Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
Application Materials
Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning STANDARDS REVIEW APPLICATION Braewood Hills Third Addition PUD Phases 5 and 6 A RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT PROJECT Assessor’s Map Tax Lots 18 04 11 12 00200 September 5, 2025 Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 2 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning Table of Contents Site Review Application ................................................................................................ 3 – 4 General Site Plan Requirements .................................................................................. 5 – 6 Site Review Written Statement ................................................................................... 7 – 14 Attachments Attachment A Legal Description Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 3 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning September 5, 2025 STANDARDS REVIEW APPLICATION PROJECT DIRECTORY PROPERTY OWNER / APPLICANT Piculell Properties, LLC 3104 E. Camelback Road, #116 Phoenix, AZ 85016 Contact: Al Lundstrom Phone : 602.418.3229 APPLICANT’S REPRESENTATIVE LAND USE PLANNER, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT Schirmer Consulting, LLC PO Box 10424 Eugene, OR 97440 Contact: Carol Schirmer Email: schirmer@schirmerconsulting.com Phone: 541.234.5108 CIVIL ENGINEER KPFF Consulting Engineers 800 Willamette Street Eugene, OR 97401 Contact: Anna Backus, P.E. Email: anna.backus@kpff.com Phone: 541.735.9249 SURVEYOR KPFF Consulting Engineers 800 Willamette Street Eugene, OR 97401 Contact: Troy Tetsuka, PLS Email: troy.tetsuka@kpff.com Phone: 503.542.2860 MAP and TAX LOT Assessor’s Map Tax Lot Current Zoning 18 04 11 12 00200 R-1/WR/PD AREA OF REQUEST 673,873 sf or 15.47 acres (approximately) EXISTING USE OF THE PROPERTY Vacant PROPOSED USE OF THE PROPERTY The proposed use is residential. Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 4 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning RELATED LAND USE APPLICATIONS PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3 Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 5 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning General Site Plan Requirements List all professional representatives See Site Plan. Date, north arrow, scale See Site Plan. Assessor’s Map and Tax Lot number See Site Plan. Vicinity Map See Site Plan. Public Improvements See Site Plan. Elevation and/or cross section See Site Plan. Existing and proposed streets See Site Plan Proposed paving materials Existing Structures None. Proposed Structures See Site Plan for proposed lots. Existing Easements See Site Plan. Public and private Proposed Easements See Site Plan. Public and private Proposed Grading See Site Plan. Outdoor lighting See Site Plan. Existing and proposed utilities See Site Plan. Existing and proposed stormwater See Site Plan. drainage. Proposed stormwater improvements See Site Plan. Approved through Tentative PUD. Type of Construction N/A. Goal 5 Resource Sites and Other Natural Features Goal 5 Resource and /WR conservation setback See Site Plan. Tops of banks of existing stream See Site Plan. Provide wetland delineation See Site Plan and attached report. Threatened or endangered species. N/A. Other wetlands See Site Plan. Slopes and Grading/Excavation Proposed Grading See Site Plan Contour Intervals See Site Plan. Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 6 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning Landscape and Vegetation Protection Requirements Existing and proposed vegetation See Site Plan Location and means of protection See Site Plan Means of protecting other areas See Site Plan Critical Root Zone N/A. Supporting Analysis and Documents Narrative report See Written Statement. Wetlands See attached delineation. Legal Description See attached. Additional Information N/A Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 7 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning STANDARDS REVIEW WRITTEN STATEMENT The following are the applicable sections found in EC 9.8460 – 9.8474 Standards Review and EC 9.4930 – 9.4980 /WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay. Criteria are in regular type face and responses are in italics. Project Overview The subject property encompasses over 15 acres designated as a residential Planned Unit Development (PUD) and subdivision. Within this area lies a resource identified under Statewide Planning Goal 5, which pertains to the conservation of natural resources, scenic and historic areas, and open spaces. To facilitate the development, the applicant proposes the extension of Randy Lane through the southern portion of the property. This proposed public road crosses the Goal 5 resource area. Therefore, as a condition of approval, the applicant must submit a Standards Review application to assess and mitigate potential impacts on the Goal 5 resource. The Goal 5 Resource (a stream) currently flows into an existing 12” stormwater pipe that deposits the water in Videra Park. This stormwater pipe will not be disturbed, unless portion so fit need to be replaced due to age related degradation, during the construction of Randy Lane and will be integrated into the road infrastructure as would any other utility. Consequently, no culvert will be required. The primary disturbance within the Goal 5 area will result from the grading and construction activities with the required road extension. Existing plants will be removed and native plants will be installed. See lists below identifying existing plants to be removed and replacement planting. See Site Plan for location of plant removal and replacement planting.. Existing plants to be removed (per Wetlands and Wildlife, LLC) The dominant grass species is Schedonorus arundinaceus, a non-native hay grass. Rubus armeniacus and Dipsacus fullonum dominate the area surrounding the upslope stormwater pipe. Minor components (trace) include Sidalcea asprella ssp. Virgata (native), Camassia leichtlinii (native), Juncus patens, Allium amplectens (native). The existing trees are either apple or pear are non-native. Proposed planting (per Wetlands and Wildlife, LLC) I recommend replanting/seeding with: · Deschampsia caespitosa – Tufted Hair Grass. · Festuca californica – California fescue · Koeleria macrantha – Prairie Junegrass · Hordeum brachyantherum – Meadow Barley Native tree replacement could be: · Quercus garryana – Oregon White Oak · Pinus ponderosa v. benthamiana – Willamette Valley Ponderosa Pine · Calocedrus decurrens – Incense Cedar · Malus fusca – Pacific Crabapple EC 9.8470 Standards Review Approval Criteria The decision maker shall determine whether the application is in compliance with the standards set out in the code section that calls for the Standards Review. Condition 18 of the Planning Commissions Final Order: Braewood Hills 3rd Addition (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) states: Prior to Final PUD approval, the applicant shall obtain Type II Standards Review approval for the proposed public street extension of Randy Lane and any other utility crossings or other allowed improvements within the protected /WR conservation area, subject to the applicable standards at EC 9.4900 – 9.4980. A Type II Standards Review application is required. 