Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDecisionBraewood Hils Third Addition (SDR 25-02 and PDF 25-01) Applicant: Piculell Properties, LLC Applicant's Representative: Carol Schirmer, Schirmer Consulting, LLC Lead City Staff: Nicholas Gioello, Associate Planner Relevant Dates: Application Submitted: September 5, 2025 Application Complete: January 29, 2026 Decision Issued: March 15, 2026 Map No. / Tax Lot(s): 18-04-11-12 / 00200 Zoning: R-1/WR Low -Density Residential with /PD Planned Unit Development and /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlays Development Area: Approximately 15.47 Acres Location: Located on the east side of Hawkins Lane and northeast of Randy Lane Application Details The applicant is requesting approval of a Final Planned Unit Development (PUD) application, which received tentative PUD approval on DATE (City File: PDT 24-01). The Tentative PUD approved the creation of 39 residential lots, the extension of Randy Lane, private streets, and other associated infrastructure improvements and was subject to 27 conditions of approval. The tentative approval was run concurrently with the Tentative Subdivision (City File: ST 24-3). A Final Subdivision application (City File: SF 25-3) was also submitted, but is not being reviewed concurrently with these applications. In order to facilitate infrastructure improvements, the applicant is also requesting concurrent approval of a Standards Review application. Specifically, the scope of the Standards Review application is the construction and extension of Randy Lane across Videra Creek, a Goal 5 protected riparian resource. The project will include grading and construction of a public road across the resource and the removal of existing plants and vegetation to be replaced with March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 1 of 28 Braewood Hill 3r1 Addition (SDR 25-2 and PDF 25-1) native vegetation. The project area spans a small section of the resource in the southwest portion of the property. Specifically, the project is within the area of Upland Resource E35 A and Wetland Resource AMA-513. Videra Creek is a Category B stream. While the protected creek crosses the entire property in the southern portion of the site, the scale of impact within the conservation area is limited to approximately 1,105 square feet of disturbance. In accordance with Eugene Code Sections (EC) 9.4930(2)(c), the removal of non-native and invasive plants and the planting of native plants are an allowed use. In accordance with EC 9.4930(3)(b), the construction of public streets is subject to a Standards Review (EC 9.8460 — 9.8472) and the standards at EC 9.4980 /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay Zone Development Standards (1) through (11). While there are other protected resources within the remainder of the subject property, at this time, the only activity that requires a Standards Review is the construction of Randy Lane. All other protected riparian and wetland resources will be protected and reviewed with individual development applications over time. Additional details of the proposal are included in the applicant's written statement, on proposed site plans and in other supporting documentation, all of which are included as part of the public record and located in the application file for reference. Procedure, Public Notice, and Agency Referrals Application Submitted September 5,. 2025 Application Complete Public notice of the subject application was mailed in accordance with EC 9.7210. Twenty-two concerned citizens submitted testimony during the public comment period, all of which are available in the file record for reference. Many of the comments submitted shared the same or very similar concerns regarding several key issues. The following testimony summary and review will focus on the general topics of concern or application deficiency as expressed throughout the various testimonies received rather than a review of each individual piece of testimony. Testimony concerns, questions or statements of application deficiencies will be listed in bold font and staff analysis will be in regular font. • Increased traffic and limited ability for emergency services response. Eugene Springfield Fire Marshal's Office reviewed the proposed plans for both this current application and the approved tentative planned unit development (PUD) and tentative subdivision (City File # PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) and expressed no concerns related to emergency service access to the site. Fire Marshal's Office comments dated February 25, 2026 (included as Attachment A), will require "No parking -Fire Lane" signage on both sides of the private streets in the development to ensure adequate widths for emergency vehicular movements within the March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 2 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) site. As indicated in the July 2024 tentative PUD staff report, Public Works staff confirmed that safe and adequate transportation systems are found in the vicinity and adjoining public streets including Hawkins Lane and Randy Lane are already built to applicable street standards. Therefore, as this proposal is the finalization of the previously approved PUD, this proposal will not general any additional concerns related to this topic that were not previously argued during the Tentative PUD process. • Land is not stable on the hillside. As discussed in the July 2024 tentative PUD staff report the site is exempt from the standards of EC 9.6710 Geological and Geotechnical Analysis due to the status of the subject property being on the City's adopted Goal 5 inventory and exempted from the standards per EC 9.6710(3)(f). However, geotechnical analysis will be required during future permitting processes, including but not limited to the Privately Engineered Public Improvement permit process, site development permits, and building permits to the extent that public improvement standards and building code requirements apply in subsequent stages of development. Therefore, as this proposal is the finalization of the previously approved PUD, this proposal will not general any additional concerns related to this topic that were not previously argued during the Tentative PUD process. • The site should include a park area, also walking trails that connect Melvin Miller Park, Skyview City Park, and Videra Park. The tentative PUD approval was approved under the Housing/Clear and Objective standards of EC 9.8325, which do not require the inclusion of parks or walking trails within the development. This application for final PUD requires substantial conformance with the tentative PUD approval. Therefore, there is no ability to require a park within the site as part of this approval process. • The Final PUD does not conform to the tentative PUD approval concerning the Joint Access Management agreement and the various Joint Access Easements, Conditions 5, 6, 15 and 16. The Final PUD does not conform to the tentative PUD Condition 7, Public Utility Easement. The Final PUD does not conform to the tentative PUD Condition 26 — stormwater compliance with EC 9.6796. Section 2 of this decision provides full analysis of how this final PUD application is in conformance with each of the above listed conditions of approval of the tentative PUD. The findings for Condition of Approval 5 include an additional condition for compliance prior to final plat. Condition 26 required the applicant to submit updated application materials that demonstrate compliance with EC 9.6796. The findings for Condition of Approval 6 include an additional condition for compliance prior to final plat. March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 3 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) • Concerns with shared driveways with and cars parked in a single driveway, the Joint Access & Maintenance Agreement (JAM) for the shared driveways, the variable widths and the maintenance responsibilities. The driveways that are too narrow for emergency vehicle access and is a risk to public safety. Section 2 of this decision provides full analysis of how this final PUD application is in conformance with each of the above listed conditions of approval of the tentative PUD. The findings for Condition of Approval 5 regarding the JAM include an additional condition for compliance prior to final site plan approval. The Fire Marshal's Office has reviewed the plans and provided referral comments, which did not express concerns with the driveway widths or indicate a risk to public safety. These referral comments are included in the record materials. Further, as this proposal is the finalization of the previously approved PUD, this proposal will not generally add any additional or new concerns related to this topic that were not previously argued during the Tentative PUD process. • Compliance with the required 25-foot buffer established at EC 9.4920(2)(b) has not been clearly demonstrated. EC 9.4920(3) Combined conservation footprint for wetland and stream Natural resource identification requirements under the /WR Overlay. No development is currently proposed within the Conservation Area identified above that is not already being considered as part of this Standards Review application. Other development, such as the development of individual lots over time will be required to demonstrate compliance with the applicable setbacks for protected riparian resources located through the development site. This approval process does include any approval criteria that would warrant or otherwise mandate the mapping of the 25-foot buffer as part of this specific process. • Violates Eugene Code 9.4930(3)(e)(3), which requires that all excavated areas be backfilled with existing native soil. This code section applies to new underground utility lines within conservation areas and requires backfilling to the existing grade with native soil to minimize the impact to the conservation area. However, EC 9.4930(3)(b) allows for the construction of public streets and public utilities subject to the standards at EC 9.4980, which are addressed in Section 1 of this Decision, therefore EC 9.4930(3)(e)(3) would not be applicable. • Did not adequately identify wetlands within 50 feet of property lines. All known, existing wetlands are shown on the plans and in relation to proposed lot lines. Most of the wetlands on the site are listed as unprotected. The only wetland identified for protection exists in the same area as the protected Videra stream. When it comes to the Goal 5 riparian March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 4 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) resources, it is common for a stream to also have related wetlands in nearly the same location. The site plans show the top of bank of the stream as it begins on the east boundary of the site and travels towards the west boundary of the site where it enters an existing underground culvert under the areas where Randy Lane is proposed and exits in the City's Videra Park. • Does not identify trees by species and dimension or map critical root zones for trees within conservation areas and how these trees and their root zones will be protected. Th applicant has identified three trees located within the area of proposed disturbance and identified for removal as it relates to the Standards Review application. All trees on the site are shown on sheet ST2.0. The closest tree to the area of disturbance within the steam setback is located in Lot 33, south of the steam, and is approximately 270 feet from the edge of proposed disturbance. This tree would need to have a diameter at breast height that well exceeds 180 inches to have any possibility of impact to its critical root zone. Trees of this extreme size are not known to exist in the area. Therefore, unless evidence is provided to the contrary, it is not possible for the critical root zone of this tree to be affected by the proposed street and area of disturbance. • The site plan does not properly identify/indicate all trees by species and dimension. There needs to be a complete and comprehensive inventory of all trees on the property. Native Willamette White Oaks on the property should be identified and protected. Deny the applications because there is less than 2% of the Willamette Valley's oak woodlands remaining and this ecosystem is critically endangered. The site plans do identify the location of existing trees on the site. There are no criteria with final PUD approval that requires an inventory of all trees on the property. As discussed in the tentative PUD staff report (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) the Tree Preservation and Removal Standards at EC 9.6885 will apply directly at the time of future development on individual lots. Depending on the timing and scope of tree removal, lot size, and other factors, a separate tree removal permit may be required per EC Chapter 6, which will be reviewed at the time of building permits on each individual lot. • Has not demonstrated compliance with construction practices within conservation areas per EC 9.4980(4). This standard is addressed in Section 1 of the Decision, and two additional conditions of approval are required to ensure consistency with this standard. • Concern with impacts to Videra Park, no mapped combined conservation footprint extending across the shared boundary, no tree identification and critical root zone mapping near the property line, and no hydrological analysis of how the Randy Lane extension and associated swales may alter water flow affecting park -side trees. March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 5 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) The applicant is required to analyze trees within the Conservation Area on their property, which they have performed as required. No off -site tree analysis is required under the land use code. As noted in Section 1 of the decision, the applicant does need to include and replant any Conservation Area to the south of the road, in between the property line and the southern edge of the sidewalk/road. This small strip is within a Conservation Area. There are no trees identified within the southern edge of the sidewalk/road impacted area of the proposed standards review and off -site trees are not part of the review for this application. The applicant proposes stormwater management in accordance with the requirements of Eugene Code, as was evaluated during the Tentative PUD process. the Videra stream will continue to utilize the existing stormwater drainage pipe that existed prior to this proposal. The road area subject to this standards review will not reroute water flowing through this existing stormwater drainage pipe. Stormwater from the street will be managed by the designed stormwater management areas consistent with Eugene Code. • No