Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPublic Testimony Through 02-20-2026From:Elaine Hanks To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Braewood Hills Development Date:Tuesday, February 10, 2026 4:15:13 PM Attachments:Braewook Hill development.pdf You don't often get email from elaine.hanks@gmail.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Dear Mr. Gioello, This is my letter (attached) to the Planning Board regarding this development. Elaine E. Hanks, M.S.N., FNP-C 541-914-4423 cell 541-338-7983 landline February 10, 2026 Mr. Nick Gioello, Associate Planner NGioello@eugene-or.gov Planning and development City of Eugene 99W 10th Avenue, Suite 290 Eugene, OR 97401 RE: Braewood Hills 3rd Addition File number: PDF 25-01/SDR 25-02 Location: East of Hawkins Ln, North of Randy Ln. Relevant approval criteria: Sections 9.8365, 9.8470, 9.4980 Dear Planning Department, My name is Elaine Evelyn Ervin Hanks. I have resided at 2505 Park Forest Dr., Eugene, OR 97405 for twenty-four years. Thank you for allowing citizen input on this development. It looks great on this small postcard sent; there is a blank spot of land so it must be filled in with housing to generate income for Eugene. From my small vantage point, this looks like the goal. Does anyone in the planning Department live here? There is constant speeding up and down Hawkins Ln. There is constant traffic and flow of vehicles from 18th up the hill because there is only one main street from town up Hawkins. People walk their dogs, people walk for their health and find peace and quiet. This is now being encroached on and will get worse if 38 more lots are developed. This will affect the ability of EMS to get to an emergency in this area. The land is not stable on that hillside. Sure, you may put in drains and retaining walls but in 10 years they will fail and the developer will be long gone which will make the property owner responsible. All the property owner would know is that they bought a $700K brand new home that was now falling off the hillside. If homes are built there make it mandatory that the developer be responsible for any home damage done due to land shifting. Since this area is so large, you could at least put in a park area; part of it as a dog park, part as a walking area, part as a small playground all maintained by the city of Eugene. There could be walking trails that connect Melvin Miller Park, Skyview City Park , and Videra Park . I would want to see a picture of what is intended to be built on the lots. The structure recently built on Bowmont Dr. is an eyesore and does not compliment the other housing in the area. Please consider any or all of my ideas. Sincerely, Elaine Ervin Hanks ATTN: Nick Gioello, Associate Planner City of Eugene, Planning and Development, Planning Division 99 West 10th Ave, Suite 290 Eugene, OR 97401 From: Albert LePage, M.Ed.Science, B.S.Biology, Member, Society for Conservation Biology 1944 Cleveland St Eugene, OR 97405 Date: February 14, 2026 Comments Re: PDF 25-01 (Final PUD – “Braewood Hills 3rd Addition”) and SDR 25-02 (/WR Water Resources Overlay – Randy Lane Extension) Hello Mr. Gioello: I am writing to provide comments on the Final Planned Unit Development application PDF 25 -01 for Braewood Hills 3rd Addition and the associated Standards Review application SDR 25 -02 for work within the /WR Water Resources Overlay to extend Randy Lane through the southern portion of the property. I respectfully request that the City deny the applications as currently submitted because the record does not demonstrate compliance with the applicable approval criteria in EC 9.8365, 9.8470, and 9.4980, and because the information provided is incomplete, inconsistent, and in several instances speculative or unsupported by data. [1][2][3] 1. EC 9.8365 – Final PUD does not conform to tentative approval and conditions EC 9.8365 requires a finding that the final PUD plan “conforms with the approved tentative PUD plan and all conditions attached thereto.”[1] The January 21, 2026 supplemental materials describe multiple conditions of approval (COA 5, 6, 7, 15, 16, 26) that were previously found not satisfied, and assert that new easement documents and a revised stormwater report now resolve these issues. However, several of these responses still do not show clear, objective conformance with the tentative approval: [6] COA 7 – Public wastewater easement: The City’s prior comment notes that the final plans “do not show a 14-foot PUE or Public Wastewater Easement to encumber the proposed public wastewater system,” yet the applicant’s response is simply that the final plans show a PUE over the entire width of the private roads and that this “satisfies this requirement,” with no revised plan sheet or measurement confirming that the easement width, alignment, and rights match the condition of approval. This is a conclusory statement, not evidence of compliance.[6] COA 26 – Stormwater compliance with EC 9.6796: The stormwater report asserts that “no errors were found in the stormwater system design” and that “the facilities and conveyance components have enough capacity to handle the required storm events and should be approved as designed,” but this is the engineer’s own self-evaluation rather than a demonstration that each applicable criterion in EC 9.6796 and related stormwater standards is actually met. The report does not provide a clear checklist cross-walk to the City’s adopted stormwater manual and code provisions, leaving gaps in the evidence needed for a final PUD finding under EC 9.8365. [2] [6] Joint Access and Maintenance (COA 5, 6, 15, 16): The various agreements (JAM and multiple “Private Utility and Joint Access Easements”) are lengthy, complex, and impose numerous cross-easement and cost-sharing obligations on future owners that are not transparent in the PUD plan itself. There is no demonstration in the record that these private easement schemes preserve the same functional circulation, emergency access, and utility access that were evaluated at tentative PUD, nor that they are consistent with the City’s street and access standards. [6] Because EC 9.8365 approval must be based on an evidentiary showing that the final plan conforms to the tentative plan and “all conditions attached thereto,” the City cannot rely on unverified assertions in the supplemental materials in place of complete, consistent final plans and clearly referenced easements that match each condition of approval. [1][5] 2. EC 9.8470 – Standards Review: inadequate demonstration of protection and mitigation for Goal 5 resources EC 9.8470 and the associated Standards Review guidance require the applicant to provide a narrative prepared by qualified professionals demonstrating compliance with all applicable standards, including the /WR overlay provisions beginning at EC 9.4900 and the conservation area requirements in EC 9.4980. [2][3][4] The City’s own Standards Review application instructions emphasize that: It is the applicant’s responsibility to provide “adequate information” demonstrating how the project satisfies the applicable approval standards, and failure to do so may result in denial.[2] Site plans must show the adopted Goal 5 resource site boundaries, required /WR conservation area, top of bank/ordinary high water, wetlands on the Local Wetlands Inventory, and detailed information about vegetation, soils, slopes, hydrology, and stormwater disposition.[2] In light of this, the current SDR 25-02 record appears deficient in several key respects: Reliance on generalized SLOPES V assumptions: The stormwater report applies SLOPES V “pre-European development” flow standards and assumes a generalized pre-development curve number of 76 for the entire “wooded hillside,” but it does not provide site-specific hydrologic measurements within the Goal 5 waterways and wetlands that will be affected by the Randy Lane extension and associated grading, nor does it analyze how localized changes in flow paths and velocities within the /WR conservation area will affect channel stability and habitat functions. [6] “Pass-through” treatment of off-site flow: Four existing lots east of the site currently discharge stormwater via a private system that outfalls near the project’s eastern boundary; the report explicitly treats these flows as “pass through,” stating that this runoff is not required to be detained and that the project “does not impact the quantity or destination of that water.” Yet the applicant also proposes to route this flow through the new detention system and downstream conveyance, and acknowledges that it increases the 2-year peak in the system from 2.43 cfs to 2.78 cfs. This is a significant change in hydrologic routing through Goal 5 wetland and stream corridors, and the applicant has not provided an impact analysis that demonstrates no adverse effect on the protected resource as required by the /WR overlay. [4][6] Lack of resource-specific impact analysis for Randy Lane extension: The extension of Randy Lane and associated swales, pipes, and detention tiers will directly encroach on and fragment Goal 5 wetlands and streams that are mapped in the City’s Water Resource Conservation maps and regulated under EC 9.4900–9.4980. However, the supplemental materials focus almost entirely on peak-flow hydrology and do not provide quantitative analysis of changes in wetland hydroperiod, inundation depth and duration, or baseflow conditions that are critical to Goal 5 resource functions.[3][6] Incomplete vegetation and habitat analysis: The report notes that much of the site will remain “wooded and vegetated,” but it does not provide a detailed inventory of native versus invasive species within the /WR conservation area, the extent of tree removal associated with the street extension and grading, or how revegetation/planting will meet EC 9.4980’s standards for replanting bare soil with appropriate native species. Without this information, there is no basis to conclude that the Randy Lane extension and associated utilities will “avoid and minimize” impacts to Goal 5 resources to the maximum extent practicable, or that required mitigation will fully replace lost functions. [2][3][4] Given that EC 9.8470 requires an affirmative demonstration of compliance with the /WR overlay standards, the absence of resource-specific impact and mitigation analysis is a substantive failure of the application, not merely a technicality.eugene.[2][3][4] 3. EC 9.4980 – /WR conservation area: insufficient demonstration of standards and long-term protection EC 9.4980 and related /WR provisions establish mandatory standards for uses and activities within the Water Resources Conservation Area, including limitations on grading, vegetation removal, and structures, and requirements for planting/replanting and long-term resource protection. [3][4] The materials in the record do not demonstrate that the proposed development—including the Randy Lane extension, detention ponds, swales, and utility corridors—will comply with these standards: Grading and tiered detention within the conservation area: The stormwater system includes five-tiered detention ponds and multiple vegetated swales located at the base of the hill and within or adjacent to wetlands and streams. This implies substantial grading, excavation, and installation of rock armoring and structural features within the conservation area, but the application does not demonstrate that these are allowed uses under EC 9.4980 or that they are the minimum necessary to achieve code compliance.[3] [4] Planting standards and maintenance: The applicant includes generic Operations and Maintenance (O&M) language for vegetated facilities, swales, rain gardens, and structural detention based on the City’s 2014 Stormwater Management Manual, but there is no project-specific planting plan for the /WR conservation area that shows species, densities, and coverage consistent with EC 9.4980 planting standards. The O&M text is essentially boilerplate language (inspection frequency, mowing heights, sediment removal, etc.) and does not demonstrate how the City will ensure long-term protection and enhancement of Goal 5 habitat functions within the conservation area. [3][6] Fragmentation and edge effects: By extending Randy Lane and installing multiple private access drives and easements near or within the /WR area, the project substantially increases edge length and potential for human disturbance, invasive species spread, and stormwater pollutant loading to protected resources. EC 9.4980 is intended to protect water quality and habitat, but the application does not provide any analysis of these fragmentation and edge effects or propose mitigation measures (such as fencing, buffer enhancement, or access restrictions) to preserve resource integrity. [3][4][6] Without a clear, detailed demonstration that each activity within the conservation area is permitted under EC 9.4980 and that all required planting and long-term protection measures will be implemented, the City cannot lawfully make the findings required for SDR 25-02. [2][3] 4. Stormwater analysis: speculative assumptions and lack of Goal 5-focused evaluation The stormwater report is central to the applicant’s claim that the project “meets or exceeds” City requirements and SLOPES V criteria. However, several aspects of the analysis are based on broad assumptions rather than site-specific data, raising concerns about the reliability of the conclusions in a sensitive Goal 5 context:[6] Impervious percentage assumptions: For detention sizing, the report assumes that lots are 20% impervious and for water quality it assumes 50% impervious, and then states that these assumptions are “conservative” and that additional detention will be required on-lot if impervious exceeds 20%. Yet the PUD itself proposes large, steep lots with significant development potential and complex private driveway systems, and there is no binding mechanism in the record ensuring that individual builders will actually provide additional detention if they exceed the assumed impervious coverage. In a /WR setting, reliance on such unverified future behavior is speculative and does not satisfy the City’s obligation to ensure compliance at the time of approval. [2][3][6] Lack of continuous or seasonal hydrologic modeling: The report uses event-based SBUH modeling for 2-year and 10-year storms, but Goal 5 wetland and stream functions are strongly influenced by seasonal hydroperiod, low-flow conditions, and small, frequent events that are not captured in this limited analysis. Without more robust modeling or monitoring data, the City cannot reasonably conclude that the project will preserve or enhance resource functions as required by Goal 5 implementation measures.