9.8472 Standards Review – Application Requirements. In addition to the provisions in EC 9.7010 Application Filing, applications for uses subject to standards review under EC 9.4780(3) or EC 9.4930(3) shall be subject to the following requirements: Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 8 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning (1) Unless waived by the planning director, the application shall be prepared by one or more of the following professionals: (a) Oregon licensed architect. (b) Oregon licensed civil engineer. (c) Oregon licensed landscape architect. (d) For applications submitted under EC 9.4780(3), a professionally trained botanist, biologist, ecologist, or geomorphologist or creek restoration specialist with a bachelor’s degree in the subject field and at least 5 years of applied experience in botany, biology, ecology, geomorphology, or a closely related field, or an Oregon licensed geologist. (e) For applications submitted under EC 9.4930(3), a professionally trained botanist or biologist, with sufficient training and experience in planning and design to evaluate consistency of the application with all applicable standards. The application is being prepared by a licensed landscape architect, licensed civil engineer, licensed surveyor and Brian Meiering, an Environmental Specialist from Wetlands and Wildlife, LLC., a professionally trained wetlands specialist (with over 30 years of experience and Specializing in Rare Species Surveys, Wetland Delineations and Mitigation Construction Administration/Compliance related to NEPA and ESA). (2) Unless waived by the planning director, if the application submitted under EC 9.4930(3) is not prepared by a professionally trained botanist or biologist, one or more of the professionals preparing the application shall have sufficient professional expertise and training in field botany or related biological sciences to evaluate consistency of the application with application standards. The application is submitted under EC 9.4930(3)(b) Construction of public improvements (including but not limited to streets, bridges, paved bikeways and pedestrian paths, and public utilities) required by this land use code or specified in adopted plans. Subject to EC 9.4980/WR Water Resources Conservation Overlay Development Standards (1) through (11). The application is being prepared by a licensed landscape architect with over 35 years of experience, and a professionally trained wetlands specialist (with over 30 years of experience and Specializing in Rare Species Surveys, Wetland Delineations and Mitigation Construction Administration/Compliance related to NEPA and ESA). Together with this level of expertise the application will be completed with sufficient specificity for approval. (3) The application shall include a site plan that shows sufficient detail and supporting narrative information to demonstrate compliance with applicable standards. Unless waived by the planning director, the site plan shall be prepared by an Oregon licensed civil engineer or Oregon licensed surveyor. The application includes a site plan that shows sufficient detail and supporting narrative information demonstrating compliance with applicable standards. Various plans within the plan set have been prepared by licensed professionals, including a licensed landscape architect and licensed civil engineer. A licensed surveyor provided the existing conditions plan and the licensed civil engineer provided the grading plan. That data has all been combined into one Site Plan demonstrating the area to be disturbed for construction of a required public road, plants to be removed and plants to be installed. As such, this criterion is met. (4) The site plan and application shall be signed by each of the professionals preparing the application, certifying that the application is true and correct to the best of his or her professional ability, and that, if applicable, the professional standards of his or her profession have been met therein. See Cover Sheet of Plan Set for signatures. EC 9.4980 /WR Water Resource Conservation Overlay Zone – Development Standards. (1) Enhancement. Where the /WR conservation area is reduced, or uses are approved within the /WR conservation area, the remaining /WR conservation area shall be enhanced consistent with this subsection and by removing non-native plant species and planting native plant species consistent with subsections and (3) below. (a) All refuse, toxic materials and any fill that limits or decreases the capacity of the conservation setback area to filter pollutants from runoff that flows across the conservation setback area shall be removed (not including stormwater collected and discharged from impervious surfaces). Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 9 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning No known toxic materials are present on-site. Any refuse and toxic materials encountered will be removed. Fill required to construct the road and the culvert will be kept to a minimum. Finished grades will replicate the pre- existing conditions as is practical. The area of disturbance is shown on the Site Plan on Sheet ST3.0. The area of disturbance is approximately 1,105 sf. A stormwater treatment facility is planned on the north side of the proposed road. This can be considered the area of fill. In this instance the fill is a stormwater treatment facility. It will serve to enhance the setback area, treat stormwater run-off and filter pollutants from stormwater that flows across the conservation setback. See Site Plan for limits of grading and limits of disturbance. (b) Where practicable, finished grades shall encourage sheet flow of runoff across conservation setback areas to maximize filtering and infiltration of precipitation and runoff within conservation setback areas (not including stormwater collected and discharged from impervious surfaces). The finished grades intentionally direct runoff from the conservation setback area as sheet flow into the proposed planted swale located on the north side of Randy Lane (refer to Site Plan, Sheet ST3.0). Because the conservation area sits at a higher elevation, runoff naturally flows downhill into the swale, which is designed to enhance pollutant filtration and promote infiltration much more effectively than the current sheet flow condition. This swale is engineered to retain water for a longer duration than existing conditions, allowing vegetation and soil media to filter sediments, pollutants, and nutrients before infiltration. It will be planted with native, dense- rooted vegetation specifically designed for the local hydrologic conditions, further maximizing its treatment performance and ecological benefit. Brian Meiering, an Environmental Specialist from Wetlands and Wildlife, LLC. specified the proposed appropriate native planting for the area that was disturbed beyond the boundaries of the proposed stormwater treatment facility. (c) On sites where the slope within the conservation setback area exceeds 15 percent, measures (e.g., planting and contouring) shall be taken to slow the flow of runoff to the maximum extent practicable (not including stormwater collected and discharged from impervious surfaces). The proposed stormwater treatment facility is designed to naturally intercept existing runoff. Once the runoff is in the stormwater treatment facility the more gradual slopes of the stormwater treatment facility and proposed planting will naturally slow the flow of the runoff, enhancing opportunities for infiltration and pollutant removal. The existing stream will remain unaffected by the construction of Randy Lane. The existing stream currently enters an existing 12” storm pipe that conveys water directly to Videra Creek. As no culvert is proposed and the pipe will remain undisturbed, stream flow direction and velocity will remain unchanged by the project (d) Non-native plants shall be permanently removed to the maximum extent practicable and replaced with native plant species in accordance with subsection (3) below. All plants in that area will be removed to construct the road. The existing plants to be removed are listed on the Site Plan as are the proposed replacement native plants. (e) Except as required by EC 9.4980(2)(c), EC 9.4980(3)(d) and EC 9.4980(3)(e), site work to enhance the conservation setback