Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAppeal Materialswww.eugene-or.gov/planning Planning & Development Updated: May 2024 Planning Division 99 W. 10TH Avenue Suite 290, Eugene, OR 97401 Phone: 541.682.5377 or E-mail: planning@eugene-or.gov Page 1 of 2 Please check one of the following: Adjustment Review, Minor Adjustment Review, Major Code Interpretation Hazardous Materials Review Historic Property Alteration Historic Property Demolition Historic Property Move Modification of a Conditional Use Permit Modification of a PUD Tentative Modification of a PUD Final Modification of a Site Review Modification of a Standards Review Modification of a Subdivision Plan Modification of a Willamette Greenway Partition Tentative Partition Final PUD Final Site Review Standards Review Subdivision Tentative Subdivision Final Traffic Impact Analysis Vacation Improved Public R‐O‐W Vacation Improved Public Easement Unimproved Public R‐O‐W with Re‐dedication Variance APPEAL OF PLANNING DIRECTOR DECISION This appeal form applies to appeals of interpretation of this Land Use Code made according to EC 9.0040(1) and to appeals to all Type II land use applications. The appeal of the Planning Director’s decision provides for a review of an administrative decision by a higher review authority specified in this Land Use Code. The Planning Director’s decision may be affirmed, reversed, or modified. City File Name:_______________________________________________________________________________________________ City File Number:_____________________________________________________________________________________________ Date of Planning Director Decision:______________________________________________________________________ Date Appeal Filed:___________________________________________________________________________________ (This date must be within 12 days of the date of the mailing of the Planning Director’s decision.) Attach a written appeal statement. The appeal statement shall include a written statement of issues on appeal and be limited to the issues raised in the appeal. The appeal statement shall explain specifically how the Planning Director’s decision is inconsistent with applicable criteria. Please contact Planning staff at the Permit and Information center, 99 West 10th Avenue, 541‐682‐5377, for further information on the appeal process. A filing fee must accompany an appeal of a Planning Director decision, with some exceptions for neighborhood groups. The fee varies depending upon the type of application and is adjusted periodically by the City Manager. Check with Planning staff at the Permit and Information Center to determine the required fee or check on the web at: www.eugeneplanning.org March 27, 2026 Mr. Nick Gioello, Associate Planner City of Eugene Planning Division 99 W. 10th Ave, Suite 290 Eugene, OR 974012 Via email: ngioello@eugene-or.gov; planning@eugene-or.gov Re: Appeal Statement: Braewood Hills 3rd Addition, Final PUD (PDT 25-01) & Standards Review (SDR 25-02) Save Videra Oak Meadows and Wes Van Winkle (“Clients”) provides the following appeal statement on the Planning Director’s Decision on Braewood Hills 3rd Addition final planned unit development (“PUD”) and standards review applications (“Final PUD” and “SDR,” respectively), File Nos. PDT 25-01/ST 25-02 (collectively, “Applications”). The Planning Director’s Decision (“Decision”) has numerous errors precluding approval of the Applications. For the following reasons, the Decision should be reversed, and the Applications for the final planned unit development and standards review denied. I. Appeal T imeliness The Decision was signed by the Planning Director on March 12, 2026, with the mailing of the Decision occurring on March 17, 2026. This Appeal is being filed on March 27, 2026, along with the required filing fee, and therefore, this appeal complies with EC 9.7605. II. Final Planned Unit Development (PDF 25-01) The Applicant has failed to comply with the applicable provisions for a final PUD, and the Decision errs in approving the application. 1. The Decision contradicts the Fire Marshal’s review and errs in finding compliance with EC 9.8365 Public comments on the file’s documents noted numerous problems with access to the site by emergency vehicles, including narrow private streets and driveways, excessively steep grades, and other issues. 3/27/2026 2 The Decision responds to these concerns by stating that the Fire Marshal’s Office reviewed the final PUD and earlier iterations of the PUD and subdivision and “expressed no concerns related to emergency service access to the site.” Decision, p. 2. In a specific response to public comments regarding the driveways being too narrow for emergency vehicle access, the Decision states that the Fire Marshal provided referral comments “which did not express concerns with the driveway widths or indicate a risk to public safety.” Decision, p. 4. These statements in the Decision are false. Attachment A to the Decision is a two-page document consisting of comments and conditions by the Fire Department which flatly contradict the Planning Director’s statements.. For example, point 1 of the Fire Marshal’s comments states: 1. The maximum street profile slope for Tambour Court has changed from the PDF-24-01 to the PTF- 25-01 from a maximum slope of 19% to 24%. This is not acceptable for fire apparatus access. (Emphasis added.) Show a revied (sic) profile with maximum slope of 20% with transitions to 10% on each side. This is especially troubling as this represents a modification, a significant change, to the original approval of the tentative PDF, which would necessarily require a new or modified tentative PUD application. This change is expressly noted by the Fire Marshal as problematic with respect to fire apparatus access. With the increased risk of wildfire in Eugene, this potential handicap to fire response endangers not just this proposed development, but the existing residences in the surrounding area. This change which the Decision fails to address represents a danger to the health and safety of the community. This modification violates EC 9.8365(1), which provides: “The planning director shall approve, approve with conditions, or deny a final PUD application, based on compliance with the following criteria: (1) The final PUD plan conforms with the approved tentative PUD plan and all conditions attached thereto.” 