[4] [6] Downstream water quality and TMDL concerns: The report acknowledges that Amazon Creek is an impaired waterbody with a TMDL for dissolved oxygen and E. coli, and that the site drains to this system. However, there is no pollutant loading analysis, no evaluation of how the proposed combination of swales and detention will affect temperature, bacteria, and nutrient loading, and no demonstration that the project will not contribute to further impairment of this Goal 5-related water resource. [4][6] These deficiencies are particularly important under Oregon’s Statewide Planning Goal 5, which requires local governments to adopt and apply clear and objective regulations to protect specified natural resources. In the absence of robust, site-specific hydrologic and water quality analysis, approval of the project would rest on unsupported assumptions, making it vulnerable to challenge.[4] 5. Legal risk under Goal 5 and LUBA case law Oregon appellate and Land Use Board of Appeals (LUBA) decisions have repeatedly emphasized that local governments must apply their adopted Goal 5 protection measures as written and cannot rely on conclusory or incomplete evidence to approve development within protected resource areas.[6] In particular: EC 9.8365, 9.8470, and 9.4980 are clear and objective standards that require affirmative evidence of compliance, not mere assertions.eugene. [1][2][3] The City’s own /WR Standards Review guidance warns that failure to provide adequate information “may result in a denial.” Approving SDR 25-02 on the current record, without complete resource impact analysis, could be viewed as inconsistent with this guidance.[2] If the City approves the Final PUD and Standards Review on the present record, a party could reasonably argue on appeal that: The City misapplied EC 9.8365 by relying on unverified statements rather than confirming that each tentative plan condition is actually met in the final plan and record.ojd.contentdm.[1][5] The City failed to require the level of site-specific analysis that EC 9.8470 and 9.4980 demand for work in a /WR conservation area, particularly with respect to wetland and stream functions. [2][3] [4] The approval is inconsistent with Goal 5 implementation because it does not ensure that the mapped water resources and their functions will be maintained or enhanced.[4] For these reasons, I believe the legally prudent course is to deny the applications as submitted , or at minimum to require substantial additional analysis and plan revisions before reconsideration. 6. Request In light of the concerns outlined above, I respectfully request that the City of Eugene : Deny PDF 25 - 01 and SDR 25 - 02 on the grounds that the applications fail to demonstrate compliance with EC 9.8365, EC 9.8470, and EC 9.4980. [1][2][3] Alternatively, remand the applications to the applicant with a requirement to provide: Full, plan - based documentation of conformance with all tentative PUD conditions; Detailed, resource - specific hydrologic, habitat, and water quality analysis for all Goal 5 wetlands and streams affected by the Randy Lane extension and associated infrastructure; A complete /WR planting and long - term management plan meeting EC 9.4980 standards; and Binding mechanisms to ensure that future lot - level development cannot exceed the stormwater assumptions without providing equivalent on-site detention and treatment. Thank you for considering these comments and for your work in applying the City’s land use code and Goal 5 protections to this sensitive site. Please include this letter in the record for PDF 25 - 01 and SDR 25 - 02. Respectfully, Albert LePage 1944 Cleveland St Eugene, OR 97405 References 1.Eugene Code EC 9.8365, Final Planned Unit Development Approval Criteria, Eugene Municipal Code (accessed Feb. 2026), https://eugene.municipal.codes/EC/9.8365 [eugene.municipal] 2.City of Eugene, “STANDARDS REVIEW – Water Resources (/WR) Overlay Zone,” application instructions (PDF) (accessed Feb. 2026), https://www.eugene- or.gov/DocumentCenter/View/5833/Standards-Review---Water-Resources-WR-Overlay-Zone [eugene- or] 3.Eugene Code EC 9.4980, /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay Zone, Eugene Municipal Code (accessed Feb. 2026), https://eugene.municipal.codes/EC/9.4980 [eugene.municipal] 4.City of Eugene, “Water Resource Conservation Maps,” webpage describing Goal 5 water resources and applicable regulations EC 9.4900–9.4980 (accessed Feb. 2026), https://www.eugene-or.gov/808/Water- Resource-Conservation-Maps.[eugene-or] 5.Court of Appeals of the State of Oregon, decision discussing application of EC 9.8365 and PUD final plan requirements (Dec. 2018), https://www.oregon.gov/LUBA/docs/Opinions/2018/10-18/18042.pdf See also this link [ojd.contentdm.oclc] https://ojd.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/api/collection/p17027coll8/id/36937/download 6.City-of-Eugene Supplemental Materials, “Braewood Hills 3rd Addition Completeness Review Response PDF 25-1 and SDR 25-2” and associated easement documents and stormwater analysis (Jan. 21, 2026). https://pdd.eugene-or.gov/LandUse/DocumentDetails?file=PDF-25-0001&id=4849048 From:al To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Comments Re: PDF 25‑01 (Final PUD – “Braewood Hills 3rd Addition”) and SDR 25‑02 (/WR Water Resources Overlay – Randy Lane Extension) Date:Saturday, February 14, 2026 7:22:12 PM Attachments:COMMENTS RE PDF 25‑01 (Final PUD – “Braewood Hills 3rd Addition”) and SDR 25‑02 Albert LePage 02-14- 2026.pdf [EXTERNAL ] Hello Nick Gioello, I am writing to provide comments on the Final Planned Unit Development application PDF 25 01 for Braewood Hills 3rd Addition and the associated Standards Review application SDR 25 02 for work within the /WR Water Resources Overlay to extend Randy Lane through the southern portion of the property. Please see attached pdf file in this regard, however, if another file format, or simply pasting the attached comments into an email, would better suit the process, please let me know and I will resend. Thank you for considering these comments and for your work in applying the City’s land use code and Goal 5 protections to this sensitive site. Please include the attached letter in the record for PDF 25 01 and SDR 25 02. Please confirm receipt of these comments, too. Thank you, again. Respectfully, Albert LePage 1944 Cleveland Street Eugene, Oregon 97405 “Clarifications and Additional Information” Addendum to Comments Submitted 02-14-2026 by Albert LePage ATTN: Nick Gioello, Associate Planner City of Eugene, Planning and Development, Planning Division 99 West 10th Ave, Suite 290 Eugene, OR 97401 From: Albert LePage, M.Ed. Science, B.S. Biology, Member, Society for Conservation Biology 1944 Cleveland St Eugene, OR 97405 Date: 02-15-2026 Re: PDF 25 - 01 (Final PUD – “Braewood Hills 3rd Addition”) and SDR 25 - 02 (/WR Water Resources Overlay – Randy Lane Extension) – Clarifications and Additional Information Hello Mr. Gioello: I am writing to add this addendum of clarifications and additional information in support of my previously submitted comments regarding PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02. These clarifications focus on the relationship between (1) completeness and substantive compliance, (2) the evidence required under EC 9.8365, 9.8470, and 9.4980, and (3) the level of analysis appropriate for development within a mapped /WR Water Resources Conservation Area implementing Statewide Planning Goal 5. 1. Completeness vs. substantive findings under EC 9.8365, 9.8470, and 9.4980 First, I recognize that the City has deemed the January 21, 2026 submittals complete for processing purposes. However, a completeness determination is only a procedural threshold and does not, by itself, demonstrate that the substantive approval criteria in EC 9.8365 (Final PUD), EC 9.8470 (Standards Review), and EC 9.4980 (/WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay) have been met. Oregon appellate decisions make clear that local governments must adopt findings supported by “substantial evidence” in the whole record; the presence of a technical report or recorded easement in the file is not enough if the record as a whole does not actually demonstrate compliance with each relevant criterion. In this case, the outstanding questions I raised about the content and clarity of the final PUD plans, the various private utility and access easements, and the stormwater analysis go directly to whether there is substantial evidence that the final development conforms to the approved tentative PUD and the /WR overlay standards, rather than to whether the application is merely complete. 2. Clarification regarding easements and conformance with tentative PUD conditions My prior comments are not intended to dispute that the applicant has drafted multiple easement documents; rather, the concern is whether the final PUD plans and recorded easements together provide a clear, objective demonstration that each tentative PUD condition—particularly COA 5, 6, 7, 15, 16, and 26—has been satisfied as required by EC 9.8365. For example, the tentative approval required dedication of “a 14-foot Public Utility Easement or Public Wastewater Easement that will encumber the proposed public wastewater system,” and staff explicitly noted that the final plans did not show such an easement. The applicant’s response is that the plans show a PUE over the entire width of the private roads and that this “satisfies this requirement,” but the record does not clearly identify where this width equals or exceeds the required 14 feet in relation to the specific wastewater alignment, nor does it plainly reconcile the new private easement structure with the public easement condition. Because EC 9.8365 requires the City to find that the final PUD “conforms with the approved tentative PUD plan and all conditions attached thereto,” there should be a direct, traceable link between each tentative condition and a corresponding element in the final plan set and easement documents. In my view, the current record still leaves room for doubt on this point, which is significant given the complexity of the joint access and utility arrangements and their importance for long-term access, maintenance, and emergency response. 3. Clarification on “adequate information” and the level of analysis expected in /WR and Goal 5 areas The City’s Standards Review guidance for the /WR Water Resources Overlay specifies that it is the applicant’s responsibility to provide “adequate information” demonstrating how the project satisfies the approval standards, and explicitly warns that failure to do so “may result in a denial.” The guidance also states that site plans and supporting materials should show the adopted Goal 5 resource boundaries, the /WR conservation area, top of bank/ordinary high water, and wetlands listed on the Local Wetlands Inventory, along with detailed information about vegetation, soils, slopes, hydrology, and stormwater disposition. I understand that the applicant has provided SLOPES V-based hydrologic modeling and a stormwater facility layout designed to meet the City’s 2014 Stormwater Management Manual and EC 9.6796. However, the project would place new roads, tiered detention ponds, and vegetated swales within and adjacent to mapped Goal 5 wetlands and streams that are protected by EC 9.4900–9.4980 and the City’s Water Resource Conservation maps. In that context, “adequate information” reasonably includes resource-specific analysis of: •how the Randy Lane extension and associated grading will affect wetland hydroperiod, inundation depth and duration, and baseflow conditions; •how changes in flow routing and peak timing will influence channel stability and erosion potential in the small streams at the toe of the slope; and •how vegetation removal, replanting, and long-term maintenance will preserve or enhance habitat functions within the /WR conservation area. Absent that level of resource-specific detail, there is a genuine question whether the City has enough information to make affirmative findings under EC 9.8470 and EC 9.4980 that the proposal avoids, minimizes, and fully mitigates adverse impacts to the protected Goal 5 resource. This is particularly important because Statewide Planning Goal 5 requires local governments to apply adopted protection measures to ensure that identified resources and their functions are maintained. 4. Clarification regarding stormwater methods, assumptions, and Goal 5 implementation I also wish to clarify that my comments are not a critique of SLOPES V or the use of event-based hydrologic modeling per se; these are tools that the City has adopted and incorporated into its stormwater standards. The issue, in my view, is that the way these tools have been applied in this particular case leaves several key questions unanswered in a sensitive Goal 5 setting: •The “pre-development” condition is represented by a single curve number and uniform soil/cover assumption for the entire wooded hillside, without site-specific measurements of how existing wetlands and streams currently store and release water over the wet season. •The analysis focuses on 2-year and 10-year storm events, yet the most ecologically important processes in small headwater wetlands and streams are often driven by frequent, lower-intensity storms and seasonal groundwater conditions not captured by event-based peak-flow modeling. •Four existing off-site lots discharge stormwater near the eastern boundary. These flows are still characterized as “pass-through,” yet they are being routed through the new system and are acknowledged to increase 2-year peak flows at one point in the system. In a Goal 5 wetland and stream corridor, any increase in the frequency or magnitude of bankfull-type flows warrants more careful evaluation of channel and habitat impacts than has been documented so far. These concerns are not intended to impose new or discretionary criteria; they instead underscore the need for the record to show that the existing code-based methods have been applied in a way that actually addresses Goal 5 resource protection, not just peak-flow control at a few design storms. 