area shall be completed prior to or concurrent with other site development, unless appropriate native plant species are not available within that time frame. Site work to enhance the conservation setback area will commence following the completion of the road construction and associated public utilities. See Site Plan and Planting Plan for finished product. Planting will be done as native plants are made available. (2) Vegetation Removal. Vegetation removal within the /WR conservation area and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 10 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning (a) Vegetation removal shall be limited to: 1. Plant species that are non-native and invasive; 2. Dead or dried native plants or grasses only when they constitute an imminent fire hazard; 3. Living native or non-native vegetation, when its removal is necessary to facilitate or encourage the growth of other native species (e.g., native wet prairie plant species) consistent with adopted plans or policies; or 4. The minimum area of native vegetation removal necessary to accommodate uses approved in accordance with EC 9.4930(3)(a) through EC 9.4930(3)(k), and uses approved through an adjustment approved in accordance with EC 9.8030(21). Removal of vegetation is required for the construction of the required public road. Native and non-native vegetation will be removed only to the extent necessary to facilitate the scheduled construction. The existing plants are: The dominant grass species is Schedonorus arundinaceus, a non-native hay grass. Rubus armeniacus and Dipsacus fullonum dominate the area surrounding the upslope stormwater pipe. Minor components (trace) include Sidalcea asprella ssp. Virgata (native), Camassia leichtlinii (native), Juncus patens, Allium amplectens (native). There are also 3 existing non-native fruit trees. (b) Clearing of more than 500 square feet of vegetation must comply with Erosion Prevention regulations for sensitive areas in EC 6.645. The construction of the road proposes approximately 1,015 sf of clearing in order to construct the required public road. Erosion Control Plans will be submitted and approved by City of Eugene. Erosion control measures will be installed and approved prior to any construction of the proposed road. (c) Any clearing of vegetation that is not within the footprint of uses approved in accordance with EC 9.4930(3)(a) through EC 9.4930(3)(k), or uses approved through an adjustment approved under EC 9.8030(21), must be followed by replanting in accordance with the requirements of subsection (3) below. Once construction is complete revegetation with native species will occur per subsection (3) below. See Planting Plan Sheet ST3.0. Should any vegetation be cleared that is not within the footprint of the approved uses replanting will comply with EC 9.4980(3). Additional clearing is not anticipated. (3) Planting and Replanting. Planting or replanting within the /WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: (a) Areas of existing bare soil and areas which have been cleared or graded in accordance with subsection EC 9.4980(2) or EC 9.4980(5) shall be planted with native plant species. Except as required in (b) and (c) below, plant species and plant spacing used for such plantings shall be appropriate to increasing to the greatest extent practicable the capacity of the conservation setback area to filter pollutants from runoff that flows across the conservation setback area (not including stormwater collected and discharged from impervious surfaces). Where existing native vegetation already serves this function to some extent, additional native plants shall be planted in order to augment native vegetation already existing. Plant species selected for all plantings shall be appropriate to the site given its topography, hydrology, soil, and existing native plant species. Plant species, rate of application (where appropriate) and size have been determined and selected by Brian Meiering, Wetlands and Wildlife, LLC. These plants and species have been selected to increase to the greatest extent practicable the capacity of the conservation setback to filter pollutants. Additionally, there is a stormwater treatment facility at the base of the conservation area that will also serve to filter out pollutants with city approved native plant materials. (b) Planting or replanting within 25 feet of a Category B, C, or D stream within the /WR conservation area shall include native tree or large shrub species and located so as to provide substantial shading of the channel during times of peak solar input. Native trees and grasses have bee proposed. The trees that were removed did not provide shade for the existing stream as that area is at the location of the existing stormwater pipe. The actual location of the Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 11 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning stream is north of the area of disturbance. The area of disturbance is around the existing stormwater pipe and not the actual stream. To the extent that they can provide shade when more fully grown, 4 native trees have been planted in the area of disturbance. (c) Where non-native or damaged trees are removed within 25 feet of a Category B, C, or D stream within the /WR conservation area, they shall be replaced with native tree or large shrub species and located so as to achieve equal or greater shading of the channel during times of peak solar input as the trees removed. The 3 existing non-native trees that were removed were located between 35’ and 45’ from the actual stream. The 4 proposed native trees were selected and placed in the area of disturbance. They are placed closer to the actual stream and spread out east to west to provide maximum amount of shade on their north side, eventually providing some shade to the actual resource and the conservation setback area when they mature. (d) Replanting of areas cleared of existing vegetation must be completed within 90 days following the removal or clearing, unless otherwise approved by the planning director. Planting will be scheduled based on seasonal timing and plant availability to ensure optimal restoration success. If this schedule cannot be accommodated within the 90-day timeline, a request for an extension will be submitted to the Planning Director. (e) Plantings shall not adversely affect adjacent protected water resources or existing native vegetation through shading or invasion by plant species introduced into the setback. See Planting Plan for proposed replanting within the /WR conservation area disturbed by construction of Randy Lane and other required public improvements. The proposed seed choices are native species and are not considered invasive. Four native trees have been planted to replace the 3 non-native trees removed. These are also not invasive species. The native replacement plantings will enhance this area by replacing non-native plants with native. These plantings will not adversely affect the adjacent protected water resource. This requirement seems contradictory to the requirement in (c) above that indicates shading of the stream might be desirable? (4) Construction Practices. Construction within the /WR conservation area, and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: (a) For purposes of this subsection, heavy machinery is defined as motorized or mechanized machinery or equipment capable of deliberately or inadvertently damaging vegetation, or damaging or compacting soil. The following standards shall apply to use of heavy machinery within the /WR conservation area: 1. On sites where soils are susceptible to severe compaction or structural damage when wet or saturated, use of heavy machinery shall be limited to the period between June 15 and September 30, unless otherwise approved by the planning director. 