the 2022 Eugene Fire Code, Section 503.2.1 which requires 20 feet clear width with no parking allowed on both sides within that 20 foot width for these private streets. “NO PARKING-FIRE LANE” signage shall be posted on both sides of the Randy Lane, Tambour Lane and Tambour Court (2022 Eugene Fire Code Section D103.6). 3. Since there is only one access to this 38 lot subdivision, all dwellings in this development shall be equipped with approved automatic fire sprinkler systems meeting NFPA requirements (2022 EFC, Appendix D107.1, exception 1). Attachment D Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 23 of 79 A shared service of the cities of Eugene and Springfield, Oregon 4. Several lots show access to be provided by 10 and 14 foot wide utility and access easements. This width will not be adequate for the required fire apparatus access requirements of 20’ minimum. Access requirements for these houses will be evaluated at the time of building permit submittal, when such access is proposed (2022 Eugene Fire Code 503.2.1). 5. Fire will review the building permit applications for all lots within this subdivision to ensure proper fire department apparatus access is provided and fire sprinklers meeting NFPA standards are applied to new houses. Fire apparatus turnarounds may be required in certain instances to the distance from Randy Lane and Tambour Lane & Court (2022 Eugene Fire Code 503.1 & D103.4). Water Supply: This proposal shows fire hydrants being proposed. 1. The spacing of the proposed fire hydrants does not meet the average spacing requirements of EFC C105.1 and table C105.1. Randy Lane and Stonehenge Way are both private dead end streets. As such the maximum average hydrant spacing is 400 feet, and maximum distance from any point on street or road frontage to a hydrant is 200 feet. Add an additional hydrant in the vicinity of the hammerhead turnaround of Tambour Ct. In order to meet fire hydrant spacing requirements FH-3 (at the end of Randy Lane) should be moved to the west. 2. The size of the dwelling units may dictate additional fire hydrants be installed depending on the square footage. Anything over 3,600 sq. ft. of fire area (which includes garages) will usually require additional fire hydrants with a minimum flow of 1,500 gpm at 20 psi residual pressure per 2022 EFC Appendix B. Again, this required fire flow can be reduced with the installation of fire sprinkler systems. Comments provided by Deputy Fire Marshal Eric Phillips-Meadow Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 24 of 79 Date: April 03, 2026 To: Nick Gioello From: Nathan Scheib, PLS Subject: PDF 25-01 Braewood 3rd Addition Stonehedge Court/Tambour Court As approved in PDT24-01, Stonehedge Court was proposed with a maximum street grade of 19%. The tentative PUD was approved with conditions, one of the conditions of approval was to require the applicant to select a different street name from Stonehedge Court (Condition of Approval #2). When the Final PUD was submitted the applicant changed the name of the private street from Stonehedge Court to Tambour Court. Sheet C3.0 of the Final PUD plans includes a profile view of Tambour Court; the updated PUD plans include a profile view of Tambour Court depicts a 29-foot portion (STA3+11- STA 3+40) with a grade of 24.22%. The updated profile view of Tambour Court does not comply with EC9.6875 as this criterion requires that all private streets be designed and constructed in accordance with the applicable requirements in the adopted “Design Standards and Guidelines for Eugene Streets, Sidewalk, Bikeways and Accessways” The 1999 Design Standards and Guideline of Eugene Streets… section (Local Street Design Standards) subsection(m)(1)(c) states in part: “Grade: Maximum grade of 15% with up to 200’ lengths of grades up to 20%...” The City of Eugene Public Improvement Design Standards (PIDS) subsection 2.05(j)(4) notes in part: “The maximum street grade permitted in hillside developments is 15 percent, with the following exception: grades in excess of 15 percent, but not more than 20 percent, may be allowed for distances not exceeding 200 feet…” In order to ensure compliance with EC9.6875 Private Street Design Standards, Public Works recommends the following condition of approval: Attachment E Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 25 of 79  Prior to Final PUD approval, the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that includes a profile view of Tambour Court. The updated profile view of Tambour Court shall comply with EC9.6875. Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 26 of 79 The Atrium Building 99 West 10th Avenue, Eugene, Oregon 97401 Phone: 541.682.5377 I Fax: 541.682.5572 www.eugene-or.gov/planning FINDINGS AND DECISION OF THE PLANNING DIRECTOR Standards Review and Final Planned Unit Development Approval Name (File Number): Applicant: Braewood Hils Third Addition (SDR 25-02 and PDF 25-01) Piculell Properties, LLC Applicant's Representative: Carol Schirmer, Schirmer Consulting, LLC Nicholas Gioello, Associate Planner Application Submitted: September 5, 2025 Application Complete: January 29, 2026 Decision Issued: March 15, 2026 Lead City Staff: Relevant Dates: Map No. / Tax Lot(s): Zoning: Development Area: Location: Application Details 18-04-11-12 / 00200 R-1/WR Low-Density Residential with /PD Planned Unit Development and /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlays Approximately 15.47 Acres Located on the east side of Hawkins Lane and northeast of Randy Lane The applicant is requesting approval of a Final Planned Unit Development (PUD) application, which received tentative PUD approval on DATE (City File: PDT 24-01). The Tentative PUD approved the creation of 39 residential lots, the extension of Randy Lane, private streets, and other associated infrastructure improvements and was subject to 27 conditions of approval. The tentative approval was run concurrently with the Tentative Subdivision (City File: ST 24-3). A Final Subdivision application (City File: SF 25-3) was also submitted, but is not being reviewed concurrently with these applications. In order to facilitate infrastructure improvements, the applicant is also requesting concurrent approval of a Standards Review application. Specifically, the scope of the Standards Review application is the construction and extension of Randy Lane across Videra Creek, a Goal 5 protected riparian resource. The project will include grading and construction of a public road across the resource and the removal of existing plants and vegetation to be replaced with March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Braewood Hill 3 rd Addition (SDR 25-2 and PDF 25-1) Page 1 of 28 Attachment F Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 27 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 28 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 29 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 30 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 31 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 32 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 33 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 34 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 35 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 36 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 37 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 38 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 39 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 40 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 41 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 42 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 43 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 44 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 45 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 46 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 47 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 48 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 49 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 50 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 51 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 52 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 53 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 54 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 55 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 56 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 57 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 58 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 59 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 60 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 61 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 62 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 63 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 64 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 65 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 66 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 67 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 68 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 69 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 70 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 71 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 72 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 73 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 74 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 75 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 76 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 77 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 78 of 79 Hearings Official Agenda 04/29/2026 Page 79 of 79