5. Clarification regarding planting, O&M, and long-term /WR protection Finally, I appreciate that the applicant has incorporated Operations and Maintenance language drawn from the City’s 2014 Stormwater Management Manual for rain gardens, swales, and structural detention facilities. However, this O&M text is general in nature and not specific to the particular /WR conservation area present on this site. It does not substitute for a project-specific planting and long-term management plan that demonstrates compliance with EC 9.4980’s requirements for vegetation, erosion control, and long-term protection. Given the extent of grading and construction proposed at the base of the slope and within or adjacent to Goal 5 wetlands and streams, I believe that the City would benefit from: •a detailed planting plan for the /WR conservation area showing species lists, densities, and expected coverage, with an emphasis on appropriate native species; •clear performance standards and timelines for achieving stable vegetated cover; and •measures to address edge effects, human disturbance, and invasive species risk associated with the extension of Randy Lane and multiple new lot access points. Such information would provide stronger support for required findings under EC 9.4980 and Goal 5, and would also give future homeowners and the City a clearer understanding of their responsibilities in maintaining these important water resources over time. 6. Summary request In light of these clarifications and the sensitivity of the mapped Goal 5 wetlands and streams on the site, I continue to believe that the current record does not adequately demonstrate compliance with EC 9.8365, EC 9.8470, and EC 9.4980. I respectfully renew my request that the City either: •deny PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 as submitted; or •at minimum, require additional, resource-specific analysis and plan revisions addressing the issues identified above before reconsidering the applications . Thank you again for your careful attention to these matters and for your work in applying the City’s land use code and Goal 5 protections to this site. Please include this letter in the record for PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02. Respectfully, Albert LePage 1944 Cleveland St Eugene, OR 97405 Relevant References . . . 1.Eugene Code EC 9.8365, Final Planned Unit Development Approval Criteria, Eugene Municipal Code (accessed Feb. 2026), [eugene.municipal] 2.City of Eugene, “STANDARDS REVIEW – Water Resources (/WR) Overlay Zone,” application instructions (PDF) (accessed Feb. 2026), [eugene-or] 3.Eugene Code EC 9.4980, /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay Zone, Eugene Municipal Code (accessed Feb. 2026), [eugene.municipal] 4.City of Eugene, “Water Resource Conservation Maps,” describing Goal 5 water resources and the EC 9.4900–9.4980 protection framework (accessed Feb. 2026), [eugene-or] 5.Court of Appeals of the State of Oregon, decision discussing application of EC 9.8365 and final PUD plan requirements (Dec. 2018), [ojd.contentdm.oclc] 6.City-of-Eugene Supplemental Materials, “Braewood Hills 3rd Addition Completeness Review Response PDF 25-1 and SDR 25-2” (Jan. 21, 2026) and associated easement documents and stormwater analysis, https://pdd.eugene-or.gov/LandUse/DocumentDetails?file=PDF-25- 0001&id=4849048 (accessed Feb. 2026). From:Sara Fagan (US) To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Application numbers PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02 Date:Tuesday, February 17, 2026 8:47:06 PM You don't often get email from sara.l.fagan@pwc.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Hi Nick, I am writing to you with some concerns about the application numbers referenced in the subject line of this email (PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02). Specifically, I wanted to raise concerns about the Private Joint Use Access and Utility Easement and Maintenance agreement ("the JAM") that was included in the application that was submitted on January 21, 2026. Based on my read of the applicable city code, the Final Planned Unit Development Proposal violates Section 9.8365 of the Eugene Code, specifically the section titled "Final Planned Unit Development Approval Criteria", which specifically requires the Final PUD plan to conform with the approved tentative PUD Plan and all conditions attached to the plan. I have multiple safety concerns with the newly submitted plan, which centers around the shared driveways ("Joint Access Easements") that will lead to Tambour Way and Tambour Court. The JAM says that there are multiple lots (between two and five) that will share a single driveway. My concerns are as follows: Depending on whether a single family home or a multi-unit housing development is placed on the lot, there could be anywhere from 4 to 10+ cars parked in a single driveway, with many cars using the same access way. Within the JAM, it designates certain homeowners within each driveway cluster to maintain the driveway in good condition, as well as maintaining any utilities shared by the benefitted owners in good condition. How will homeowners with absolutely no training be expected to manage those responsibilities? What does this responsibility mean for the ability of these lots to be sold? What if no one purchases these properties? Who will be responsible for the upkeep? The JAM and site maps indicate that the shared driveways will be either 14 feet wide or "variable width." What does variable width mean? That does not set a clear standard. In addition, 14 feet wide is not wide enough for two larger vehicles, such as two SUVs or two trucks, to pass one another. My overall concern for this proposal is that having shared driveways be maintained and monitored by busy homeowners (with no city oversight) is clearly a recipe for disaster. This entire development could easily fall into disrepair if these access areas aren't maintained. Thank you, Sara Fagan PwC Private - Director Mobile: (541) 760 1547 PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP The information transmitted, including any attachments, is only for the intended recipient and may contain confidential and/or privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited, and all liability arising therefrom is disclaimed. If you received this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer and destroy any copies. If the content of this email includes tax advice, the advice is limited to the matters specifically addressed herein and is not intended to address other potential tax consequences or the potential application of tax penalties. PwC refers to one or more US member firms of the PwC network. Each member firm is a separate legal entity. Please see www.pwc.com/structure for further details. From:Nelson Lopez To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02 Date:Tuesday, February 17, 2026 2:31:34 PM You don't often get email from nelsonsinthewhit@gmail.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] My name is Nelson Lopez and I own Nelson's in the Whit and have been living in the Videra Oak Meadows area for a little over a year and have truly enjoyed the natural Oregon scenery with the wildlife and the streams that was deemed a protected Goal 5 site originally. During the approval process, the city designated the entire area as a Goal 5 and now somehow it's not? That doesn't seem right. Wetland 2B obviously does not meet the minimum 25-foot setback requirement. Are we just forcing this along for the money, despite how it will negatively impact our natural resources that were already deemed protected land despite the Oregon wildlife? Truly, it's just surreal that we are even having to have this conversation. It's already been deemed protected by the city and somehow we're getting an override? What is Eugene turning into? It's supposed to be a city that loves, protects, and cherishes the natural environment. Not this GOP led agenda of saying "screw you" to the environment! We need to stand on our morals and not sell out for money once again. Thank you for your time. Nelson From:Tom Woodcock To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02 Date:Tuesday, February 17, 2026 5:27:49 AM You don't often get email from tomwoodco@gmail.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Dear Mr. Gioello, I am a Eugene resident submitting formal comments regarding PDF 25-01 (Final Planned Unit Development) and SDR 25-02 (Standards Review with (WR) Water Resources Overlay) for the proposed Videra Oak Meadow development. Based on review of the application materials and site plan, I believe the proposal fails to demonstrate compliance with multiple applicable Eugene Code provisions, including: EC 9.8365 – Final PUD conformity with Tentative PUD approval EC 9.4920(2)(b) – 25-foot setback for Category B wetlands EC 9.4920(3) – Combined conservation footprint for wetland and stream Natural resource identification requirements under the /WR Overlay EC 9.4930(3)(e)3 – Native soil backfill requirements EC 9.4980(4) – Construction practices within conservation areas For these reasons, and as detailed below, I respectfully request denial of both applications. I. Final PUD Non-Conformance (EC 9.8365) Under EC 9.8365, a Final PUD must conform to the approved Tentative PUD and all attached conditions. The Joint Access & Maintenance Agreement (JAM), introduced late in the review process, establishes extensive shared driveway infrastructure and assigns long-term maintenance obligations to individual lot owners. These elements materially affect site design, access, and long-term infrastructure viability. The JAM provides that: Between 2 and 5 lots will share a single driveway Driveways may be only 14 feet wide or of “variable width” Specific lots are designated as responsible for maintaining shared access and utilities A 14-foot driveway is insufficient for safe two-way passage of larger vehicles. The term “variable width” fails to establish a measurable or enforceable standard. Delegating infrastructure maintenance to private homeowners without city oversight creates long-term safety and durability risks inconsistent with sound PUD planning. Because these provisions introduce material changes affecting access and infrastructure responsibility, the Final PUD does not demonstrate conformity with EC 9.8365. II. WR Overlay and Goal 5 Non-Compliance The property contains a Category B wetland (AMA 5B / Wetland 2B) and Category C stream (E35A / Videra Creek), and the City previously determined the entire property is Goal 5. A. Wetland Setback – EC 9.4920(2)(b) Category B wetlands require a 25-foot setback from the jurisdictional boundary. The application materials indicate areas where the mapped wetland extends beyond the conservation setback depicted on the site plan. Compliance with the required 25-foot buffer has not been clearly demonstrated. Without an accurate and updated conservation setback, the standard is not met. B. Combined Conservation Area – EC 9.4920(3) Where wetland and stream occur together, the WR conservation area must reflect the combined footprint of required setbacks. The application does not properly calculate or map the total combined conservation area for the wetland and stream. Without a mapped and quantified /WR footprint, compliance cannot be verified. C. Natural Resource Identification Deficiencies Under the WR overlay and Goal 5 requirements, the application must adequately: Identify wetlands within 50 feet of property lines Identify trees by species and dimension Map critical root zones for trees within conservation areas The site plan shows numerous mature native oaks in proximity to proposed infrastructure, including the Randy Lane extension. The application does not adequately demonstrate how these trees and their root zones will be protected. Failure to properly identify and protect Goal 5 resources is grounds for denial. D. Construction Practices – EC 9.4930 & 9.4980 The applicant has not demonstrated compliance with: Native soil backfill requirements (EC 9.4930(3)(e)3) Specific, enforceable measures to prevent petroleum, chemicals, or construction materials from entering wetlands or the stream (EC 9.4980(4)) Protection of saturated soils from compaction within the conservation area General statements of acknowledgment are not equivalent/sufficient to demonstrated compliance with mandatory code requirements. III. Impacts to Videra Park A substantial portion of the southern boundary abuts Videra Park, which contains Videra Creek and associated wetlands. The application does not provide: A mapped combined conservation footprint extending across the shared boundary Tree identification and critical root zone mapping near the property line Hydrological analysis of how the Randy Lane extension and associated swales may alter water flow affecting park-side trees Given the sensitivity of native oaks to altered drainage patterns, these omissions are significant and should be resolved before approval. Conclusion – Request for Denial Approval requires clear and affirmative demonstration of compliance with Eugene Code. The applicant has not demonstrated compliance with: EC 9.8365 – Final PUD conformity EC 9.4920(2)(b) – 25-foot wetland setback EC 9.4920(3) – Combined conservation footprint /WR Overlay natural resource identification requirements EC 9.4930(3)(e)3 – Native soil backfill EC 9.4980(4) – Construction practice protections Additionally, the proposal: Introduces unsafe and insufficiently defined shared driveway standards Delegates critical infrastructure maintenance to private homeowners without oversight Fails to adequately demonstrate protection of Goal 5 natural resources Does not sufficiently address impacts to adjacent Videra Park For these reasons, I respectfully request that PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 be denied. Sincerely, Tom Woodcock 2692 Blacktail Drive Eugene, OR 97405 From:drclee@comcast.net To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Videra Oak Meadow development comments Date:Wednesday, February 18, 2026 4:08:04 PM You don't often get email from drclee@comcast.net. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Dear Mr. Gioello, As a resident of the Braewood Hills subdivision, I am well aware of the plans to develop Videra Oak Meadow. I have grave concerns about this, and I am requesting that the developer's plan be denied. The following issues showing non-compliance on the part of the developer are paramount: 1. The applicant hasn't included Wetland AMA 5B/Wetland 2B in the conservation zone so hasn't fulfilled the requirement to preserve critical tree root zones, nor has he provided information about how these ones will be impacted by the project. 2. There is a requirement that excavated areas must be refilled with existing native soil. The developer isn't in compliance with this requirement, as he hasn't addressed it. Additionally, there are significant concerns about the effects of construction on the surrounding area: 3. Chemical products must be prevented from entering streams or wetlands while construction is taking place. However, the developer has given no specifics about how he will comply with this requirement. It is critical that he state how he will ensure that these harmful substances and materials are prevented from infiltrating the wetland or stream. 