2. Use of heavy machinery shall be the minimum necessary for the use or activity and shall be restricted to those areas where its use is necessary. Machinery, tools, supplies and other construction materials will not be stockpiled or stored in the /WR area. Machinery use within the /WR area will be the minimum necessary and limited to the period between June 15 and September 30 unless otherwise approved by the planning director. (b) Petroleum products, chemicals, or other deleterious materials used in the construction process shall not be allowed to enter a stream or wetland that is within a /WR conservation area. Acknowledged and agreed. Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 12 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning (5) Filling, Grading and Excavating. Filling, grading and excavating within the /WR conservation area and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area shall comply with the following standards: (a) Filling, grading or excavating of more than 500 square feet must comply with Erosion Prevention regulations for sensitive areas in EC 6.645. There will be more than 500 square feet of filling, grading or excavating. An Erosion Control permit will be submitted to the city for review and approval. Erosion control measures will be installed prior to commencement of construction, maintained throughout construction and until re-vegetation establishment has occurred. Upon conclusion of construction, finish grades replicating the pre-existing condition, blending in with adjacent non-impacted conditions, will be established. (b) Grading and excavating conducted as part of restoration or enhancement projects, and bank and channel reconfiguration shall result in topography that resembles landscapes shaped only by natural processes, for example, incorporating the undulations, meanders and slopes found in such landscapes. For purposes of this standard, straight lines and geometric or angular shapes are not acceptable. Channel and stream bank slopes shall not exceed 25 percent at elevations of 500 feet or less. Natural slopes, grades and contours will be established. Straight lines and geometric shapes will not be permitted. Elevations in this area are above 800 feet. Minimal grading is done north of Randy Lane to re- establish grades as the proposed road and related utilities are constructed. Except for the proposed road and stormwater treatment facility, the existing stream and its banks will remain largely undisturbed. Although the side slopes of the swale exceed 25%, they are oriented perpendicular to the stream’s flow direction. As runoff from the conservation area enters the stormwater treatment facility, its velocity is naturally reduced due to the change in flow direction. From there the water turns and runs through the stormwater treatment facility which is fully vegetated and designed to slow the run-off. See Site Plan and Planting Plan. (6) Impervious Surfaces. Within the /WR conservation area, construction of new impervious surfaces shall comply with the following standards: (a) Impervious surfaces are prohibited within the /WR conservation area unless they are part of a use approved in accordance with EC 9.4930(3). (b) Impervious surfaces that are part of a use approved in accordance with EC 9.4930(3) shall be no larger than the minimum necessary for the approved use. For sites with wetlands, impervious surfaces shall be located as far from the boundaries of locally significant wetlands as practicable. For riparian and upland wildlife habitat sites, impervious surfaces shall be located as far from the line of ordinary high water as practicable. (c) Durable porous paving treatments or other infiltration devices approved by the planning director or decision- maker shall be used in lieu of standard impervious paving surfaces to increase infiltration of stormwater where practicable. This standard shall apply only to low volume parking areas, foot paths or lightly used access roads, where porous soils and flat topography will facilitate infiltration of runoff. For the purposes of this subsection, gravel surfaces are not acceptable as porous paving or as an infiltration device. The construction of a public road is an approved use in accordance with EC 9.4930(3). Impervious surfaces will be installed only where approved through the PEPI Permit (Permit No. 37011) and be of no greater extent than the minimum necessary. See Site Plan for extent of impact of impervious surfaces. (7) Site Layout. On sites where the /WR conservation area is reduced, high intensity uses within the entire development site, including high volume traffic lanes and truck loading docks, shall be designed and located so that adverse impacts to wetland and riparian habitats within the /WR conservation area are minimized to the greatest extent practicable. Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 13 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning The design and layout of the proposed impacts will be limited to what is necessary and placed as far from the resource area as feasible. Both horizontal and vertical alignments will be designed to follow existing grades as closely as possible. The road is located as approved and the narrowest right of way dimension (40 feet) was approved through the PUD process. This narrower right of way served to lessen the impact. Sidewalks are only required on one side instead of 2 sides. No high intensity uses, high volume traffic lanes or truck loading docks are proposed, (8) Lighting. Within the /WR conservation area, and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area, outdoor area lighting shall be prohibited, except to illuminate walkways, bike paths, pedestrian gathering areas, and parking areas, where these facilities are intended to be used after dark. Outdoor area lighting is lighting designed to illuminate an outdoor activity area, trail or bicycle path. Where lighting is to be provided within the /WR conservation area and within areas removed from the /WR conservation area, the following standards shall apply: (a) Illumination for walkways, pathways or pedestrian gathering areas shall be no more than an average maintained luminance of 0.5 foot-candle at grade. (b) Output from all other light sources shall be no more than an average maintained luminance of 0.9 foot-candle at grade. (c) All lighting fixtures shall be designed to direct light downward to areas intended for human use after dark, and shall be shielded such that light shining toward /WR conservation areas is minimized to the maximum extent practicable. Lighting will be provided only where required to meet other applicable standards (i.e., street lighting). Output will be the minimum required. Light cast will be directed downward and away from the /WR resource. See proposed lighting on the PEPI Plans and Site Plan. (9) Trails. Within the /WR conservation area, trails shall be constructed of gravel, wood chips or other pervious material, unless otherwise approved by the city manager or decision-maker. Trail construction shall involve the least removal of native vegetation practicable for the area and the minimum amount of fill or excavation practicable. Not applicable. No trails are proposed. (10)Stream and Channel Crossings. Bridges or other structures that cross streams or wetlands within the /WR conservation area or areas removed from the /WR conservation area shall be constructed so that water flow, vegetation growth and movement of aquatic animals and water dependent wildlife are impeded to the least extent practicable. To meet this standard, bridges and crossings shall include, but are not limited to, applicable items from the following list: (a) Bridges across Category A or Category B streams as identified in the Goal 5 Water Resources Conservation Plan shall, where practicable, be designed to avoid channel constriction when flows reach the top of