specifics about how chemical products, harmful substances and other materials are prevented from infiltrating the wetland, stream and Videra Park. In Section 1 of the Decision, EC 9.4980(4)(b) addresses this issue and a new condition of approval is required to ensure consistency with this standard. • The extension of Randy Lane, as well as the swales to the north of it, must be prevented from denying critical water for the trees on the other side of the property line in Videra Park. There are no approval criteria in the Final PUD or the Standards Review that would require the applicant to monitor the health of trees not located on their property. • The map labels the wetland as Wetland 2B and shows clearly that the wetland is wider than the conservation setback on the developer's site map and thus the setback does not meet the 25-foot setback requirement. The proper /WR conservation area has not been determined, as the /WR conservation area for the wetlands was not calculated or mapped at all. Nor was the total footprint combined. The City should insist that a 25-foot setback for the wetland be combined with the 40-foot setback for the Category C stream. In some places, this revised setback will be more than that in the current the site plan. This Standards Review is looking only at the impacted area of the Conservations Area where it is impacted by the construction and extension of Randy Lane. When it comes to the Goal 5 riparian resources, it is common for a stream to also have related wetlands in nearly the same location. The extent of the construction is limited to the southern portion of the creek, where March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 6 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) the wetlands closely overlay the banks of the creek. The Conservation Area for the creek is 40 feet on either side, whereas the wetland setback is 25 feet. At this impacted location (i.e. the extent of Standards Review), the 40-foot setback is greater than the extent of the 25-foot setback and therefore, it receives the same level of protection. The mapped 25-foot buffer around the remaining wetland is not something that can be required under the approval criteria for these applications. However, staff understands that it would be helpful for the future development of the individual lots to know where the 25-foot buffer is located, as opposed to remapping it for every permit. Therefore, staff recommends that the applicant include this buffer on their final site plan, though we lack the direct approval criteria to mandate the inclusion of the buffer on their site plan. • How will snow removal be coordinated. What happens if the designated responsible lot does not sell. What enforcement mechanism exists if maintenance lapses? Snow removal on the private streets and driveways would be the responsibility of individual lot owners. Once the final plat is approved and recorded with Lane County and the State of Oregon, the lots would then become legal lots owned initially by the developer and could be sold either individually or in whole to another developer. Enforcement of maintenance responsibilities for private accessways and streets would be through civil actions between private parties and not the responsibility of the City. • Condition of Approval 11, EWEB documentation has not been provided. This condition of approval is required to be met during the Final Subdivision process and approval of the final plat and not required at this stage of approval. • The Removal/Fill wetland removal in Lot 38 should be disallowed per EC 9.6715. This code section restricts heights in the Skinner Butte area and is not applicable to this site. • EC 9.8055 requires that access points for proposed lots must be shown on site maps and development maps, and many of the lots on these maps do not show how access points will be sited after setbacks and conservation areas have been created. This code section is the General/Discretionary approval criteria for Cluster Subdivisions and is not applicable to this site. The Planning Division also provided information concerning the application to other appropriate City departments, and neighborhood services. Any referrals received may be discussed and summarized in the evaluation below and are incorporated herein by reference. A copy of any referrals and public comments are included in the application file for reference. March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 7 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) Evaluations This concurrent request includes two applications, a Standards Review and Final Planned Unit Development. Both the Standards Review and Final Planned Unit Development applications are subject to the Type II land use application procedures, which are primarily addressed at EC 9.7200-9.7230. Section 1 of this decision addresses the Standards Review application. In accordance with the Standards Review process beginning at EC 9.8460, the Planning Director shall approve, conditionally approve, or deny this application. The Planning Director's decision is based on the following evaluation of the proposal in the context of determining the uses subject to Standards Review at EC 9.4930(3) and compliance with the applicable approval criteria and related standards listed at EC 9.8470 and EC 9.4980 /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay Zone - Development Standards. Section 2 of this decision addresses the Final Planned Unit Development application. In accordance with the Final Planned Unit Development (PUD) process beginning at EC 9.8350 the Planning Director shall approve, conditionally approve, or deny this application. The Planning Director's decision for Final PUD is based on the evaluation of the proposal and compliance with the applicable approval criteria at EC 9.8365, which include conformance with the approved Tentative PUD and its conditions of approval. In each of the evaluations below, the applicable standards and criteria for the Standards Review and the Final PUD are provided below (in bolded text) in two sections and include findings addressing compliance with each. SECTION 1 STANDARDS REVIEW EVALUATION The areas subject to a Standards Review are those impacted portions of a Conservation Area, when an activity explicitly requires a Standards Review approval in accordance with EC 9.4930. This proposal includes the extension of Randy Lane and associated infrastructure, which includes construction activities within the Conservation Area of a protected riparian resource. The proposed construction of a public street is permitted subject to a Standards Review in accordance EC 9.4930(3)(b). EC 9.4930(3): Uses Subject to Standards Review Within /WR Conservation Areas. Except as prohibited by subsection (4), or as excepted under subsection (5), within /WR conservation areas, the following uses are permitted, subject to the standards review process beginning with EC 9.8460 in which consistency with the specific standards referenced for each use below shall be used as the criteria for approval. (b) Construction of public improvements (including but not limited to streets, bridges, paved bikeways and pedestrian paths, and public utilities) required by this land use March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 8 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) code or specified in adopted plans. Subject to EC 9.4980 /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay Zone Development Standards (1) through (11). The above code section allows for the applicant to apply for a Standards Review approval for the construction of a public street through the Standards Review process. The applicant's submitted materials also indicate that their proposal includes several other uses subject to standard review; the construction of new underground utility lines, restoration of impacted conservation areas and construction of stormwater facilities. The public improvements are associated with public streets which were required as part of their approved Tentative Planned Unit Development, in accordance with the land use code. As such, this proposal includes public improvements required by the land use code, consistent with EC 9.4930(3)(b). It is worth noting that the code section above requires a review of all development standards for the /WR overlay zone. With a wide scope, and improvements required by the land use code, staff believes that it is appropriate for the applicant to seek approval for the public street, private utilities, restoration of impacted conservation areas and construction of stormwater facilities under EC 9.4930(3). The proposed extension of Randy Lane impacts one conservation area in the southern portion of the site where Videra Creek crosses the site and is channeled into an existing underground 12-inch storm drain that empties into abutting Videra Park southeast of the site. The street, utility and storm drainage construction will occur over the area where the existing drainage pipe is buried. No alteration or construction will occur within the above ground portion of the creek located on the site. Based on the available information, the proposed project is subject to approval of a standards review in accordance with EC 9.8470 and the /WR Water Resource Conservation Overlay Zone development standards EC 9.4980(1) through (11), which are provided below (in bolded text) followed by findings. EC 9.8470 Standards Review Approval Criteria The decision -maker shall determine whether the application is in compliance with the standards setout in the code section that calls for standards review. In this case, as noted above, the proposed project is subject to the /WR Water Resource Conservation Overlay Zone Development Standards EC 9.4980(1) through (11), which are provided below (in bolded text) followed by findings. EC 9.4980 /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay Zone Development Standards (1) Enhancement. Where the /WR conservation area is reduced, or uses are approved within the /WR conservation area, the remaining /WR conservation area shall be enhanced consistent with this subsection and by removing non-native plant species and planting native plant species consistent with subsections (2) and (3) below. March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 9 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) (a) All refuse, toxic materials and any fill that limits or decreases the capacity of the conservation setback area to filter pollutants from runoff that flows across the conservation setback area shall be removed (not including stormwater collected and discharged from impervious surfaces). In their application materials, the applicant acknowledges and states that any refuse or toxic materials found during construction will be removed. All required fill material for the street construction will be kept to a minimum. A stormwater treatment facility is proposed along the eastern side of the street and is considered an area of fill within the conservation easement. As indicated in the applicant's written narrative, the stormwater treatment facility will filter various pollutants that flow across it and will enhance the setback area and is consistent with this standard. (b) Where practicable, finished grades shall encourage sheet flow of runoff across conservation setback areas to maximize filtering and infiltration of precipitation and runoff within conservation setback areas (not including stormwater collected and discharged from impervious surfaces). The applicant states and site plans show that finished grades will intentionally direct runoff from the conservation setback area as sheet flow into a swale on the northeast side of Randy Lane (See applicant's Sheet ST3.0). Also, as noted by the applicant, the conservation area sits at a higher elevation and runoff naturally flows downhill into the swale. The swale is designed to enhance pollutant filtration and promote infiltration more effectively than the current sheet flow conditions and is consistent with this standard. Staff review of the applicant's analysis finds their proposal to be consistent with this standard. (c) On sites where the slope within the conservation setback area exceeds 15 percent, measures (e.g., planting and contouring) shall be taken to slow the flow of runoff to the maximum extent practicable (not including stormwater collected and discharged from impervious surfaces). In this case, the stormwater treatment facility is designed to intercept and collect existing runoff. As designed, the gradual slopes of the stormwater treatment facility and vegetative plantings will slow the flow of the runoff, enhancing opportunities for infiltration and pollutant removal. Based on the applicant's proposal, their design is consistent with this standard. (d) Non-native plants shall be permanently removed to the maximum extent practicable and replaced with native plant species in accordance with subsection (3) below. The applicant notes that the area within the extent of the construction will be cleared of vegetation. As discussed in more detail in subsection (3) below and incorporated herein by reference, all areas impacted by this construction will be revegetated with native plant species, consistent with this standard. March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 10 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) (e) Except as required by EC 9.4980(2)(c), EC 9.4980(3)(d) and EC 9.4980(3)(e), site work to enhance the conservation setback area shall be completed prior to or concurrent with other site development, unless appropriate native plant species are not available within that time frame. Site work to enhance the conservation setback area will occur in conjunction with the street construction project. The applicant notes that the installation of replacement vegetation will occur after the street and stormwater facility are constructed as discussed in more detail at EC 9.4980(3)(d) and is consistent with this standard. Based on the materials in the record and the above findings, the standards at EC 9.4980(1) are met. (2) Vegetation Removal. Vegetation removal within the /WR conservation area and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: (a) Vegetation removal shall be limited to: 1. Plant species that are non-native and invasive; 2. Dead or dried native plants or grasses only when they constitute an imminent fire hazard; 3. Living native or non-native vegetation, when its removal is necessary to facilitate or encourage the growth of other native species (e.g., native wet prairie plant species) consistent with adopted plans or policies; or 4. The minimum area of native vegetation removal necessary to accommodate uses approved in accordance with EC 9.4930(3)(a) through EC 9.4930(3)(k), and uses approved through an adjustment approved in accordance with EC 9.8030(21). The applicant indicates that three non-native fruit trees and other native and non-native vegetation will be removed only to the extent necessary to facilitate the construction of the street and stormwater facility. The site plans and description of work demonstrate consistency with this standard. (b) Clearing of more than 500 square feet of vegetation must comply with Erosion Prevention regulations for sensitive areas in EC 6.645. The street construction will require approximately 1,015 square feet of vegetation clearing; therefore, the following condition of approval is warranted: 1. The applicant shall obtain an Erosion Prevention permit prior to the initiation of any development activities in the Conservation Setback as shown on the site plans. March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 11 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) Based on the available information and condition above, this standard will be met. (c) Any clearing of vegetation that is not within the footprint of uses approved in accordance with EC 9.4930(3)(a) through EC 9.4930(3)(k), or uses approved through an adjustment approved under EC 9.8030(21), must be followed by replanting in accordance with the requirements of subsection (3) below. All clearing of vegetation occurring outside of the footprint of the proposed scope of work will be replanted in accordance with the standards in EC 9.4980(3), which is discussed in detail below consistent with this standard. The applicant's site plans only indicate that the impacted Conservation Area is located where the road is being constructed and the area north of the road. This does not take into account that there is Conservation Area also located on the south side of the finished road between the road/sidewalk and the property line. As this small strip is also located within a Conservation Area and warrants replanting consistent with this standard, the following condition is warranted: 2. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised final site plan that identifies the Conservation Area in between the southern property line and the southern edge of the road and sidewalk. The revised site plans shall also show replanting details consistent with the requirement at EC 9.4980(2)(c). Based on the materials in the record and the above findings and condition of approval, the standards at EC 9.4980(2) are met. (3) Planting and Replanting. Planting or replanting within the /WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: (a) Areas of existing bare soil and areas which have been cleared or graded in accordance with subsection EC 9.4980(2) or EC 9.4980(5) shall be planted with native plant species. Except as required in (b) and (c) below, plant species and plant spacing used for such plantings shall be appropriate to increasing to the greatest extent practicable the capacity of the conservation setback area to filter pollutants from runoff that flows across the conservation setback area (not including stormwater collected and discharged from impervious surfaces). Where existing native vegetation already serves this function to some extent, additional native plants shall be planted in order to augment native vegetation already existing. Plant species selected for all plantings shall be appropriate to the site given its topography, hydrology, soil, and existing native plant species. The applicant has proposed revegetating the area of disturbance with vegetation identified on the site plan by plant species, rate of application and size. The site plan lists Tuffed Hairgrass, Meadow Barley and Prairie June Grass ground covers and four Pacific Northwest Crabapple March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 12 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) trees for replanting. However, only Meadow Barley is listed in the City's adopted Goal 5 plant list (Native and Non -Native Plant List, Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351) as appropriate for this area. To ensure that grass and tree species are selected in accordance with the Goal 5 plant list, the following condition is warranted: 3. Prior to site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised final site plan that includes tree and plant species that are selected from the Native and Non -Native Plant List, Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351. Based on the above findings and condition of approval above, this standard will be met. For ease of reference, Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 is included as Attachment B. (b) Planting or replanting within 25 feet of a Category B, C, or D stream within the /WR conservation area shall include native tree or large shrub species and located so as to provide substantial shading of the channel during times of peak solar input. As discussed above and conditioned at 3(a), only native plants and trees will be planted in the conservation area. The area for proposed tree planting is to the immediate west where the stream channel enters the existing underground culvert and will provide shade to a portion of the channel during the afternoon hours. The small strip of Conservation Area between the property line and the south edge of the public improvements does not warrant planting of trees given that the extent of the channel at this location is within a culvert. Based on these findings, the proposal is consistent with this standard. (c) Where non-native or damaged trees are removed within 25 feet of a Category B, C, or D stream within the /WR conservation area, they shall be replaced with native tree or large shrub species and located so as to achieve equal or greater shading of the channel during times of peak solar input as the trees removed. The three existing non-native trees that were removed were located between 35 and 45 feet from the actual stream. The four proposed replacement trees will be located approximately 10 to 20 feet closer to the stream. The increase in the number of trees, location and closer proximity to the Goal 5 resource will increase the amount of shade to the stream and conservation setback area during afternoon hours. Based on these findings, the proposal is consistent with this standard. (d) Replanting of areas cleared of existing vegetation must be completed within 90 days following the removal or clearing, unless otherwise approved by the planning director. The applicant indicates planting will be scheduled based on seasonal timing and plant availability to ensure optimal restoration success. If this schedule cannot be accommodated March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 13 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) within the 90-day timeline, a request for an extension will be submitted to the Planning Director. To ensure this standard I met, the following condition is warranted: 4. Prior to Final PUD approval, the following note shall be added to the final site plans: "Any disturbed areas within the Conservation Setback shall be replanted within 90 days of any clearing or vegetation removal activities, unless otherwise approved by the Eugene Planning Director." Based on the above findings and condition of approval, this standard will be met. (e) Plantings shall not adversely affect adjacent protected water resources or existing native vegetation through shading or invasion by plant species introduced into the setback. The applicant's statement indicates that the selected plant species will enhance the area by replacing non-native plants with native plants and will not adversely impact the water resource. With the condition suggested above at EC 9.4980(3)(a) for a revised planting list, incorporated herein by reference, the applicant's proposal will comply with the standard above due to the existing methodology for selecting plants provided by the City's adopted Goal 5 native plant list Based on the materials in the record and the above findings and conditions of approval, the standards at EC 9.4980(3) are met. (4) Construction Practices. Construction within the /WR conservation area, and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: (a) For purposes of this subsection, heavy machinery is defined as motorized or mechanized machinery or equipment capable of deliberately or inadvertently damaging vegetation, or damaging or compacting soil. The following standards shall apply to use of heavy machinery within the /WR conservation area: 1. On sites where soils are susceptible to severe compaction or structural damage when wet or saturated, use of heavy machinery shall be limited to the period between June 15 and September 30, unless otherwise approved by the planning director. 2. Use of heavy machinery shall be the minimum necessary for the use or activity and shall be restricted to those areas where its use is necessary. The applicant states that machinery, tools, supplies and other construction materials will not be stockpiled or stored in the /WR conservation areas. The applicant states that machinery use will be limited to the period between June 15 and September 30 and be the minimum necessary to complete construction. The applicant's site plans show an area of construction within the protective setback and includes protective fencing along the perimeter of the Conservation Area north of the road to March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 14 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) delineate the extent of the construction impact area. The above standards are concerned with minimizing the impact of machinery needed for the construction of a use allowed by Standards Review approval. The applicant's plan does not show staging locations for machinery, and provides no explanation in the written statement, likely due to the fact that the construction will utilize the proposed road as the access for the site which is mostly located outside of any Conservation Area. However, without that clarity in the record, the following conditions are warranted to minimize impacts to areas that do not need to be impacted by heavy machinery to construct the street and stormwater facility: 5. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan that shows staging area(s) for heavy machinery. Alternatively, the applicant may include a note on the final site plan stating, "No staging areas for heavy equipment will be located within a Conservation Area." 6. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan that shows the location of access for and use of heavy machinery within the extent of the Conservation Area impacted by the construction of the road. 7. Prior to final site plan approval, the following note shall be added to the final site plans: "Heavy machinery may only be used in the /WR conservation areas between .tune 15 and September 30 and will not be used outside of the area shown on this site plan for staging and access to the construction impact area. Based on these findings and conditions, the above standards are met. (b) Petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process shall not be allowed to enter a stream or wetland that is within a /WR conservation area. The applicant provides a statement that agrees to the above criterion, however evidence to demonstrate how their plan will comply is not provided. To ensure compliance with this standard, the following condition is warranted: 8. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall add a note to the final site plans that states, "Petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process shall not be allowed to enter a stream or wetland that is within a /WR conservation area." Based on the materials in the record and the above findings and conditions of approval, the standards at EC 9.4980(4) are met. (5) Filling, Grading and Excavating. Filling, grading and excavating within the /WR conservation area and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 15 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) (a) Filling, grading or excavating of more than 500 square feet must comply with Erosion Prevention regulations for sensitive areas in EC 6.645. As proposed, because more than 500 square feet of grading or excavating is required as part of this project, consistency with the applicable regulations of EC 6.645 are required. As discussed above at EC 9.4980(2)(b) and incorporated herein by reference, a condition of approval was required to ensure the applicant will obtain an Erosion Prevention permit, therefore this standard is met. (b) Grading and excavating conducted as part of restoration or enhancement projects, and bank and channel reconfiguration shall result in topography that resembles landscapes shaped only by natural processes, for example, incorporating the undulations, meanders and slopes found in such landscapes. For purposes of this standard, straight lines and geometric or angular shapes are not acceptable. Channel and stream bank slopes shall not exceed 25 percent at elevations of 500 feet or less. The applicant states that natural slopes, grades and contours will be established and straight lines and geometric shapes will not occur. A proposed swale runs parallel to the north side of the road extension that will exceed 25% slope due to the existing terrain. The side slopes of the swale that exceed 25% are oriented perpendicular to the stream's flow direction and located above the existing culvert where the stream flows in to. The swale will have no effect on the existing stream channel or its banks. Based on the applicant's statement and site plan that shows contouring lines, this standard is met. Based on the materials in the record and the above findings, the standards at EC 9.4980(5) are met. (6) Impervious Surfaces. Within the /WR conservation area, construction of new impervious surfaces shall comply with the following standards: (a) Impervious surfaces are prohibited within the /WR conservation area unless they are part of a use approved in accordance with EC 9.4930(3). (b) Impervious surfaces that are part of a use approved in accordance with EC 9.4930(3) shall be no larger than the minimum necessary for the approved use. For sites with wetlands, impervious surfaces shall be located as far from the boundaries of locally significant wetlands as practicable. For riparian and upland wildlife habitat sites, impervious surfaces shall be located as far from the line of ordinary high water as practicable. (c) Durable porous paving treatments or other infiltration devices approved by the planning director or decision -maker shall be used in lieu of standard impervious paving surfaces to increase infiltration of stormwater where practicable. This standard shall apply only to low volume parking areas, foot paths or lightly used access roads, where porous soils and flat topography will facilitate infiltration of March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 16 