4. Eugene City Parks' Videra Park shares a property boundary with the proposed development. This park has a creek and an area of wetlands that cover parts of both the park and the development area. The developer must be required to specify how Videra Park and its natural resources will be protected from the effects of machinery, chemicals, or other harmful products that may be used during development of the property. The city's parks are a precious part of Eugene, and ensuring the full protection of the entirety of Videra Park and its natural resources is critical. Additionally, all trees within 30 feet of the property line should be identified and mapped to show their critical root zones, and the developer must be prevented from any construction activity that would have a deleterious impact on this zone. Please consider each of these issues carefully and thoroughly. The destruction of Videra Oak Meadow in pursuit of development will have far-reaching ecological impacts. Thank you, Carolyn Lee, Ph.D. 3222 Jayhawk Ct. Eugene, OR 97405 From:Max Wilbert To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Comment on application #s PDF 25-1 and SDR 25-2 Date:Wednesday, February 18, 2026 3:04:58 PM You don't often get email from max@maxwilbert.org. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Hello Mr. Gioello, I am writing to urge you to completely deny the application to develop Videra Oak Meadow. There is less than 2% of the Willamette Valley’s oak woodlands remaining. This ecosystem is critically endangered. Eugene needs to be doing everything it can to protect those few remaining fragments of oak woodland. Please take every opportunity to deny or restrict this development to protect as much land as possible. Thank you, ----------------- Max Wilbert Author of the Biocentric newsletter | Sent with Proton Mail. From:Gabriel Yospin To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02 Date:Thursday, February 19, 2026 9:52:54 AM You don't often get email from drgabrielyospin@gmail.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Dear Nick Gioello, I am writing to you today to request that you deny application PDF 25-001, Braewood Hills 3rd Addition. The Final Planned Unit Development Proposal violates Section 9.8365 of the Eugene Code, titled “Final Planned Unit Development Approval Criteria” which requires the “Final PUD plan conforms with the approved tentative PUD plan and all the conditions attached thereto.” The Joint Use Access and Utility Easement and Maintenance Agreement (JAM) shared with concerned parties on February 7th, 2026, describes shared driveways that are either 14 feet wide or of "variable width." This is vague and fails to set a clear standard. The possibility of driveways that are too narrow for emergency vehicle access is a risk to public safety and against the public interest. This will be of special concern during a wildland fire. The proposed plan does not include adequate setbacks for the documented wetlands. The plan does not include the 25 foot buffer required under Section 9.4920(2)(b) of the Eugene Code. Because of the category C stream, the plan also violates Section 9.4920(3) of the Eugene Code by failing to include the required 40-foot setback. The City has determined that this is a Goal 5 property and thus needs to be inventoried for natural resources, including but not limited to: all wetlands within 50 feet of property lines; all trees inventoried by size and species; and the preservation of critical root zones for trees. The plan violates Eugene Code 9.4930(3)(e)(3), which requires that all excavated areas be backfilled with existing native soil. For these reasons, I request that you deny these applications. Sincerely, Gabriel Yospin, PhD 2127 Lincoln St Eugene, OR 97405 From:Mark Biggin To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:re PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Date:Thursday, February 19, 2026 9:19:37 AM You don't often get email from markbiggin@sbcglobal.net. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Dear Nick Gioello, I request that the applications for the Braewood Hills 3rd addition Final PUD (PDF 25-01) and Standards Review (SDR 25-02) be denied for the following reasons. Re SDR 25-02 1. Eugene City code EC 9.4920 (2) (b) requires a predetermined setback on Goal 5 wetlands. The wetland on the property (AMA 5B) is a Category B wetland and thus requires a 25-foot buffer. The established boundary of the wetland can be from the jurisdictional wetland boundary accepted by the Oregon Department of State Lands, if provided by the property owner. Indeed, the application includes such a map accepted by Oregon Department of State Lands. The map labels the wetland as Wetland 2B and shows clearly that the wetland is wider than the conservation setback on the developer’s site map and thus the setback does not meet the 25-foot setback requirement. Obviously the developer’s setback must be widened. 2. Eugene City code EC 94920 (3) code indicates that if a wetland and stream exist together, the /WR conservation area is the total footprint of the /WR conservation areas combined. a. The proper /WR conservation area has not been determined, as the /WR conservation area for the wetlands was not calculated or mapped at all. Nor was the total footprint combined. The City should insist that a 25-foot setback for the wetland be combined with the 40-foot setback for the Category C stream. In some places, this revised setback will be more than that in the current the site plan. b. All wetlands within 50 feet of property lines need to be identified and noted since all wetlands are a natural resource and the City has designated the whole site as a Goal 5 resource. c. The site plan should also properly identify all trees by species and dimension on the site plan as they, too, are a natural resource. d. Critical root zones for trees to be preserved within the /WR conservation area must be shown and information provided on how they will not be negatively impacted. As the applicant has not provided the proper conservation zone to include wetland AMA 5B/Wetland 2B, they cannot have properly fulfilled this requirement. 3. Eugene City code EC 9.4930 (3) (e) 3: Requires that excavated areas be backfilled with existing native soil: This was not addressed by the developer at all, so therefore it is not in compliance. 4. Eugene City code EC 9.4980 (4) (b) covers prevention of chemicals, petroleum, products, etc. from entering stream or wetland during construction. However, the applicant gave no indication of how they will comply with this code’s requirements. The developer must state what measures they will take to ensure that petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process will be prevented from entering the stream or wetland. Further, the proposed development shares a property line with Eugene City Parks’ Videra Park, which is home to Videra Creek as well as wetlands that straddle both the property and park. The developer should be required to state how Videra Park and its natural resources will be protected from any incursion by machinery, products or chemicals. Re PDF 25-01 Section 9.8365 of the Eugene City Code requires that “the final PUD plan conforms with the approved tentative PUD plan and all conditions attached thereto”. However, the Developers only included in their most recent submission on January 21, 2026 information on Joint Access Easements for shared driveways (defined as JAM), including their maintenance, and the responsibilities of homeowners. Since this new important information was not included in the tentative PUD plan, the final PUD plan violates City Code Section 9.8365. There are several specific deficiencies with the proposed JAM. 1. Both the JAM and the site maps indicate the shared driveways will be either 14 feet wide or of “variable width.” Variable width is a fuzzy description that fails to set out a clear standard. 14 feet wide is insufficient for two SUV’s or trucks to pass each other – only compact or medium size cars would be able to travel in opposite directions at the same time. This will reduce the likelihood that the affected lots will sell. 2. In cases where a single-family home is placed on the lot, that could mean between four and ten or more vehicles sharing a driveway. In the case of multi-unit housing on any lot, it will mean many more vehicles using the same access way. I hope that the planning department will appreciate that the current proposal, like two other failed developments in the South Eugene Hills that the department approved, is deeply flawed and likely to lead to yet another set of “roads to nowhere” as well as needlessly destroyed wetlands and natural resources with at best a scattering of built and part built houses. Sincerely Mark Biggin Mark Biggin 2478 Randy Lane Eugene, OR 97405 USA phone 510 610 9493 From:Katie Buss To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02 Date:Thursday, February 19, 2026 4:15:22 PM You don't often get email from buss.katie@gmail.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Dear Mr. Gioello, I am asking that applications PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 be denied because theapplicant has not demonstrated compliance with the Eugene Code’s protections forGoal 5 natural resources. This is not about opposing housing. It is about whether the rules we adopted to protect wetlands, streams, and native oaks are being followed. Under EC 9.4920(2)(b), a Category B wetland requires a 25-foot setback. The Department of State Lands–accepted wetland map (Wetland 2B / AMA 5B) clearly shows portions of the wetland extending beyond the conservation setback shown onthe site plan. If the wetland boundary is wider than the setback drawn, then the 25-foot buffer is not being met. Under EC 9.4920(3), when a wetland and streamcoexist, the conservation area must reflect the total combined footprint. Theapplication does not calculate or map the wetland conservation area at all, nor does itcombine it with the required 40-foot stream setback for E35A. Without that combinedfootprint, compliance cannot be verified. The City previously determined the entire property is Goal 5. If that determination has meaning, then: All wetlands within 50 feet of property lines must be identified. All trees must be identified by species and dimension. Critical root zones must be mapped and protected. The application does not demonstrate that this has been done. The development shares two-thirds of its southern boundary with Videra Park.Construction adjacent to wetlands and saturated soils is not a theoretical risk —compaction, altered drainage, and petroleum contamination can permanentlydegrade both the site and the adjacent public park. Under EC 9.4980(4)(b), theapplicant merely states that chemical prevention requirements are “acknowledgedand agreed.” That is not a compliance plan. As a parent who walks this park and relies on the integrity of these natural systems, I am asking you to hold the applicant to the code as written. If the conservation areas have not been properly calculated, mapped, and protected, the applications should be denied. Respectfully, Katie Buss3093 Herald Lane, Eugene OR 97405425-480-8458buss.katie@gmail.com From:Joseph Sventek To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02 Date:Thursday, February 19, 2026 12:13:02 PM Attachments:SDR25-02.comment.pdf You don't often get email from jsventek@gmail.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Attached please find comments on SDR 25-02. Joseph Sventek 3072 Wintercreek Drive Eugene, OR 97405 To: Nick Gioello, Associate Planner, NGioello@eugene-or.gov From: Joseph Sventek, Professor Emeritus, UO Computer Science Department, jsventek@gmail.com Date: 19 February 2026 Subject: Comments on SDR 25-02 Thank you for this opportunity to comment on SDR 25-02. The executive summary is that this application does not fulfill/address a number of Goal 5 city codes, and, as such, the application should be denied. EC 9.4920(2)(b) The wetland on the property is a Category B wetland requiring a 25-foot buƯer. The map provided with the application clearly shows places where the wetland is wider than the conservation setback on the map; the application, therefore, does not meet the 25-foot setback requirement. EC 9.4920(3) During the approval process for the Tentative Planned Unit Development, the City determined that the entire property was Goal 5. This code states that if a wetland and stream exist together, the /WR conservation area is the total footprint of the /WR conservation areas combined. This leads to several violations of this code. 1. The proper /WR conservation area has not been determined, as the /WR conservation area for the wetlands was not calculated or mapped at all. The total combined footprint was also not calculated or mapped. 2. The application must properly include the 25-foot setback for the wetlands combined with the 40-foot setback for the Category C stream. 3. The resulting setback will exceed that of the site plan in several places. Furthermore, the site plan must:  identify and note all wetlands within 50 feet of property lines,  identify/indicate all trees by species and dimension on the site plan, and  show and provide information regarding critical root zones for trees to be preserved within the /WR conservation area. EC 9.4930(3)(e) The application does not discuss how the required backfill of excavated areas with existing native soil will be addressed. EC 9.4980(4)(a) 1 & 2 Soil in the development area is always saturated and, as a result, susceptible to severe compaction. The application indicates that machinery, tools, supplies, and other construction materials won’t be stockpiled or stored. Due to the susceptibility to compaction, all machinery must be removed from the /WR conservation area each day. EC 9.4980(4)(b) The application does not state exactly what measures will be taken to ensure that construction materials described in this code will be prevented from entering the stream or wetland. Due to the adjacency of the development to Eugene City Parks’ Videra Park, the application should be required to state how Videra Park and its natural resources will be protected from any incursion by machinery, products, or chemicals. Other Videra Park concerns Nearly 2/3 of the southern property line for the development is shared with Videra Park. Actions taken during development near or on the property line can have an adverse eƯect on the natural environment and resources of Videra Park.  Either the developer or the City must provide a full survey and mapping of the combined Wetland and Creek Conservation area for the portion of AMA 5B and E35A in Videra Park to ensure conservation codes are met.  All trees in Videra Park within 30 feet of the property line need to be identified and mapped, along with their critical root zones, to ensure that native oak trees are not negatively impacted by any proposed construction.  