3/27/2026 3 As the final PUD plan does not conform to the approved tentative PUD plan, the Applicant has failed to demonstrate compliance with EC 9.8365(1), and therefore, the Decision should be reversed and the PDF application denied. Similarly, point 2 of the Fire Marshal’s comments notes: 2. Street widths of 21 feet with parking on one side appear to meet City of Eugene engineering standards for local public access However, Eugene Springfield Fire strongly recommends following the 2022 Eugene Fire Code, Section 503.2.1 which requires 20 feet clear width with no parking allowed on both sides withing that 20-foot width for these private streets. “NO PARKING FIRE LANE” signage shall be posted on both sides of the Randy Lane, Tambour Lane, and Tambour Court (2022 Eugene Fire Code Section D103.6). Point 4 of the Fire Marshal’s comments states: 4. Several lots show access to be provided by 10-and 14-foot-wide utility and access easements. This width will not be adequate for the required fire apparatus access requirements of 20’ minimum. (Emphasis added.) Access requirements will be evaluated at the time of building permit submittal, when such access is proposed (2022 Eugene Fire Code 503.2.1). Each of the Fire Marshal’s quoted comments contradict the Decision and support the public comments arguing that the development plan is a fire hazard and poses a threat to public safety. The roads and, in particular, the driveways are inadequate for access by fire apparatus. These flaws are especially grave in view of the fact that the entire project is essentially designed as a cul de sac and naturally existing fire-resistant features of the property, such as the majority of the wetlands and Oregon oak trees, are proposed to be removed. These deficiencies must be addressed and rectified. In sum, the Decision erred in finding compliance with EC 9.8365(1) as the Applicant has not carried their burden of proof by providing evidence of compliance, instead providing evidence of impermissibly changing the approved tentative PUD. III. Standards Review (SDR 25-02) A. The Applicant has not demonstrated compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(a) 3/27/2026 4 EC 9.4980(4) provides: “Construction Practices. Construction within the / WR conservation area, and within areas removed from the / WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: a) For purposes of this subsection, heavy machinery is defined as motorized or mechanized machinery or equipment capable of deliberately or inadvertently damaging vegetation, or damaging or compacting soil. The following standards shall apply to use of heavy machinery within the / WR conservation area: 1. On sites where soils are susceptible to severe compaction or structural damage when wet or saturated, use of heavy machinery shall be limited to the period between June 15 and September 30, unless otherwise approved by the planning director. 2. Use of heavy machinery shall be the minimum necessary for the use or activity and shall be restricted to those areas where its use is necessary.” With respect to compliance with this provision, the Decision states: “The applicant' s plan does not show staging locations for machinery, and provides no explanation in the written statement, likely due to the fact that the construction will utilize the proposed road as the access for the site which is mostly located outside of any Conservation Area. However, without that clarity in the record, the following conditions are warranted to minimize impacts to areas that do not need to be impacted by heavy machinery to construct the street and stormwater facility: 5. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan that shows staging area( s) for heavy machinery. Alternatively, the applicant may include a note on the final site plan stating, ‘No staging areas for heavy equipment will be located within a Conservation Area.’ 6. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan that shows the location of access for and use of heavy machinery within the extent of the Conservation Area impacted by the construction of the road. 7. Prior to final site plan approval, the following note shall be added to the final site plans: Heavy machinery may only be used in the / WR conservation areas between .tune 15 and September 30 and will not be used outside of the area shown on this site plan for staging and access to the construction impact area. Based on these findings and conditions, the above standards are met.” Decision, p. 15. First, the Decision recognizes that the Applicant failed to provide evidence of compliance. Second, by including the word “alternatively” the Decision contradicts itself with regard to Condition of Approval 7 which requires a note on the site plan referring to areas that are designated as the staging areas for heavy equipment. Providing a note that allows the Applicant not to designate staging areas on the site plan renders the conditions of approval insufficient to ensure compliance with the provision. Regardless, without the actual evidence of 3/27/2026 5 where the heavy equipment will be staged, it is impossible to state that the Applicant has complied with this provision. Additionally, the Decision notes that the Applicant has proposed fencing along the Conservation Area, north of the road, but fails to address the lack of protective fencing proposed along the Conservation Area south of the road. Here, again, the Applicant has failed to provide evidence of compliance. Therefore, the Decision erred in finding compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(a) as the Applicant has not carried their burden of proof by providing evidence of compliance. B. The Applicant has not demonstrated compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(b) EC 9.4980(4)(b) provides: “Petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process shall not be allowed to enter a stream or wetland that is within a /WR conservation area.” With respect to compliance with this provision, the Decision states: “The applicant provides a statement that agrees to the above criterion, however evidence to demonstrate how their plan will comply is not provided. To ensure compliance with this standard, the following condition is warranted: 8. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall add a note to the final site plans that states, " Petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process shall not be allowed to enter a stream or wetland that is within a WR conservation area.’ Based on the materials in the record and the above findings and conditions of approval, the standards at EC 9.4980(4) are met.” Decision, p. 15. First, the Decision recognizes that the Applicant failed to provide evidence of compliance. Second, adding the language of the provision to the final plat in no way actually provides any evidence that ensures compliance with this provision. Sinply restating the provision is not evidence of compliance. Therefore, the Decision erred in finding compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(b) as the Applicant has not carried their burden of proof by providing evidence of compliance. IV. Conclusion 3/27/2026 6 For the above reasons, Save Videra Oak Meadows and Wes Van Winkle requests that the Decision on the final PUD and the standards review applications, File Nos. PDT 25-01/ST 25-02, should be reversed and denied. Respectfully submitted, Charles W. Woodward, IV Attorney for Save Videra Oak Meadows and Wes Van Winkle