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) runoff. For the purposes of this subsection, gravel surfaces are not acceptable as porous paving or as an infiltration device. This standard is met because any impervious surfaces being added will be permitted in accordance with EC 9.4930(3)(b), which allows for the construction of public streets when required by the land use code. (7) Site Layout. On sites where the /WR conservation area is reduced, high intensity uses within the entire development site, including high volume traffic lanes and truck loading docks, shall be designed and located so that adverse impacts to wetland and riparian habitats within the /WR conservation area are minimized to the greatest extent practicable. This application is for a public road required under the land use code, as found during the Tentative PUD approval. The design and layout of the proposed impacts will be limited to what is necessary and placed as far from the resource area as feasible. Both horizontal and vertical alignments will be designed to follow existing grades as closely as possible. The road is located as approved and the narrowest right of way dimension (40 feet) was approved through the PUD process. This narrower right of way served to lessen the impact. Sidewalks are only required on one side instead of 2 sides. No high intensity uses, high volume traffic lanes or truck loading docks are proposed. The applicant states that the design and layout is the minimum necessary, and notes that finish grades will follow existing grades as much as possible. While certainly features worth mentioning, the above standard appears to be related to high intensity uses which by the standard's own context does not include the street required to serve this residential development. The applicant's plan could have included a wider street crossing the riparian area, but the applicant proposed constructing an access lane site layout is the minimum necessary in the event it is found that the above standard should apply to the applicant's request. Based on these findings, the standard at EC 9.4980(7) is met. (8) Lighting. Within the /WR conservation area, and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area, outdoor area lighting shall be prohibited, except to illuminate walkways, bike paths, pedestrian gathering areas, and parking areas, where these facilities are intended to be used after dark. Outdoor area lighting is lighting designed to illuminate an outdoor activity area, trail or bicycle path. Where lighting is to be provided within the /WR conservation area and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area, the following standards shall apply: (a) Illumination for walkways, pathways or pedestrian gathering areas shall be no more than an average maintained luminance of 0.5 foot-candle at grade. March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 17 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) (b) Output from all other light sources shall be no more than an average maintained luminance of 0.9 foot-candle at grade. (c) All lighting fixtures shall be designed to direct light downward to areas intended for human use after dark, and shall be shielded such that light shining toward /WR conservation areas is minimized to the maximum extent practicable. The applicant states that only required street lighting is proposed, and all fixtures will be directed downward and away from the /WR resource. Street lighting is required to illuminate the area for human use of the street and sidewalk after dark (i.e. pedestrian, cyclists, and vehicle parking). The standard uses the term "outdoor area" providing the context that the areas are intended to be used for activities, trails and bicycle paths which further reinforces the notion that the standard does not contemplate street lighting. Because the proposed street is allowed, subject to the Standards Review approval, the street lighting in the /WR conservation area is subject to the above standards. While street lighting is not directly addressed, it does not fall under the purview of (8)(a) above, but does warrant compliance with (8)(b) and (8)(c). To ensure the applicant provides lighting that complies with the standards above, the following condition is warranted: 9. Prior to final plat approval, the applicant shall add a note to the final site plans that states, "All lighting within the /WR Conservation Area shall meet the lighting standards under EC 9.4980(8)(b) and EC 9.4980(8)(c)." Based on the above findings and condition of approval, this standard will be met. (9) Trails. Within the /WR conservation area, trails shall be constructed of gravel, wood chips or other pervious material, unless otherwise approved by the city manager or decision -maker. Trail construction shall involve the least removal of native vegetation practicable for the area and the minimum amount of fill or excavation practicable. This standard does not apply to the applicant's request because the proposal does not include any trails. (10) Stream and Channel Crossings. Bridges or other structures that cross streams or wetlands within the /WR conservation area or areas removed from the /WR conservation area shall be constructed so that water flow, vegetation growth and movement of aquatic animals and water dependent wildlife are impeded to the least extent practicable. To meet this standard, bridges and crossings shall include, but are not limited to, applicable items from the following list: (a) Bridges across Category A or Category B streams as identified in the Goal 5 Water Resources Conservation Plan shall, where practicable, be designed to avoid channel constriction when flows reach the top of high bank. Where practicable, bridges shall span a distance 1.2 times the width of the stream channel from top of March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 18 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) high bank to top of high bank to help prevent scouring within the structure or at the outlet during less frequent floods. N Crossings over Category A or Category B streams as identified in the Goal 5 Water Resources Conservation Plan shall utilize bridges or natural substrate culverts where possible. Where practicable, the lower lip of any natural substrate culvert shall be embedded at least 1 foot for box culverts and pipe arches, and at least 25% of the pipe diameter for pipe culverts. The substrate within the structure shall match the composition of the substrate in the natural stream channel at the time of construction. The substrate shall either resist displacement during flood events or the structure shall be designed to maintain an appropriate bottom through natural bed load transport. (c) Bridges and culverts on Category A or Category B streams as identified in the Goal 5 Water Resources Conservation Plan shall be constructed so that the "openness ratio" of the structure is equal to or greater than 0.25. The "openness ratio" is the cross -sectional area of the passage area under or within the structure divided by the length of the stream segment it crosses over. For a box culvert, the openness ratio shall be (height x width)/length. (d) Culverts shall not substantially increase or decrease water depth or flow rate conditions upstream or downstream from the culvert. (e) The lower lip of all culverts shall meet the stream or channel bed at or below grade. (f) Culverts shall be the minimum length practicable, and fill on top of the culvert shall have the minimum footprint practicable. An underground 12-inch storm drain line existed in this location prior to this application and development proposal. The drainage line spans beyond the area of road construction, conveying runoff from the Goal 5 stream north of the street into Videra Park and Videra Creek to the south. The existing culvert will remain intact without modification beneath the proposed public roadway. To the extent that it is relevant, the applicant has sited the road location over this drainage line, limiting the impact to non -piped portions of the water resource. Based on the existing culvert, which appears to function as intended by conveying stream runoff to Videra Park, and that the prosed road construction will not alter the existing culvert or have any impact on the stream channel, the proposal is consistent with the requirements of this standard. T (11) Interpretive Facilities. Within the /WR conservation area, boardwalks, viewing platforms, interpretive information kiosks, trail and interpretive signs shall be constructed in a manner that involves the least removal of native vegetation March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 19 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) practicable. Signs shall be no more than 5 feet tall, and 16 square feet per face in surface area, except for signs intended to be read from moving automobiles, such as site entrance signs, which shall be no more than 8 feet tall and 32 square feet per face in surface area. Kiosks shall be no more than 8 feet tall and 16 square feet per face in surface area. The number of signs shall be the minimum necessary to accomplish project objectives. This standard does not apply because no interpretive facilities are proposed or required as part of the project. Based on the findings and conditions of approval, this proposal is consistent with the standards at EC 9.4980(1)-(11). SECTION 2 FINAL PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT EVALUATION EC 9.8365(1): The final PUD plan conforms with the approved tentative PUD plan and all conditions attached thereto. The applicant submitted revised site plans as part of their Final PUD application. These plans conform to the approved Tentative PUD plans as required. The following conditions (also in bolded text) were attached to the Hearings Official's approval of the Tentative PUD and are further addressed below with findings of compliance addressing each. 1. On the final PUD site plans and final plat, the applicant shall create an access restriction strip along the westerly boundary line of Lot 15 abutting Hawkins Lane. Sheet L2.0 of the Final PUD plans depicts an access restriction strip along the west boundary line of Lot 15. Therefore, this condition has been met. 2. Prior to final plat approval, the applicant shall demonstrate approval from the regional road naming group for alternate street names to replace "Stonehedge Way" and "Stonehedge Court". Public Works staff have confirmed that the proposed street names of Tambour Lane and Tambour Court are unique names not duplicated within Lane County and are approvable. Therefore, this condition is met. 3. The private streets shall be labeled on the final plat and final PUD site plans as March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 20 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) "[Approved Street Name] - Private". Sheet L2.0 of the final PUD plans have been revised and include the label "Private" at the end of proposed private streets. Therefore, this condition has been met. 4. The structural design and construction inspection for the private streets will remain the developer's responsibility. Certification by a licensed engineer that a structural design meeting the applicable standards will be required at the time of the site development permit for the private street. This condition of approval will be further reviewed during the site development permit process. S. Prior to final PUD and plat approval, the applicant shall submit Private Joint Use Access and Utility Easement and Maintenance Agreement (JAM). The JAM will include a description defining the area of the private street and will also identify permitted improvements, construction expectations, rights of usage and maintenance responsibilities for the facilities in the street. The JAM will be recorded concurrent with and cross-referenced on the final plat. A JAM was submitted with the application materials that defines the private street area, identifies permitted improvements, construction expectations, rights of usage and maintenance responsibilities for the facilities in the street. However, Public Works review has found that the Recitals section describes Lot A as only Tambour Lane — Private, however, the JAM will need to be revised and include Tambour Court as part of Lot A. Additionally, in the Permitted Improvements and Construction Expectations section, the creation of a blanket Public Utility Easement (PUE) and a blanket Private Utility Easement in the same area is not allowed. The JAM will need to be revised to either define a blanket PUE with a private utility corridor or a blanket private utility easement with a PUE corridor. Based on the identified issues above and the requirement that the JAM will be recorded concurrent with and cross-referenced on the final plat, the following condition of approval is warranted: 10. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised Private Joint Use Access and Utility Easement and Maintenance Agreement (JAM) that includes referencing Tambour Lane and Tambour Court as part of Lot A, and the Permitted Improvements and Construction Expectations section shall be revised to either define a blanket PUE with a private utility corridor or a blanket private utility easement with a PUE corridor. Based on the above findings and condition of approval, this condition will be met. 6. Provisions for a public emergency access easement within the private street may be March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 21 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) included in the proposed JAM which creates the private street, or alternatively, may be dedicated as a Public Emergency Access Easement on a standard City form. The proposed JAM includes provisions for public emergency access. Therefore, this condition has been met. 7. Prior to final plat approval, the applicant shall dedicate a 14-foot Public Utility Easement or Public Wastewater Easement that will encumber the proposed public wastewater system. The required easement shall also be shown on revised final PUD plans. The plans depict a variable width PUE over the entirety of Lot A. As discussed above and under condition of approval 5, the JAM will need to be revised to either define a blanket PUE with a private utility corridor or a blanket private utility easement with a PUE corridor, therefore the following condition of approval is warranted: 11. Prior to final site plan approval, the final site plans shall be revised to either define a blanket PUE with a private utility corridor or a blanket private utility easement with a PUE corridor. Based on the above findings and condition of approval, this condition will be met. 8. The final PUD site plans shall include the following note: "No building, structure, tree or other obstruction shall be placed or located on or in a Public Utility Easement, consistent with EC 9.6500(3)". The required note is shown on Sheet L2.0 of the site plans. Therefore, this condition has been met. 9. The final PUD site plans shall include the following note: "Compliance with public improvement requirements shall be demonstrated in accordance with EC 9.6505 as part of the permitting process for development within the PUD including Privately Engineered Public Improvement (PEPI) Permits, Site Development Permits and Building Permits." The required note is shown on Sheet L2.0 of the site plans. Therefore, this condition has been met. 10. The final PUD site plans shall include the following note: "A Privately Engineered Public Improvement (PEPI) permit shall be issued for the construction of public improvements prior to development." The required note is shown on Sheet L2.0 of the site plans. Therefore, this condition has been met. 11. Prior to final plat approval, the applicant shall provide documentation that EWEB has March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 22 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) received a financial guarantee, ensuring water will be provided to each lot in the plat. This condition of approval will be required to be met during the Final Subdivision process and approval of the final plat. 12. Prior to final PUD approval, the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that depicts wastewater service to Lot 38. Alternatively, the applicant may combine Lots 37 and 38 to demonstrate compliance with the requirement for wastewater service. Sheet L2.0 of the site plans depicts previously numbered lots 37 and 38 have been combined into one lot 37. Therefore, this condition has been met. 13. The applicant shall submit an Irrevocable Petition for public improvements in Hawkins Lane to include sidewalks. The applicant has submitted an Irrevocable Petition for public improvements in Hawkins Lane. Therefore, this condition has been met. 14. The applicant shall submit an Irrevocable Petition for public improvements in Randy Lane (existing portion between Hawkins Lane and Blacktail Drive) to include setback sidewalks and street trees. The applicant has submitted an Irrevocable Petition for public improvements in Randy Lane. Therefore, this condition has been met. 15. The proposed Joint Access Easements, which are subject to City review and approval prior to recording with the final plat, shall be cross-referenced on the plat and be accompanied by a maintenance agreement for each shared driveway, which addresses the rights and responsibilities of each parcel relative to each shared driveway. Joint Access Easements for each shared driveway have been submitted for review. Therefore, this condition has been met. 16. The location of proposed Joint Access Easements shall also be clearly shown and labeled as such on final PUD plans. All proposed Joint Access Easements are clearly shown on the final PUD plans. Therefore, this condition has been met. 17. Prior to final PUD approval, the applicant shall update their stormwater memo to show how the proposed shared driveways will satisfy EC 9.6792(3)(c). March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 23 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) An updated stormwater report (dated August 2025) was submitted and demonstrates how the shared driveways will satisfy EC9.6792(3)(c). Therefore, this condition has been met. 18. Prior to final PUD approval, the applicant shall obtain Type II Standards Review approval for the proposed public street extension of Randy Lane and any other utility crossings or other allowed improvements within the protected /WR conservation area, subject to the applicable standards at EC 9.4900-9.4980. A Standards Review application for the street extension of Randy Lane was submitted concurrent with this Final Planned Unit Development application and reviewed and approved in section 1 of this decision. Therefore, with concurrent approval of the Standards Review, this condition is met. 19. All future building permits for Lots 30 through 35 shall depict the Goal 5 resource and its 40-foot setback from top of bank and shall include site plans showing the location of protective fencing subject to the applicable standards at EC 9.4920-9.4930. This requirement will be assessed with each future building permit for lots 30 through 35, Therefore, this condition will be met. 20. The final PUD plans shall include the following note: "Compliance with all applicable development standards, special use limitations, and other general development standards for single -unit or middle housing residential dwelling types shall be demonstrated at the time of future building permit on each individual lot." The required note is shown on Sheet L2.0 of the site plans. Therefore, this condition is met. 21. The final PUD plans shall be revised to remove any references to middle housing lots to be created on land above 901-foot elevation. The final PUD plans shall also include a note stating that: "No development of middle housing, single -unit dwellings, or any other development, including but not limited to land divisions, may occur on any land above 901-feet in elevation." The required note is shown on Sheet L2.0 of the site plans. Therefore, this condition has been met. 22. The final PUD plans shall include the following note: "No site alteration is allowed prior to final PUD approval. This prohibition includes site grading and the removal of trees and other vegetation, as well as any impacts to wetlands and the protected stream on the subject property including changes to the existing drainage pattern. Any such alterations shall only be allowed subject to permit review and approval, and erosion control measures as required for the proposed work." March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 24 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) The required note is shown on Sheet L2.0 of the site plans. Therefore, this condition has been met. 23. Prior to final PUD approval, the applicant shall submit an updated site plan depicting that portion of Randy Lane now shown as a proposed private street on Sheet L2.0 of the applicant's site plans, as a public street instead. The revised site plan shall show that portion of Randy Lane will be designed and constructed to City standards as a public street meeting the standards for an Access Lane in accordance with EC 9.6505(3)(a) and the Local Street Design Standards of the Design Standards and Guidelines for Eugene Streets, Sidewalks, Bikeway and Accessways, as well as the City's Public Improvement Design Standards (PIDS) Manual. Public Works confirms that sheets L2.0 and C3.0 depict Randy Lane as being designed in accordance with EC9.6505(3) and the PIDS manual. Therefore, this condition has been met. 24.On the final plat, the applicant shall dedicate a 40-foot-wide right-of-way extending the public right-of-way for Randy Lane from its existing intersection with Blacktail Drive westerly (toward the western terminus of Randy Lane) to the proposed terminus of Randy Lane as currently depicted on Sheet L2.0 of the applicant's site plans. The right-of- way shall also encompass the required turnaround area at the end of the street and include a reserve strip in accordance with EC 9.6840(1). The right-of-way dedication for the extension of Randy Lane will be reviewed during the future Final Subdivision process. Therefore, this condition will be met. 25. Prior to final PUD approval, the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that depicts that Lot 38 will have frontage on a public street or having access to a public street over a private street or proposed private access easement. Alternatively, the applicant may combine Lots 37 and 38 to demonstrate compliance with the requirement for public street access. Sheet L2.0 depicts all lots having frontage on a public street or having access to a public street via private easements. In addition, previously numbered lots 37 and 38 have been combined into one lot 37. Therefore, this condition is met. 26. Prior to final PUD approval, the applicant shall submit updated application materials that demonstrate compliance with EC 9.6796. The applicant submitted an updated stormwater report (updated October 2025), which notes that all proposed stormwater facilities will be publicly owned. However, no public stormwater easements are proposed. Because these stormwater facilities will be publicly owned and maintained, public stormwater easements are required for all facilities that are not located within public right-of-way, therefore the following condition of approval is warranted: March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 25 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) 12. Prior to final site plan approval, the final plans shall be revised so that all public stormwater facilities are located in either public right-of-way, public utility easements, or public stormwater easements in compliance with EC 9.6796. Based on the above findings and condition of approval, this condition will be met. 27. Prior to final PUD approval, the applicant shall submit an updated site plan that includes the following notes: "The approved stormwater system shall be designed and sized by a civil engineer for the full build -out of the project including 20% of each lot assumed to be impervious surface area. If a lot is proposed to be developed with more than 20% impervious surface area, then additional on -site detention is required. Stormwater runoff from private facilities may also be combined with runoff from the public street (Randy Lane), so long as the public detention system is sized and designed in accordance with applicable Public Improvement Design Standards." "In addition to the on -site detention requirements noted above, all subsequent site development permits, building permits, and Privately Engineered Public Improvement (PEPI) permits for development of the PUD shall demonstrate compliance with applicable stormwater standards at EC 9.6791 through 9.6797 and requirements of the Stormwater Management Manual." Both required notes are included as notes 6 and 7 on sheet L2.0. Therefore, this condition is met. Based on the above findings and conditions of approval, EC 9.8365(1) is met. (2) For final PUDs not associated with a land division, public improvements as required by this land use code or as a condition of tentative plan approval will be completed prior to issuance of a development permit, or: (a) A performance bond or suitable substitute as agreed upon by the city has been filed with the city finance officer in an amount sufficient to assure the completion of all required public improvements; or (b) A petition for public improvements and for the assessment of the real property for the improvements has been signed by the property owner seeking the subdivision, and the petition has been accepted by the city engineer. This final PUD includes a land division. Therefore, this criterion does not apply. March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 26 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) Decision Based on the available information and evidence, and based on the preceding findings of compliance with applicable approval criteria and standards, the Standards Review and Final Planned Unit Development are APPROVED with the following conditions: Conditions related to Standards Review (SDR 25-02) 1. The applicant shall obtain an Erosion Prevention permit prior to the initiation of any development activities in the Conservation Setback as shown on the site plans. 2. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised final site plan that identifies the Conservation Area in between the southern property line and the southern edge of the road and sidewalk. The revised site plans shall also show replanting details consistent with the requirement at EC 9.4980(2)(c). 3. Prior to site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised final site plan that includes tree and plant species that are selected from the Native and Non -Native Plant List, Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351. 4. Prior to Final PUD approval, the following note shall be added to the final site plans: "Any disturbed 'areas within the Conservation Setback shall be replanted within 90 days of any clearing or vegetation removal activities, unless otherwise approved by the Eugene Planning Director." 5. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan that shows staging area(s) for heavy machinery. Alternatively, the applicant may include a note on the final site plan stating, "No staging areas for heavy equipment will be located within a Conservation Area." 6. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised site plan that shows the location of access for and use of heavy machinery within the extent of the Conservation Area impacted by the construction of the road. 7. Prior to final site plan approval, the following note shall be added to the final site plans: "Heavy machinery may only be used in the /WR conservation areas between .tune 15 and September 30 and will not be used outside of the area shown on this site plan for staging and access to the construction impact area. 8. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall add a note to the final site plans that states, "Petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process shall not be allowed to enter a stream or wetland that is within a /WR conservation area." 9. Prior to final plat approval, the applicant shall add a note to the final site plans that states, "All lighting within the /WR Conservation Area shall meet the lighting standards under EC 9.4980(8)(b) and EC 9.4980(8)(c)." March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 27 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) Conditions related to planned Unit Development (PDF 25-01) 10. Prior to final site plan approval, the applicant shall submit a revised Private Joint Use Access and Utility Easement and Maintenance Agreement (JAM) that includes referencing Tambour Lane and Tambour Court as part of Lot A, and the Permitted Improvements and Construction Expectations section shall be revised to either define a blanket PUE with a private utility corridor or a blanket private utility easement with a PUE corridor. 11. Prior to final site plan approval, the final site plans shall be revised to either define a blanket PUE with a private utility corridor or a blanket private utility easement with a PUE corridor. 