The extension of Randy Lane, as well as the swales to the north of it, must be prevented from denying critical water for the trees on the other side of the property line in Videra Park. Summary This application does not appear to take Goal 5 requirements with respect to wetlands and old-growth trees seriously. As a result, the application does not fulfill/address the Goal 5 city codes enumerated above, and, as such, the application should be denied. From:julieb17@comcast.net To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Comments on SDR 25-02 and PDF 25-01 Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 4:17:50 PM Attachments:Comments SDR 25-2 and PDF 25-1.pdf [EXTERNAL ] Hi Nick, I’ve attached my comments. Please let me know you have received this. Thank you, Julie Butler To Whom it may concern, I am writing to express my opposition to SDR 25-02 with /WR Resources Overlay and PDF 25-01. There are several areas that are problematic with codes and requirements that have not been met by the applicant. EC 9.4920 (2) (b), which addresses the required setbacks for a Goal 5 wetland has not been met. The wetland in question is AMA 5B, a Category B wetland which has also been determined to be an official Waters of the United States. The code states that one method of determining established boundaries is from the jurisdictional wetland boundary accepted by the Oregon Department of State Lands, if provided by the property owner. A map fulfllling that method along with an accompanying letter from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which identifles that wetland as Wetland 2B, is part of the application for SDR 25-02 and clearly determines that the wetland at the northern end of the Category C stream extends beyond the Goal 5 stream’s established 40-foot setback, both to the east and west. The true conservation setback would add an additional 25-foot setback from the jurisdictional boundary of the wetland, into Lots 33, 32, and 27. Additionally, there are areas in Lot 35 where the wetland appears to be lacking the full 25-foot setback required. The applicant will argue that additional setbacks will render some lots unbuildable. It was the applicant’s choice to create the lot lines where they are, and they can be moved or lots changed to accommodate the proper setbacks. EC 9.4920 (3) Clearly states that if a Goal 5 stream and wetland exist together, “…the /WR conservation area for each of the individual water features shall be calculated and mapped separately, and the total footprint of all the individual /WR conservation areas combined shall be the /WR conservation area for that site.” (emphasis mine) This code has clearly not been met. While the conservation area for E35A, the Category C stream, was established and mapped, no conservation area has been established for the Category B Wetland, or as per the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers determination letter of 25 July 2025 labels it, Wetland 2B, a jurisdictional Water of the U.S. Not only was the 25-foot setback for the wetland was not established, nor was the total footprint of both the wetland and stream setbacks combined, and therefore, the proper /WR conservation of that site was not calculated or mapped. EC 9.4920 (2) (b) and (3) have not been met. Given the City’s insistence that the entire property is Goal 5, there needs to be an emphasis on proper conservation area establishment and protection. With this Goal 5 label, the City has declared the entire property is part of the City-adopted natural resource inventory. Per the application for Standards Review: Water Resources (/WR) Overlay Zone the applicant has failed to complete the application process in these areas: • All wetlands within 50 feet of property lines need to be identifled and noted. While the wetlands are mapped on the site plan, there are no indicators identifying or noting those within 50 feet of property lines. • The site plan does not properly identify/indicate all trees by species and dimension. As these, too, are a natural resource and speciflcally one of the categories under which the City’s determination of this property’s Goal 5 designation falls, there needs to be a complete and comprehensive inventory of all trees on the property. As there are native Willamette White Oaks on the property aged between 150-300 years old, they should be identifled and protected. EC 9.4930 (3) (e) 3 has not been met as it wasn’t addressed by the applicant at all. Considering the critical nature of native soil in a natural resource protected area, the developer must absolutely ensure that any excavated and disturbed areas are backfllled with the existing native soil. EC 9.4980 (4) (a) 1 & 2: The applicant uses the terms stockpiled and stored only. As the soil in the setback area is always saturated by the nature of it being a wetland area and not just a stream, speciflcity that any machinery, tools or construction materials be removed from the /WR conservation area each day is mandated. EC 9.4980 (4) (b) has not been met. “Acknowledged and agreed,” means nothing without a description of how compliance will be achieved. The applicant must describe exactly what measures will be taken to ensure petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process will be prevented from entering the stream or wetland. It is extremely important to note that the adjoining property, which shares a substantial length of property line, is Videra Park, a natural park owned and maintained by City of Eugene Parks and Open Space. The park contains the continuation of the Category C stream, as well as associated Goal-5 wetlands. These have not been mapped nor given an established conservation zone as a part of the application process, yet will be impacted in a major way by the proposed construction. It is incumbent on the applicant to provide and describe in detail a means of protecting the Goal 5 natural resources in Videra Park from any incursion by chemicals, petroleum products, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process as required in EC 9.4980 (4) (b). On the south side of the proposed Randy Lane extension, at the location of the SDR request site as well as other areas, Videra Park contains saturated soggy wetland soil, which should also be protected under EC 9.4980 (4) (a) to ensure their continued health, especially as their waters fiow directly into Videra Creek. SDR 25-02 addresses the protection requirements for constructing the extension of Randy Lane crossing the conservation setback for the Category C stream on the property. However, a quick look at Eugene’s own mapping of the Category B Wetland and a visual examination at Videra Park show there is a strong possibility that the wetland’s required 25- foot setback on the Videra Park side could also overlap the Randy Lane extension beyond what has been applied. As a condition of approval, the Category C stream’s continuation on Videra Park and associated Category B wetland need to be officially surveyed, and their conservation setbacks plotted, to ensure no encroachment of the setback will occur. EC 9.0500: Videra Park is home to rapidly dwindling native Willamette Oaks of the variety which used to dominate the Willamette Valley and of which only an estimated 2-3% remain. Given the renewed attention to this important ecological feature, its rapid decline, and the ever-growing emphasis on preservation, the Critical Root Zones as of these trees along the shared property line of the subject property and Videra Park must be identifled and mapped. In this photograph, the property line markers are clearly within the critical root zone of this ring of native oak trees, with one being less than a foot away from the trunk of the tree. As this is where the Randy Lane extension will be constructed, it is obvious that Timber Trespass will be a factor. Randy Lane needs to be reconflgured to take into account the natural resources on this publicly owned natural park. While the trees can’t be moved to protect them and their Critical Root Zones, the road can! Walking through Videra Park, one can easily envision the impact the extension of Randy Lane will have on the health of the park’s trees. On what would be the south side of Randy Lane, directly across Lot 34, begins a stand of healthy native oak and flr trees that run the length of the park east. The trees on the south side of Randy will suffer due to the rerouting of their life-giving water. Currently, water fiows down the slope of the property toward Videra Creek with tree roots slowing and drinking the water along the way. The construction of Randy Lane and the swales on the north side, will completely divert this water and endanger the trees which rely on it. One can see a real-time example of this impact in Phase 4 of Timberline Hills, currently under construction. The construction of the Timberline Road extension cut off the downhill water fiow for a large stand of trees identifled for protection in the PUD process. As a result, within 2 years of road completion, almost all of the “protected” trees have died. We cannot look at the natural resources of the property and Videra Park as compartmental or isolated; they live, fiow and work together. A Goal 5 determination means the natural resource was deemed important enough to protect. Until all aspects of codes and measures designed to protect these resources have been fully implemented and met, the applications for SDR 25-02 and PDF 25-01 need to be denied. Sincerely, Julie Butler 3234 Jayhawk Ct. From:Patrick Clark To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02 Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 10:06:52 AM You don't often get email from patrick.james.clark@gmail.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Dear Mr. Gioello, I am requesting denial of PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 because the applicant has notdemonstrated conformity with EC 9.8365 and has left substantial compliance gaps inenvironmental protections. First, regarding the Final Planned Unit Development: EC 9.8365 requires that the Final PUD conform to the approved Tentative PUD and all attached conditions. The Joint Access & Maintenance Agreement (JAM), introduced atthe final stage, materially affects how the development will function. Most of the 37 lots rely on shared driveways serving two to five properties. Thatcould mean: 4–10+ vehicles per driveway for single-family homes, Significantly more if multi-unit housing is built. Driveways are described as 14 feet wide or of “variable width.” Fourteen feet is insufficient for two standard SUVs or trucks to pass safely. “Variable width” is not a defined engineering standard. The JAM assigns driveway and utility maintenance responsibilities to specific futurelot owners (Lots 5, 7, 10, 21, 31, 32, 33). These are substantial infrastructureobligations typically managed by public entities or structured associations, notindividual homeowners. Questions that remain unanswered: How will emergency vehicles access lots during peak congestion? How will snow removal be coordinated? What happens if the designated responsible lot does not sell? What enforcement mechanism exists if maintenance lapses? If these operational realities differ from the expectations under the Tentative PUD,the Final PUD may not conform under EC 9.8365. Second, under EC 9.4920(3), the applicant has not properly mapped the combinedconservation footprint of the Category B wetland and Category C stream. Without the combined footprint, compliance cannot be confirmed. A development of this density adjacent to protected natural resources requires clarity and precision. The application does not provide it. For these reasons, I respectfully request denial. Patrick Clark From:Whitney Gould To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Comment on Final Application for Braewood Hills 3rd Addition, Final PUD (PDT 25-01) and Standards Review (SDR 25-02)Th Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 4:39:10 PM You don't often get email from whitneygould@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] To: Mr. Nick Gioello From: Whitney Gould, whitneygould@yahoo.com, (510) 368-8941 Subject: Comment on Final Application for Braewood Hills 3rd Addition Requesting Application for FINAL Planned Unit Development (PDF 25-01) and Standards Review (SDR 25-02) be DENIED. Introduction: The Applicant’s Final Planned Unit Development Proposal for Braewood Hills 3rd Addition clearly shows the project will have disastrous environmental effects on the 15-acre parcel and create considerable safety and liability risks for future residents of the property and residents of the surrounding neighborhood. The Private Joint Use Access and Utility Easement and Maintenance Agreement (JAM,) which was added to the application on January 21, 2026, and shared with concerned parties on February 7, 2026, delineates some of the conditions that will contribute to these issues. Code Violation Because the JAM presents, for the first time, details of the shared driveways, or “Joint Access Easements,” their maintenance, maintenance costs, and the responsibilities of selected homeowners, the Final Planned Unit Development Proposal violates Section 9.8365 of the Eugene Code which states the “Final PUD plan conforms with the approved tentative PUD plan and all the conditions attached.” Because of the new information, the document does not conform. EWEB Documentation Not Provided In violation of Eugene Planning Commission, Condition of Approval 11, EWEB documentation of the JAM agreement has NOT been provided. The application materials are insufficient to demonstrate compliance. Issues Raised: In an effort to cram as many homes as possible on the property, the developer’s plan shows that a majority of the 37 buildable lots will have shared driveways, (aka “Joint Access Easements”) with each driveway leading to one of two private streets in the development. According to the JAM, homes on lots 1, 2, 6 and 7 will share a driveway; homes on parcels 4,5,9 and 10 will share a driveway; homes on 9, 10, 13 and 14 will share a driveway; (lots 9 and 10 have access to two driveways) homes on 18, 20 and 21 will share a driveway, and homes on lots 25, 27, 28, 29 and 32 will share a driveway. Lots 30 and 31 will share a driveway; and lots 33, 36 and 37 will share a driveway. In a case where a single-family home is constructed on each lot, that could mean between four and ten (or more) vehicles sharing a driveway. In the case of multi-unit housing, it will mean several times that estimate. Further, the JAM states that in each shared situation, one homeowner will both “maintain the Driveway in good condition,” and “maintain any Utilities shared by all of the Benefitted Owners in good condition.” The future owners of lots 5, 7, 10, 21, 31, 32 and 33 are designated as the responsible parties for these considerable tasks, with the burden of continued upkeep passing along to subsequent future owners of those