high bank. Where practicable, bridges shall span a distance 1.2 times the width of the stream channel from top of high bank to top of high bank to help prevent scouring within the structure or at the outlet during less frequent floods. (b) Crossings over Category A or Category B streams as identified in the Goal 5 Water Resources Conservation Plan shall utilize bridges or natural substrate culverts where possible. Where practicable, the lower lip of any natural substrate culvert shall be embedded at least 1 foot for box culverts and pipe arches, and at least 25% of the pipe diameter for pipe culverts. The substrate within the structure shall match the composition of the substrate in the natural stream channel at the time of construction. The substrate shall either resist displacement during flood events or the structure shall be designed to maintain an appropriate bottom through natural bed load transport. (c) Bridges and culverts on Category A or Category B streams as identified in the Goal 5 Water Resources Conservation Plan shall be constructed so that the “openness ratio” of the structure is equal to or greater than Braewood Hills 3rd Addition PUD (PDT 24-1 and ST 24-3) Page 14 of 14 Standards Review Application: Written Statement September 5, 2025 Schirmer Consulting, LLC · PO Box 10424, Eugene, OR 97440 · (541) 234-5108 Landscape Architecture + Land Use Planning 0.25. The “openness ratio” is the cross-sectional area of the passage area under or within the structure divided by the length of the stream segment it crosses over. For a box culvert, the openness ratio shall be (height x width)/length. (d) Culverts shall not substantially increase or decrease water depth or flow rate conditions upstream or downstream from the culvert. (e) The lower lip of all culverts shall meet the stream or channel bed at or below grade. (f) Culverts shall be the minimum length practicable, and fill on top of the culvert shall have the minimum footprint practicable. Many of the criteria are not applicable. No culverts are proposed. An existing 12-inch storm drain line, conveying runoff from the Goal 5 Resource to Videra Creek, will remain intact beneath the proposed public road. The road design accommodates this utility without modification—no culvert installation is required. See detail entitled Culvert Section (even though no culvert is being proposed) on Sheet ST2.0. (11)Interpretive Facilities. Not applicable. No interpretive facilities proposed. If you have any questions or need additional clarification, please do not hesitate to call. We look forward to your review and approval of this important housing project. Sincerely, Schirmer Consulting, LLC Carol Schirmer Principal Order No. 0328567 Page 3 PROPERTY DESCRIPTION A parcel of land being a portion of the Northeast quarter of Section 11, Township 18 South, Range 4 West of the Willamette Meridian, being more particularly described as follows: Commencing at a found 1 inch iron rod marking the North quarter corner of said Section 11; thence following along the North-South midsection line of said Section 11, South 00° 08’ 13” West, 389.75 feet; thence leaving said North-South midsection line, South 63° 25’ 30” East, 16.65 feet; thence South 89° 52’ 31” East 12.30 feet to a point of curvature; thence following along the arc of a 127.50 foot radius curve to the right, through a central angle of 48° 20’ 30”, an arc distance of 107.57 feet, (the long chord of which bears South 65° 42’ 16” East, 104.41 feet) to a point of tangency; thence South 41° 32’ 01” East 410.17 feet; thence South 48° 27’ 59” West 55.00 feet; thence South 41° 32’ 01” East, 81.72 feet to a point of curvature; thence following along the arc of a curve to the right, through a central angle of 20° 10’ 42”, an arc distance of 25.53 feet (the long chord of which bears South 31° 26’ 39” East, 25.40 feet) to a point of tangency; thence South 21° 21’ 18” East, 25.19 feet to a point of curvature; thence following along the arc of a curve to the left, through a central angle of 67° 38’ 49”, an arc distance of 321.73 feet (the long chord of which bears South 55° 10’ 43” East, 303.37 feet) to a point of tangency; thence South 89° 00’ 07” East, 203.98 feet to a point of curvature; thence following along the arc of a curve to the right, through a central angle of 21° 58’ 47”, an arc distance of 27.81 (the long chord of which bears South 78° 00’ 43” East, 27.64 feet) to a point of tangency; thence South 67° 01’ 20” East, 167.47 feet, to a point of curvature; thence following along a curve to the left, through a central angle of 36° 25’ 18”, an arc distance of 81.05 feet (the long chord of which bears South 85° 13’ 59” East, 79.69 feet) to a point of tangency; thence North 76° 33’ 22” East, 38.06 feet, to a point of curvature; thence following along the arc of a curve to the right, through a central angle of 14° 16’ 02”, an arc distance of 18.05 feet (the long chord of which bears North 83° 41’ 22” East, 18.01 feet) to a point of tangency; thence South 89° 12’ 39” East, 145.09 feet to a point on the West line of the REPLAT OF LOT 64, BRAEWOOD HILLS 2ND ADDITION P.U.D., as platted and recorded in File 75, Slides 1125 and 1126, Lane County Oregon Plat Records, Eugene, Lane County, Oregon; thence following along the exterior boundary of said Plat, North 03° 01’ 16” West, 146.50 feet; thence North 55° 06’ 19” West, 84.78 feet to the most Southerly corner of Lot 9, BRAEWOOD NORTH P.U.D. as platted and recorded in File 75, Slides 384 through 386, Lane County Oregon Plat Records, Eugene, Lane County, Oregon; thence following along the exterior boundary of said Plat, North 63° 13’ 20” West, 272.85 feet; thence North 68° 10’ 07” West, 233.91 feet; North 35° 41’ 55” West, 168.86 feet; thence North 18° 54’ 40” West, 168.76 feet; thence North 05° 14’ 11” West, 104.98 feet; thence North, 324.76 feet to a point on the North line of Section 11; thence following along said North line, North 89° 33’ 50” West, 641.67 feet to the point of beginning, all in said Section 11, Township 18 South, Range 4 West of the Willamette Meridian, Eugene, Lane County, Oregon. DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS, PORTLAND DISTRICT P.O. BOX 2946 PORTLAND, OR 97208-2946 July 25, 2025 Regulatory Branch Corps No. NWP-2022-30 Mr. Al Lundstrom Piculell Properties LLC 3104 East Camelback Road, Suite 116 Phoenix, AZ 85016 al@katchmor.com Dear Mr. Lundstrom: The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) received your request for an Approved Jurisdictional Determination (AJD) of the aquatic resources, including wetlands, within the review area on the property located at Tax Lot 1804111200200 in Eugene, Lane County, Oregon, Latitude / Longitude: 44.0239850°, -123.1358888°. Other aquatic resources, including wetlands, that may occur on this property or on adjacent properties outside the review area are not the subject of this determination. The Corps has determined Wetland 2B within the review area are waters of the United States. The Corps has also determined Wetland 1, Wetland 2, Wetland 2C, Wetland 3, Wetland 4 and Wetland 5 are not waters of the United States. The enclosed Memorandum for Record (MFR) (Enclosure 1) provides the size, criteria and rationale for jurisdiction for all aquatic resources within the review area. The perimeter of the review area and the boundaries of the delineated waters of the United States subject to this AJD are identified on the enclosed drawings (Enclosure 2). This AJD is valid for a period of five years from the date of this letter unless new information warrants revisions of the determination. The delineation included herein has been conducted to identify the location and extent of the aquatic resources for purposes of the Clean Water Act for the particular site identified in this request. This delineation may not be valid for the Wetland Conservation Provisions of