12. Prior to final site plan approval, the final plans shall be revised so that all public stormwater facilities are located in either public right-of-way, public utility easements, or public stormwater easements in compliance with EC 9.6796. Jeff Gepp4r,Yr(ncipal'Plann//, for the Eugene Planning Director Date Attachments Attachment A: Fire Marshal's Office comments (February 25, 2026) Attachment B: Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351-Native and Non -Native Plant List Post Approval & Expiration Pursuant to EC 9.7220(4), the Planning Director's decision regarding this Type II application is effective on the 13t" day after notice of the decision is mailed, unless appealed according to the procedures in EC 9.7605. Per EC 9.7230, the applicant shall submit an application for a development permit within 36 months of the approval effective date, or the approval shall expire. A performance agreement in accordance with EC 9.7025 is required. The Standards Review shall remain effective for 18 months following the effective date of approval, in accordance with EC 9.7230. Within that time period, the applicant must submit a final plan meeting the applicable conditions of approval and execute a performance agreement in accordance with EC 9.7025. It is also noted that this approval does not relieve the applicant of complying with other applicable provisions of the Eugene Code or Oregon Revised Statutes, which may otherwise govern the development of the subject property. March 2026 Findings & Decision of the Planning Director Page 28 of 28 Braewood Hills Third Addition (SDR 25-02 & PDF 25-01) Eugene Office 1320 Willamette Street Eugene, OR 97401 (541) 682-5411 (541) 682-6882 FAX Fire Attachment A FIRE DEPARTMENT ('.OMMENTS FOR EUG"'ENE, OR SP1tI\'GFIIiLD PLA\'\TIN( DEPARTMENTS Date: February 25, 2026 Project: Braewood Hills 3rd Addition File Number: PDF-25-01 Address: not yet assigned; east of Hawkins Lane -Eugene Existing Use: Vacant Proposal: Final Planned Unit Development to create 38 residential lots, streets, and associated infrastructure improvements. Planner: Nick Gioello, Associate Planner Fire Department Comments/Conditions Access: 1. The maximum street profile slope for Tambour Court has changed from the PDF-24-01 to the PTF-25-01 from a maximum slope of 19% to 24%. This is not acceptable for fire apparatus access. Show a revied profile with maximum slope of 20% with transitions to 10% on each side. 2. Street widths of 21 feet with parking on one side appear to meet City of Eugene engineering standards for local public access. However, Eugene Springfield Fire strongly recommends following the 2022 Eugene Fire Code, Section 503.2.1 which requires 20 feet clear width with no parking allowed on both sides within that 20 foot width for these private streets. "NO PARKING -FIRE LANE" signage shall be posted on both sides of the Randy Lane, Tambour Lane and Tambour Court (2022 Eugene Fire Code Section D103.6). 3. Since there is only one access to this 38 lot subdivision, all dwellings in this development shall be equipped with approved automatic fire sprinkler systems meeting NFPA requirements (2022 EFC, Appendix D107.1, exception 1). SPRftdGrirLD A shared service of the cities of Eugene and Springfield, Oregon 4. Several lots show access to be provided by 10 and 14 foot wide utility and access easements. This width will not be adequate for the required fire apparatus access requirements of 20' minimum. Access requirements for these houses will be evaluated at the time of building permit submittal, when such access is proposed (2022 Eugene Fire Code 503.2.1). 5. Fire will review the building permit applications for all lots within this subdivision to ensure proper fire department apparatus access is provided and fire sprinklers meeting NFPA standards are applied to new houses. Fire apparatus turnarounds may be required in certain instances to the distance from Randy Lane and Tambour Lane &Court (2022 Eugene Fire Code 503.1 & D103.4). Water Supply: This proposal shows fire hydrants being proposed. 1. The spacing of the proposed fire hydrants does not meet the average spacing requirements of EFC C105.1 and table C105.1. Randy Lane and Stonehenge Way are both private dead end streets. As such the maximum average hydrant spacing is 400 feet, and maximum distance from any point on street or road frontage to a hydrant is 200 feet. Add an additional hydrant in the vicinity of the hammerhead turnaround of Tambour Ct. In order to meet fire hydrant spacing requirements FH-3 (at the end of Randy Lane) should be moved to the west. 2. The size of the dwelling units may dictate additional fire hydrants be installed depending on the square footage. Anything over 3,600 sq. ft. of fire area (which includes garages) will usually require additional fire hydrants with a minimum flow of 1,500 gpm at 20 psi residual pressure per 2022 EFC Appendix B. Again, this required fire flow can be reduced with the installation of fire sprinkler systems. Comments provided by Deputy Fire Marshal Eric Phillips -Meadow SPRINGFIELD A shared service of the cities of Eugene and Springfield, Oregon Attachment B Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Native and Non -Native Plant List Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Native and Non -Native Plant List Part 1 NATIVE PLANT SPECIES FOR SITES AT OR ABOVE 425 FEET IN ELEVATION WITHIN THE EUGENE UG B The plant species included in this list are species that grow and propagate themselves in the Eugene area through natural processes, are adapted to the weather, soils and hydrology of the area, and have evolved in the area or been introduced to the area by natural causes. These native plant species are distinguished from plant species that have been deliberately or accidentally imported or introduced from other areas by humans or human activities. This list applies to all habitat types, including riparian, upland and wetland areas, above 425 feet in elevation. To meet Eugene Code requirements for native plants, these species are to be used within the specified geographic area or elevation. Do not substitute alternate species. You must use the specific species, subspecies or variety listed. Wetland Indicator Status and Site Suitability information in the table below is intended as a guideline for identifying suitable locations for plant species based on additional site characteristics, such as soils and hydrology. Common Name grand fir vine maple Oregon bigleaf maple red alder Pacific madrone incense cedar Pacific dogwood Oregon ash Ponderosa pine black cottonwood Douglas fir Oregon white oak California black oak Pacific willow Scouler's willow Sitka willow Pacific yew Scientific Name Wetland Indicator Status Abies grandis NOL Acer circinatum FACU+ Acer macrophyllum FACU Alnus rubra FAC Arbutus menziesii NOL Calocedrus decurrens NOL Corms nuttallii NOL UB Fraxinus latifolia FACW Pinus ponderosa FACU Populus trichocarpa FAC Pseudotsuga menziesii var. menziesii NOL Quercus garryana var. garryana NOL Quercus kelloggii NOL Salix lucida ssp. lasiandra FACW+ Salix scouleriana FAC Salix sitchensis FACW Taxus brevifolia FACU- Site Suitability UB UB UB LB, UB UB UB LB, UB UB LB UB UB UB WE, LB LB, UB WE, LB UB Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 1 Shrubs and Vines Common Name serviceberry tall Oregon grape common buckbrush redstem ceanothus wild clematis Suksdorf s hawthorn red -osier dogwood California hazel salal ocean spray orange honeysuckle hairy honeysuckle osoberry/indian plum mock -orange Pacific ninebark chokecherry cascara buckthorn straggly gooseberry red currant baldhip rose Nootka rose thimbleberry salmon berry dewberry blue elderberry red elderberry Douglas spiraea snowberry red huckleberry viburnum Scientific Name Amelanchier alnifolia var. semiintegrifolia Berberis aquifolium Ceanothus cuneatus Ceanothus sanguineus Clematis ligusticifolia Crataegus suksdorfii FAC Corms sericea Corylus cornuta var. californica Gaultheria shallop Holodiscus discolor Lonicera ciliosa Lonicera hispidula Oemleria cerasiformis Philadelphus lewisii Physocarpus capitatus Prunus virginiana var. demissa Rhamnus purshiana Ribes divaricatum Ribes sanguineum Rosa gymnocarpa Rosa nutkana var. nutkana Rubus parviflorus Rubus spectabilis Rubus ursinus Sambucus mexicana Sambucus racemosa var. arborescens Spiraea douglasii var. douglasii Symphoricarpos albus var. laevigatus Vaccinium parviflorum Viburnum ellipticum Wetland Indicator Site Status Suitability FACU UB NOL NOL NOL FACU UB FACW NI NOL NOL NOL NOL NOL NOL FAC+ FACU FAC- NI NOL NI NI FACU+ FAC NOL FAC- FACU WE, LB UB UB UB UB UB UB UB WE, LB UB UB UB UB UB LB, UB UB LB, UB UB UB UB FACW WE, LB FACU UB NOL UB NOL UB Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 2 Herbaceous Plants Common Name Scientific Name Wetland Indicator Site Status Suitability vanilla -leaf Achlys triphylla NOL UB baneberry Actaea rubra NOL UB pathfinder Adenocaulon bicolor NOL UB red columbine Aquilegia formosa FAC LB, UB wild ginger Asarum caudatum NOL UB wild aster Eurybia radul ina (Aster radul inus) NOL UB lady -fern Athyrium fil ix fem ina FAC WE, LB, UB American wintercress Barbarea orthoceras FACW+ LB elegant brodiaea Brodiaea elegans FACU UB harvest Brodiaea Brodiaea coronaria NOL UB wood bittercress Cardamine angulata FACW LB, UB spring beauty Cardamine nuttallii var. nuttallii NOL UB miner's lettuce Claytonia perfoliata FAC UB candyflower Claytonia sibirica FACW UB tall larkspur Delphinium trolliifolium NOL UB bleeding heart Dicentra formosa NOL UB Hooker's fairy bells Prosartes hookeri NOL UB Watson's willow herb Epilobium ciliatum var. watsonii FACW- WE, LB Oregon fawn lily Erythronium oregonum NOL UB large -leaf avens Geum macrophyllum FACW+ LB, UB lowland cudweed Gnaphalium palustre FAC+ WE Willamette valley gumweed Grindelia integrifolia FACW WE, LB cow -parsnip Heracleum lanatum FAC UB Pacific waterleaf Hydrophyllum tenuipes NOL UB bog St. John's -wort Hypericum anagalloides OBL SW, WE tiger lily Lilium columbianum FAC UB miniature lupine Lupinus polycarpus NOL UB riverbank lupine Lupinus rivularis FAC LB, UB skunk cabbage Lysichiton americanus OBL SW, WE big smilacina Maianthemum racemosum FAC- UB little smilacina Maianthemum stellatum FAC- UB Oregon bigroot Marah oreganus NOL UB western bluebell Mertensia platyphylla NOL UB water montia Montia fontana OBL SW, WE aquatic caytonia Montia linearis NOL LB, UB small forget-me-not Myosotis laxa OBL SW, WE small flowered nemophila Nemophila parviflora var. nemophylla NOL UB water -parsley Oenanthe sarmentosa OBL SW, WE sweet cicely Osmorhiza berteroi NOL UB w. yellow wood sorrel Oxalis suksdorfii NOL UB sweet colt's-foot Petasites frigidus var. palmatus FACW LB Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 3 woodland phacelia Phacelia nemoralis FACU UB swordfern Polystichum munitum NOL UB bracken fern Pteridium aquilinum FACU UB self -heal Prunella vulgaris var. lanceolata FACU+ UB white water buttercup Ranunculus aquatil is OBL S W, WE woods buttercup Ranunculus uncinatus FAC UB willow leaved dock Rumex salicifolius FACW WE Pacific sanicle Sanicula crassicaul is NOL UB yerba buena Satureja douglasii NOL UB Idaho blue-eyed grass Sisyrinchium idahoense var. idahoense FACW WE, LB beautiful blue eyed grass Sisyrinchium bellum FACW- UB hedge -nettle Stachys mexicana FACW LB, UB spring queen Synthyris reniformis NOL UB fringecups Tellima grandiflora NOL UB western meadowrue Thalictrum occidentale FACU UB tall western meadowrue Thalictrum polycarpum NOL UB piggy -back plant Tolmiea menziesii FAC LB star -flower Trientalis latifolia FAC- UB sessile trillium Trillium albidum NOL UB western trillium Trillium ovatum ssp. ovatum NOL UB inside -out flower Vancouveria hexandra NOL UB American vetch Vicia americana NI WE, LB woodland violet Viola glabella FACW+ UB Grasses, Sedges, Rushes Wetland Indicator Site Common Name Scientific Name Status Suitability Sitka brome Bromus sitchensis NOL UB Dewey's sedge Carex deweyana var. leptopoda FAC+ UB Henderson's sedge Carex hendersonii NI LB slough sedge Carex obnupta OBL SW, WE sawbeak sedge Carex stipata var. stipata NOL WE, LB needle spikerush Eleocharis acicularis OBL SW, WE creeping spikerush Eleocharis palustris OBL SW, WE blue wild -rye Elymus glaucus ssp. glaucus FACU UB tall manna grass Glyceria striata FACW+ WE, LB meadow barley Hordeum brachyantherum FACW WE, LB common rush Juncus effusus var. gracil is FACW+ S W, WE spreading rush Juncus patens FACW SW, WE lacquered rush Juncus laccatus ? SW, WE onion grass Mellica subulata NOL UB Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 4 Key to Wetland Indicator Status OBL = Obligate Wetland Plants. Under normal conditions, these plants almost always occur in wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 99%). FACW = Facultative Wetland Plants. Under normal conditions these plants are usually found in wetlands, but also may be found outside wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 67-99%) FAC = Facultative Plants. Under normal conditions, these plants are found equally in wetlands and non -wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 33-66%). FACU = Facultative Upland Plants. Under normal conditions, these plants are most likely to be found in non -wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 1-33%). UPL = Obligate Upland Plants. These plants are almost always found in non -wetlands, and are expected to be found in wetlands less than 1 % of the time. NOL = Not on U.S.F.W.S. wetland plant list. Key to Site Suitability SW = Shallow water WE = Water's edge LB = Lower bank UB = Upper bank and terraces above the ordinary high water line Wetland indicator status information is taken from: "National List of Plant Species That Occur In Wetlands: Northwest (Region 9)," U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, May 1988; 1993 supplement. Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 5 Part 2 NATIVE PLANT SPECIES FOR SITES AT OR BELOW 500 FEET IN ELEVATION WITHIN THE E UGENE UG B The plant species included in this list are species that grow and propagate themselves in the Eugene area through natural processes, are adapted to the weather, soils and hydrology of the area, and have evolved in the area or been introduced to the area by natural causes. These native plant species are distinguished from plant species that have been deliberately or accidentally imported or introduced from other areas by humans or human activities. This list applies to all habitat types, including riparian, upland and wetland areas, below 500 feet in elevation within the UGB, except within the West Eugene Wetlands Plan area, and within seasonal wet prairie habitats (see Part 3). To meet Eugene Code requirements for native plants, these species are to be used within the specified geographic area and elevation. Do not substitute alternate species. You must use the specific species, subspecies or variety listed. Wetland Indicator Status and Site Suitability information in the table below is intended as a guideline for identifying suitable locations for plant species based on additional site characteristics, such as soils and hydrology. Common Name Scientific Name Wetland Indicator Site Status Suitability grand fir Abies grandis NOL UB vine maple Acer circinatum FACU+ UB Oregon bigleaf maple Acer macrophyllum FACU UB white alder Alnus rhombifolia FACW LB, UB red alder Alnus rubra FAC LB, UB incense -cedar Calocedrus decurrens NOL UB Pacific dogwood Cornus nutallii NOL UB Oregon ash Fraxinus latifolia FACW LB, UB ponderosa pine Pinus ponderosa FACU UB black cottonwood Populus balsamifera FAC LB ssp. trichocarpa Douglas -fir Pseudotsuga menziesii var. menziesii NOL UB Oregon white oak Quercus garryana var. garryana NOL UB California black oak Quercus kelloggii NOL UB Pacific willow Salix lucida FACW+ WE, LB ssp. lasiandra western yew Taxus brevifolia FACU- UB western redcedar Thuja plicata FAC UB Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 6 Shrubs Wetland Indicator Site Common Name Scientific Name Status Suitability serviceberry Amelanchier alnifolia FACU UB var. semiintegrifolia tall Oregon grape Berberis aquifolium NOL UB common buckbrush Ceanothus cuneatus NOL UB Suksdorf s hawthorn Crataegus suksdorfii FAC UB var. suksdorfii red -osier dogwood Cornus sericea FACW WE, LB California hazel Corylus cornuta NI UB var. californica ocean spray Holodiscus discolor NOL UB osoberry/indian plum Oemleria cerasiformis NOL UB mock -orange Philadelphus lewisii NOL UB Pacific ninebark Physocarpus capitatus FAC+ WE, LB chokecherry Prunus virginiana FACU UB var. demissa cascara buckthorn Rhamnus purshiana FAC? UB straggly gooseberry Ribes divaricatum NI UB red currant Ribes sanguineunz NOL UB baldhip rose Rosa gynznocarpa NI UB Nootka rose Rosa nutkana NI LB, UB blackcap Rubus leucodermis NOL UB thimbleberry Rubus parviflorus FACU+ UB salmonberry Rubus spectabilis FAC LB, UB dewberry Rubus ursinus NOL UB Columbia River willow Salix fluviatilis OBL SW, WE Piper's willow Salix hookeriana (piperi) FACW LB Scouler's willow Salix scouleriana FAC LB, UB Sitka willow Salix sitchensis FACW WE, LB blue elderberry Sambucus mexicana (cerulea) FAC- UB red elderberry Sambucus racemosa FACU UB var. arborescens Douglas spiraea Spiraea douglasii var. douglasii FACW WE, LB snowberry Symphoricarpos albus var. laevigatus FACU UB oval -leaved viburnum Viburnum ellipticum NOL UB Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 7 Vines Wetland Indicator Site Common Name Scientific Name Status Suitability wild clematis Clematis ligusticifolia FACU UB orange honeysuckle Lonicera cil iosa NOL UB hairy honeysuckle Lonicera hispidula NOL UB Herbaceous Plants Wetland Indicator Site Common Name Scientific Name Status Suitability vanilla -leaf Achlys triphylla NOL UB baneberry Actaea rubra NOL UB pathfinder Adenocaulon bicolor NOL UB red columbine Aquilegia formosa FAC LB, UB wild ginger Asarum caudatum NOL UB lady -fern Athyrium filix femina FAC WE, LB, UB American wintercress Barbarea orthoceras FACW+ LB camas Camassia leichtlinii FACW- LB, UW wood bittercress Cardamine angulata FACW LB, UB spring beauty Cardamine nuttallii var. nuttallii NOL UB small -flowered claytonia Claytonia pare flora NOL UB miner's lettuce Claytonia perfoliata FAC UB candyflower Claytonia sibirica FACW UB tall larkspur Delphinium trolliifolium NOL UB bleeding heart Dicentra formosa NOL UB coastal shield fern Dryoptera arguta NOL UB Watson's willow herb Epilobium ciliatum (watsonii) FACW- LB Oregon fawn lily Erythronium oregonum NOL UB large -leaf avens Geum macrophyllum FACW+ LB, UB lowland cudweed Gnaphalium palustre FAC+ UB Willamette valley gumweed Grindelia integrifolia FACW WE, LB cow -parsnip Heracleum lanatum FAC UB Pacific waterleaf Hydrophyllum tenuipes NOL UB bog St. John's -wort Hypericum anagalloides OBL SW, WE tiger lily Lilium columbianum FAC UB miniature lupine Lupinus polycarpus NOL UB riverbank lupine Lupinus rivularis FAC UB skunk cabbage Lysichiton americanus OBL SW, WE big smilacina Maianthemum racemosa FAC- UB little smilacina Maianthemum stellaum FAC- UB Oregon bigroot Marah oreganus NOL UB western bluebell Mertensia platyphylla NOL UB water montia Montia fontana OBL SW, WE Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 8 aquatic claytonia Montia l inearis NOL LB, UB small forget-me-not Myosotis laxa OBL SW, WE small -flowered nemophila Nemophila pare flora var. nemophylla NOL UB water -parsley Oenanthe sarmentosa OBL SW, WE sweet cicely Osmorhiza berteroi NOL UB w. yellow wood sorrel Oxalis suksdorfii NOL UB sweet colt's-foot Petasites frigidus FACW LB var. palmatus woodland phacelia Phacelia nemoralis FACU UB swordfern Polystichum munitum NOL UB Hooker's fairy bells Prosartes hookeri NOL UB self -heal Prunella vulgaris var. lanceolata FACU+ UB white water buttercup Ranunculus aquatil is OBL S W, WE woods buttercup Ranunculus uncinatus FAC UB western dock Rumex occidentalis FAC- UB var. procerus willow leaved dock Rumex salicifolius FACW WE Pacific sanicle Sanicula crassicaulis NOL UB yerba buena Satureja douglasii NOL UB small -fruited bulrush Scirpus microcarpus OBL WE Hitchcock's blue-eyed grass Sisyrinchium hitchcockii NOL UB hedge -nettle Stachys mexicana FACW LB, UB fringecups Tell ima grandiflora NOL UB western meadowrue Thalictrum occidentale FACU UB tall western meadowrue Thalictrum polycarpum NOL UB piggy -back plant Tolmiea menziesii FAC LB star -flower Triental is latifol is FAC- UB sessile trillium Trillium albidum NOL UB western trillium Trillium ovatum ssp. ovatum NOL UB stinging nettle Urtica dioica FAC+ UB inside -out flower Vancouveria hexandra NOL UB American vetch Vicia americana NI WE, LB woodland violet Viola glabella FACW+ UB Grasses, Sedges, Rushes Wetland Indicator Site Common Name Scientific Name Status Suitability Dewey's sedge Henderson's sedge green -fruited sedge slough sedge sawbeak sedge needle spikerush Carex deweyana var. leptopoda Carex hendersonii Carex interrupta Carex obnupta Carex stipata var. stipata Eleocharis acicularis FAC+ NI OBL OBL NOL OBL UB LB SW, WE SW, WE WE, LB SW, WE Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 9 creeping spikerush Eleocharis palustris OBL SW, WE blue wild -rye Elymus glaucus ssp. glaucus FACU UB tall manna grass Glyceria striata FACW+ WE, LB meadow barley Hordeum brachyantherum FACW WE, LB taper -tip rush Juncus acuminatus OBL SW, WE three -stamen rush Juncus ensifolius FACW WE, LB common rush Juncus effusus FACW+ SW, WE shiny rush Juncus laccatus NOL SW, WE pointed rush Juncus oxymeris FACW+ SW, WE spreading rush Juncus patens FACW SW, WE slender rush Juncus tenuis FAC LB onion grass Melica subulata NOL UB Key to Wetland Indicator Status OBL = Obligate Wetland Plants. Under normal conditions, these plants almost always occur in wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 99%). FACW = Facultative Wetland Plants. Under normal conditions these plants are usually found in wetlands, but also may be found outside wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 67-99%) FAC = Facultative Plants. Under normal conditions, these plants are found equally in wetlands and non -wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 33-66%). FACU = Facultative Upland Plants. Under normal conditions, these plants are most likely to be found in non -wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 1-33%). UPL = Obligate Upland Plants. These plants are almost always found in non -wetlands, and are expected to be found in wetlands less than 1% of the time. NOL = Not on U.S.F.W.S. wetland plant list. Key to Site Suitab i 1 ity SW = Shallow water WE = Water's edge LB = Lower bank UB = Upper bank and terraces above the ordinary high water line Wetland indicator status information is taken from: "National List of Plant Species That Occur In Wetlands: Northwest (Region 9)," U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, May 1988; 1993 supplement. Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 10 Part 3 NATIVE PLANT SPECIES FOR SITES IN THE WEST EUGENE WETLANDS PLAN AREA AND IN SEASONAL WET PRAIRIE HABITAT IN OTHER GEOGRAPHIC AREAS The plant species included in this list are species that grow and propagate themselves in the Eugene area through natural processes, are adapted to the weather, soils and hydrology of the area, and have evolved in the area or been introduced to the area by natural causes. These native species are distinguished from plant species that have been deliberately or accidentally imported or introduced from other areas by humans or human activities. This list applies to sites within the West Eugene Wetlands Plan area and within wet prairie habitats (e.g., in Westmoreland Park and Amazon Park). To meet Eugene Code requirements for native plants, these species are to be used within the specified geographic area or elevation. Do not substitute alternate species. You must use the specific species, subspecies or variety listed. Wetland Indicator Status and Site Suitability information in the table below is intended as a guideline for identifying suitable locations for plant species based on additional site characteristics, such as soils and hydrology. Scientific Name Common Name Wetland Indicator Site Status Suitability Fraxinus latifolia Oregon ash FACW BA, TW Pinus ponderosa Ponderosa pine FACU- BA, TN Popul us trichocarpa black cottonwood FAC BA, TN Pseudotsuga menziesii var. menziesii Douglas -fir NOL TN Quercus kelloggii California black oak NOL TN Quercus garryana var. garryana Oregon white oak NOL TN Salix sitchensis Sitka willow FACW WE, BA Salix scouleriana Scouler's willow FAC BA Salix piperi Piper's willow FACW WE, BA Salix lucida ssp. lasiandra Pacific willow FACW+ WE, BA Shrubs Wetland Indicator Site Scientific Name Common Name Status Suitability Amelanchier alnifolia serviceberry FACU TN var. semiintegrifolia Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 11 Berberis aquifolium tall Oregon -grape NOL TN Corylus cornuta western hazelnut NI TN Crataegus suksdorf i Suksdorfs hawthorn FAC BA, TN Holodiscus discolor ocean spray NOL TN Lonicera hispidula hairy honeysuckle NOL TN Oemleria cerasiformis Indian plum NOL TN Physocarpus capitatus Pacific ninebark FAC+ BA Pyrus fusca western crab-apple FAC+ TN Rhamnus purshiana cascara NI TN Rosa nutkana Nootka rose NI TN Rosa pisocarpa clustered wild rose FACU TN Spiraea douglasii var. douglaii Douglas' spiraea FACW WE, BA, TW Symphoricarpos albus common snowberry FACU TN var. laevigatus Viburnum ellipticum Oregon viburnum NOL TN Herbaceaous Plants Wetland Indicator Site Scientific Name Common Name Status Suitability Achillea millefolium common yarrow FACU TN Alisma plantago-aquatica broad -leaf water -plantain OBL SW, WE var. americana Allium amplectens slimleaf onion NOL TN Aster hallii Hall's aster FAC TN, TW Bidens cernuua nodding beggar's -tick FACW+ WE, TW Bidens frondosa leafy beggar's -tick FACW+ WE, TW Boisduvalia densiflora dense spike -primrose FACW- WE Brodiaea hyacinthina hyacinth brodiaea FACU TN Brodiaea coronaria harvest brodiaea NOL TN Callitriche heterophylla water-starwort OBL SW, WE Camassia leichtlinii ssp. Suksdorfii tall camas FACW- TW Camassia quamash ssp. maximacommon camas FACW TW Cardamine pendul flora Willamette Valley bittercress OBL SW, WE, TW Cardamine nutallii slender toothwort NOL UB var. nutall i i Claytonia sibirica candyflower FACW UB Delphinium trolliifolium Columbia larkspur NOL TN Downingia elegans common downingia OBL SW, WE Epilobium paniculatum autumn willow -herb NOL TN Eriophyllum lanatum woolly sunflower NOL TN Eryngium petiolatum Oregon coyote -thistle OBL SW, WE Geum macrophyllum large -leaved avens FACW+ WE, BA Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 12 Grindelia integrifolia Willamette valley gumweed FACW WE, BA var. integrifol is Heracleum lanatum cow -parsnip FAC BA, TN Hydrocotyle ranunculoides floating marsh-pennywort OBL SW Lasthenia glaberrima smooth lasthenia OBL SW Lotus formosissimus seaside lotus FACW+ WE Lotus pinnatus bog lotus FACW SW, WE Lotus purshianus spanish-clover NOL TN Ludwigia palustris var. pacifica water -purslane OBL S W, WE Lupinus polyphyllus bigleaf lupine FAC+ BA, TN Marah oreganus Oregon bigroot NOL TN Microseris laciniata cut -leaved microseris NOL TN Montia l inearis narrow -leaved montia NOL TN Myosotis laxa small -flowered forget-me-not OBL WE Nuphar polysepalum pond lily OBL SW Oenanthe sarmentosa water parsely OBL SW, WE Osmorhiza chilensis sweet -Cicely NOL TN Perideridia gairdneri Gairdner's yampah FACU TN Plagiobothrys fguratus fragrant popcorn -flower FACW SW, TW Polygonum hydropiperoides waterpepper OBL SW, WE, TW Polystichum munitum common sword fern NOL BA, TN Potentilla gracilis var. gracilis slender cinquefoil FAC TN Prunella vulgaris var. lanceolata self -heal FACU+ TN Ranunculus uncinatus disappointing buttercup FAC BA Ranunculus orthorhynchus straight -beak buttercup FACW- BA Ranunculus occidental is western buttercup FACW BA Ranunculus aquatilis white water -buttercup OBL SW, WE, TW Rorippia curvisiliqua western yellowcress FACW+ WE, TW Rubus ursinus Pacific blackberry NI TN Rumex salicifolius willow -leaved dock FACW TW Sanicula crassicaulis western sanicle NOL TN var. crassicaul is Saxftaga oregana Oregon saxifrage FACW+ WE, BA Sidalcea cusickii Cusick's checkermallow NOL WE Sparganium emersum simple -stem bur -reed OBL SW, WE, TW Stachys rigida rigid hedge -nettle FACW- BA Tellima grandiflora fringecups NOL TN Trillium albidum sessile trillium NOL TN Typha latifolia broad-leafcattail OBL SW, WE Veratrum californicum tailed false -hellebore OBL SW, WE var. caudatum Veronica americana American speedwell OBL SW, WE Veronica scutellata marsh speedwell OBL SW, WE Wyethia angustifol is narrow -leaf wyethia FACU TN Zigadenus venenosus death camas FAC TW, TN Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 13 var. venenosus Grasses, Sedges and Rushes Wetland Indicator Site Scientific Name Common Name Status Suitability Agrostis exarata spike bentgrass FACW BA, TW Alopecurus geniculatus water foxtail FACW+ BA, TW Beckmannia syzigachne American slough grass OBL SW, WE Carex densa dense sedge OBL SW, WE Carex deweyana var. leptopoda Dewey's sedge FAC+ BA, TW Carex lanuginosa woolly sedge OBL SW, WE Carex leporina hare sedge FAC BA, TW Carex obnupta slough sedge OBL SW, WE Carex unilateralis one-sided sedge FACW WE, TW Danthonia californica California oatgrass FACU- TN Deschampsia cespitosa tufted hairgrass FACW TW Deschampsia danthonioides annual hairgrass FACW- TW Deschampsia elongata slender hairgrass FACW- TW Eleocharis acicularis needle spikerush OBL SW, WE Eleocharis ovata ovoid spike-rush OBL SW, WE Eleocharis palustris creeping spikerush OBL SW, WE Elymus glaucus ssp. glaucus blue wildrye FACU TN Glyceria occidentalis western mannagrass OBL SW, WE Hordeum brachyantherum meadow barley FACW WE, TW Juncus acuminatus tapered rush OBL SW, WE Juncus articulatus jointed rush OBL SW, WE Juncus nevadensis Sierra rush FACW WE, TW Juncus oxymeris pointed rush FACW+ WE, TW Juncus patens spreading rush FACW WE, TW Juncus tenuis var. tenuis slender rush FAC BA, TW Koeleria cristata junegrass NOL TN Panicum occidentale western witchgrass FACW WE, TW Scirpus validus softstem bulrush OBL SW, WE Key to Wetland Indicator Status OBL = Obligate Wetland Plants. Under normal conditions, these plants almost always occur in wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 99%). FACW = Facultative Wetland Plants. Under normal conditions these plants are usually found in wetlands, but also may be found outside wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 67-99%) Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 14 FAC = Facultative Plants. Under normal conditions, these plants are found equally in wetlands and non -wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 33-66%). FACU = Facultative Upland Plants. Under normal conditions, these plants are most likely to be found in non -wetlands (estimated probability of wetland occurrence 1-33%). UPI = Obligate Upland Plants. These plants are almost always found in non -wetlands, and are expected to be found in wetlands less than 1 % of the time. NOL = Not on U.S.F.W.S. wetland plant list. Key to Site Suitability SW = Shallow water WE = Water's edge BA Bank TW = Top of Bank, wetland (e.g., where prairie wetlands exist adjacent to a stream or channel) TN_ Top of Bank, non -wetland Wetland indicator status information is taken from: "National List of Plant Species That Occur In Wetlands: Northwest (Region 9)," U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, May 1988; 1993 supplement. Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 15 Part 4 NON-NATIVE, INVASIVE PLANT SPECIES KNOWN OR LIKELY TO OCCUR WITHIN THE EUGENE URBAN GROWTH BOUNDARY The plant species included in this list are species that have been deliberately or accidentally imported or introduced from other areas by humans or human activities. In addition, these species escape from cultivated settings and spread aggressively into natural areas, and are capable of displacing large areas of native vegetation. These non-native, invasive plant species are distinguished from those native species that grow and propagate themselves in the Eugene area through natural processes, are adapted to the weather, soils and hydrology of the area, and have evolved in the area or been introduced to the area by natural causes. This list applies to all habitat types within the Eugene Urban Growth Boundary. To meet Eugene Code requirements for removal of non-native, invasive plants, you must remove the specific species, subspecies or variety listed. Scientific Common Name Name Notes Reference Acer Norway maple Invasive tree spreading into forested natural areas 1 platanoides around town including Skinner's Butte. Aesculus horsechestnut Populations have been found in south end of 1 hippocastanum Hendricks Park and this species is known to be problematic in other cities. Ailanthus tree -of -heaven Invasive tree that is problematic in City parks, alleys, 1,3 altissima and undeveloped property. This species is capable of becoming established through cracks in concrete. Alliaria garlic mustard One of the most invasive forest under story plants in 19 4 petiolata the east and Midwest, starting to establish in the Seattle area. Documented as present in Portland and Eugene Anchusa azurea anchusa; Exploding in large patches roadside and in woods in 1, 3 common western Benton County. Also known recently from bugloss Lane and Clackamas counties. Arum italicum Arum While it appears to be moved primarily by humans, it 1 occasionally is found away from human activity areas. Once established, it is extremely difficult to remove. Betula European birch This species is spreading rapidly along waterways and 5 pendula/pubesc is now established along the entirety of Amazon Creek from near its headwaters to Fern Ridge Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 16 ens Reservoir. Brachypodium false-brome Highly invasive grass rapidly spreading through l , 3, 4 sylvaticum forests and along rivers in our area in numerous places including Alton Baker Park. It has the potential to permanently alter the forest under story, as it out - competes most other species and no control is known. Buddleia fountain Both butterfly bushes displace native willows which 1, 4 alternifolia, butterfly bush are essential host plants for native butterflies. Buddleia davidii Clematis vitalba traveler's joy Invasive climber comparable to English ivy is a 1, 3, 4 problem in areas of Portland and Seattle. Currently appearing in several areas along the Willamette River with large populations established on Skinner Butte. Cotoneaster cotoneaster Occurring in native prairies and woodland edges. 1 ftanchettii (Cotoneaster franchetti, C. horizontalis, C. parneyi, etc. Best to avoid all cotoneasters.) Cotoneaster cotoneaster Occurring in native prairies and woodland edges. 1 horizontalis (Cotoneaster franchetti, C. horizontalis, C. parneyi, etc. Best to avoid all cotoneasters.) Crataegus English This species is well established and spreading rapidly 1, 3, 4 monogyna hawthorn into woodlands and prairies throughout town. It interbreeds with the native hawthorn creating hybrids that are difficult to accurately identify. Cynoglossum common This common garden species has escaped and appears 2, 3 officinale houndstongue regularly in several City parks, along waterways and in unimproved alleys. Cytisus French broom This species is a serious problem in CA and OR south 1, 2, 3, 4 monspessulana coast and is now appearing in Eugene Cytisus Scot's broom Dense populations established along the Willamette, 15 2, 3, 4 scoparius in the south hills, throughout the West Eugene Wetlands, along roadways and railways and in several city parks. Avoid use of all brooms. Daphne spurge laurel Spread by birds into forested areas throughout town. 1, 3 laureola Digitalis foxglove This common and attractive garden wild flower 1, 3 purpurea escapes easily and forms dense populations. It is becoming well established in some areas along the Willamette River. Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 17 Genista broom This species is a serious problem in CA and along the monspessulana south OR coast. Now beginning to appear in Eugene. Geranium shining Beginning to dominate forest understories in south 1 lucidum crane's -bill Eugene. Geranium herb robert Dominates forest understories in several areas in 1, 35 4 robertianum Eugene including Hendrick's park. This species is spreading rapidly throughout town. Glecoma ground ivy; Can become a dominant plant in moist, shady riparian e eracea creeping areas. Charlie Hedera helix English ivy Spreads vegetatively in forested and open areas. Seeds 1, 2, 3, 4 spread mostly by exotic birds including starlings. This species is an extensive and widespread problem throughout Eugene, especially in forested areas and along the Willamette River. Hypericum St. John's wort This species invades meadows, trailsides, roadsides, 1, 2, 3, 4 perforatum and other areas throughout town. Ilex aquifolium English holly Spread by birds and appears regularly in forest 1, 3 understories throughout town. Iris yellow flag iris Forms monocultures in wetlands. This species has 1, 3 pseudoacorus established in Bertelsen Slough, Amazon Creek, Flat Creek, Spring Creek and along the Willamette River. Juniperus eastern Birds eat berries and spread seeds. 1 virginiana redcedar Lamiastrum Yellow Primarily spread by humans. Very aggressive, 1 galeobdolan archangel primarily moving out from landscaped areas. Has escaped in Springfield, Corvallis, and in Seattle, where a botanist says it "covers hillsides." Lathyrus sp. latifolius Well -established, primarily along roadsides and 1 sweet, hedgerows, large population on Chamber' s connector. perennial or Listed in "Weeds of the West" everlasting pea Leucanthemum oxeye daisy This species is common in commercial "wildflower 1, 3, 4 vulgare mixes". It has become widely established in meadows in West Eugene, Amazon Park, and along roadsides and mowed waterways. Formerly Chrysanthemum leucanthemum. Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 18 Ligustrum common privet Birds eat fruits and spread plants into woods and vulgare prairies. Linaria vulgaris yellow Roadside weed expanding into prairies. toadflax Lotus birdsfoot corniculatus trefoil Lunaria annua honesty; money plant Lysimachia moneywort nummularia Lythrum purple salicaria loosestrife Melissa lemon balm officinalis Mentha Mentha pulegium pulegium Myriophyllum Eurasian spicatum watermilfoil Myosotis common scorrpioides forget-me-not Myriophyllum parrot's ssp. feather, et. al. Phal aris Harding grass aq uati ca Phalaris reed arundinacea canarygrass Sold in pasture mixes. This species has invaded wetland areas throughout town including most drainage channels. Invasive in forest understories. Regular dominant of riparian wetlands in our areas, both in sun and shade. This species forms monocultures in wetlands and is a species of national concern. Although not yet widespread, populations have been found in Amazon Creek and Willamette River and appear to be expanding. Widespread weed in native prairies and openings in woods. Forms large monocultures in emergent wetlands in West Eugene, displacing native wetland plants. 1 1,2,3,4 1, 3 1 1 1, 2, 39 4 1 11 Includes water-milfoils. Myriophyllum aquaticum L 2 3 4 (M. brasiliense; parrot's feather) and M. spicatum ' (Eurasian milfoil) are common aquatic species in waterways and ponds throughout Eugene. Can dominate forest understories, especially openings 1 and on edges. This genus of floating aquatic plants includes the 1 water milfoils. Myriophyllum aquaticum (parrot's feather) is the major offender, and Myriophyllum spicatum (Eurasian milfoild) is also very damaging. This wetland species is found in slightly drier 1, 3, 4 conditions than P. arundinacea. While populations are not yet as widespread as P. arundinacea, populations are rapidly expanding. This species forms dense monocultures and is one of 1, 3, 4 the most widespread species in all types of wetlands Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 19 throughout Eugene. It permanently and dramatically effects ecosystems where it has become established. This species is still sold commercially. Polygonum Japanese This species forms riparian monocultures. This 1, 2, 3 cuspidatum (and knotweed species is not yet common in Eugene but populations related species are becoming more common and larger. It is already a and hybrids) significant problem in the Portland and Seattle areas. Avoid all the large knotweeds. Populus alba white poplar This species spreads rapidly via suckers and is 3 difficult to remove once established. It also quickly becomes a hazard tree as the brittle branches are prone to breakage. This species is found is several City parks including Alton Baker Park. Prunus avium sweet cherry This species is spread by birds into forested areas and 1, 3, 4 is a quite common understory invader in forested areas throughout Eugene. Prunus thundercloud Grafted species and rootstocks that sucker and flower, 1 cerasifera plum produce fruit which is spread easily by birds. This species is appearing in prairie areas in West Eugene and woodland edges throughout town. Prunus plum Not as invasive as P. avium. 1 domestica Prunus English laurel This common hedge evergreen is spread by birds and 1,3 laurocerasus appears regularly in forested understories, especially at Skinner Butte, Morse Ranch, and Hendricks Park. Prunus Portugal laurel Similar to P. laurocrasus, this species appears 1 lusitanica regularly in forest understories. Prunus mahaleb mahaleb cherry Birds spread seeds of this species, which is common 3 in the understories of forested areas and woodland edges throughout town. Pueraria kudzu While populations have not been found in Eugene, 1, 2, 4 montana var. two occurrences have been noted in the Willamette lobata Valley. This species has devastated plant communities in southern and eastern states. Pyracantha spp. fire thorn Birds eat fruits and spread plants into prairies. P. 1 angustifolia, P. coccinea, et al. Pyrus communis pear This species appears occasionally in prairie areas and 5 shrub/scrub communities throughout town. Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 20 Ranunculus lesser Highly invasive in Hendricks Park and Mt. Pisgah 1 ficaria celandine Arboretum. Once established populations are extremely difficult to control. Ranunculus creeping This species is allelopathic. It forms large 1 repens buttercup monocultures, especially in moist areas. It is common in many of our parks including Tugman Park. Robinia black locust Widely escaped east of Cascades, beginning to 113 pseudoacacia naturalize on West Side (Portland area, Benton County, Lane County.) This species can form woodland monocultures. Rorippa watercress Chokes out small waterways on the valley floor. l , 3 nasturtium- aquaticum Rosa eglanteria sweet -briar This species easily invades prairie areas and is 1, 3 common throughout town especially in West Eugene. Rosa multijlora multiflowered This species, similar to R. eglantaria, is a common 1 rose problem in west Eugene wetlands and Fern Ridge Wildlife Area. Rubus Himalaya or One of the most widespread exotic species in the 1, 3, 4 armeniacus Armenian Pacific Northwest. Populations are well established in (discolor) blackberry all plant communities throughout Eugene. Rubus evergreen Not as invasive as R. armeniacus, but still forms l , 3 laciniatus blackberry dense clumps. Sorbus European Appearing in west Eugene wetlands and uplands. 193 aucuparia mountain -ash Birds spread seed. Ulex europeaus gorse A massive problem on the OR coast, now beginning 1 to appear in the Willamette Valley. Extremely difficult to remove. Vinca major periwinkle; Mostly near old homesites -- they appear to spread 1 vinca vegetatively only. Completely dominates understories. Vinca minor periwinkle; Mostly near old homesites -- they appear to spread 1, 3 vinca vegetatively only. Completely dominates understories. Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 21 References: 1. Invasive Gardening and Landscaping Plants of the Southern Willamette Valley, Native Plant Society of Oregon, Emerald Chapter, updated April 2002. 2. Oregon's Quarantine Against Noxious Weeds, Oregon Department of Agriculture, from http://www.oda.state.or.us/Plant/Weed_ control/NoxWeedQuar.pdf accessed on 04/10/02. 3. Draft of Exotic Pest Plants of Greatest Ecological Concern in Oregon and Washington; May 23 1997, The Pacific Northwest Exotic Pest Council, from http://www.wnps.org/eppclet.html accessed on 04/10/02, 4. NW Oregon most harmful invasive plant species list: based on information provided at & before the October 10, 2001 meeting in Salem BLM, Bureau of Land Management, Salem District, 2001. 5. City of Eugene staff recommendation based on resources required to remove species from parks, open spaces and waterways. Exhibit F to Ordinance No. 20351 Page 22