lots. This “assignment” of responsibilities for a shared right-of-way creates a host of issues: It anticipates giving those duties to individuals without experience or qualifications in driveway or utility maintenance. It relies on the naïve assumption that homeowners, who typically seek good relations with their neighbors, will monitor for driveway and utility issues and challenge the ‘responsible’ homeowner to deal with the repair process. It does not consider a situation where the lot designated as the one responsible for maintenance is slow to sell or is still unsold before others in the driveway cluster. Compounding the issue, the added responsibility of driveway maintenance could make these lots less attractive to buyers. Another issue of grave concern, along with lack of detail, is the width of these shared driveways. In two instances, the width of the Joint Access Easement delineated in the JAM does not match the width shown on the site plan. According to the JAM, the Joint Access Easement serving lots 1, 2, 6 and 7 will be of “variable width.” However, the site map shows the driveway as 14 feet wide. The JAM states the Joint Access Easement serving lots 4, 5, 9 and 10 as of “variable width.” The site map uses the same language. The JAM shows the Joint Access Easement serving lots 9, 10, 13 and 14 is 14’ wide. The site map shows the driveway as 14’ wide. The JAM shows the Joint Access Easement serving lots 18, 20 and 21 as 14’ wide. The site map shows this driveway as 14’ wide. The JAM shows the Joint Access Easement serving lots 25, 27, 28, 29 and 32 as “variable width.” The site map also states it is of “variable width.” The JAM shows the Joint Access Easement serving lots 30 and 31 as 14’ wide. The site map shows the shared driveway as 14’ wide. The JAM shows the Joint Access Easement serving lots 33, 36 and 37 as of “variable width.” The site map shows it as 14’ wide. Whether the driveways in this crowded development in a high fire risk area are to be 14’ feet in width or of “variable width,” both situations are concerning. The 14’ width would make it a challenge for a moving van to navigate this passageway. It is insufficient all but two compact or mid-size cars to pass each other on the driveway. Further, the term “variable width,” fails to provide details of the driveway’s actual dimensions and leaves much uncertainty about the final width of the easement. Additionally, the shared driveway situation will make it more difficult for homeowners to put out their trash for pickup. It is assumed that all homeowners will be required to haul their trash and recycling bins to one of the two private streets for pick-up since it would be difficult, if not impossible, for a waste collection vehicle – typically 8 to 10 feet in width – to navigate and turn around in a joint access easement. This extra burden on homeowners of hauling their trash bins several hundred feet could also make the lots less attractive to buyers. Remedy: It is of grave concern that if this development gets final approval, the developer will begin the destructive and irreversible process of removing the wetlands and installing infrastructure on this pristine property. As has occurred in other locations in Eugene and around the state, a project like this can then stall for years, leaving the property in a damaged and blighted state with only partial work completed. Right now, this site is a gem. It needs to stay that way! Thank you, Sincerely, Whitney Gould From:Keri Green To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Testimony PDF 25-01/SDR 25-02 Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 3:10:27 PM Attachments:Comments PDF 25-01 SDR 25-02 Feb 20.2026.pdf You don't often get email from kgreen@mind.net. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Dear Mr. Gioello: Please see the attached document. Sincerely, Keri Green Comments of Keri Green PDF-25-01/SDR 25-02 ____________________________________________________________________________________ 1 February 20, 2026 2225 McLean Blvd. Eugene, Oregon 97405 Mr. Nick Gioello, Associate Planner City of Eugene Re: Braewood Hills 3rd Addition File Numbers: PDF 25-01 / SDR 25-02 Dear Mr. Gioello, The applicant’s proposal remains incomplete and out of compliance with Eugene’s code requirements. I request this application be denied for the reasons below. EC 9.4920 (2)(b) /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay Zone This code is applicable because the property contains a Goal 5 water resource site identified for conservation. For Wetland 2B, the applicant has not met the required setback of 25 feet. This code must be considered in tandem with EC 9.4920 (3) which requires that a total calculation be done when wetlands exist along with a riparian site. The code states: “…the /WR conservation area for each of the individual water features shall be calculated and mapped separately, and the total footprint of all the individual /WR conservation areas combined shall be the /WR conservation area for that site.” The required setback for the Category C stream is 40 feet. Therefore, the setback for Wetland 2B should be at least 65 feet. The City of Eugene has previously acknowledged that the subject property is Goal 5. As such, it behooves the planning department to apply the land use standards required by the Goal 5 natural resources conservation regulations of the State of Oregon (Oregon’s Statewide Planning Goals and Guidelines OAR 660-015-0000(5). For reference, here is an excerpt from the Hearings Official Decision Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1; ST 24-3) September 5, 2024, Page 8: …the subject property is included on the City’s acknowledged Goal 5, based on its inclusion in the April 12, 1978, Scenic Sites Working Paper, which is adopted as an inventory of significant Goal 5 resource within the City of Eugene by Ordinance No. 20351. As the staff report explains, the Scenic Sites Working Paper designates the subject site as one of the Natural Sites of Visual Prominence and Prominent and Plentiful Vegetation. The City entered into the Record an undated and unlabeled map that the City states is the “Figure H2” that is identified as “Metro Plan Update, Natural Assets and Constraints-Working Papers Scenic Areas.” According to staff’s calculations, this “Figure H-2” generally identifies the entire subject property (as well as a large swath of the City’s South, Southwest and East Hills) as being within the acknowledged Goal 5 inventory. Within that general area, a protected upland stream corridor on the subject property is listed on the City’s adopted Goal 5 Water Resources Inventory (2005), as reflected by the /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay zone for this property. EC 9.6885 Tree Preservation and Removal Standards My comments in this section refer to Tree Preservation within Videra Park Comments of Keri Green PDF-25-01/SDR 25-02 ____________________________________________________________________________________ 2 Throughout previous Braewood Hills planning actions, going back to 1996, the city required that every tree on the existing landscape, pre-development, be inventoried. The applicant retained the services of arborists to assess the health of existing trees, pre- and post-development. By 2006, arborists were advising new residents to remove dead and dying trees that had been impacted by the buildout of the neighborhood. Reference June 27 letter from Kyle W. King, Certified Arborist, to a Blacktail Street resident: “At your request, I inspected the Douglas fir tree on the right side of your house. It appears to be in serious decline. The needles are quite sparse and there is little indication of new growth. The several fir trees around it are in similar condition. Many of the firs on the downhill side of Blacktail Street near your lot have died and most of them exhibit serious stress. The street and home construction has probably changed the natural water course and has affected the trees’ health. Logging operations that allowed lots to be created in the first place have exposed these trees to much more heat by removing much of the forest originally surrounding them – this also caused further stress. Whatever the causes, in my opinion, your tree will most likely die, along with its neighbors, withing the year and probably sooner. I think your tree should be removed now…” To ensure preservation of the centuries old heritage oaks and Douglas fir trees that line the south side of Videra Creek in city-owned Videra Park, the city should require the applicant to conduct a full survey and mapping of the wetland and Videra Creek within the Park to ensure that conservation zone codes are met. It is possible that the applicant’s proposed extension of Randy Lane will create deleterious impacts to the root zones of the existing trees. Given that the city, by its own admission, neglected to apply tree preservation standards to this PUD application, the buildout creates a risk to the trees of Videra Park. Reference: Hearings Official Decision Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1; ST 24-3) September 5, 2024, Page 8: The written staff report also explained that, subject to some potential exceptions, because the property is included in the City’s acknowledged Goal 5 inventory, the Tree Preservation and Removal Standards at EC 9.6885 would apply directly at the time of future development depending on the timing and scope of tree removal, lot size, and other factors that may require a separate tree removal permit under the requirements of EC Chapter 6. However, at the public hearing on the application, the staff explained that the staff report was in error and that because of changes to the City’s clear and objective standards, the acknowledged Goal 5 resources that have no specific environmental protections in place are no longer subject to any protections. As staff stated during the public hearing: “Unfortunately, the entire site is identified as a Goal 5 resource due to its inclusion on the Scenic Sites Working Paper, which was adopted as a Goal 5 resource. Unlike the protections create for wetlands and other riparian resources, there were no specific environmental protections put in place for areas identified on the scenic working papers. As an outcome, we are left with a development project that can be approved without any specific tree preservation, exception for the protected stream and runs across the property. Given these facts, we believe we lack the authority to require tree preservation on the majority of the property through this PUD process and at the time of building permit.” Comments of Keri Green PDF-25-01/SDR 25-02 ____________________________________________________________________________________ 3 The existing trees on the south side of Videra Creek within Videra Park provide wildlife shelter and habitat, create shade and cooling for the stream, create quiet places for peoples’ mental health, and provide natural beauty. The city should be concerned that approval of the extension of Randy Lane risks destruction of this Park asset. The extension of Randy Lane and the associated buildout of homes on the south side of Videra Creek are likely to kill many of the existing trees through a combination of alteration of needed water sources for tree health, soil compaction, introduction of up to 50% impervious surfaces on each lot, and the impervious surface created by the road extension. PDT 01-11, Decision of the Hearings Official – January 17, 2002 Page 3 of 26 requires the following: 12. Detailed tree protection measures shall be specified and the detail tree protection notes approved, prior to final PUD approval. The final plan, in number 13 of PDT 01-11, also required a conservation zone be established. I urge the city to consider the impact of the proposed Randy Lane extension on the health of the existing trees in adjacent city-owned Videra Park. Full survey and mapping should be done to assess the impacts of construction. The health of the trees should be ensured as city assets. Finally, a word about wetlands. The wetlands on this property have become hostage to the Supreme Court’s decision in Sackett v. EPA (2023). Cutting up and destroying parts of the wetlands likely means the destruction of the entire wetland ecosystem. There are some sections of this property that may hold more environmental value than other sections. The southern section in which the Randy Lane extension is proposed, is a very special area, special enough that the city purchased a swath of it for inclusion into its park inventory. I urge the city to deny the Randy Lane extension and to instead consider the value of this section of the property to uses other than housing. It is a very special place that deserves consideration for the unique wild place it provides, simply on its own merits. I have included below a photograph of Wetland 3. It is located at what would be the eastern terminus of the proposed road extension. Consider that without protections, this wetland ecosystem will likely not survive the proposed road and home construction. Sincerely, Keri Green From:Martha Hugo To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02 Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 3:43:56 PM You don't often get email from cathugo13@gmail.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Dear Mr Giollo, I request that this application be denied based on the developer’s failure to observe many things that may not be in compliance and only partly addressed, I worry in particular about EC 9.4980 (4) (b). To just say “acknowledged and agreed” regarding compliance regarding chemicals, etc from entering the streams and wetlands is not very reassuring. The south end of the property borders the park, so how can we be assured that the park and creek would not be affected? I often see children at play in the park and people walking on the outskirts of the property. Thank you. Sincerely, Martha Ciattei From:Caitlyn Kari To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02 Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 8:51:12 AM You don't often get email from caitlyn.kari@gmail.