the Food Security Act of 1985, as amended. If you or your tenant are U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) program participants, or anticipate participation in USDA programs, you should discuss the applicability of a Natural Resources Conservation Service Certified Wetland Determination with the local USDA service center, prior to starting work. This letter contains an AJD for the subject site. If you object to the enclosed AJD, you may request an administrative appeal under the Corps regulations at 33 CFR Part 331. - 2 - Enclosed you will find a Notification of Administrative Appeal Options and Process (NAP) and Request for Appeal (RFA) form (Enclosure 3). If you request to appeal this AJD, you must submit a completed RFA form to the Corps Northwestern Division Office at the following address: Melinda Larsen, Regulatory Appeals Review Officer U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Northwestern Division 1201 NE Lloyd Blvd., Suite 400 Portland, OR 97232 You may contact the Appeals Review Officer by phone at 503-808-3888 or by email at melinda.m.larsen@usace.army.mil. In order for an RFA to be accepted by the Corps, the Corps must determine that it is complete, that it meets the criteria for appeal under 33 CFR § 331.5, and that it has been received by the Division Office within 60 days from the date on the NAP. Should you decide to submit an RFA form, it must be received at the above address by September 23, 2025. It is not necessary to submit an RFA form to the Division Office if you do not object to the enclosed AJD. We would like to hear about your experience working with the Portland District, Regulatory Branch. Please complete a customer service survey form available on our website (https://regulatory.ops.usace.army.mil/customer-service-survey/). If you have any questions regarding our Regulatory Program or permit requirements for work in waters of the United States, please contact Ms. Alexandra Holecek by telephone at (541) 297-9938 or by email at alexandra.holecek@usace.army.mil. FOR THE COMMANDER, LARRY D. CASWELL, JR., PE, PMP, COLONEL, U.S. ARMY, DISTRICT COMMANDER and DISTRICT ENGINEER: For: William D. Abadie Chief, Regulatory Branch Enclosures cc with drawings: Wetlands and Wildlife, LLC (Brian Meiering, brian@wetlandsandwildlifellc.com) Oregon Department of State Lands (Charles Redon, charles.redon@dsl.oregon.gov) Oregon Department of Environmental Quality (Haley Teach, haley.teach@deq.oregon.gov) DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS, PORTLAND DISTRICT P.O. BOX 2946 PORTLAND, OR 97208-2946 CENWP-ODG 25 July 2025 MEMORANDUM FOR RECORD SUBJECT: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) Approved Jurisdictional Determination in accordance with the “Revised Definition of ‘Waters of the United States’”; 88 FR 3004 (18 January 2023) as amended by the “Revised Definition of ‘Waters of the United States’; Conforming” 88 FR 61964 (8 September 2023) ,1 NWP- 2022-30 2 BACKGROUND. An Approved Jurisdictional Determination (AJD) is a Corps document stating the presence or absence of waters of the United States on a parcel or a written statement and map identifying the limits of waters of the United States on a parcel. AJDs are clearly designated appealable actions and will include a basis of JD with the document.3 AJDs are case-specific and are typically made in response to a request. AJDs are valid for a period of five years unless new information warrants revision of the determination before the expiration date or a District Engineer has identified, after public notice and comment, that specific geographic areas with rapidly changing environmental conditions merit re-verification on a more frequent basis.4 On 18 January 2023, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Department of the Army (“the agencies”) published the “Revised Definition of ‘Waters of the United States,’” 88 FR 3004 (18 January 2023) (“2023 Rule”). On 8 September 2023 the agencies published the “Revised Definition of ‘Waters of the United States’; Conforming”, 88 FR 61964 (8 September 2023) which amended the 2023 Rule to conform to the 2023 Supreme Court decision in Sackett v. EPA, 598 U.S. 651, 143 S. Ct. 1322 (2023) (“Sackett”). This Memorandum for Record (MFR) constitutes the basis of jurisdiction for a Corps AJD as defined in 33 CFR § 331.2. For the purposes of this AJD, we have relied on Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 (RHA),5 the 2023 Rule as amended, 1 While the Revised Definition of “Waters of the United States”; Conforming had no effect on some categories of waters covered under the CWA, and no effect on any waters covered under RHA, all categories are included in this Memorandum for Record for efficiency. 2 When documenting aquatic resources within the review area that are jurisdictional under the Clean Water Act (CWA), use an additional MFR and group the aquatic resources on each MFR based on the TNW, the territorial seas, or interstate water that they are connected to. Be sure to provide an identifier to indicate when there are multiple MFRs associated with a single AJD request (i.e., number them 1, 2, 3, etc.). 3 33 CFR § 331.2. 4 Regulatory Guidance Letter 05-02. 5 USACE has authority under both Section 9 and Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 but for convenience, in this MFR, jurisdiction under RHA will be referred to as Section 10. NWP-2022-30 1 of 7 Enclosure 1 CENWP-ODG SUBJECT: 2023 Rule, as amended, Approved Jurisdictional Determination in Light of Sackett v. EPA, 143 S. Ct. 1322 (2023), NWP-2022-30 as well as other applicable guidance, relevant case law, and longstanding practice in evaluating jurisdiction. 1.SUMMARY OF CONCLUSIONS. a.Provide a list of each individual feature within the Review Area and the jurisdictional status of each one (i.e., identify whether each feature is/is not a water of the United States and/or a navigable water of the United States). i.Wetland 1, non-jurisdictional ii.Wetland 2, non-jurisdictional iii.Wetland 2B, jurisdictional iv.Wetland 2C, non-jurisdictional v.Wetland 3, non-jurisdictional vi.Wetland 4, non-jurisdictional vii.Wetland 5, non-jurisdictional 2.REFERENCES. a.“Revised Definition of ‘Waters of the United States,’” 88 FR 3004 (18 January 2023) (“2023 Rule”) b.“Revised Definition of ‘Waters of the United States’; Conforming” 88 FR 61964 (8 September 2023) c.Sackett v. EPA, 598 U.S. 651, 143 S. Ct. 1322 (2023) d.“Memorandum on LRB-2021-01386. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the Office of the Assistant Secretary of the Army for Civil Works at the U.S. Department of the Army (16 February 2024).” e.“Memorandum To The Field Between The U.S. Department Of The Army, U.S. Army Corps Of Engineers And The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Concerning The Proper Implementation Of ‘Continuous Surface Connection’ Under The Definition Of “Waters Of The United States” Under The Clean Water Act” (March 12, 2025) NWP-2022-30 2 of 7 Enclosure 1 CENWP-ODG SUBJECT: 2023 Rule, as amended, Approved Jurisdictional Determination in Light of Sackett v. EPA, 143 S. Ct. 1322 (2023), NWP-2022-30 3.REVIEW AREA. The Review Area is 15.50 acres (ac) and includes Tax Lot 1804111200200 in Eugene, Lane County, Oregon, Latitude / Longitude: 44.0239850°, -123.1358888°. 