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Mr. Gioello - I am writing to request denial of PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02. The applicant has not demonstrated compliance with key provisions of the Eugene Code designed to protect public natural resources. Under EC 9.4920(2)(b), a Category B wetland requires a 25-foot setback. The Department of State Lands–accepted wetland map shows Wetland 2B extending beyond the conservation setback depicted in the current site plan. If the wetland boundary is wider than the setback drawn, then the 25-foot buffer is not being met. Under EC 9.4920(3), when a wetland and stream coexist, the conservation area must reflect the total combined footprint. The application does not map or calculate the wetland conservation area, nor combine it with the 40-foot stream setback. Without that, compliance cannot be evaluated. The City determined that the entire property is Goal 5. That determination carries consequences; Specifically: all wetlands within 50 feet of property lines must be identified, all trees must be identified by species and dimension, and critical root zones must be mapped and protected. The application does not demonstrate that this has been done. Additionally, under EC 9.4980(4)(b), the applicant must demonstrate specific measures to prevent petroleum and chemicals from entering the stream or wetland during construction. Simply stating “acknowledged and agreed” does not demonstrate compliance. The proposed development shares a substantial boundary with Videra Park. Impacts do not stop at property lines. If setbacks are miscalculated or drainage is altered, public park resources may be affected without having been surveyed or mapped. The Code exists to protect shared community assets. If the conservation footprint has not been properly calculated and mapped, and if construction mitigation measures are not clearly specified, the applications do not meet the standard for approval. Furthermore, EC 9.8365 requires that the Final PUD conform to the approved Tentative PUD and all attached conditions. Based on the Joint Access & Maintenance Agreement (JAM), Most of the 37 lots rely on shared driveways serving two to five properties, resulting in 4–10+ vehicles per driveway for single-family homes and significantly more if multi-unit housing is built. This is a recipe for congestion and barrier to access for emergency vehicles, especially since driveways are described as 14 feet wide (insufficient for two standard SUVs or trucks to pass safely) or of “variable width”, which is not a defined engineering standard and could be so narrow as to preclude safe and smooth flow of traffic. The JAM assigns driveway and utility maintenance responsibilities to specific future lot owners (Lots 5, 7, 10, 21, 31, 32, 33). These are substantial infrastructure obligations typically managed by public entities or structured associations, not individual homeowners. What happens if the designated responsible lot does not sell, and what enforcement mechanism exists if maintenance lapses? These questions must be sufficiently addressed before the application be allowed to proceed in conformance with EC 9.8365. For these reasons, I respectfully request denial of PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02. This is not about opposing housing. It is about ensuring that the rules our community has established to protect natural resources and ensure safety and maintenance are being followed. Caitlyn Kari From:James Knackstedt To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Re: PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 4:51:18 PM You don't often get email from jjknackstedt@gmail.com. Learn why this is important [EXTERNAL ] Dear Mr Gioello, I have been looking at the documents and maps that have been submitted by the developer of the Braewood property below my street, Suncrest Avenue, over the past week. I have found that some of the contingencies outlined in code do not align with what I am seeing (and NOT seeing) on the maps and proposals presented by the developer. EC 9.4920 (2) (b) The required 25ft setback for Category B wetlands has not been met EC 9420 (3) the /WR conservation area for each of the individual water features shall be calculated and mapped separately, and the total footprint of all the individual /WR conservation areas combined shall be the /WR conservation area for that site. THIS DOES NOT APPEAR TO HAVE BEEN DONE BY THE DEVELOPER. Tree identification and species, and accurate count and locations, and root zones, have not been provided so I feel proposed buffers are nebulous. The due diligence by the developer demanded by codes, has been shotty and inadequate. The negative impact on the property, to established homes and habitats adjacent to and above the development, could be substantial, by affecting wetlands, worsening fire risk, and landslides. Because of these dire consequences, Codes, buffers, and respect environmental integrity must be a cornerstone in proper, responsible development. As it stands, I am requesting that the applications be denied. James J. Knackstedt From:Gary Lape (via Google Docs) To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Comments on PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 11:36:39 AM Attachments:Untitled document.pdf [EXTERNAL ] Gary Lape attached a document Gary Lape (garymlape9@gmail.com) has attached the following document: Untitled document Does this item look suspicious? Report Google LLC, 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043, USA You have received this email because garymlape9@gmail.com shared a document with you from Google Docs. To NGioello@eugene-or.gov Person Person Cc Person Bcc Carrie R. Lape Subject Comments on PDF 25-01 and SDR 25-02 Dear Mr. Gioello: Again, I (Gary Lape) and my wife (Carrie Lape) reside at 3034 Hawkins, within 150 yards of the proposed development and Randy Lane. The application,PDF 25-01, does not meet the requirements of the Eugene Code in at least the following particulars: EC 9.4920 (2)(b) requires a predetermined setback on Goal 5 wetlands. The wetland on this property (AMA 5B) is a Category B wetland and requires a 25-foot buffer. The application includes a map accepted by the Oregon Department of State Lands. The applicant’s map shows places where the wetland is wider than the conservation setback on the map and does not meet the 25-foot setback requirement. EC 94920(3) demands that where a wetland and a stream exist together, the /WR conservation area is the total footprint of the /WR conservation areas combined. Here, the /WR conservation area for the wetlands has not been calculated or mapped. Nor was the total footprint combined. If the applicant wants to proceed, it must include the 25-foot setback for the wetland and the 40-foot setback for the Category C stream. Recall that the City has determined that the entire property is a Goal 5 property. Thus, because the entire property is part of the City-adopted natural resource inventory, (1) all wetlands within 50 feet of property lines need to be identified and noted; (2) the site plan should identify all trees by species and dimension, as they are a natural resource; and (3) critical root zones for trees to be preserved within the /WR conservation area must be shown and information provided on how they will not be negatively impacted. EC 9.4980(4)(b) deals with the prevention of petroleum, chemicals, and other products used in the construction process from entering the stream or wetland. Given how close my wife and I live to the proposed development, this safety measure reflected in the Code is of the utmost importance, but all the developer says is that the requirement is “acknowledged and agreed”. But the developer should specify exactly what measures will be taken to prevent petroleum products, chemicals, and other deleterious material used in construction from entering the stream or wetland. The developer should also indicate how the natural resources of Videra Park (also adjacent to the development and my house) will be protected from any incursion by machinery, products, or chemicals. My mailing address is 3034 Hawkins Ln. Eugene OR 97405. From:Frederick Pool To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Re: Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PDF 25-01 / SDR 25-02 Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 3:50:17 PM Attachments:FPool Comments - Braewood Hills_3rd Addition_PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02.docx [EXTERNAL ] Nick, Please accept the attached comments regarding PDF 24-01 / SDR 25-02. I am a home owner at 3055 Herald Lane, Eugene, 97405 adjacent to the property. Regards, Frederick Pool February 20, 2026 From: Frederick Pool, 3055 Herald Lane, Eugene OR 97405 To: Nicholas Gioello, Associate Planner, City of Eugene RE: Braewood Hills, 3rd Addition, # PDF 25-01 & SDR 25-02 Thank-you for the notification I received dated February 6, “Notice of Proposed Land Use Action” and opportunity for comment. REQUEST: There are numerous instances where the proposed development does not meet code requirements and therefore should be denied. 1. Videra Park Property Line: EC 9.4980 (4) (b) & EC 9.4920 (2) (b) Approximately 2/3 of the southern property line is shared with Videra Park, a playground area for children and families of the community. The developer was required to do a survey and map showing the required Goal 5 conservation setback, but not required to do one for the portion on Videra Park with which it shares a property line. Videra Park is home to Videra Creek as well as wetlands that are contiguous across the property and park. Actions taken during development near or on the property line will have adverse effects on the natural environment and resources in Videra Park and hence the environment to which children of the community are exposed. Please note: EC 9.4980 (4) (b), which covers prevention of chemicals, petroleum, products, etc. from entering stream or wetland during construction. The applicant has checked “acknowledged and agreed”, without specifics of how compliance will be met. The developer must state specifically what measures will be taken to ensure that petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process will be prevented from entering the stream or wetland and in this instance Videra Park and adjoining waters. Visual inspection of the portion of Videra Park that adjoins where Randy Lane is proposed, shows a high likelihood that the required setback for a combined Goal 5 Stream and Wetland (E35A/AMA 5B) conservation setback in the Videra Park portion would overlap other areas of Randy Lane beyond what has been applied for in SR 25-02. i) The developer or the City needs to provide a full survey and mapping of the combined Wetland and Creek Conservation area for the portion of AMA 5B (wetland) and E35A (Videra Creek) in Videra Park to ensure conservation zone codes are met per EC 9.4920 (2) (b). ii) All trees in Videra Park within 30 feet of the property line need to be identified and mapped, along with their critical root zone to ensure native oak trees in Videra Park are not negatively impacted by any proposed construction. iii) Address how to prevent the extension of Randy Lane, as well as the swales to the north of it, from detouring and denying critical water for the trees directly on the other side of the property line in Videra Park. (Note: the new development at the end of Southview, almost all trees with their downhill flow of water cut off by the new extension of Timberline Dr. died within a year or two.) REQUEST: application must be denied based on the developer’s failure to comply with EC 9.4980 (4) (b) & EC 9.4920 (2) (b). 2. Wetland Removal Lot 38, Eugene Municipal Code 9.6715 Height Limitation. Lot 38 has been disallowed for development by City of Eugene Municipal Code 9.6715 Height Limitation. However, the developer has proposed destroying the associated Wetland 3B in anticipation of some future change to land use laws which may never be enacted. If a developer is allowed to destroy aspects of the natural environmental in anticipation of undefined and undetermined future land use law changes, why couldn’t any action be justified? REQUEST: The Removal/Fill wetland removal in Lot 38 be disallowed per City of Eugene Municipal Code 9.6715. Development must be consistent with current approvals for the property and not create a precedent where developers can cite “future land use law changes” to allow current environmental destruction that is in violation. 3. EC 9.9420 (2) (b) Requires a predetermined setback on Goal 5 wetlands. The wetland on the property (AMA 5B) is a Category B wetland requiring a 25-foot buffer. The established boundary of the wetland can be from the jurisdictional wetland boundary accepted by the Oregon Department of State Lands, if provided by the property owner. The application includes a map accepted by Oregon Department of State Lands. The map labels the wetland as Wetland 2B and clearly shows places where the wetland is wider than the conservation setback on the site map and is therefore not meeting the 25-foot setback requirement. 4. EC 94920 (3) if a wetland and stream exist together, the /WR conservation area is the total footprint of the /WR conservation areas combined. i) The proper /WR conservation area has not been determined, as the /WR conservation area for the wetlands was not calculated or mapped. Nor was the total footprint combined. ii) A 25-foot setback must be included for the wetland combined with the 40-foot setback for the Category C stream. In some places the setback will be more than what is currently on the site plan. These points are valid since during the approval process for the Tentative Planned Unit Development, the City determined that the entire property was Goal 5. 5. Application Standards Review: Water Resources (/WR) Overlay Zone and Goal Designation. The City of Eugene declared the entire property is a Goal 5 resource and is therefore part of the City-adopted natural resource inventory (which applies to a Goal 5 property). A Goal 5 designation requires: i) All wetlands within 50 feet of property lines must be identified and noted (all wetlands are a natural resource). ii) the site plan must also properly identify/indicate all trees by species and dimension on the site plan as they, too, are a natural resource. iii) Critical root zones for trees to be preserved within the /WR conservation area must be shown and information provided on how they will not be negatively impacted. As the applicant has not provided the proper conservation zone to include wetland AMA 5B/Wetland 2B, they cannot have properly fulfilled this requirement. REQUEST: the developer must meet the specifications for the Goal 5 designation for the property of approval be denied. 6. EC 9.4930 (3) (e) 3: Requires that excavated areas be backfilled with existing native soil: This was not addressed by the developer, so therefore it is not in compliance. REQUEST: the developer is not in compliance with EC 9.4930 (3) (e) 3 and therefore application should be denied. From:Wes Van Winkle To:GIOELLO Nick R Subject:Public comment regarding Braewood Hills 3rd Addition, Final PUD (PDT 25-01), and Standards Review (SDR 25- 02) Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 4:32:29 PM [EXTERNAL ] Dear Mr. Gioello, I serve as president of Save Videra Oak Meadow, a nonprofit organization opposed to the development of the 15-acre property referenced above. SVOM and I are represented by attorney Charles Woodward IV in this matter, and Mr. Woodward has already submitted comments stating our position with regard to this pending action. However, I have also prepared a few additional comments and am submitting them in this email. The application should be denied in its entirety for noncompliance with the Eugene Code planning sections noted herein. In particular, there are several problems with the Standards Review documents. The first area of noncompliance concerns the requirements of the Eugene Code for setbacks from Category B wetlands and a Category C stream (also designated a Goal 5 stream) on the property. It should first be noted that the application and site maps submitted by the applicant assume the issuance of a wetlands fill/removal permit from the DEQ and ODSL. The developer has applied for this permit, but it has not yet been granted. However, even if the permit were to be granted, the application fails to comply with Eugene Code requirements for setbacks. It is also possible that the permit will not be granted in its entirety, or perhaps will not be granted at all, in which case the application will obviously have to be denied. Solely for the purposes of this comment, I will assume hypothetically that the permit is granted and that the wetlands are filled or removed as indicated in the site map. However, Save Videra Oak Meadow opposes granting this permit, as I do also. The proposed private street extension crosses a Category B wetland area which requires a 25-foot setback zone. (Eugene Code section 9.4920(2)(b).) The application relies upon a map which appears to have been accepted by the Oregon Department of State Lands, within the meaning of the foregoing section, in which the wetland is identified as Wetland 2B. However, the map clearly shows several locations where the wetland is wider than the required conservation setback, and the proposal therefore fails to conform to section 9.4920(2)(b). The Goal 5 stream also has its own separate setback requirement. EC section 9.4920, subdivision (3) states as follows: "To determine the /WR conservation area for sites in which wetlands exist along with either an upland wildlife habitat site or a riparian site, the /WR conservation area for each of the individual water features shall be calculated and mapped separately, and the total footprint of all the individual /WR conservation areas combined shall be the /WR conservation area for that site." The wetlands in question include the Goal 5 stream, which is classified as a Category C stream for purposes of section 9.4920. (See Goal 5 Water Resources Conservation Plan, Section IV, Map 7.) Therefore, the conservation area for the wetlands and the stream must be calculated and mapped separately, and the total footprint of the combined /WR conservation areas for the wetlands and the stream constitute the /WR conservation area for the site. Under section 9.4920, the wetlands require a setback of 25 feet, and the Category C stream requires a setback of 40 feet. However, it does not appear from the application that the conservation area for the wetlands was ever calculated or mapped at all, and thus the combined /WR conservation area for the site has not been determined. It seems clear that the combined setback will be greater in places than the setbacks currently shown on the site plan. For example, the application materials fail to include, or provide wetlands setbacks for, wetlands in Lots 32 and 27 where a portion of the site map continues to represent parts of Wetlands 2 as being removed when more recent maps show them being retained even if the permit is granted. (The area in question can be seen on map on page 31 of the application Materials-SDR.pdf (i.e., the second page of the attached maps at the end of the document) as the blue area above and attached to the wetlands and Goal 5 creek. Although the application site plan for SDR 25-02 shows only a portion of the wetlands in Lot 32 will be preserved, the applicant’s current maps show that the entire wetland area attached to the creek in Lots 32 and 27 will be preserved.) The application is therefore not complete and does not comply with section 9.4920(3). In addition, setbacks from the Goal 5/Category C stream must be calculated from "the top of the high bank" on each side of the stream, not from the stream center (EC 9.4920(1)(c) and 9.4720), and it appears from the application materials that the stream center may have been used instead. The "high bank" is defined as "the highest point at which the bank meets the grade of the surrounding topography, characterized by an abrupt or noticeable change from a steeper grade to a less steep grade, and, where natural conditions prevail, by a noticeable change from topography or vegetation primarily shaped by the presence and/or movement of the water to topography not primarily shaped by the presence of water. Where there is more than one such break in the grade, the uppermost shall be considered the top of the high bank." (EC 9.4920(1)(c).) Based upon our visual inspections, it does not appear that the applicant's measurements accurately reflect the "high bank." At a minimum, it is not apparent that a consistent, objective standard was used in identifying the top of the bank. The Planning Department should view the site to ensure compliance with this requirement. Critical root zones for trees to be preserved within the /WR conservation area must also be shown on site maps, together with tree species and size. (See EC 9.6240.) Since the conservation areas for the wetlands and Category C stream were either not mapped at all or were not correctly mapped, the applicant has not complied with this requirement. The application also does not show the access points for many of the lots. Although in most cases it can be assumed that access will be made from a street or driveway adjacent to the lot, in the case of Lot 34, for example, the access point is not clear. A substantial portion of that lot will be occupied by the 40-foot setback from the top of the creek bank, thereby greatly reducing the size of the lot, leaving not much buildable area remaining. EC 9.8055 requires that access points must be shown on site maps and development maps, and many of the lots on these maps do not show how access points will be sited after setbacks and conservation areas have been created. Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this application and please do not hesitate to contact me if there is any additional information I can provide. Sincerely, Wesley A. Van Winkle From:Charles Woodward, IV To:GIOELLO Nick R Cc:Wes Van Winkle Subject:Comment on Braewood Hills 3rd Addition, Final PUD (PDT 25-01) & Standards Review (SDR 25-02) Date:Friday, February 20, 2026 4:27:39 PM Attachments:SVOM PDT 25-01 SDR 25-02 Statement - 2.20.26.pdf [EXTERNAL ] Mr. Gioello, Attached are comments for the record in the above captioned planning applications. Please acknowledge receipt. Thank you, and have a great weekend! Best, Charles W. Woodward, IV Attorney at Law 1165 Pearl St., Ste. 101 Eugene, OR 97401 (971) 206-4384 cwwoodwardiv@gmail.com CONFIDENTIALITY STATEMENT This message transmission contains information from Charles W. Woodward, IV, Attorney at Law. The e-mail message (including attachments) is covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. §§ 2510- 2521, and is protected by attorney-client and/or attorney/work product privilege. It is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and the privileges are not waived by virtue of this having been sent by electronic mail transmission. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure, dissemination, copying, forwarding or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply e-mail or telephone and destroy all copies of the original message. If you are the intended recipient but do not wish to receive communications through this medium, please so advise the sender immediately by telephone at (971) 206-4384. February 20, 2026 Mr. Nick Gioello, Associate Planner City of Eugene Planning Division 99 W. 10th Ave, Suite 290 Eugene, OR 974012 Via email: ngioello@eugene-or.gov Re: Comment on Braewood Hills 3rd Addition, Final PUD (PDT 25-01) & Standards Review (SDR 25-02) Save Videra Oak Meadows and Wes Van Winkle (“Clients”) provide the following comments on the Braewood Hills 3rd Addition final planned unit development (“PUD”) and standards review applications (“Final PUD” and “SDR,” respectively), File Nos. PDT 25-01/ST 25-02. The Applicant has failed to carry their burden of proving compliance with the all of the applicable provisions. For the following reasons, these applications for a final PUD and the standards review should be denied. I. Final Planned Unit Development (PDF 25-01) The Conditions of Approval for this Final PUD were described in the Final Order of the Eugene Planning Commission approving the Tentative PUD for the subject property (“Order”). The application materials are insufficient to demonstrate compliance with at least one of the required Conditions of Approval. Condition of Approval 11 states: “Prior to final plat approval, the applicant shall provide documentation that EWEB has received a financial guarantee, ensuring water will be provided to each lot in the plat.” The Applicant responds: “Acknowledged and agreed.” Final PUD, p. 4. “Acknowledged and agreed” is insufficient to demonstrate compliance with the condition of approval as it is a vague assertion without the required documentation which is expressly required by the provision. Therefore, the Applicant has not carried their burden of proof and demonstrated compliance with all of the required conditions of approval, and the Final PUD should be denied. 2/20/2026 2 II. Standards Review (SDR 25-02) Condition 18 of the Order requires a Standards Review approval for the proposed public street expansion of Randy Lane within the protected Water Resources Conservation Area (/WR), subject to the standards at EC 9.4900-9.4980. Here, the Applicant has failed to demonstrate compliance with multiple applicable provisions for the /WR, thus, the application for the SDR must be denied. A. The Applicant has not demonstrated compliance with EC 9.4920 The subject property includes a designated Category C stream and a Category B wetland that is at issue with this SDR application. Accordingly, compliance with provisions involving the stream and wetland must be demonstrated by the Applicant for approval. Here, neither has occurred. i. EC 9.4920(2)(b) EC 9.4920(2)(b) provides: “The area within the applicable conservation setback. The conservation setback for a particular site is determined based on whether it is a Category A, B or C wetland in the Goal 5 Water Resources Conservation Plan. Conservation setback distances for wetlands are measured horizontally from wetland boundaries established under the “Goal 5 Locally Significant Wetland Sites Within the Eugene Urban Growth Boundary” map or if provided by the property owner, from the jurisdictional wetland boundary accepted by the Oregon Department of State Lands. Conservation setback distances are as follows: Resource Conservation Setback Category A Wetland 50 feet Category B Wetland 25 feet Category C Wetland no conservation setback” The Applicant provided a jurisdictional wetland boundary map which was accepted by the Oregon Department of State Lands. On that map, the wetland boundaries for Wetland 2b (entirely a designated water of the US) are clearly demarcated. The Site Plan provided by the Applicant shows that the required 25-foot setback, for the designated Category B wetland, fails to follow the entirety of Wetland 2b (Wetland 2b clearly extends past the proposed setback indicated on the Site Plan) into Lots 27, 31, and 32. Additionally, the required Category B wetland setback does not extend 25 feet from the boundary of the wetland into Lots 24, 31, 32, 33, 34, and 38. 2/20/2026 3 Furthermore, the proposed extension of Randy Lane will intrude into the missing but required setback for development from the boundary of Wetland 2. Therefore, for the reasons explained herein, the Application fails to demonstrate compliance with EC 9.4920(2)(b). It is important to note that all of Wetland 2 is considered a water of the US, and requires a federal permitting application process for filling that wetland, which the applicant has chosen not to pursue, the present site plan erroneously denotes that part of that wetland is to be filled, which renders the site plan completely inaccurate. Thus, the Applicant’s site plan violates all provisions requiring an accurate site plan, including, but not limited to, EC 9.8472(3). ii. EC 9.4920(3) EC 4.4920(3) provides: “To determine the /WR conservation area for sites in which wetlands exist along with either an upland wildlife habitat site or a riparian site, the /WR conservation area for each of the individual water features shall be calculated and mapped separately, and the total footprint of all the individual /WR conservation areas combined shall be the /WR conservation area for that site.” The /WR conservation area has not been calculated or mapped separately according to this Code provision. Specifically, the provision requires that the riparian stream must be combined with Wetland 2b to determine the conservation area. Here, the 40-foot setback for the Riparian stream must be combined with the 25-foot setback for Wetland 2b. See Subsection (ii) above. While it appears that the Site Plan does refer to an area as the Conservation area, it is not calculated or mapped separately, and does not combine Wetland 2 with the stream as required under this provision. Therefore, the Application fails to demonstrate compliance with EC 9.4920(3). B. The Applicant has not demonstrated compliance with EC 9.4980(4)(b) EC 9.4980(4) provides: “Petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process shall not be allowed to enter a stream or wetland that is within a /WR conservation area.” 2/20/2026 4 The Applicant responds: “Acknowledged and agreed.” Standards Review Application, p. 11. Such a broad and vague assertion without supporting evidence is insufficient to demonstrate compliance with the Code provision. “Acknowledged and agreed” does not indicate the methodologies to be utilized that will ensure that no petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process are allowed to enter the stream and wetland on the subject property. Therefore, the Applicant has not carried their burden of proof and demonstrated compliance with EC 9.4980(4). III. Conclusion For the above reasons, Save Videra Oak Meadows and Wes Van Winkle requests that the final PUD and the standards review applications, File Nos. PDT 25-01/ST 25-02, be denied. Respectfully submitted, Charles W. Woodward, IV Attorney for Save Videra Oak Meadows and Wes Van Winkle