4.NEAREST TRADITIONAL NAVIGABLE WATER (TNW), THE TERRITORIAL SEAS, OR INTERSTATE WATER TO WHICH THE AQUATIC RESOURCE IS CONNECTED. The nearest TNW to which waters from the Review Area is connected is the Willamette River located approximately 28 miles north of the Review Area at River Mile (RM) 146. The Willamette River has been determined to be a TNW to RM 183.2 by Portland District Corps of Engineers as described in the October 1993 District list of Navigable Riverways within the State of Oregon.6 5.FLOWPATH FROM THE SUBJECT AQUATIC RESOURCES TO A TNW, THE TERRITORIAL SEAS, OR INTERSTATE WATER. Wetland 2B flows south and west through the Review Area and extends west outside of the Review Area where it directly abuts and flows into Videra Creek, an RPW, 1.86 miles to Amazon Creek, an RPW, and continues 27 miles to the Willamette River, a TNW. 6.SECTION 10 JURISDICTIONAL WATERS 7: Describe aquatic resources or other features within the Review Area determined to be jurisdictional in accordance with Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899. Include the size of each aquatic resource or other feature within the Review Area and how it was determined to be jurisdictional in accordance with Section 10.8 N/A 7.SECTION 404 JURISDICTIONAL WATERS: Describe the aquatic resources within the Review Area that were found to meet the definition of waters of the United States in accordance with the 2023 Rule as amended at 33 CFR § 328.3(a)(1) through 6 This MFR should not be used to complete a new stand-alone TNW determination. A stand-alone TNW determination for a water that is not subject to Section 9 or 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 (RHA) is completed independently of a request for an AJD. A stand-alone TNW determination is conducted for a specific segment of river or stream or other type of waterbody, such as a lake, where upstream or downstream limits or lake borders are established. 7 33 CFR § 329.9(a) A waterbody which was navigable in its natural or improved state, or which was susceptible of reasonable improvement (as discussed in § 329.8(b) of this part) retains its character as “navigable in law” even though it is not presently used for commerce, or is presently incapable of such use because of changed conditions or the presence of obstructions. 8 This MFR is not to be used to make a report of findings to support a determination that the water is a navigable water of the United States. The district must follow the procedures outlined in 33 CFR § 329.14 to make a determination that a water is a navigable water of the United States subject to Section 10 of the RHA. NWP-2022-30 3 of 7 Enclosure 1 CENWP-ODG SUBJECT: 2023 Rule, as amended, Approved Jurisdictional Determination in Light of Sackett v. EPA, 143 S. Ct. 1322 (2023), NWP-2022-30 (a)(5), consistent with the Supreme Court’s decision in Sackett. List each aquatic resource separately, by name, consistent with the naming convention used in section 1, above. Include a rationale for each aquatic resource, supporting that the aquatic resource meets the relevant category of “waters of the United States” in the 2023 Rule as amended. The rationale should also include a written description of, or reference to a map in the administrative record that shows, the lateral limits of jurisdiction for each aquatic resource, including how that limit was determined, and incorporate relevant references used. Include the size of each aquatic resource in acres or linear feet and attach and reference related figures as needed. a.Traditional Navigable Waters (TNWs) (a)(1)(i): N/A b.The Territorial Seas (a)(1)(ii): N/A c.Interstate Waters (a)(1)(iii): N/A d.Impoundments (a)(2): N/A e. Tributaries (a)(3): N/A f.Adjacent Wetlands (a)(4): Wetland 2B: Wetlands 2 (East) and 2b were delineated and reported as two wetlands in the April 2025 wetland delineation report. Wetlands 2 (East) and 2b have no discernable division separating the two features in the Review Area. For the purposes of the Corps review and determination, Wetlands 2 (East) and 2b are evaluated as one-wetland under Wetland 2B. Wetland 2B is classified as palustrine scrub shrub (PSS) Cowardin class wetland totaling 0.536-acre near the center of the Review Area. Wetland 2B flows south into an 8-inch corrugated culvert and flows 100-feet outside of the Review Area where it exists into a channel in an offsite wetland with similar vegetation directly adjacent to and abutting Videra Creek. Flow was visible during the 30 May 2025 site visit through the adjacent wetland and into Videra Creek (RPW). Wetland 2B maintains a continuous surficial connection to a requisite (a)(1), (a)(2), or (a)(3) water. Therefore, the Corps has determined Wetland 2B is a water of the U.S. g. Additional Waters (a)(5): N/A 8.NON-JURISDICTIONAL AQUATIC RESOURCES AND FEATURES NWP-2022-30 4 of 7 Enclosure 1 CENWP-ODG SUBJECT: 2023 Rule, as amended, Approved Jurisdictional Determination in Light of Sackett v. EPA, 143 S. Ct. 1322 (2023), NWP-2022-30 a.Describe aquatic resources and other features within the Review Area identified in the 2023 Rule as amended as not “waters of the United States” even where they otherwise meet the terms of paragraphs (a)(2) through (5). Include the type of excluded aquatic resource or feature, the size of the aquatic resource or feature within the Review Area and describe how it was determined to meet one of the exclusions listed in 33 CFR 328.3(b).9 N/A b.Describe aquatic resources and features within the Review Area that were determined to be non-jurisdictional because they do not meet one or more categories of waters of the United States under the 2023 Rule as amended (e.g., tributaries that are non-relatively permanent waters; non-tidal wetlands that do not have a continuous surface connection to a jurisdictional water). Wetland 1: Wetlands 1 and 1b were delineated and reported as two wetlands in the April 2025 wetland delineation report. Wetlands 1 and 1b have no discernable division separating the two features in the Review Area. For the purposes of the Corps review and determination, Wetlands 1 and 1b are evaluated as one-wetland under Wetland 1. Wetland 1 is classified as a slope Hydrogeomorphic (HGM) class and a seasonally saturated palustrine emergent (PEME) Cowardin class wetland with small patches of scrub-shrub (PSS) totaling 3.21 acres within the northern most portion of the Review Area. Wetland 1 occurs in a sloped and previously disturbed area and is separated from the nearest relatively permanent water (RPW) (Videra Creek) by uplands. Wetland 1 does not extend offsite beyond the Review Area and is not located within a mapped floodplain. Based on a review of light detection and ranging (LiDAR) data, available topographic mapping, wetland delineation report and delineation data forms, and ground level photographs, the Corps found no evidence that Wetland 1 has a continuous surficial connection to a requisite (a)(1), (a)(2), or (a)(3) water. Therefore, the Corps has determined Wetland 1 is not a water of the U.S. Wetland 2 is classified as palustrine scrub shrub (PSS) Cowardin class wetland totaling 0.34-acre within the upper center of the Review Area. Wetland 2 occurs in a sloped and previously disturbed area and is separated from Wetland 2B and the nearest RPW (Videra Creek) by uplands. Wetland 2 does not extend offsite beyond the Review Area and is not located within a mapped floodplain. Based on a review of LiDAR data, available topographic mapping, wetland delineation report and delineation data forms, and ground level photographs, the Corps found no evidence that Wetland 2 has a continuous surficial connection to a 9 88 FR 3004 (18 January 2023) NWP-2022-30 5 of 7 Enclosure 1 CENWP-ODG SUBJECT: 2023 Rule, as amended, Approved Jurisdictional Determination in Light of Sackett v. EPA, 143 S. Ct. 1322 (2023), NWP-2022-30 requisite (a)(1), (a)(2), or (a)(3) water. Therefore, the Corps has determined Wetland 2 is not a water of the U.S. Wetland 2c is classified as palustrine scrub shrub (PSS) Cowardin class wetland totaling 0.01-acre within the center of the Review Area. Wetland 2c occurs in a sloped and previously disturbed area and is separated from Wetland 2 and the nearest RPW (Videra Creek) by uplands. Wetland 2c does not extend offsite beyond the Review Area and is not located within a mapped floodplain. Based on a review of LiDAR data, available topographic mapping, wetland delineation report and delineation data forms, and ground level photographs, the Corps found no evidence that Wetland 2c has a continuous surficial connection to a requisite (a)(1), (a)(2), or (a)(3) water. Therefore, the Corps has determined Wetland 2c is not a water of the U.S. Wetland 3 is classified as PSS Cowardin class wetland totaling 0.44-acre within the center of the Review Area. Wetland 3 occurs in a sloped and previously disturbed area and is separated from Wetland 2 and the nearest RPW (Videra Creek) by uplands. Wetland 3 extends offsite beyond the Review Area, but the Corps determined from the 30 May 2025 onsite meeting, as well as review of LiDAR data, available topographic mapping, wetland delineation report and delineation data forms, and ground level photographs, that Wetland 3 has no continuous surficial connection to a requisite (a)(1), (a)(2), or (a)(3) water. Therefore, the Corps has determined Wetland 3 is not a water of the U.S. Wetland 4 is classified as a slope HGM class and a PEME Cowardin class wetland totaling 0.01-acre south of Wetland 2c in the Review Area. Wetland 4 occurs in a sloped and previously disturbed area and is separated from Wetland 2 and the nearest RPW (Videra Creek) by uplands. Wetland 4 does not extend offsite beyond the Review Area and is not located within a mapped floodplain. Based on a review of LiDAR data, available topographic mapping, wetland delineation report and delineation data forms, and ground level photographs, the Corps found no evidence that Wetland 4 has a continuous surficial connection to a requisite (a)(1), (a)(2), or (a)(3) water. Therefore, the Corps has determined Wetland 4 is not a water of the U.S. Wetland 5 is classified as a slope HGM class and a PEME Cowardin class wetland totaling 0.01-acre west of Wetland 4 in the Review Area. Wetland 5 occurs in a sloped and previously disturbed area and is separated from Wetland 2 and the nearest RPW (Videra Creek) by uplands. Wetland 5 does not extend offsite beyond the Review Area and is not located within a mapped floodplain. Based on a review of LiDAR data, available topographic mapping, wetland delineation report and delineation data forms, and ground level photographs, the NWP-2022-30 6 of 7 Enclosure 1 CENWP-ODG SUBJECT: 2023 Rule, as amended, Approved Jurisdictional Determination in Light of Sackett v. EPA, 143 S. Ct. 1322 (2023), NWP-2022-30 Corps found no evidence that Wetland 5 has a continuous surficial connection to a requisite (a)(1), (a)(2), or (a)(3) water. Therefore, the Corps has determined Wetland 5 is not a water of the U.S. 9.DATA SOURCES. List sources of data/information used in making determination. Include titles and dates of sources used and ensure that information referenced is available in the administrative record. a.A field visits were conducted on 04 April 2025 and on 30 May 2025 by Corps’ staff. b.A desktop evaluation was completed on 07 April 2025. c.Wetland Delineation Report for Tax Lot 1804111200200, Eugene, Lane County, Oregon. Prepared by Wetlands and Wildlife LLC, dated April 11, 2025. d.Oregon Department of State Lands Local Wetlands Inventory, Accessed 07 April 2025. e.Oregon Department of State Lands Statewide Streams, Accessed 07 April 2025. f.U.S. Geological Survey National Hydrography Dataset, Accessed 07 April 2025. g.Corps Portland District October 1993 list of Navigable Riverways within the State of Oregon, Accessed 07 April 2025. h.Oregon DOGAMI LiDAR imagery, Accessed 07 April 2025. 10. OTHER SUPPORTING INFORMATION. N/A 11. NOTE: The structure and format of this MFR were developed in coordination with the EPA and Department of the Army. The MFR’s structure and format may be subject to future modification or may be rescinded as needed to implement additional guidance from the agencies; however, the approved jurisdictional determination described herein is a final agency action. NWP-2022-30 7 of 7 Enclosure 1 5HYLVLRQV 'DWH 'HVFULSWLRQ3URMHFW1XPEHU'UDZQ%\© 2018 WETLANDS AND WILDLIFE LLC&KHFNHG%70VICINITY MAP-EUGENE EAST QUADCity of Eugenel, ORMap and Taxlots 1804111200200Eugene, OR'DWHUHY:HWODQGVDQG:LOGOLIH//&32%R[(XJHQH25KWWSZZZZHWODQGVDQGZLOGOLIH//&FRPWETLANDS AND WILDLIFELLC,EXPRESSLY RESERVE ITS COMMON LAW COPYRIGHT AND OTHER PROPERTY RIGHTS IN THESE PLANS. THESE PLANS ARE NOT TO BE REPRODUCED, CHANGED, OR COPIED IN ANY FORM OR MANNER WHATSOEVER, NOR ARE THEY TO BE ASSIGNED TO A THIRD PARTY WITHOUT FIRST OBTAINING THE WRITTEN PERMISSION AND CONSENT OFWETLANDS ANDWILDLIFE LLC. INTHE EVENTOF UNAUTHORIZED REUSE OF THESE PLANS BY A THIRD PARTY, THE THIRD PARTY SHALL HOLD WETLANDS AND WILDLIFE LLC HARMLESS.WETLANDS ANDWILDLIFE LLCSOURCE7KHLQIRUPDWLRQRQWKLVPDSZDVGHULYHGIURPPXOWLSOHVRXUFHV$HULDO3KRWRVFRXUWHV\RI/DQH&RXQW\VWUHDPLQJGDWD*RRJOH(DUWK5RDGFHQWHUOLQHVWD[ORWVDQG$3,FRXUWHV\RI/&2*&RQWRXUVGHULYHGIURP'2*$0,/L'$5'DWD1$9'*HRLG$4XHVWLRQVUHJDUGLQJSURGXFWLRQRIWKLVPDSFDQEHVHQWWR%ULDQ0HLHULQJEULDQ#ZHWODQGVDQGZLOGOLIH//&FRP)HDWXUHVDUHPDSSHGWRZLWKLQPHWHURIWKHLUWUXHORFDWLRQ01,000500FeetN°LQFK IHHWFigure1LegendREVIEW $5($ R$NWP-2022-301 of 2Enclosure 2 Revisions# Date DescriptionProject Number:Drawn By© 2025 WETLANDS AND WILDLIFE LLCCheckedBTMPICULELL WETLAND DELINEATION MAPCity of Eugenel, ORMap and Taxlot 1804111200200 (part)Eugene, OR0078Date rev5: 6/30/2025Wetlands and Wildlife LLCP.O. Box 50878Eugene, OR 97405541.214.6051http://www.wetlandsandwildlifeLLC.comWETLANDS AND WILDLIFELLC,EXPRESSLY RESERVE ITS COMMON LAW COPYRIGHT AND OTHER PROPERTY RIGHTS IN THESE PLANS. THESE PLANS ARE NOT TO BE REPRODUCED, CHANGED, OR COPIED IN ANY FORM OR MANNER WHATSOEVER, NOR ARE THEY TO BE ASSIGNED TO A THIRD PARTY WITHOUT FIRST OBTAINING THE WRITTEN PERMISSION AND CONSENT OF WETLANDSAND WILDLIFE LLC. IN THE EVENT OF UNAUTHORIZED REUSE OF THESE PLANS BY A THIRD PARTY, THE THIRD PARTY SHALL HOLD WETLANDS AND WILDLIFE LLC HARMLESS.WETLANDS ANDWILDLIFE LLCSOURCEThe information on this map was derived from multiple sources. Aerial Photos courtesy of Lane County streaming data (Google Earth, 2014).Road centerlines, taxlots and API courtesy of LCOG. Contours derived from DOGAMILiDAR Data (NAVD88, Geoid 12A).Questions regarding production of this map can be sent to Brian Meiering: brian@wetlandsandwildlifeLLC.comFeatures are mapped to within 1 meter of their true location.---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Wetlands extend from offsiteWetlands extend from offsiteroad cut concentrateshydrology supporting W3Wetlands extendoffsiteWetland 1a is a swale intercepting upslope hydrologyALL PLOTS AND WETLAND BOUNDARIES ARE ACCURATE TO 1-METER BASED ON REAL TIME ARROW 100 GPS PROCESSING AND 2024/2025 GROUND TRUTHING.41524600445310032003300340035003900130058015600570058006600202203204205206207208209210223300HAWKINS LNBLACKTAIL DRRANDY LN29TH AV E MYSTIC LNRIDGEMONT DRRAN D Y LNSUNCREST AVE1025 1015 1005 995 9 85 975 965 955 945 935 925 915 905 895 885 875 865 855 84 5 835 825 815 80 5 795 785 775 765 755 745 10351015 965955 83580577575 5 735 WETLAND13.202ACRESWETLAND2(EAST)0.52ACRESWETLAND30.428ACRESWETLAND2(WEST)0.34ACRESWETLAND40.009ACRESWETLAND50.009ACRESWETLAND2C0.013ACRESWETLAND1B0.012ACRESWETLAND2B0.016ACRESLot200¬«4¬«2¬«3¬«10¬«5¬«7¬«6¬«8¬«11¬«9¬«1¬«12SP 24(W)SP 21(U)SP 22(W)SP 42(W)SP 43(U)SP 47(U)SP 46(W)SP 35(W)SP 03(W)SP 29(U)SP 30(W)SP 39(U)SP 50(U)SP 37(U)SP 31(U)SP 45(U)SP 44(W)SP 38(W)SP 36(W)SP 49(W)SP 51(W)SP 33(W)SP 34(U)SP 01(U)SP 02(W)SP 04(U)SP 07(W)SP 08(U)SP 27(U)SP 28(W)SP 23(U)SP 20(W)SP 11(U)SP10(W)SP 12(W)SP 18(W)SP 19(W)SP 06 (W)SP0 5(U)SP 13(U)SP 48(U)0 10050Feet¹LegendRARemovedfrom 2024 SA(probablewetland)AdjacenttaxlotsWetlands andOther Waters---ResampledPoints"V¸Ground PhotoPoints andDirection 2018!PCulvert5 ft contourFigure6Name acreswetland 1 3.202wetland 1b 0.012wetland 2 (east) 0.52wetland 2 (west) 0.34wetland 2b 0.016wetland 2c 0.013wetland 3 0.428wetland 4 0.009wetland 5 0.009Wetland Acreage SummaryNWP-2022-302 of 2Enclosure 2